Psychology by BogdanovaThe Encyclopedia of Psychology for the Artificial Era

RESEARCH DOSSIER

Cultural Neuroscience and Biocultural Development

Abstract. Cultural neuroscience investigates the relationship between culturally organized experience and neural systems underlying perception, attention, self-representation, emotion, and social behavior. Biocultural development situates these relationships within the reciprocal organization of biological maturation, culturally mediated practice, and historical environments across multiple timescales. This fundamental critical research monograph synthesizes foundational cross-cultural neuroimaging experiments, theoretical reviews, developmental neuroscience, population-genetic hypotheses, and methodological investigations. It evaluates evidence from self-referential judgment, attentional-control, visual processing, affective response, family-related adolescent reward, and longitudinal research, alongside systematic concerns about sample selection, psychometric comparability, scanner confounding, causal identification, candidate genes, and reproducibility. The synthesis identifies task- and context-specific variation in neural recruitment as an established empirical research phenomenon and distinguishes these findings from stronger developmental or evolutionary causal claims requiring prospective and genetically informative designs. It proposes a scientific agenda based on multisite replication, longitudinal exposure measurement, local conceptual validation, multimodal corroboration, and transparent population inference, including new questions raised by culturally mediated digital environments.

Keywords: cultural neuroscience; biocultural development; neuroplasticity; cultural experience; cross-cultural fMRI; developmental cultural neuroscience; self-representation; cultural attention; gene–culture coevolution; measurement invariance; developmental neurobiology; neuroimaging reproducibility; cultural learning; Artificial Era

Research Object, Definitions, and Explanatory Levels

Cultural neuroscience studies how culturally organized experience is associated with, and can shape, neural processes involved in cognition, emotion, social understanding, and behavior. Biocultural development examines the reciprocal relations among biological maturation, learning opportunities, institutions, material conditions, and culturally patterned activity across the life span. The research object is a developmental process situated at multiple explanatory levels: persons performing tasks, neurocognitive systems recruited during those tasks, social practices that organize repeated experience, and populations in which particular experiences are distributed. Cultural differences in measured activation are observations to be explained, with task interpretation, sampling, and physiology considered alongside cultural learning Kitayama & Uskul (2011) Li (2003) Han et al. (2013).

This monograph treats culture as historical, transmitted, and continually reconstructed practices, conventions, institutions, meanings, and shared tools. Neither citizenship nor self-reported ethnic identity alone measures the frequency, significance, or developmental timing of the practices through which neural adaptation may occur. Relevant variables include language use, schooling, caregiving routines, interpersonal obligations, discrimination exposure, occupational expertise, digital media, migration, and normative expectations. Researchers require clear operationalization and multiple measures because the same country contains substantial individual heterogeneity, and related activities occur in geographically distant communities. Cultural neuroscience gains explanatory force when it measures the proximal experiences hypothesized to alter perception or learning Henrich et al. (2010) Kim & Sasaki (2014).

The central questions are which neurocognitive processes show robust variation with cultural experience; which neural effects track differences in performance, strategy, or personal identification; how such associations emerge developmentally; and what designs can distinguish selection, training, and environmental mediation. Biocultural claims also require attention to biological constraints, sensitive periods, developmental timing, and genetic population structure. This investigation integrates peer-reviewed experimental studies, neuroimaging reports, cross-cultural comparisons, developmental evidence, and methodological reviews. It is a critical narrative synthesis organized by explanatory problem, without a registered systematic-search protocol or statistical pooling. It therefore evaluates plausible mechanisms and evidential boundaries rather than estimating global population effect sizes Qu et al. (2021) Putnick & Bornstein (2016).

Historical Formation of Cultural Neuroscience

Psychological questions about cultural variation preceded neuroimaging. Comparative investigations of perception and reasoning, cultural models of selfhood, and research on analytic and holistic attention supplied cognitive hypotheses that later became testable in neurobiological experiments. Nisbett and colleagues assembled evidence and predictions for differences in attention to objects and relational context, while scene-recall experiments associated American and Japanese sampling contexts with differences in descriptions of focal objects and background relationships. These behavioral traditions offered mechanisms more precise than the assumption that distinct populations possessed inherently different brains Nisbett et al. (2001) Masuda & Nisbett (2001).

The field acquired a recognizable interdisciplinary identity as functional magnetic resonance imaging and related techniques were applied to culturally relevant cognitive tasks. The 2007 self-representation investigation by Zhu and colleagues, the 2008 attentional-control experiment by Hedden and colleagues, and the subsequent syntheses of Han and Northoff and of Kitayama and Uskul clarified how cultural psychological hypotheses could inform predictions about activation patterns. These works developed a research program in which neuroimaging was combined with measurements of social identity, cultural endorsement, and behavior, albeit often in relatively small student samples Zhu et al. (2007) Hedden et al. (2008) Han & Northoff (2008) Kitayama & Uskul (2011).

Cultural neuroscience expanded from comparisons of national samples toward questions about dynamic experience, neural mediation, emotion, developmental transitions, and gene–environment interpretations. Chiao's methodological synthesis explicitly treated culture, neural activity, and behavior as interacting levels, while later reviews emphasized the biosocial organization of the brain and the importance of studying neural adaptation within an individual's social environment. This historical expansion broadened the field's hypotheses but also increased its vulnerability to overinterpretation when population labels were mistaken for causal exposures or when imaging associations were treated as direct demonstrations of biological essence Chiao (2009) Chiao et al. (2010) Han et al. (2013).

Cultural Practices, Psychological Constructs, and Population Sampling

Studies often begin with constructs such as independent and interdependent self-construal, holistic and analytic attention, or culturally preferred social goals. Those constructs connect theoretical predictions to performance differences, but their operational indicators cannot be assumed equivalent across languages or communities. A self-report item about dependence on relatives may describe obligation, practical cooperation, emotional reliance, or economic necessity in different settings. Researchers must establish its local meaning, response processes, and measurement properties before interpreting scores as a common underlying dimension. The problem extends to behavioral tasks, where instructions, test-taking familiarity, and perceptual materials may alter the difficulty of an ostensibly identical problem Putnick & Bornstein (2016) Kitayama & Uskul (2011).

Sampling remains a defining limitation. The methodological critique of heavily Western, educated, industrialized, rich, and democratic research populations established that findings from narrow recruitment pools cannot automatically describe humanity. This is especially important for neural methods, because expensive scanners, laboratory travel, language demands, and exclusions related to movement or health can produce additional selection. Researchers should document who could enter the study, who was excluded, how recruitment was organized, and what socioeconomic and socialization variables characterize the analyzed sample. The target of inference should be stated in advance: individuals in a particular study site, a defined institutional population, or a broader population justified by the sampling design Henrich et al. (2010) Qu et al. (2021).

International differences may arise from migration histories, urban versus rural residence, education, food insecurity, occupational demands, family systems, linguistic practice, or age structures. Each can vary within national borders and correlate with regional membership. A rigorous study therefore collects explanatory exposures alongside conventional group labels and tests whether conclusions survive sensible adjustments and within-group analyses. Such analyses cannot remove every unmeasured confounder, but they clarify which dimensions of the cultural interpretation are supported. Claims about ethnic or national biological predispositions are particularly weak when cultural exposure was never measured and genotype or ancestry structure was uncontrolled Kim & Sasaki (2014) Han et al. (2013).

Biocultural Plasticity and Developmental Time Scales

Biocultural plasticity refers to the capacity of developing systems to change through reciprocal interactions among biological processes and patterned experiences. Li's developmental synthesis distinguishes moment-to-moment adaptation, change over the individual life span, and evolutionary time, while emphasizing their interaction without treating them as interchangeable levels. Learning a visuospatial strategy during a task, gradually becoming skilled in a form of social interaction, and the long-run transmission of cultural practices can contribute to different kinds of neural adaptation. Each timescale needs its own evidence and analytic unit Li (2003).

Neuroplasticity is measurable through changes in synaptic, functional, structural, or network properties, but common cultural neuroscience paradigms primarily observe task-related hemodynamic differences. A group difference in blood-oxygen-level-dependent signal on a single scanning day establishes a conditional association between the task, recruited neural systems, and sampling context. It does not identify how much of that difference developed through training, at what age it emerged, or whether the underlying neural tissue changed. Longitudinal measurements, well-characterized training exposures, and convergent behavioral data are needed to argue that experience caused a particular developmental neural change Park & Huang (2010) Qu et al. (2021).

Developmental mechanisms may differ by age. Early language exposure, peer influence during adolescence, accumulated occupational practices, and later-life changes in sensory function place different demands on learning systems. The appropriate question is not whether one culture produces a fixed neural phenotype, but which reproducible environmental features interact with maturation and opportunities for practice during specified developmental windows. Cross-sectional adult contrasts generate hypotheses about such interactions; prospectively followed cohorts and within-person changes give stronger evidence about developmental pathways. Historical change may alter exposures within the same community, making repeated cohorts preferable to timeless national stereotypes Li (2003) Qu et al. (2021).

Interpreting Neural Plasticity Without Biological Essentialism

The brain is a biological organ whose organization reflects both species-typical constraints and individual histories of activity. Interpreting a cultural neural effect requires identifying the measured brain property and the proposed relationship between that property and a psychological operation. An activation difference can arise because one task condition requires more effort, because participants select different strategies, because they differ in stimulus familiarity, or because they recruit alternative networks. Greater activation cannot be translated into superior ability without independent behavioral and computational justification. Comparisons should include performance, reaction time, subjective difficulty, and alternative explanations tied to stimulus properties Hedden et al. (2008) Park & Huang (2010).

Neural representation is frequently distributed rather than localized to a single region, and the same cortical territory may contribute to multiple cognitive operations. Cultural differences in medial prefrontal activation during self-reference, for example, have meaning only relative to the self, close-other, and control judgments that establish the contrast. Similarly, differences during a perceptual judgment must be interpreted in light of the instructed relation between a focal target and its context. A culturally informed experiment improves explanation when it isolates a specific computation and shows that changing relevant experience or task demand changes its expression Zhu et al. (2007) Chiao et al. (2010).

Strong biocultural explanations combine neural measurements with behavioral replication, developmental histories, measurement comparability, and theoretical coherence. Evidence of an association at one scale can constrain hypotheses at another scale without automatically identifying causality. Neural measurements may help distinguish mechanisms when competing theories predict different patterns; they do not inherently outrank carefully collected behavioral or ethnographic observations. This multilevel principle organizes the following analyses of attention, self, emotion, development, and genetic claims, and establishes a common evidential standard across them Han et al. (2013) Kim & Sasaki (2014).

Cultural Attention and Visuospatial Control

Attentional-control studies transform the analytic–holistic cognition distinction into manipulable task demands. In Hedden and colleagues' functional MRI experiment, American and East Asian participants completed judgments that required either preserving an absolute visual quantity or reproducing a relative relation within a frame. Frontal and parietal activation associated with attentional control increased when the task emphasized the form of judgment less typical for the participants' sampled cultural context. The critical observation concerned differences in neural recruitment while making specific judgments, and individual questionnaire measures also related to activation. This experiment demonstrates culture-sensitive task processing within its recruitment and measurement conditions, rather than a universal neural classification of populations Hedden et al. (2008).

The task design helps distinguish executive demand from general perceptual capacity: participants can perform both absolute and relative judgments, yet the processing requirements and familiarity of those judgments differ. More activation may reflect additional control needed to override a habitual strategy. It does not establish that people from one national sample lack a cognitive capacity that another possesses. Replication should vary framing, trial order, instructions, language, and the social meanings of the task, and should test whether individual participation in relevant cultural practices predicts performance or activation more strongly than nationality Hedden et al. (2008) Nisbett et al. (2001).

Behavioral evidence provides a necessary reference point. Masuda and Nisbett's comparison of attention to changing aquatic scenes showed that descriptions and recall could be organized around focal objects or their relationships to background details. Such findings motivate hypotheses about context-sensitive attention but do not determine the neural implementation by themselves. A decisive program links eye movements, stimulus selection, memory performance, and imaging under matched experimental conditions, then asks which aspects of attention change through experience. It also examines variability within each community rather than treating mean group contrasts as mutually exclusive psychological types Masuda & Nisbett (2001) Park & Huang (2010).

Visual Objects, Scenes, and Contextual Binding

Visual neuroscience offers candidate neural systems for studying cultural variation in attention to objects and context. Goh and colleagues examined object processing and object–scene binding across age and sampling groups with functional MRI, using a paradigm that separated components of visual interpretation. Their work illustrates how developmental age and culturally patterned experience can be analyzed together rather than attributed to a single generic population difference. Because the measured response arises from specific stimuli and laboratory conditions, its interpretation depends on whether groups view and recognize the same materials in comparable ways Goh et al. (2007).

A subsequent investigation examined neural responses to faces and houses in ventral visual cortex and found culture-related effects for particular face-processing contrasts rather than a uniform alteration across every visual category. This differentiation matters: if cultural exposure changes the functional response to familiar social stimuli, different perceptual networks need not show identical patterns. Researchers should assess visual experience, contact with stimulus classes, scanner task performance, and whether patterns generalize to novel identities or naturally occurring scenes. Such tests transform a regional contrast into a constrained account of perceptual adaptation Goh et al. (2010) Park & Huang (2010).

Age differences in visual processing create a second challenge to simple cultural explanation. Older and younger participants may rely on different combinations of sensory processing and contextual information, and cohorts can differ in schooling, media exposure, and everyday visual environments. Cross-sectional sampling mixes these influences. Within-community longitudinal designs, repeated measures, and training manipulations would help identify the contribution of experience and aging to object–scene representation. The central scientific value of visual cultural neuroscience is the possibility of discriminating task-specific neural mechanisms, contingent on behavioral validation and adequately powered comparison Goh et al. (2007) Li (2003).

Self-Representation and Medial Prefrontal Processing

Studies of self-representation test whether judgments about oneself and close others produce distinctive neural response patterns across cultural environments. Zhu and colleagues compared neural activity when participants evaluated traits concerning self, mother, and a familiar public figure. Their findings indicated that neural differentiation between self and mother varied with the sampled cultural group, particularly within medial prefrontal territory implicated in self-referential processing. These contrasts supplied a neural correlate for earlier cultural psychological theories of independent and interdependent selfhood. The evidence concerns the particular judgment paradigm and population samples, rather than the existence of an anatomically separate kind of self Zhu et al. (2007) Han & Northoff (2008).

Chiao and colleagues extended the approach by examining neural representations of individualistic and collectivistic views of self and by relating differences to culturally relevant psychological orientation. This moves explanation beyond a country-level indicator: people may access multiple ways of understanding personal identity, and their relative accessibility can depend on context. Tasks that ask about one's own traits, social roles, or relationships can evoke different reference frames. For such studies, investigators should validate translation, distinguish closeness from familial obligation, and record how participants construe the target person Chiao et al. (2009) Kitayama & Uskul (2011).

Neural self-reference signals are sensitive to task instructions and control conditions. If one group perceives a mother judgment as personally relevant and another treats it as a judgment about an independent person, a contrast may reflect relational relevance, representational overlap, familiarity, or different evaluative strategies. A robust interpretation therefore combines ratings of perceived closeness, self-construal, response confidence, and within-person task variation. No brain response alone reveals a complete theory of personhood. The methodological opportunity lies in testing whether distinct cultural concepts predict conditional patterns across neural and behavioral measures Zhu et al. (2007) Kim & Sasaki (2014).

Cultural Priming, Frame Switching, and Neural Flexibility

An important methodological advance replaces a fixed comparison of populations with experimentally manipulated cultural cues. Chiao and colleagues studied dynamic cultural influences on neural representations of self by examining how cultural orientation could be made salient before self-referential judgments. A priming result can indicate that accessible interpretations of personhood, and their neural correlates, depend on immediate context. The inference is narrower than a claim about permanent structural rewiring: shifts across experimental blocks or sessions demonstrate state-sensitive recruitment under controlled conditions Chiao et al. (2010).

Cultural priming requires careful controls. Brief exposure to symbols, pronouns, or narratives can also change language processing, task expectations, mood, attention, or experimenter demand. Successful causal interpretation requires active comparison conditions and manipulation checks showing that the intended psychological construct, rather than an unrelated feature of the cue, changed. Researchers should preregister predicted neural contrasts and distinguish culturally patterned identities from generic salience or familiarity effects. Within-participant manipulations are valuable because many stable individual differences are held constant, but they do not independently establish the long-term developmental source of a neural pattern Chiao et al. (2010) Putnick & Bornstein (2016).

Repeated measures of migrants, multilingual participants, and people who regularly cross institutional contexts can test how neural representations vary across ordinary daily settings. Such designs would combine experience sampling with validated laboratory tasks rather than assuming one enduring cultural orientation per person. A causal account would compare short-lived context effects, accumulated practice, and developmental persistence. This distinction is especially relevant to biocultural theory: flexible recruitment may be one mechanism through which experience is expressed without necessarily implying lasting anatomical change Li (2003) Han et al. (2013).

Behavioral–Neural Convergence and Explanatory Limits

Neuroimaging can identify systems associated with a culturally variable task while leaving the psychological computation uncertain. Convergence is stronger when an observed activation contrast appears alongside a predicted behavioral effect, a validated individual-difference measure, and a control task that rules out a simple difference in speed or difficulty. Experimental contrasts also need adequate test–retest reliability, transparent regional or whole-brain analysis, and independent replication. If a cultural category predicts a signal only after many analytic choices, it provides a weaker foundation for developmental explanation than a reproducible within-person relation between exposure, strategy, and performance Hedden et al. (2008) Han et al. (2013).

The distinction between reverse inference and process measurement is central. Activation of a region often associated with self-related thought, attention, or affect does not prove that a participant experienced that process in the absence of behavioral and design constraints. A region can support several tasks, while one psychological function depends on multiple interacting systems. Cultural neuroscience must therefore interpret neural findings at the level supported by its experimental contrast. Process claims gain force when competing tasks or models yield discriminable predictions rather than merely associating a region with a familiar psychological label Han & Northoff (2008) Park & Huang (2010).

Across these visual and self-related studies, the most defensible synthesis is that human neurocognitive processing is sensitive to culturally organized tasks, meanings, and experiences. The evidence gives specific examples of conditional recruitment and context-related representation. The general causal pathway from childhood socialization to particular adult functional MRI signals remains incompletely identified, and few demonstrations isolate culture from all correlated environmental conditions. These limits define the next generation of research designs rather than erasing the empirical contributions of the original experiments Kitayama & Uskul (2011) Qu et al. (2021).

Cultural Emotion and the Neural Processing of Social Signals

Emotion-related neural responses are shaped by stimulus meaning, familiarity, attention, perceived social affiliation, and task instructions. Chiao and colleagues compared amygdala responses to fearful faces from culturally familiar and unfamiliar groups, reporting a cultural specificity in response under the experimental presentation conditions. The finding is relevant to social salience and experience-dependent tuning, but the amygdala participates in multiple operations and cannot serve as a simple detector of a fixed emotion or group identity. Researchers need to distinguish face familiarity, perceptual expertise, gaze patterns, emotional appraisal, and social evaluations when interpreting the contrast Chiao et al. (2008) Han et al. (2013).

Expression recognition is not exclusively a matter of neural response magnitude. Participants interpret a face in relation to conventions of expression, interpersonal distance, situational context, and learned expectations. Emotion labels are themselves subject to translation and conceptual nonequivalence, while laboratory photographs remove much of the natural social information that gives an expression meaning. A culturally sensitive design combines stimulus validation, behavioral judgments, and physiologically appropriate controls. It should include within-group variation and assess whether responses track personal contact with the stimulus category better than categorical group assignment Kim & Sasaki (2014) Kitayama & Uskul (2011).

The developmental significance of these effects concerns how repeated exposure to socially meaningful signals calibrates attention and appraisal. A child encounters facial expressions in interactions marked by caregiver practices, language, and local social rules; an adult may acquire new repertoires through migration or sustained intercultural contact. The proposed route from these experiences to neural response is plausible but requires direct tests with repeated assessments and measured exposure histories. Amygdala effects observed at a single time point provide clues about contemporary processing, not a map of the entire developmental history that produced it Li (2003) Chiao et al. (2008).

Social Affiliation, Identity, and Neural Meaning

Social identity and culturally patterned relational roles influence which people, objects, and actions become salient. Self-reference experiments suggest that judgments about close others may recruit neural systems associated with self-related processing under some conditions, while emotion experiments show context-dependent responses to socially categorized faces. These findings converge on the importance of relational meaning, although they arise from different tasks and measurement contrasts. A coherent explanation asks what informational features are shared: personal relevance, familiarity, obligation, social prediction, or an attentional priority established through repeated interactions Zhu et al. (2007) Chiao et al. (2008).

A major problem is construct overlap. A measure intended to assess collectivism may correlate with family closeness, peer identification, education, migration background, or institutional expectations, and these may have different neural associations. Studies must establish discriminant validity and include several measures with distinct causal roles. Multi-group measurement invariance can help determine whether questionnaire comparisons preserve comparable interpretations, while interviews and ecological observations clarify what individuals mean by the chosen categories. More refined constructs will often yield better explanations than undifferentiated labels such as Eastern and Western Putnick & Bornstein (2016) Kim & Sasaki (2014).

Neural measures can contribute to this refinement by testing whether psychological dimensions predict activity across multiple experimental paradigms. If self-related processing, attention to relatives, and reward responses covary with a validated pattern of social obligation, the hypothesis becomes more specific; it still requires replication and caution about common-method and sampling effects. Prospective studies during developmental transitions may help establish whether changes in relationships precede changes in behavior and neural recruitment. Cross-sectional cultural contrasts should be regarded as an entry point into this explanatory program Han et al. (2013) Qu et al. (2021).

The Developmental Cultural Neuroscience Research Program

Developmental cultural neuroscience explicitly integrates cultural psychology, developmental science, and cognitive neuroscience. Its scientific object is the developmental formation and changing operation of brain–behavior processes under culturally structured opportunities and constraints. The perspective expands the question of whether two groups differ at one age into an investigation of when such differences appear, which experiences predict change, and whether developmental paths converge or diverge as roles and institutions change. Qu, Jorgensen, and Telzer provide a methodological rationale for building culture directly into developmental brain research rather than treating it as a peripheral demographic field Qu et al. (2021).

The sampling problem is striking in the literature they examined: among 80 publications identified through five prior meta-analyses concerning adolescent developmental neuroscience, 79 used Western-country samples, while only 18 supplied detailed racial or ethnic information and 14 detailed socioeconomic information. The percentages, 99%, 22%, and 18%, characterize this defined group of publications, not the complete worldwide neuroscience literature. Their analysis demonstrates a substantial gap between broad claims about adolescent brain development and the documented sampling base of selected influential studies Qu et al. (2021).

Developmental designs should consider biological maturation, school grade, pubertal stage, family roles, exposure to cultural practices, and transitions in responsibility. Chronological age alone may not align the same institutional experience across settings. Longitudinal measurement can track individual change, while cross-sequential cohorts can help disentangle developmental age and historical period. Cross-cultural research further needs calibrated tasks and local collaboration to avoid misinterpreting unfamiliar tests as developmental delay. These requirements provide an agenda for identifying actual biocultural mechanisms rather than substituting regional averages for developmental evidence Li (2003) Qu et al. (2021).

Adolescent Social Values, Cognitive Control, and Reward

Adolescence is useful for studying biocultural development because reward learning, social affiliation, self-regulation, and family expectations undergo concurrent change. Telzer and colleagues examined neural responses associated with adolescent risk taking in the context of meaningful family relationships, showing how family-related motivational and cognitive factors can be investigated in a developmental imaging paradigm. The study's contribution is to specify a social experience with plausible relevance to adolescent choices and to relate it to task-based neural responses. The findings do not license a claim that one cultural group has a universally protective neural pattern Telzer et al. (2013).

A separate longitudinal investigation by Telzer and colleagues related ventral striatal activation during prosocial reward processing to subsequent changes in risk-taking behavior. This design offers stronger temporal information than a single cross-sectional group contrast, although observational prediction of later behavior still leaves possible shared causes. The important distinction is between neural responses to different reward contexts: the significance of an action for family or community can influence what is motivationally salient. Culturally structured social goals are therefore an empirical variable to measure, not merely an interpretive label applied after scanning Telzer et al. (2013) Kim & Sasaki (2014).

Future multisite research can measure family obligation, institutional norms, the availability of prosocial roles, peer relationships, material pressures, and reward-learning behavior before testing neural mechanisms. Investigators should compare the same psychological construct in culturally valid tasks, seek longitudinal within-person relations, and report the extent to which findings generalize beyond their recruited adolescents. Brain activation may contribute to a mediation model only when temporality, confounding, measurement error, and plausible alternative pathways are handled explicitly. The developmental value of this research lies in connecting meaningful cultural experience to carefully defined behavioral trajectories Qu et al. (2021) Telzer et al. (2013).

From Childhood Learning to Adult Expertise and Aging

Biocultural development extends beyond early socialization. School routines can repeatedly emphasize some forms of categorization and attention, while occupations and media practices train other perceptual or memory skills. The nervous system changes through learning, yet an observed group difference among adults does not show which practice created it. Researchers could use interventions that vary instruction or exposure, measure baseline competence, and follow participants through skill acquisition. Such work would identify the degree to which experimentally induced learning reproduces the pattern observed in community comparisons Li (2003) Park & Huang (2010).

Age-comparative neuroimaging has investigated whether object processing and contextual binding vary jointly with cultural sampling contexts and age. These results suggest that cultural experience remains relevant to the study of aging, but cross-sectional cohorts carry histories of schooling, technology use, sensory health, and migration. Age-related neural changes also influence task difficulty and hemodynamic response. Studies should avoid assigning every late-life difference to culture or maturation without examining these confounded dimensions Goh et al. (2007).

Longitudinal biocultural neuroscience can organize measurements at three linked intervals: immediate task performance, accumulated practice over months or years, and life-course changes across institutions and generations. One research design may repeatedly measure participants before and after migration or occupational change, comparing them with a carefully characterized group that did not undergo the transition. Another can follow children entering different educational arrangements while measuring language, caregiving, socioeconomic resources, and neural function. Both require ethical design and robust handling of attrition and selective participation. The aim is to trace developmental mechanisms with the right temporal evidence Li (2003) Qu et al. (2021).

Gene–Culture Coevolution and Levels of Selection

Gene–culture coevolution theory examines the long-term feedback through which socially transmitted practices may modify environments relevant to selection, and genetically influenced traits may in turn affect cultural learning or behavior. The theory addresses population processes unfolding over many generations and should be distinguished from neural plasticity within an individual lifetime. To establish a particular coevolutionary claim, researchers need evidence about genetic variants, population histories, exposures, transmission pathways, and mechanisms of selection. A cross-sectional association between a cultural questionnaire and a gene frequency does not directly identify such a historical pathway Chiao & Blizinsky (2010) Li (2003).

Chiao and Blizinsky investigated country-level associations involving individualism–collectivism, a serotonin transporter polymorphism, and selected population indicators. Their work is historically important as an attempt to connect cultural measures with population genetics. Its ecological design, however, cannot reveal whether the same individual possesses a genetic variant, experiences a particular cultural practice, and exhibits a specific neural mechanism. Population structure, geographic history, social institutions, measurement comparability, and correlated environmental factors create alternative explanations. These inferential limits should remain explicit whenever the study is discussed Chiao & Blizinsky (2010).

Current gene–culture research needs adequately powered genomic analysis, ancestry-aware models, representative sampling, theoretically justified interaction terms, and independent replication. Evolutionary selection claims additionally require historical and demographic inference rather than a single contemporary comparison. Genotype frequencies cannot serve as proxies for psychological ability or cultural identity. The proper relationship between cultural neuroscience and gene–culture theory is thus one of potentially complementary hypotheses operating at different scales, with separate datasets and methods needed to connect them Kim & Sasaki (2014) Han et al. (2013).

Lessons From Candidate Gene Research

The candidate-gene era encouraged interpretations in which one or a few polymorphisms could be assigned broad roles in emotion, social behavior, or susceptibility to culturally patterned experiences. Such models frequently depended on small samples, numerous analytical choices, and the assumption of large effects. In research on major depression, Border and colleagues used substantially larger datasets to test historical candidate-gene and candidate-gene-by-environment claims. Their results offered no support for the established candidate hypotheses as explanations of the tested depression outcomes. This result is evidence about that field, with methodological implications for similarly ambitious cultural genetic claims Border et al. (2019).

The relevance of this negative evidence lies in study design and interpretation. A molecular marker associated with a social category at the population level may simply track demographic or ancestral structure. Candidate-gene interactions require careful multiple-testing control, precise exposure measurement, and sufficient power for effects generally smaller than early reports anticipated. Psychological measures such as self-construal are heterogeneous and context-sensitive, increasing the risk that a broad genetic explanation will conceal construct ambiguity. Genetic information should be integrated only when the biological and statistical mechanisms are directly testable Border et al. (2019) Putnick & Bornstein (2016).

A biocultural account can be substantial without assigning it a simple genetic signature. The strongest neural evidence reviewed in this monograph concerns context-sensitive task performance and recruitment, whereas claims about inherited population differentiation require a different order of proof. Treating these areas separately improves scientific precision: culture-related neural flexibility can arise through learning and changing environments regardless of whether a specific genetic difference exists between sampled groups. Future genomic work should therefore begin from reproducible phenotypes, well-characterized environments, and cross-population replication rather than historically attractive one-gene narratives Li (2003) Chiao & Blizinsky (2010).

Functional MRI, Hemodynamics, and the Measurement Problem

Functional MRI most commonly measures blood-oxygen-level-dependent signal, a physiological correlate of neural activity influenced by local vascular response. Cultural neuroscience uses contrasts between conditions, groups, or changes over time to infer which brain systems participate in the task. The measurement is indirect and sensitive to head motion, scanner properties, acquisition parameters, preprocessing, and statistical modeling. The signal should be interpreted as a condition-specific physiological observation with uncertainty, not a direct quantitative reading of cultural beliefs or a universal measure of mental strength Park & Huang (2010) Han et al. (2013).

Investigators must define the estimand before examining images. A within-person comparison of self versus close-other judgments estimates a task contrast in a specified sample; a between-site difference in that contrast adds confounding by site, equipment, and recruitment. Multiple analytic pipelines can yield different statistical maps, while group averaging can conceal individual heterogeneity. Good practice includes transparent region definition, appropriate whole-brain correction, motion thresholds, independent checks, and release of sufficient materials to evaluate model choices. Neural patterns should be interpreted jointly with accuracy, latency, and task engagement Zhu et al. (2007) Hedden et al. (2008).

Reliability limits the interpretability of cultural variation. If a neural difference score varies substantially across sessions, it is a weak basis for ranking individuals or predicting long-term development. Individual-difference neuroimaging needs especially careful sample-size justification, as large-scale analyses of brain–behavior associations have highlighted the instability of small-sample correlations. The exact number of participants needed depends on the design, contrast, reliability, and effect being estimated; the general lesson is to plan precision and replication rather than rely on customary small imaging samples Marek et al. (2022).

EEG, Multimodal Methods, and Convergent Evidence

Electroencephalography measures scalp voltage dynamics and can help establish the timing of perceptual, attentional, or affective processing. Functional MRI provides comparatively detailed spatial information about hemodynamic responses. Eye tracking, reaction-time distributions, self-report, behavioral observation, and ecological experience sampling each contribute different evidence. A well-designed cultural neuroscience program triangulates these methods according to an explicit mechanism. Agreement across modalities increases confidence when measures have been validated for the psychological process; disagreement may reveal that a task engages several operations rather than one culturally stable trait Chiao et al. (2010) Han et al. (2013).

Temporal resolution is especially important for distinguishing early perceptual selection from later decision or regulatory activity. Cross-cultural differences in a late EEG component need not imply different early sensory encoding, and differences in early visual response do not determine the content of a participant's social interpretation. Investigators should specify the component, latency window, electrode or source estimate, and task events before data analysis. Differences in visual displays, literacy, language, and motor demands must be managed across sites so that the recorded signal is linked to comparable processing Kim & Sasaki (2014) Park & Huang (2010).

Biocultural developmental studies benefit from repeated multimodal measurement. A cohort might combine assessments of family and school practices, behavioral tasks, noninvasive neural recordings, and prospective measures of social change. Selection of methods must account for participant age, fatigue, cultural acceptability, local infrastructure, and privacy. An expensive method contributes little if it excludes most of the community of interest or if its conditions alter the very practice under study. Evidence quality depends on construct fit and transparent inference more than on technological sophistication Qu et al. (2021) Li (2003).

Population Structure, Research Ethics, and Interpretation

Cultural neuroscience often handles information that can be misread as implying biological hierarchies among social groups. Scientific responsibility begins with accurate design: specify sampling frames, document recruitment and exclusion, report within-group variability, and distinguish cultural exposures from ancestry and racialized social experience. Population labels should be justified for the research question and should never substitute silently for a measured psychological mechanism. Research collaborations should include relevant local investigators in question formation, material validation, interpretation, and dissemination Henrich et al. (2010) Qu et al. (2021).

Neuroimaging and genetic data carry distinctive privacy risks because they can be linked to health, ancestry, and identity. Ethical protocols must address consent, secondary use, community expectations, secure sharing, and the possibility that group results will be detached from their limitations. In developmental research, assent, guardianship, age-appropriate explanation, and ongoing consent are important. Reporting should make it difficult to confuse average task-related effects with diagnoses, innate capacity, or individual prediction. Interpretive precision is a substantive part of research ethics Qu et al. (2021) Kim & Sasaki (2014).

Broad representation improves science when communities enter the research as sources of theory and methodological insight as well as participants. Local researchers may identify a task demand, social value, or translation problem missed by a distant laboratory. Comparative work gains validity when it incorporates emic descriptions and explicit cross-site coordination while retaining common measurements needed for comparison. The objective is explanatory generalization based on observed conditions and mechanisms, with population labels serving transparent descriptive purposes rather than standing in for unexplained causality Putnick & Bornstein (2016) Han et al. (2013).

Cross-Language Task Equivalence and Measurement Invariance

Cross-cultural inference requires that a task or scale represent the intended construct comparably across populations. Identical stimuli can have different meanings when linguistic categories, visual familiarity, learned classroom conventions, and social expectations differ. In psychometric studies, configural, metric, and scalar invariance tests address progressively stronger requirements for comparisons, but those statistical properties depend on the model, sample, and item content. The appropriate threshold depends on whether investigators compare associations, latent means, or predictive relationships. In neuroimaging, analogous concerns affect whether an activation contrast reflects comparable cognitive operations at different sites Putnick & Bornstein (2016).

Researchers should use translation and back-translation as starting procedures, then investigate local interpretation through cognitive interviewing, pilot tasks, and observed response strategies. A task may require different forms of educational experience even when every word has been translated accurately. Where a common measure fails, investigators can use linked measures, partially invariant models, or carefully restricted claims. The purpose is to retain meaningful comparison without erasing differences in how participants understand the stimulus. Behavior should corroborate the construct that the neural contrast is supposed to isolate Putnick & Bornstein (2016) Kitayama & Uskul (2011).

Evidence can be lost when culturally relevant indicators are treated only as nuisance variables. A social judgment may incorporate obligations and consequences that are essential to the phenomenon under study. Combining local qualitative inquiry with formally modeled common tasks can reveal both the shared operation and the culturally variable conditions under which it is performed. Such integration is particularly necessary before applying population-comparison findings to education, mental health, or any intervention that presumes the same constructs and performance standards across groups Kim & Sasaki (2014) Qu et al. (2021).

Multisite Neuroscience, Scanner Effects, and Statistical Generalization

An international imaging comparison often confounds participant population with acquisition site. If all participants from one setting are scanned on one machine and all participants from another setting on a second, systematic differences in hardware, sequences, motion, recruitment, and local experimental practice may mimic or amplify group contrasts. Harmonization can reduce some measurement variance, but it cannot restore causal identification where site and cultural environment are perfectly coupled. Better designs include overlapping calibration samples, repeated visits across sites where feasible, multiple sites per population, and transparent quality-control diagnostics Marek et al. (2022) Qu et al. (2021).

Statistical models should reflect sampling and data structure. Observations from people within schools, families, cities, or scanners are not independent to the same degree as randomly sampled individuals. Multilevel models can estimate within-site and between-site variability while accounting for selected covariates, but their interpretation depends on enough independent sites and correct model specification. Reporting a large sample of individual scans without the number of independent communities may conceal the limited basis for population-level inference. Researchers should report both participant and site counts, missingness, and the substantive meaning of every modeled effect Henrich et al. (2010) Putnick & Bornstein (2016).

Transportability concerns whether an estimated relation can be expected to hold in a population with different distributions of measured effect modifiers. Cultural neuroscience should make the source and target populations explicit and test moderator hypotheses across comparable designs. A neural correlation replicated only in student samples from two wealthy cities does not automatically extend to subsistence communities, different age cohorts, or institutional arrangements. The goal is a calibrated map of conditions under which a mechanism operates, not an indefinite extrapolation from national labels Qu et al. (2021) Han et al. (2013).

Causal Inference, Training, Migration, and Natural Experiments

Observational cultural comparisons identify distributions of exposures and outcomes; they generally leave several causal pathways unresolved. A region-related signal may reflect repeated cultural practices, selection into institutions, common environmental causes, experimental familiarity, or reverse causation through individual interests. Randomized training can test whether a particular experience changes task behavior and neural recruitment. Even then, the manipulation demonstrates an effect of the specified training rather than the causal influence of an entire society. Researchers should define intervention, comparator, outcomes, follow-up interval, and plausible mechanisms before scanning Li (2003) Park & Huang (2010).

Migration studies can exploit changes in linguistic environment, family expectations, and educational or occupational routines. Longitudinal comparisons before and after relocation may clarify within-person change, but migration is selective and often coincides with stress, income changes, discrimination, or disrupted social ties. Natural experiments involving policy or schooling can support causal inference when assignment mechanisms and counterfactual assumptions are defensible. Instrumental variable or difference-in-differences methods are useful only when their assumptions match the real institutional setting. A cultural explanation becomes more credible as these assumptions are made visible and tested Qu et al. (2021) Henrich et al. (2010).

The most informative projects connect experimental control with ecological specificity. An intervention could teach a strategy common in a local community while measuring participants' baseline use of that strategy and later application outside the scanner. Replication across communities would test whether the mechanism is portable; long-term follow-up would distinguish immediate task learning from persistent developmental adaptation. Neural mediation analysis would require caution about measurement error, confounding between mediator and outcome, and the temporal ordering of changes. Mechanism is earned by design, not by the anatomical detail of a colorful statistical image Han et al. (2013) Li (2003).

Reproducibility, Publication Bias, and the Quality of the Evidence

Much foundational cultural neuroscience consists of suggestive experiments with focused regional contrasts, small recruited samples, and theoretical interpretations developed during the field's rapid emergence. These studies established testable questions and important methods, but strength of evidence varies. Some findings rely on independent behavioral research or converge across tasks; others have fewer direct replications under equivalent conditions. A scientifically responsible synthesis identifies the original design, the sampled participants, the measured contrast, and the difference between a successful statistical comparison and a confirmed general mechanism Kitayama & Uskul (2011) Han et al. (2013).

Replication should reproduce the theoretically relevant manipulation while changing factors likely to cause artificial stability. Independent laboratories can examine whether effects survive alternative scanners, stimulus sets, analysis strategies, and recruitment pools. Preregistered outcome definitions and public analysis code reduce the influence of flexible modeling, while precise effect estimates and uncertainty intervals improve interpretation. The need for adequate sample size is particularly important for correlations between individual psychological characteristics and complex whole-brain measures. Large-scale evidence on the instability of many brain-wide associations reinforces the need for explicit power and precision planning Marek et al. (2022).

Evidence synthesis should preserve contradictions. If some tasks show attention-related activation differences but other tasks do not, theories must specify when culturally patterned strategies should be expressed. If experimental priming produces temporary changes while long-term longitudinal evidence is absent, flexibility should be distinguished from durable developmental reorganization. If ecological gene-frequency associations lack individual-level replication, the coevolutionary mechanism remains an hypothesis. The most useful assessment is a graded account of which results replicate, what constructs they support, and which inferences require future data Border et al. (2019) Chiao et al. (2010) Qu et al. (2021).

A Structured Evidence Appraisal Across Research Programs

The attentional-control literature offers direct experimental evidence that task context and cultural sampling can interact with neural recruitment, with mechanistic interpretation constrained by performance and familiarity. Self-representation studies document conditional patterns in medial prefrontal responses and demonstrate that experimentally salient cultural orientation can alter neural contrasts. Visual processing studies differentiate face and object responses rather than establishing one universal pattern. Emotion investigations identify context-sensitive social signal processing but require independent evidence about emotion recognition and exposure histories. Each literature contributes a bounded observation about a particular process Hedden et al. (2008) Zhu et al. (2007) Goh et al. (2010) Chiao et al. (2008).

Developmental cultural neuroscience identifies a serious representativeness problem and advances prospective designs connecting family, institutional, and social experiences to brain–behavior trajectories. Evidence on adolescent prosocial reward and family-related motivation offers examples of socially meaningful mechanisms that may be measured in development. In contrast, broad claims about how particular childhood cultural practices construct adult neural differences remain less directly tested than cross-sectional group contrasts. The stronger research path combines ecological measurements with within-person change and prospective developmental follow-up Qu et al. (2021) Telzer et al. (2013) Li (2003).

Genetic accounts require the most careful separation of theoretical possibility and demonstrated mechanism. Gene–culture coevolution is a legitimate multigenerational research framework, but ecological associations involving a candidate polymorphism cannot establish gene-level psychological causation. Later high-powered candidate-gene reassessment in a related mental-health field demonstrates why small-study positive associations must receive rigorous replication. Across the full dossier, the hierarchy of claims runs from measured task effects through convergent behavioral correlates and prospective mechanisms toward multilevel causal models that remain research objectives Chiao & Blizinsky (2010) Border et al. (2019).

Community Collaboration and Responsible Knowledge Production

International cultural neuroscience benefits from partnerships that begin before data collection. Researchers embedded in the communities under study can identify the local significance of social categories, tasks, and practices; negotiate consent procedures; and clarify findings that appear anomalous under externally imposed assumptions. Participation in theoretical design improves construct validity because the inquiry can represent meaningful differences without losing comparability. Local scientific leadership, transparent agreements about data stewardship, and opportunities to contest inaccurate interpretations are therefore methodological resources as well as ethical commitments Qu et al. (2021) Putnick & Bornstein (2016).

Research governance must account for individual privacy and group-level consequences. Neural and genomic data can be sensitive, while public descriptions of populations can be repurposed to justify unsupported biological rankings. Ethical reports state what was measured, how participants were recruited, which factors remained uncontrolled, and the uncertainty of any population inference. Responsible authors avoid converting a group-mean laboratory contrast into claims about a country's inherent temperament or cognitive potential. This standard follows directly from the sampling and construct-validity requirements of the field Henrich et al. (2010) Kim & Sasaki (2014).

Local scientific capacity also shapes what can be studied. A program relying exclusively on expensive MRI facilities will disproportionately recruit populations near wealthy institutions and may privilege tasks familiar to university-educated volunteers. Collaboratively selected behavioral methods, EEG where appropriate, mobile assessment, and training of local research teams can improve geographic reach. The resulting evidence will be more informative when it is matched to clearly defined questions, adequately powered, and made available through data-sharing practices consistent with participant consent and community expectations Qu et al. (2021) Han et al. (2013).

Cultural Change, Media, and the Artificial Era

Digital platforms, machine translation, algorithmic recommendation, and human–artificial interactions increasingly structure exposure to language, social signals, information, and norms. These environments are relevant to biocultural development because they may alter the frequency and timing of learning opportunities. A child who learns through multilingual media, a worker who practices decisions with an artificial assistant, and a migrant who sustains transnational relationships encounter distinct patterned experiences. Cultural neuroscience can investigate how those experiences relate to attention, memory, social learning, and reward, using operational measures of exposure rather than general labels of technological modernity Li (2003) Qu et al. (2021).

The Artificial Era provides a research horizon for extending cultural neurodevelopmental questions to mediated environments. It does not by itself establish new neural mechanisms or demonstrate psychological properties of artificial systems. The scientifically testable question concerns humans: whether repeated interaction with digitally organized cultural material influences behavioral strategies and neural processing, under what circumstances, and relative to what alternative experiences. Proposed longitudinal and experimental studies could distinguish the effects of language learning, interface familiarity, delegated memory, perceived social presence, and institutional demands Han et al. (2013) Park & Huang (2010).

Artificial systems can also become research instruments: adaptive tasks, multilingual instructions, and remote data collection may allow broader sampling. Their outputs require validation for linguistic fairness, consistent task difficulty, transparency, and data privacy. If an algorithm presents systematically different materials across communities, its recommendation rules become part of the exposure under study rather than a neutral delivery mechanism. Future cultural neuroscience should investigate these environments within the same principles of construct definition, causal comparison, longitudinal measurement, and ethical local participation that govern established field research Putnick & Bornstein (2016) Qu et al. (2021).

Outstanding Questions in Biocultural Development

The field has yet to determine how reliably adult neural differences can be traced to particular developmental experiences. Longitudinal cross-cultural cohorts are difficult to construct and retain, and many purported cultural exposures co-vary with school systems, socioeconomic conditions, language, health, and migration. Research needs precise models predicting when an exposure affects behavior, which neural measure captures the relevant operation, how effects accumulate or reverse, and what differences should be observable after training. A longitudinal account is stronger when it identifies a specific mechanism rather than repeating the general statement that culture shapes the brain Li (2003) Qu et al. (2021).

Further questions concern measurement invariance and the relationship between task performance and neural responses. When two communities recruit different strategies for a nominally identical task, should the research compare the same stimulus sequence or the same psychologically meaningful difficulty? There is no universal answer; the choice follows the estimand. Studies should report both forms of comparison when possible and use qualitative observation to interpret what the task accomplishes in each setting. Multisite replication must address acquisition differences, statistical multiplicity, and individual variation before asserting generalization Hedden et al. (2008) Putnick & Bornstein (2016).

Gene–culture models require genomic and historical evidence that is capable of distinguishing ancestry, migration, selection, and cultural transmission. Emotion research needs richer naturalistic stimuli and explicit models of social context. Developmental imaging needs participants from more varied regions and institutions, with attention to education, resources, and within-group heterogeneity. Digital environments offer new opportunities to study cultural learning but also change the exposure landscape rapidly. Collectively these needs call for theories specifying reproducible links between practices, psychological functions, and biological measurements across timescales Border et al. (2019) Kim & Sasaki (2014) Qu et al. (2021).

Scientific Synthesis of Culture, Brain, and Development

The reviewed literature supports three interconnected findings. First, culturally relevant tasks and meanings can covary with recruitment of neural systems involved in attention, visual processing, self-reference, and social signal evaluation. Second, such effects can be context-sensitive, as illustrated by designs that vary task demands or make alternative identity orientations salient. Third, the developmental origin and generalizability of these effects require evidence extending beyond single-time-point neural contrasts. These findings make cultural neuroscience a productive interdisciplinary research program when its interpretations remain linked to the actual operations and populations measured Hedden et al. (2008) Chiao et al. (2010) Han et al. (2013).

Biocultural development places these results within a larger model of reciprocal influence across experience, biological maturation, and changing environments. Neural response differences during a laboratory task represent one observable point in that system. The stronger explanatory challenge is to establish which repeated practices, at which developmental stages and under which social conditions, produce changes that persist or generalize. Prospective cohorts, interventions, developmental ecological measurement, and transparent multimodal experiments are complementary approaches to that challenge. Gene–culture theories may address still longer timescales, but their evidence must be evaluated separately from individual neuroplasticity Li (2003) Qu et al. (2021).

Scientific synthesis therefore calls for an explicitly multilevel account: carefully described environments and activities, valid constructs, behavioral function, physiological measurement, temporal change, and defensible population inference. Research quality increases as explanations become more local to identified mechanisms and more general through independent tests across settings. A coherent theory of cultural neurodevelopment will be one that predicts which experiences change which processes, with measured uncertainty and clear counterfactual comparisons, while retaining the real heterogeneity of human social life Putnick & Bornstein (2016) Marek et al. (2022).

Conclusion

Cultural neuroscience and biocultural development investigate the development and operation of the human brain within patterned social environments. The literature documents differences in neural responses associated with culturally relevant judgments of self and close others, attentional-control demands, social signals, and selected forms of visual processing. These observations are important because they show that explanations of cognition and emotion benefit from specifying the practices and meanings under which tasks are performed. Their interpretation remains conditional on experimental design, behavioral corroboration, measurement validity, and the sampled populations Zhu et al. (2007) Hedden et al. (2008) Chiao et al. (2008).

The developmental evidence establishes a research agenda linking cultural participation with neural processes over time. Biocultural plasticity operates through learning and changing life conditions, while theories of gene–culture coevolution concern population histories and evolutionary timescales requiring separate evidence. Current studies justify neither a simple cultural map of brain types nor automatic causal claims from cross-sectional neuroimaging differences. Stronger evidence will emerge from multisite longitudinal designs, experimentally identified exposures, reproducible analyses, and more representative sampling with precise environmental and socioeconomic description Li (2003) Border et al. (2019) Qu et al. (2021).

The central conclusion is that cultural experience is a measurable dimension of human neurocognitive development, and the mechanisms of its influence can be investigated at behavioral, neural, developmental, and social levels. A mature cultural neuroscience will join original experiments with locally valid concepts, collaborative fieldwork, longitudinal evidence, and careful causal reasoning. Its significance extends to culturally diverse human communities and emerging mediated environments within the Artificial Era, where new learning practices create further empirically tractable questions about the organization of human cognition and development Kitayama & Uskul (2011) Kim & Sasaki (2014) Qu et al. (2021).

References

  • Border, R., Johnson, E. C., Evans, L. M., Smolen, A., Berley, N., Sullivan, P. F., & Keller, M. C. (2019). No support for historical candidate gene or candidate gene-by-interaction hypotheses for major depression across multiple large samples. American Journal of Psychiatry, 176(5), 376–387. https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ajp.2018.18070881
  • Chiao, J. Y. (2009). Cultural neuroscience: A once and future discipline. Progress in Brain Research, 178, 287–304. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0079-6123(09)17821-4
  • Chiao, J. Y., & Blizinsky, K. D. (2010). Culture–gene coevolution of individualism–collectivism and the serotonin transporter gene. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 277(1681), 529–537. https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2009.1650
  • Chiao, J. Y., Harada, T., Komeda, H., Li, Z., Mano, Y., Saito, D., Parrish, T. B., Sadato, N., & Iidaka, T. (2009). Neural basis of individualistic and collectivistic views of self. Human Brain Mapping, 30(9), 2813–2820. https://doi.org/10.1002/hbm.20707
  • Chiao, J. Y., Harada, T., Komeda, H., Li, Z., Mano, Y., Saito, D., Parrish, T. B., Sadato, N., & Iidaka, T. (2010). Dynamic cultural influences on neural representations of the self. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience, 22(1), 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1162/jocn.2009.21192
  • Chiao, J. Y., Hariri, A. R., Harada, T., Mano, Y., Sadato, N., Parrish, T. B., & Iidaka, T. (2010). Theory and methods in cultural neuroscience. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience, 5(2–3), 356–361. https://doi.org/10.1093/scan/nsq063
  • Chiao, J. Y., Iidaka, T., Gordon, H. L., Nogawa, J., Bar, M., Aminoff, E., Sadato, N., & Ambady, N. (2008). Cultural specificity in amygdala response to fear faces. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience, 20(12), 2167–2174. https://doi.org/10.1162/jocn.2008.20151
  • Goh, J. O., Chee, M. W., Tan, J. C., Venkatraman, V., Hebrank, A., Leshikar, E. D., Jenkins, L., Sutton, B. P., Gutchess, A. H., & Park, D. C. (2007). Age and culture modulate object processing and object–scene binding in the ventral visual area. Cognitive, Affective, & Behavioral Neuroscience, 7(1), 44–52. https://doi.org/10.3758/cabn.7.1.44
  • Goh, J. O. S., Leshikar, E. D., Sutton, B. P., Tan, J. C., Sim, S. K. Y., Hebrank, A. C., & Park, D. C. (2010). Culture differences in neural processing of faces and houses in the ventral visual cortex. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience, 5(2–3), 227–235. https://doi.org/10.1093/scan/nsq060
  • Han, S., & Northoff, G. (2008). Culture-sensitive neural substrates of human cognition: A transcultural neuroimaging approach. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 9, 646–654. https://doi.org/10.1038/nrn2456
  • Han, S., Northoff, G., Vogeley, K., Wexler, B. E., Kitayama, S., & Varnum, M. E. W. (2013). A cultural neuroscience approach to the biosocial nature of the human brain. Annual Review of Psychology, 64, 335–359. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-psych-071112-054629
  • Hedden, T., Ketay, S., Aron, A., Markus, H. R., & Gabrieli, J. D. E. (2008). Cultural influences on neural substrates of attentional control. Psychological Science, 19(1), 12–17. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9280.2008.02038.x
  • Henrich, J., Heine, S. J., & Norenzayan, A. (2010). The weirdest people in the world? Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 33(2–3), 61–83. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0140525X0999152X
  • Kim, H. S., & Sasaki, J. Y. (2014). Cultural neuroscience: Biology of the mind in cultural contexts. Annual Review of Psychology, 65, 487–514. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-psych-010213-115040
  • Kitayama, S., & Uskul, A. K. (2011). Culture, mind, and the brain: Current evidence and future directions. Annual Review of Psychology, 62, 419–449. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-psych-120709-145357
  • Li, S.-C. (2003). Biocultural orchestration of developmental plasticity across levels: The interplay of biology and culture in shaping the mind and behavior across the life span. Psychological Bulletin, 129(2), 171–194. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.129.2.171
  • Marek, S., Tervo-Clemmens, B., Calabro, F. J., Montez, D. F., Kay, B. P., Hatoum, A. S., Donohue, M. R., Foran, W., Miller, R. L., Hendrickson, T. J., Malone, S. M., Kandala, S., Feczko, E., Miranda-Dominguez, O., Graham, A. M., Earl, E. A., Perrone, A. J., Cordova, M., Doyle, O., ... Dosenbach, N. U. F. (2022). Reproducible brain-wide association studies require thousands of individuals. Nature, 603, 654–660. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-022-04492-9
  • Masuda, T., & Nisbett, R. E. (2001). Attending holistically versus analytically: Comparing the context sensitivity of Japanese and Americans. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 81(5), 922–934. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.81.5.922
  • Nisbett, R. E., Peng, K., Choi, I., & Norenzayan, A. (2001). Culture and systems of thought: Holistic versus analytic cognition. Psychological Review, 108(2), 291–310. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.108.2.291
  • Park, D. C., & Huang, C.-M. (2010). Culture wires the brain: A cognitive neuroscience perspective. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 5(4), 391–400. https://doi.org/10.1177/1745691610374591
  • Putnick, D. L., & Bornstein, M. H. (2016). Measurement invariance conventions and reporting: The state of the art and future directions for psychological research. Developmental Review, 41, 71–90. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dr.2016.06.004
  • Qu, Y., Jorgensen, N. A., & Telzer, E. H. (2021). A call for greater attention to culture in the study of brain and development. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 16(2), 275–293. https://doi.org/10.1177/1745691620931461
  • Telzer, E. H., Fuligni, A. J., Lieberman, M. D., & Galván, A. (2013). Meaningful family relationships: Neurocognitive buffers of adolescent risk taking. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience, 25(3), 374–387. https://doi.org/10.1162/jocn_a_00331
  • Telzer, E. H., Fuligni, A. J., Lieberman, M. D., & Galván, A. (2013). Ventral striatum activation to prosocial rewards predicts longitudinal declines in adolescent risk taking. Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience, 3, 45–52. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dcn.2012.08.004
  • Zhu, Y., Zhang, L., Fan, J., & Han, S. (2007). Neural basis of cultural influence on self-representation. NeuroImage, 34(3), 1310–1316. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2006.08.047