RESEARCH DOSSIER
Cultural Cognition
Abstract. Cultural cognition investigates how socially transmitted practices, meanings, environments, and relational expectations shape the operations through which people attend to, interpret, remember, and reason about information. This critical narrative research monograph examines the conceptual development of cultural psychology; analytic and holistic processing; cross-cultural experiments on contextual attention, the framed-line test, eye movements, categorization, causal attribution, and dialectical reasoning; and contemporary theories connecting cultural tasks, social orientation, visual ecology, livelihood, and norms to cognitive performance. Its critical analysis distinguishes group-level comparisons from individual traits, observational differences from causal inference, and proximal experimental manipulations from developmental and historical hypotheses. The synthesis integrates original experiments, methodological findings, and peer-reviewed reviews and identifies open problems of measurement invariance, sampling, replication, mediation, and generalizability. It also outlines evidence-driven research questions for human–artificial cognitive environments. No new experiment or independent empirical theory is claimed.
Keywords: cultural cognition; cultural psychology; cross-cultural cognition; analytic and holistic processing; contextual attention; framed-line test; cultural differences in perception; causal attribution; categorization; dialectical reasoning; independent and interdependent self-construal; cultural neuroscience; ecological psychology; cross-cultural measurement; human–artificial cognitive interaction
The Scientific Object of Cultural Cognition
Cultural cognition is the investigation of how socially learned meanings, practices, institutions, material environments, and recurrent relationships shape the selection, interpretation, organization, and use of information. Its observable domain includes attention to objects and contexts, perceptual judgments, causal attribution, conceptual classification, inference, memory, and reasoning under culturally meaningful task demands. Culture enters this definition as a pattern of historically transmitted and presently enacted activities, rather than a country label or a personal essence. The central question is how patterned participation in social worlds changes the conditions under which general cognitive capacities are expressed Nisbett et al. (2001) Kitayama & Salvador (2024).
The term identifies a scientific intersection. Cognitive psychology describes representational and information-processing operations, cultural psychology studies the reciprocal formation of persons and their social worlds, and cross-cultural research tests the transportability of particular findings between populations. An experimental difference between national samples establishes a population contrast under the tested conditions. Explaining that contrast requires separately examining social orientation, language, educational practice, perceptual ecology, task interpretation, and selection effects. A cultural interpretation becomes stronger when a proposed mediating process is measured or experimentally manipulated, rather than inferred from nationality alone Varnum et al. (2010) Miyamoto et al. (2006).
This monograph evaluates a critical narrative body of original experiments, theoretical articles, comparative studies, and methodological analyses. Its research questions concern the existence, functional organization, causal conditions, generalizability, developmental acquisition, and measurement of cultural variation in cognition. It treats the analytic–holistic distinction as one influential research program within a broader domain. Evidence from folk biology, social attribution, self-construal, and ecological differences expands the inquiry beyond a single contrast between East Asian and Euro-American students Medin & Atran (2004) Bender & Beller (2016).
Culture as an Explanatory Variable
A cultural explanation requires an account of exposure and participation. Repeated communicative conventions, norms of coordination, visual settings, schooling, occupational practices, and shared explanatory frameworks can change what is salient, what information a person trusts, and which actions count as competent in a particular setting. Researchers can operationalize these influences through socialization histories, task-specific norms, behavioral observations, language usage, experimentally presented cues, and documented local ecological conditions. Such indicators refer to different causal pathways; combining them under one national dummy variable obscures precisely what a theory aims to explain Kitayama & Salvador (2024).
Culture can occupy several locations in a causal model. It may structure the environment that supplies information, train expectations about relevant evidence, furnish conventional categories, stabilize social incentives, or alter the interpretation of an experimental request. Some proposed influences are slow, arising through years of learning; others operate through transient cues and situational roles. Demonstrations that priming relational or autonomous self-representations changes performance support a role for accessible cultural meanings, while leaving open the relative contribution of durable experience, demand effects, and measurement features Kühnen et al. (2001) Oyserman & Lee (2008).
The explanatory units must be specified with equal precision. A cultural community is an imperfect proxy for heterogeneous memberships, and people can move among linguistic, institutional, familial, and digital settings over the course of a day. Cultural environments also change across generations. A well-formed claim therefore identifies who was observed, the task and its language, where the behavior occurred, which contrast was estimated, and what inferential scope is justified. The distinction between a contextual explanation and a permanent national stereotype is essential for both scientific validity and interpretation of observed individual differences Na et al. (2010) Henrich et al. (2010).
Intellectual History and the Comparative Problem
Research on cultural cognition emerged from several traditions: anthropological study of local systems of knowledge, experimental analysis of perception and reasoning, developmental examination of conceptual acquisition, and cultural psychology's account of the mutual constitution of person and environment. The modern field acquired unusual prominence when investigators began to compare performance in closely matched laboratory paradigms across different social contexts. These comparisons challenged the practice of treating findings from a small set of university populations as direct evidence about a universal psychological mechanism Henrich et al. (2010) Bender & Beller (2016).
Markus and Kitayama's influential 1991 analysis placed culturally patterned independence and interdependence within a framework linking self-understanding to cognition, emotion, and motivation. Morris and Peng subsequently examined culturally distributed explanations of social events, while Peng and Nisbett tested culturally different approaches to contradictory propositions. Nisbett and colleagues' 2001 synthesis linked attention, causality, categorization, and reasoning to broader systems of thought. These works helped turn isolated contrasts into a research program with identifiable constructs, predictions, and experimental tasks Markus & Kitayama (1991) Morris & Peng (1994) Peng & Nisbett (1999) Nisbett et al. (2001).
The historical narrative also contains important corrective developments. Controlled manipulations of self-relevant cues and perceptual environments tested causal candidates; studies within large countries challenged a simple geographic divide; research on measurement showed that group-level patterns do not necessarily map onto coherent individual traits. The criticism of WEIRD sampling gave the methodological challenge an institutional formulation. Recent syntheses explicitly situate cognition within multiple cultural zones and ecological complexes rather than one East–West continuum Miyamoto et al. (2006) Talhelm et al. (2014) Na et al. (2010) Kitayama & Salvador (2024).
Analytic and Holistic Processing as Research Constructs
Analytic processing ordinarily denotes selective focus on focal objects, assignment to relatively stable categories, and explanation through object properties or explicit rules. Holistic processing denotes comparatively greater attention to relationships and background, contextual explanations, and sensitivity to how elements form an organized field. The two descriptions are idealized patterns derived from specific comparisons. They identify a family of hypotheses about attentional distribution and inferential preference, not two discrete classes of mind. Their usefulness depends on predictions that can be operationalized in tasks with competing focal and contextual demands Nisbett et al. (2001).
The same participant may pursue an analytic solution during one activity and a contextual solution during another. Task instructions, expertise, motivation, visual complexity, educational practice, and performance criterion all alter the response that is adaptive. Because different measures sample different operations, one cannot assume that successful relative-line reproduction, background fixation, and situational attribution are manifestations of a single stable latent factor. Investigators must establish the empirical correlations and measurement invariance of indicators before constructing an individual-level cognitive-style score Na et al. (2010).
Comparative claims also require careful language. East Asia and the West are labels for historically and internally diverse regions. Results from Chinese, Japanese, Korean, or American university participants do not license statements about every member of their societies. A meaningful account of analytic–holistic contrasts therefore treats reported differences as conditional distributions with substantial overlap, asks what cultural practices may produce them, and searches for contexts where a predicted difference becomes smaller, reverses, or disappears Kitayama et al. (2009) Ji et al. (2000).
Frameworks of Self, Relationship, and Cultural Task
Independent and interdependent self-construals are influential theoretical explanations of cultural cognition. Independent self-understanding foregrounds distinct personal attributes and autonomous choice; interdependent self-understanding emphasizes relational location, mutual responsiveness, and the self as constituted in ongoing social ties. Markus and Kitayama proposed that these orientations shape how situations are interpreted, which goals are activated, and what forms of attention support effective action. The proposed relation is psychologically plausible because categorization and attention are recruited in the service of situated objectives Markus & Kitayama (1991).
Research on cultural tasks sharpened this explanation by studying recurrent activities through which culturally meaningful goals become enacted. Kitayama and colleagues compared North America, Western Europe, and East Asia, finding that North American forms of implicit independence differed in several measures even from Western European samples. This evidence argues against treating independence as a simple property of every society categorized as Western. It also illustrates why explanatory models benefit from concrete practices and reward structures rather than broad geographic shorthand Kitayama et al. (2009).
The social-orientation hypothesis predicts relations between culturally typical forms of social coordination and attentional or inferential organization. Reviews identify studies designed to distinguish social orientation from alternative causes, including linguistic and ecological factors Varnum et al. (2010). Yet culture, person, and situation interact, and the meaning of the same individual difference can vary across contexts. An adequate framework specifies the social activity, the cognitive demand it imposes, and the boundary conditions under which one processing strategy becomes advantageous Leung & Cohen (2011).
Contextual Attention in Dynamic Scenes
The best-known behavioral paradigms compare responses to a focal object embedded within an informative setting. Masuda and Nisbett asked Japanese and American participants to describe animated underwater events and later recognize previously encountered objects in original or changed contexts. Japanese participants reported more contextual relationships, and the recognition of objects depended more strongly on preserving the original setting. The tasks therefore connected verbal description, perceptual organization, and recognition memory within a common research question Masuda & Nisbett (2001).
Those findings are informative because they distinguish what observers report from what they subsequently recognize. A difference in description might reflect conversational convention, whereas a context-dependent recognition pattern suggests that the relationship between target and background entered the memory representation or retrieval conditions. Neither outcome independently settles whether early vision, allocation of attention, encoding strategy, or decision threshold drives the contrast. Experiments that combine report, eye movements, and later memory reduce the number of plausible explanations without eliminating all of them.
Laboratory stimuli pose a generalization problem: artificial animated scenes can be easier to control while lacking the density, familiarity, and learned affordances of real environments. A stronger program samples varied settings, counterbalances object salience, standardizes presentation, and checks whether unfamiliarity changes eye movements or memory. Field-based observation of habitual attention would add ecological breadth but introduce selection and environmental confounds. The scientific value of controlled and naturalistic methods lies in their complementary ability to isolate and contextualize a measured difference Miyamoto et al. (2006).
Contextual attention must also be separated from accuracy in a universal sense. Focal extraction can be useful when a task requires identifying a discrete object; relational encoding can be useful when background is diagnostic or changes the object's meaning. Consequently performance advantages can reverse with task criteria, and a comparative result often establishes differential adaptation to demands rather than an absolute superiority of a processing mode. The empirical object is the distribution of attention relative to a specified informational purpose Nisbett et al. (2001).
Eye Movements and the Perceptual Sampling Hypothesis
Eye tracking provides a measurement of where and when observers direct overt visual attention. Chua, Boland, and Nisbett compared Chinese and American participants viewing photographs composed of a salient foreground object and a complex background. Americans fixated the focal objects earlier and more extensively; Chinese participants made more movements toward background regions. The experiment furnished a process measure consistent with the claim that cultural experience can influence the sampling of visual information before an explicit verbal judgment is rendered Chua et al. (2005).
Fixations are an important but incomplete index of cognition. Viewers can allocate covert attention away from the eyes' point of fixation, and looking longer at a region can indicate difficulty, uncertainty, familiarity, task importance, or different encoding strategies. Eye movements therefore cannot be translated directly into a claim about a person's worldview or the contents of an unobserved belief. The value of the finding increases when paired with task instructions, independent comprehension measures, and memory tests that connect observed gaze behavior to a defined cognitive operation.
A rigorous replication should control visual properties of stimulus sets, screen geometry, calibration quality, instructions, and the distribution of relevant targets. Cross-population comparisons further require checking visual familiarity and whether all groups interpret the instruction to observe a picture similarly. Sampling different everyday contexts can reveal whether the original contrast is robust or specific to densely populated, ambiguous backgrounds. Cultural history may affect gaze strategies through environmental learning, social attention norms, or deliberate task goals; measured gaze differences alone do not identify the pathway Miyamoto et al. (2006).
Theoretically, eye-movement evidence shows how culture can enter cognition at the interface between environmental availability and moment-to-moment information acquisition. Two perceivers may look at identical stimuli and receive systematically different effective inputs because their sequences of fixations differ. Such an account supplies a plausible bridge from cultural practice to memory and judgment, but it remains conditional on demonstrating that culturally patterned sampling mediates later performance rather than merely covarying with it Chua et al. (2005).
The Framed-Line Test and Relational Geometry
The framed-line test isolates a perceptual conflict between reproducing an object's absolute magnitude and reproducing its relation to an enclosing frame. Participants observe a line inside a square and later reproduce either the original line length or its proportional length in another square. Kitayama, Duffy, Kawamura, and Larsen used this design to compare Japanese and American performance. Japanese participants were more accurate under relative instructions, while Americans showed an advantage when an absolute match was requested Kitayama et al. (2003).
The crucial feature is that the relevant stimulus remains visually comparable while the scoring rule changes. Relative judgments reward encoding line-to-frame relations; absolute judgments reward separation of the line from its context. The reported interaction supports a culturally patterned task preference or processing tendency, yet the evidence cannot in isolation determine whether perception, remembered magnitude, drawing ability, response strategy, or familiarity with geometric testing is responsible. Detailed error distributions and response-time analysis can discriminate among competing accounts.
Performance on the framed-line test also raises measurement questions. Difference scores across two conditions may be sensitive to ceiling effects, motor variability, and how the procedure is explained. A researcher should examine within-person stability across sessions, internal consistency when multiple stimuli are used, and correspondence with other tests purportedly measuring holism. Without that work, the test is evidence of a task-specific contrast rather than a stand-alone diagnostic instrument that classifies cultural cognition at the individual level Na et al. (2010).
The same experiment has a theoretical virtue: temporary participation in another cultural environment was associated with shifts toward its more common processing pattern. This points toward cognitive plasticity and experience-dependent organization, although observational comparisons of migrants or sojourners require accounting for selection and adaptation histories. A broader theory should specify the duration and intensity of exposure required for a measurable change, its persistence, and the kinds of contextual demands that call it forth Kitayama et al. (2003).
Visual Ecology and Situated Perception
Cultural environments are themselves sources of structured perceptual information. Miyamoto, Nisbett, and Masuda compared photographs of Japanese and American urban settings, assessing visual complexity and ambiguity. In a further experiment, exposure to scenes from one environment influenced participants' subsequent contextual attention. Because the prime was presented within an experiment, the findings suggest that at least part of a contextual-attention pattern can be affected by immediate perceptual ecology, even across participants from different national populations Miyamoto et al. (2006).
This work makes an explanatory advance by specifying a manipulable environmental property instead of assuming a generalized national mentality. Dense fields with many potentially relevant objects can encourage broad sampling and relational detection, while sparse settings may support focal extraction. Yet the contrast can be correlated with architecture, signage, social density, learned reading habits, and prior experience. A complete ecological explanation requires isolating the active features and testing their effect over both short and developmental timescales.
Perceptual affordances also interact with the task's subjective meaning. A person instructed to identify an object for later recognition may adopt focal attention even in an otherwise relational visual environment. Conversely, a social coordination task may induce distributed attention in a sparse scene. The cultural pattern arises through the joint organization of environmental structure, acquired skill, and active goal. This is why situational experiments form a necessary counterpart to comparisons between country samples Miyamoto & Wilken (2010).
Contemporary ecological accounts increasingly connect the built environment with livelihoods, institutions, and repetitive practices. The resulting causal chain is multilayered: ecology affects opportunities for coordinated action, practices stabilize attentional expectations, and expectations influence sampling during a new task. Every link warrants its own evidence. A study demonstrating environmental priming supports the proximal link; a claim about long-run historical causality needs developmental, longitudinal, or quasi-experimental confirmation Kitayama & Salvador (2024).
Field Dependence, Covariation, and Perceived Control
Ji, Peng, and Nisbett investigated cultural differences in detecting environmental covariation and in visual field dependence. In their studies, Chinese participants tended to report stronger event associations and greater responsiveness to covariation; Americans showed an advantage in the rod-and-frame measure of field independence. Importantly, experimental manipulation of perceived control affected some cultural contrasts. These results connect cultural cognition to beliefs about action and control, rather than reducing the findings to a single perceptual capacity Ji et al. (2000).
Covariation detection asks whether two events occur together more often than expected. Accuracy depends on base rates, trial sampling, memory for co-occurrence, confidence, and response criteria. A higher tendency to perceive relationships can reflect greater sensitivity when genuine covariation exists and more false associations when it does not. Accordingly, comparing participant groups requires examining signal and noise conditions rather than assuming that more relational responses are invariably more accurate.
Perceived control matters because individuals may process an environment differently when they expect their intervention to alter an outcome. Control manipulations introduce motivational and causal-attribution components into tasks previously classified as purely perceptual. They also suggest why an observed cultural gap can disappear in a condition that changes the participant's role. The field must distinguish experimentally demonstrated moderation by perceived control from the larger hypothesis that cultural socialization routinely produces those motivational conditions Ji et al. (2000).
Together, field dependence and covariation findings sharpen the definition of cultural cognition. The object is not a fixed visual style; it includes the predictive relationships that learners extract from environments and the goals under which they evaluate these relationships. A model with explicit task control, baseline performance, and competing cues is more informative than an undifferentiated score for holistic thinking. Subsequent replications should assess how distinct these operations remain across tasks and populations Na et al. (2010).
Categorization, Similarity, and Conceptual Relations
Categorization converts a potentially unbounded array of experiences into manageable classes that support prediction and action. A category can be organized taxonomically, by shared defining properties, or thematically, by relationships among objects and events. Cultural cognition research asks which relations become salient when several defensible classifications compete. Norenzayan, Smith, Kim, and Nisbett presented tasks in which intuitive thematic similarity and a formal rule could lead to different answers; responses differed across the sampled university populations Norenzayan et al. (2002).
The distinction is experimentally useful only when the conflict is explicit. In ordinary settings, rule-based and relational classification can converge, yielding an apparently universal response regardless of the processes used. Conflict paradigms improve discrimination among hypotheses, although they also add demands of instruction comprehension and metacognitive control. Studies must establish that competing answers are understood as intended and that translation does not privilege one response. Observed cultural preferences in conflict tasks are conditional choices among strategies, rather than evidence that a population lacks formal reasoning Norenzayan et al. (2002).
Folk biological categories illustrate why culturally organized expertise must enter theory. Medin and Atran compared biological reasoning across developmental and cultural settings, arguing that ecological experience and community knowledge can substantially influence how living kinds are classified and used for induction. A learner whose daily work involves plants or animals encounters different diagnostic features from a learner exposed mostly to textbook pictures. Such evidence places local knowledge within cognitive science while retaining the possibility of broadly shared learning capacities Medin & Atran (2004).
The methodological challenge is to disentangle domain familiarity from classificatory process. A thematic response about animals may reflect sophisticated ecological understanding rather than a generic cognitive style. Transfer tests using equally familiar and unfamiliar stimuli, controls for domain expertise, and elicitation of explanations can reveal the operation underlying classification. A general account should specify when culturally acquired conceptual content changes inference and when the structure of an information-processing operation itself changes Bender & Beller (2016).
Causal Attribution and Social Explanation
Causal attribution concerns how observers explain behavior or an event by assigning importance to actors, circumstances, intentions, constraints, and preceding conditions. Morris and Peng compared American and Chinese accounts of social events, newspaper descriptions, and interpretations of violence. Their investigations revealed stronger dispositional explanation in several American contexts and stronger situational interpretation in several Chinese contexts. Contrasts involving physical events did not simply duplicate the social-event findings, indicating a domain-sensitive explanation Morris & Peng (1994).
These results are theoretically consequential because two observers can witness the same behavior yet treat different causal information as decisive. An explanation focused on personal character will support different predictions and counterfactual judgments from an explanation emphasizing social obligations, situational pressure, or opportunity. Causal cognition therefore mediates moral judgment, interpersonal expectations, and institutional responses. However, the act of providing an explanation is itself social; norms about suitable public accounts may affect expressed attributions as well as private causal inference.
Comparing media accounts creates an additional methodological opportunity and risk. Reports of the same event can expose recurring explanatory conventions, but editorial policies, translation, legal framing, and intended readership also influence language. Laboratory vignette experiments offer control over supplied facts while sacrificing some ecological validity. Strong inference triangulates both approaches and considers whether differences remain when participants receive explicit causal evidence and equivalent opportunities to attribute responsibility Morris & Peng (1994).
Attribution studies also show why a single national score cannot represent all cognition. Social explanations may be particularly sensitive to culturally salient interpersonal norms, whereas explanations of mechanical events may vary less under similar task conditions. Domain-specific contrasts should be interpreted alongside work on the cultural logics of honor, dignity, and face, in which the meaning of the social event and the appropriate response vary jointly Leung & Cohen (2011).
Reasoning About Contradictions and Multiple Perspectives
Peng and Nisbett studied ways of responding to apparent contradictions, including preferences for proverbs and interpretations of conflicting claims. Their research described a stronger tendency in some Chinese samples to accommodate opposing perspectives or seek a synthetic middle way, compared with greater differentiation in some American samples. The experimental program situated these preferences within culturally transmitted practices of reasoning, providing a specific test of a theoretical contrast Peng & Nisbett (1999).
A dialectical judgment can preserve evidence from multiple sides of an uncertain issue; formal logical reasoning can identify incompatibility among propositions within a stipulated system. These activities operate under different goals and standards. Endorsement of two everyday claims that appear contradictory need not constitute a violation of elementary logic, because hidden qualifications, changing contexts, or different interpretations may reconcile them. Experimental comparisons should therefore distinguish logical validity, epistemic tolerance, social compromise, and sensitivity to uncertainty Peng & Nisbett (1999).
Norenzayan and colleagues found differences in the relative weight assigned to intuitive and formal responses when those responses conflicted, while observing similarities when conflict was absent. This pattern emphasizes competition among available strategies rather than exclusive possession of a reasoning faculty. A compelling explanation requires measuring beliefs about what the task rewards, the frequency of strategic switching, and the extent to which training or incentive changes the chosen response Norenzayan et al. (2002).
The broader implication is that cognitive diversity can concern the criterion for an adequate answer. A task evaluating strict consistency, one asking for a workable social resolution, and one requesting a forecast under ambiguous evidence impose different normative constraints. Research programs that translate performance on one criterion into an overall measure of rationality risk importing local epistemic values into measurement. Comparative reasoning science becomes stronger when its success standard is explicit and justified by the task Bender & Beller (2016).
Attention to Language, Emotion, and Prosodic Meaning
Language carries propositional content through words and relational information through voice, timing, politeness conventions, and social positioning. Ishii, Reyes, and Kitayama used interference methods to compare attention to verbal meaning and emotional vocal tone. Their studies reported different patterns for American and Japanese participants, while Tagalog–English bilingual participants in the Philippines showed a tone-oriented pattern across tested languages. The findings support an interpretation involving culturally patterned communicative attention as well as linguistic processing Ishii et al. (2003).
An interference paradigm does more than ask participants which aspect they prefer. It measures the cost of disregarding an irrelevant signal when two dimensions compete for response control. This creates leverage for claims about automatic attentional priority, although the degree of automaticity still depends on instructions, stimulus discriminability, repetition, and task familiarity. A finding across languages in a bilingual sample helps challenge a narrow lexical explanation, but broader replication must vary dialect, proficiency, and acoustic properties Ishii et al. (2003).
Culture and language remain analytically separable while historically intertwined. Language provides a representational resource, and social practice regulates which distinctions become useful and worthy of attention. A researcher assessing a culturally variable effect should specify whether the relevant difference concerns a linguistic category, a conversational norm, a memory code, or a contextual goal. A finding attributed to a nation without language-use measurements leaves these mechanisms unresolved Bender & Beller (2016).
Communication research also makes the topic relevant beyond formal reasoning tasks. Interpreting a request, expression of doubt, or social cue can influence the information a person retrieves and how disagreement is resolved. Such phenomena support studying cognition in interaction, where a participant's understanding of what an experimental question asks is itself a target of analysis. The social meaning of a task can be as causally relevant as the perceptual properties of its stimuli Leung & Cohen (2011).
Memory, Retrieval Context, and Representational Organization
Memory research in cultural cognition asks whether learning histories affect the organization of remembered episodes and the circumstances under which information can be recovered. Context-dependent object recognition in Masuda and Nisbett's experiments provides a concrete example: presenting an object against its original background supported recognition differently across compared groups. This result can arise if background features become part of the encoded representation or serve as especially effective retrieval cues Masuda & Nisbett (2001).
The distinction between encoding and retrieval is central. The learner may attend to more contextual properties during initial exposure, or both groups may encode those properties but differ in whether they consult them during the final decision. One can test these explanations by changing backgrounds only during encoding, only at retrieval, or both, and by adding measures of confidence and response latency. Without such controls, a context effect documents a robust phenomenon under the tested paradigm yet leaves its processing stage partially undetermined.
Research must also separate autobiographical or semantic knowledge from event recognition. Cultural practices influence what experiences are narrated, rehearsed, and treated as personally significant. Those differences can plausibly change long-term accessibility, but a laboratory test of visual recognition cannot alone establish a population difference in the architecture of autobiographical memory. Cross-domain inference requires direct measurement and careful controls for language, familiarity, and narrative conventions Markus & Kitayama (1991) Medin & Atran (2004).
The same methodological caution applies to the claim that holistic cognition produces globally superior relational memory. In a memory task where relation is diagnostic, contextual encoding may improve performance; when relation is misleading, selective attention to the target may be beneficial. An adequate account predicts the dependence of accuracy on encoding conditions and task goals, and evaluates false alarms alongside hits. Culture affects the organization of relevant information within precisely specified demands Na et al. (2010).
Cultural Variation Beyond National Dichotomies
Comparing Americans with East Asian samples helped establish replicable questions about cognition, yet the resulting geography is too coarse to define the scientific domain. Communities differ within countries by livelihood, educational opportunities, religion, language, neighborhood ecology, social class, migration history, and institutional arrangements. Kitayama and Salvador's contemporary synthesis explicitly expands comparison beyond East Asia and Western Europe or North America, treating Arab, Latin American, and South Asian cultural zones as necessary parts of psychological theory Kitayama & Salvador (2024).
The scientific point is structural. Two countries can differ along several interrelated dimensions, and their average contrast cannot reveal which dimension is causally active. Sampling additional populations can expose cases where a proposed dimension predicts cognition despite geographic separation, or where groups within one country diverge. Such designs offer stronger tests of a theory than continually comparing the same two familiar student populations. The population structure, recruitment pathway, and exclusion criteria must remain visible in each claim Henrich et al. (2010).
Research on honor, face, and dignity provides an example of cultural logics that organize the social meaning of situations. Leung and Cohen examined how person characteristics, cultural contexts, and situational demands jointly condition behavior. The framework shows why the same response style may have different implications depending on local norms. Although their central outcomes concern social behavior, the theoretical consequences for cultural cognition include interpretation of evidence, salience of reputation, and expectations about causal responsibility Leung & Cohen (2011).
A comprehensive comparative science should include communities frequently excluded from laboratory recruitment, document translation and collaboration procedures, and test the portability of effects across settings. It should also report overlaps among distributions and avoid portraying a single dimension as the full description of a population. The goal is to explain conditional patterns and mechanisms across human settings with increasingly explicit sampling frames Bender & Beller (2016) Kitayama & Salvador (2024).
Within-Culture Variation and Levels of Analysis
Population averages and individual psychological traits answer different questions. Na and colleagues examined measures of social orientation and analytic–holistic cognition and found that dimensions differentiating cultural or social groups were not necessarily coherent individual-difference dimensions inside those groups. Measures that separated sample averages could exhibit weak correlations across individuals. This result challenges the assumption that a useful cultural-level construct must correspond to a stable personality-like cognitive-style factor Na et al. (2010).
Statistically, a relationship among group means can differ from the relationship among participants within a group. Inferring one from the other risks an ecological or atomistic error. A cognitive measure may be reliable for detecting a contrast between independently sampled settings yet insufficiently coherent for predicting an individual's responses on other tasks. Researchers should distinguish the level of theory, level of data aggregation, and level at which explanatory relations are actually estimated Na et al. (2010).
Consequently, questionnaires claiming to measure a global holistic mindset deserve special scrutiny. Their validity requires evidence that reported thoughts correspond to the cognitive operations performed in actual tasks, that the instrument functions comparably across languages, and that scores maintain interpretable relationships with other measures. Translating a scale and comparing national means cannot establish invariance or within-person generalizability. Multilevel designs with independent cohorts and performance indicators provide stronger tests.
Within-population heterogeneity is theoretically productive. Differences by educational specialization, social role, bilingual experience, rural or urban environment, and socioeconomic position can test which learning histories shape specific operations. Such analyses must avoid treating those factors as independent when their distributions overlap. The correct response to heterogeneity is more explanatory precision and appropriately modeled interactions, not abandonment of cross-cultural comparison Kitayama et al. (2009) Talhelm et al. (2014).
Ecology, Agriculture, and Historical Livelihood
One influential ecological hypothesis links long-standing agricultural coordination demands to contemporary social orientation and reasoning. Talhelm and colleagues compared Han Chinese participants across regions historically associated with rice or wheat agriculture. Their 2014 study included 1,162 participants across six sites and reported differences on measures relevant to interdependence and holistic thinking, including analyses near a rice–wheat boundary. The study was designed to examine variation within a single country rather than rely solely on an East–West contrast Talhelm et al. (2014).
The proposed mechanism is historically plausible: wet-rice production has often required intense coordination of water and labor, while certain wheat practices place different demands on mutual dependence. Yet historical agricultural type correlates with climate, settlement history, economic pathways, institutions, education, and contemporary migration. Regional association cannot uniquely identify a long-run causal effect of historical livelihood. The study provides evidence consistent with the hypothesis while inviting scrutiny of how each proposed mediator was measured.
Research can strengthen the claim using longitudinal migration data, family histories, variation across multiple agricultural societies, and independent measures of ongoing coordination practices. Such designs would help differentiate mechanisms transmitted by continuing institutions from effects carried through individual learning or environment. Formal mediation tests must respect temporal order: a presently measured value cannot automatically be treated as a demonstrated mediator of a historical exposure that predates measurement by generations.
Ecological explanation also has a wider scope than agriculture. Urban complexity, disease threat, mobility, institutional sanction, and social coordination systems can reshape the opportunities under which attention and inference develop. Kitayama and Salvador describe these configurations as eco-cultural complexes, connecting geography and social practice to multiple psychological outcomes. A rigorous research agenda evaluates competing pathways and considers whether local adaptations change when economic or technological circumstances change Kitayama & Salvador (2024) Miyamoto et al. (2006).
Norm Strength, Social Regulation, and Situation Meaning
Norms specify what conduct is appropriate, expected, rewarded, or sanctioned in a setting. Gelfand and colleagues examined cultural tightness and looseness across 33 nations, linking the strength of norms and tolerance of deviance to broader ecological and institutional patterns. These dimensions are particularly relevant to cultural cognition because a participant's interpretation of an ambiguous social cue, perceived cost of an error, and willingness to challenge an instruction may depend on local normative expectations Gelfand et al. (2011).
A tight–loose account does not directly imply a particular perceptual advantage. Rather, it furnishes a theory of how contexts affect monitoring of behavioral regularity, expectation violation, and uncertainty. To connect this theory with visual or inferential tasks, an experiment must measure or manipulate norm-relevant cues and show how they alter the cognitive outcome. Otherwise the model remains a plausible contextual hypothesis instead of a demonstrated explanation of an analytic–holistic score.
Research on cultural cognition benefits from measuring what participants believe the experimenter wants. In some settings, a task framed as abstract logic may encourage explicit rules, while an interpersonal scenario elicits deference to roles or concern for relational consequences. These changes may resemble differences in reasoning capacity despite being differences in inferred conversational purpose. Task framing can be controlled, counterbalanced, or examined as an outcome in its own right Miyamoto & Wilken (2010) Leung & Cohen (2011).
Norm strength also complicates generalization from experimental rooms to everyday life. Laboratory cooperation, explicit consent, anonymity, and unusual instructions can produce conditions unlike routine public interactions. Cross-cultural science therefore requires a defensible model of the relation between an experimental situation and the community practices it is meant to approximate. Reporting the setting and its meaning improves interpretability as much as reporting task stimuli Gelfand et al. (2011).
Cultural Neuroscience and the Problem of Neural Explanation
Cultural neuroscience investigates whether socially acquired self-representations and practices are associated with systematic differences in measured neural activity. Chiao and colleagues examined neural responses associated with individualistic and collectivistic self-views and tested culturally relevant self-processing contexts. This research contributes an additional level of observation: activity patterns during a defined task can be studied alongside participants' cultural schemas and behavioral responses Chiao et al. (2010).
Neural contrasts do not establish that cultures possess distinct neural organs or immutable brain types. Functional imaging measures signals indirectly related to local neural activity, and between-group differences depend on task strategy, stimulus interpretation, statistical threshold, motion, recruitment, and preprocessing. Similar observed behavior can involve different measured patterns, while different behaviors can recruit overlapping networks. A neural correlate is one explanatory clue within a multilevel account, rather than a substitute for demonstrating a cognitive mechanism.
Studies of cultural-schema accessibility are especially relevant because they test whether self-representation depends on current interpretive context. The central issue is how acquired meanings modulate task engagement, attention, and self-relevant evaluation. Experimental manipulation, within-person designs, and converging behavioral indicators can make the causal analysis more persuasive, although their conclusions should remain tied to particular manipulations and measurements Chiao et al. (2010) Oyserman & Lee (2008).
Future neurocognitive research needs adequate sample sizes, preregistered contrasts, transparent analysis pipelines, and comparisons across diverse communities. It should report whether observed effects replicate with alternative tasks and whether neural measurements predict behavior outside the scanner. A mature theory of cultural cognition integrates neural, computational, social, and ecological evidence through explicit bridges instead of treating a brain image as proof of cultural essence Bender & Beller (2016).
Experimental Designs and Measurement Validity
Culture-and-cognition studies rely on several complementary designs: cross-sectional group comparison, within-person task switching, randomized priming, natural experiments, longitudinal tracking, and multilevel sampling. Each answers a different question. Cross-sectional work estimates the distribution of responses under defined sampling conditions; randomized task manipulation can support a causal claim about the assigned cue; longitudinal research can measure change over time. None automatically proves the historical origin of a group contrast. Evaluating evidence requires matching claims to the identification strategy actually used Miyamoto et al. (2006) Oyserman & Lee (2008).
Construct validity begins with transparent task definition. Analytic attention, context dependence, relational reasoning, and dispositional attribution are distinguishable measurements, despite their appearance within one intellectual tradition. Studies should specify stimulus selection, objective scoring, source language, recruitment, incentives, response format, item difficulty, missingness, and protocol deviations. Reliability assessed within one participant group does not establish equivalent interpretation in another. Factor structures, measurement invariance, and differential item functioning deserve explicit investigation before comparisons of latent scores are interpreted Na et al. (2010).
Bias can also enter through convenience sampling, experimenter expectations, publication selection, and flexibility in selecting among multiple correlated outcomes. Cross-cultural studies may have substantial design costs that encourage small numbers of independent cultural units, so impressive participant counts can conceal a weak basis for estimating cultural-level effects. Hierarchical statistical models should distinguish participants from classrooms, laboratories, regions, and countries, with uncertainty appropriate to each level of aggregation Henrich et al. (2010).
The strongest practical standard is convergent evidence. When eye tracking, reproduction error, contextual recognition, and causal judgments point toward related conclusions under independently collected designs, an explanatory program gains credibility. Contradictions are equally informative because they identify which aspects of the proposed construct travel between contexts. Transparent materials, open reporting, independent replication, and cross-disciplinary collaboration allow cultural cognition to develop cumulative knowledge beyond a collection of memorable national contrasts Bender & Beller (2016).
Causal Inference, Priming, and Replication
A claim that culture changes a cognitive process requires evidence beyond group association. Self-construal priming experiments manipulate accessible ideas of independence or interdependence and examine resulting judgments or attention. Oyserman and Lee synthesized this literature and reported effects on relationality and cognition, supporting a situated interpretation of culturally available orientations. A priming effect provides evidence for a proximal mechanism under the particular procedure, while effects of lifelong cultural participation involve larger and less readily randomized causal pathways Oyserman & Lee (2008).
Experiments nevertheless require evaluation of manipulation strength, baseline equivalence, plausible demand characteristics, and robustness across outcomes. Prime-induced behavior can reflect participants' guesses about a task, changes in motivation, or activation of learned procedures. Studies that vary instruction transparency, use independent manipulation checks, and preregister primary outcomes can distinguish these possibilities. The existence of a statistically significant effect in one laboratory does not demonstrate a universal causal principle or guarantee transportability to a new population.
Some work shows important situation-by-culture interactions. Miyamoto and Wilken investigated interpersonal influence and adjustment in American and Japanese contexts, finding that the cognitive consequences of an interpersonal situation depended on cultural meaning. This challenges a simple model in which the same prime produces an invariant effect for all participants. A culturally meaningful situation must be understood within the institutional and relational expectations of the individuals who encounter it Miyamoto & Wilken (2010).
Independent replication should reproduce the critical manipulation and compare relevant implementation features, while conceptual replication should test the proposed mechanism with different tasks. A multistudy program can reveal whether variation reflects procedural sensitivity or genuine boundary conditions. A credible synthesis should identify what was measured, by whom, in which populations, and under which instructions. Selective attention to successful comparisons would exaggerate the coherence of the literature; registered studies and reported null findings are indispensable for estimating its scope Na et al. (2010) Henrich et al. (2010).
Interpretive Disputes and Scientific Boundaries
The central theoretical dispute concerns what cultural variation changes. One position treats differences primarily as strategies deployed by otherwise broadly shared cognitive machinery; another emphasizes that culturally acquired meanings and practices can alter how information is encoded, weighted, and represented. A third explanatory family focuses on ecological distribution of stimuli and opportunities. These possibilities may coexist in different tasks. The evidence becomes discriminating when a study identifies a mechanism and predicts the outcome of altering task goals, environmental density, social relationships, or learned categories Nisbett et al. (2001) Kitayama & Salvador (2024).
A second dispute concerns universality. Establishing that university samples in two countries differ does not establish that either sample expresses the modal cognition of a continent, and failing to find a difference does not demonstrate cultural irrelevance. Henrich, Heine, and Norenzayan described the disproportionate reliance of behavioral science on WEIRD participants and the resulting limits of species-wide generalization. A mature cultural psychology treats population sampling as part of theory construction, because patterns can be universal, widespread, ecology-dependent, or local Henrich et al. (2010).
A third dispute concerns the relation between reported self-values and processing performance. Meta-analyses and comparative investigations have challenged simplistic assumptions about the global structure of individualism and collectivism Oyserman & Lee (2008). Na and colleagues showed that coherent cultural contrasts need not entail coherent individual-level psychological traits Na et al. (2010). The implication is methodological: researchers should examine the covariation they actually observe rather than stipulate it from a familiar conceptual vocabulary. Theories of self-construal have heuristic and empirical value when their predictions are formulated at the correct level.
Claims about cultural superiority are outside what these paradigms establish. A style that improves contextual recognition can impose costs in a focal discrimination task, and a greater reliance on formal rules may be helpful when explicit consistency is the criterion. Cultural cognition describes conditional fit between learned practices and task demands, with potential benefits and limitations evaluated empirically. Critical work also examines researcher standpoint: translation decisions, stimulus selection, scoring standards, and what counts as a satisfactory answer influence the observed psychological object Medin & Atran (2004) Bender & Beller (2016).
Contemporary Applications and Human–Artificial Environments
Cultural cognition matters for education because instruction often assumes shared ways of categorizing evidence, approaching contradiction, or interpreting a teacher's request. An instructional task emphasizing discrete objects may demand different strategies from a task requiring context and relationship monitoring. Evidence on cultural learning encourages educators to examine the task itself, learner expertise, and actual performance instead of inferring ability from cultural identity. The same principle applies to intercultural communication, research instrument design, and organizations using standardized assessments Kitayama et al. (2009) Bender & Beller (2016).
Digital interfaces change cognitive environments by ranking information, highlighting objects, establishing categories, and supplying default explanations. Their design can privilege focal choice, contextual comparison, or patterns of social coordination. Cultural cognition supplies empirically grounded questions for studying these interfaces: which cues users attend to, how they interpret uncertainty, whether automated explanations match local expectations, and which task designs enable accurate understanding. These are research questions requiring direct experiments with diverse users rather than deductions from geographic stereotypes Chua et al. (2005) Miyamoto et al. (2006).
In the Artificial Era, human–artificial cognitive partnership adds new environments of interpretation. A language model, recommender, or decision-support system can present categories and causal accounts shaped by its training distribution and design. Human users then assess outputs through culturally learned expectations about expertise, relational context, evidence, and appropriate response. Studying this interaction calls for controlled comparisons of interface framing, user background, comprehension, calibration, and downstream judgment. Existing cultural cognition experiments provide methods, although their findings cannot simply be transferred to contemporary artificial systems without validation Henrich et al. (2010) Kitayama & Salvador (2024).
Future research can test whether collaboration with artificial agents changes contextual attention, category formation, and social expectations over time. Experimental interventions might compare culturally varied explanation styles and quantify transfer to later independent tasks. Longitudinal designs could distinguish immediate interface effects from durable learning, and multilingual studies could separate linguistic format from the social meaning of advice. These proposals extend established research questions without claiming that a specific artificial architecture already possesses human-like cultural cognition or an experimentally established psychological identity.
Conclusion
Cultural cognition is a fundamental domain for explaining how thought unfolds in historically and socially organized environments. Its central empirical contribution is the demonstration that information selection, contextual attention, object recognition, causal attribution, categorization, and reasoning can vary systematically with cultural participation and experimentally manipulated circumstances. The framed-line task, eye tracking, event description, priming, and comparative reasoning experiments reveal different aspects of this organization. Their combined significance lies in treating culture as a possible contributor to cognitive operations that earlier theories sometimes presumed uniform Kitayama et al. (2003) Chua et al. (2005) Norenzayan et al. (2002).
The evidence also establishes boundaries. A reliable cultural mean difference does not identify a personal cognitive type, a country proxy does not measure a unique cause, and immediate priming does not reconstruct a lifetime of socialization. Multilevel research, measurement invariance, independent replication, and diverse sampling must carry explanatory claims from laboratory contrasts toward a more general science. The strongest contemporary accounts integrate social orientation, cultural tasks, perceptual ecology, historical livelihood, and norm systems while specifying which pathways have been directly demonstrated Na et al. (2010) Talhelm et al. (2014) Kitayama & Salvador (2024).
Cultural cognition connects psychology with anthropology, linguistics, education, neuroscience, and the study of information environments. It provides an empirical language for understanding why the same available information may produce different interpretive priorities or decisions across contexts. The resulting theoretical task is to explain how shared psychological capacities operate through locally acquired meanings and recurrent forms of action, and which generalizations survive changes in people, places, stimuli, and institutions Bender & Beller (2016) Medin & Atran (2004).
The research horizon extends to the Artificial Era, where human knowledge practices increasingly interact with artificial informational systems. This extension calls for new measurement of culturally situated human–artificial exchanges while maintaining the distinctions between observed results, causal hypotheses, and theoretical interpretations. A durable science of cultural cognition will be defined by transparent evidence, explicit mechanisms, and precise accounts of variation across levels of analysis. This monograph offers an integrated interpretation of the published research and a framework for evaluating its future tests.
References
- Bender, A., & Beller, S. (2016). Current perspectives on cognitive diversity. Frontiers in Psychology, 7, Article 509. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2016.00509
- Chiao, J. Y., Harada, T., Komeda, H., Li, Z., Mano, Y., Saito, D., Parrish, T. B., Sadato, N., & Iidaka, T. (2010). Dynamic cultural influences on neural representations of the self. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience, 22(1), 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1162/jocn.2009.21192
- Chua, H. F., Boland, J. E., & Nisbett, R. E. (2005). Cultural variation in eye movements during scene perception. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 102(35), 12629–12633. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0506162102
- Gelfand, M. J., Raver, J. L., Nishii, L., Leslie, L. M., Lun, J., Lim, B. C., Duan, L., Almaliach, A., Ang, S., Arnadottir, J., Aycan, Z., Boehnke, K., Boski, P., Cabecinhas, R., Chan, D., Chhokar, J., D'Amato, A., Ferrer, M., Fischlmayr, I. C., . . . Yamaguchi, S. (2011). Differences between tight and loose cultures: A 33-nation study. Science, 332(6033), 1100–1104. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1197754
- Henrich, J., Heine, S. J., & Norenzayan, A. (2010). The weirdest people in the world? Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 33(2–3), 61–83. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0140525X0999152X
- Ishii, K., Reyes, J. A., & Kitayama, S. (2003). Spontaneous attention to word content versus emotional tone: Differences among three cultures. Psychological Science, 14(1), 39–46. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9280.01416
- Ji, L.-J., Peng, K., & Nisbett, R. E. (2000). Culture, control, and perception of relationships in the environment. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 78(5), 943–955. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.78.5.943
- Kitayama, S., Duffy, S., Kawamura, T., & Larsen, J. T. (2003). Perceiving an object and its context in different cultures: A cultural look at new look. Psychological Science, 14(3), 201–206. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9280.02432
- Kitayama, S., Park, H., Sevincer, A. T., Karasawa, M., & Uskul, A. K. (2009). A cultural task analysis of implicit independence: Comparing North America, Western Europe, and East Asia. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 97(2), 236–255. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0015999
- Kitayama, S., & Salvador, C. E. (2024). Cultural psychology: Beyond East and West. Annual Review of Psychology, 75, 495–526. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-psych-021723-063333
- Kühnen, U., Hannover, B., & Schubert, B. (2001). The semantic–procedural interface model of the self: The role of self-knowledge for context-dependent versus context-independent modes of thinking. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 80(3), 397–409. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.80.3.397
- Leung, A. K.-Y., & Cohen, D. (2011). Within- and between-culture variation: Individual differences and the cultural logics of honor, face, and dignity cultures. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 100(3), 507–526. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0022151
- Markus, H. R., & Kitayama, S. (1991). Culture and the self: Implications for cognition, emotion, and motivation. Psychological Review, 98(2), 224–253. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.98.2.224
- Masuda, T., & Nisbett, R. E. (2001). Attending holistically versus analytically: Comparing the context sensitivity of Japanese and Americans. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 81(5), 922–934. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.81.5.922
- Medin, D. L., & Atran, S. (2004). The native mind: Biological categorization and reasoning in development and across cultures. Psychological Review, 111(4), 960–983. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.111.4.960
- Miyamoto, Y., Nisbett, R. E., & Masuda, T. (2006). Culture and the physical environment: Holistic versus analytic perceptual affordances. Psychological Science, 17(2), 113–119. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9280.2006.01673.x
- Miyamoto, Y., & Wilken, B. (2010). Culturally contingent situated cognition: Influencing other people fosters analytic perception in the United States but not in Japan. Psychological Science, 21(11), 1616–1622. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797610385954
- Morris, M. W., & Peng, K. (1994). Culture and cause: American and Chinese attributions for social and physical events. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 67(6), 949–971. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.67.6.949
- Na, J., Grossmann, I., Varnum, M. E. W., Kitayama, S., Gonzalez, R., & Nisbett, R. E. (2010). Cultural differences are not always reducible to individual differences. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 107(14), 6192–6197. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1001911107
- Nisbett, R. E., Peng, K., Choi, I., & Norenzayan, A. (2001). Culture and systems of thought: Holistic versus analytic cognition. Psychological Review, 108(2), 291–310. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.108.2.291
- Norenzayan, A., Smith, E. E., Kim, B. J., & Nisbett, R. E. (2002). Cultural preferences for formal versus intuitive reasoning. Cognitive Science, 26(5), 653–684. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15516709cog2605_4
- Oyserman, D., & Lee, S. W. S. (2008). Does culture influence what and how we think? Effects of priming individualism and collectivism. Psychological Bulletin, 134(2), 311–342. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.134.2.311
- Peng, K., & Nisbett, R. E. (1999). Culture, dialectics, and reasoning about contradiction. American Psychologist, 54(9), 741–754. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.54.9.741
- Talhelm, T., Zhang, X., Oishi, S., Shimin, C., Duan, D., Lan, X., & Kitayama, S. (2014). Large-scale psychological differences within China explained by rice versus wheat agriculture. Science, 344(6184), 603–608. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1246850
- Varnum, M. E. W., Grossmann, I., Kitayama, S., & Nisbett, R. E. (2010). The origin of cultural differences in cognition: Evidence for the social orientation hypothesis. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 19(1), 9–13. https://doi.org/10.1177/0963721409359301