Psychology by BogdanovaThe Encyclopedia of Psychology for the Artificial Era

RESEARCH DOSSIER

Signed Language Processing and Acquisition

Abstract. Signed Language Processing and Acquisition investigates how natural languages expressed through manual, facial, and spatial articulations are recognized, combined, learned, and sustained through social transmission. This fundamental research monograph traces the formal study of sign languages; contrasts phonological organization, lexical competition, grammatical and semantic interpretation, and discourse processing; examines infant manual babbling, vocabulary growth, early and delayed first-language acquisition, and adult second-language signing; synthesizes neural and electrophysiological evidence; and compares homesign and emerging community languages. Its method is a critical narrative analysis of original experiments, longitudinal and observational research, validated lexical resources, scholarly monographs, and contemporary reviewed scientific syntheses through 2026. Particular attention is given to accessibility of linguistic input, confounding between hearing status and language experience, ecological validity, cross-linguistic diversity, and the limits of inference from behavioral and neural data. The synthesis identifies shared linguistic functions and visual-manual constraints, specifies open empirical questions, and contextualizes comparative language research within the Artificial Era. It reports no original experiments, registered systematic-review protocol, or meta-analysis.

Keywords: signed language processing; sign language acquisition; American Sign Language; British Sign Language; visual-manual language; sign phonology; sign lexical access; morphology; signed syntax; nonmanual marking; deaf language development; language access; age of acquisition; sensitive periods; manual babbling; iconicity; sign language neuroscience; ASL-LEX; ASL-CDI; homesign; Nicaraguan Sign Language; language emergence; cross-modal psycholinguistics; Artificial Era

Scientific Definition, Research Object, and Questions

Signed language processing is the set of perceptual, lexical, grammatical, semantic, and pragmatic operations through which people recognize and interpret conventional languages expressed principally by hands, face, body, and visual space. Signed language acquisition is the developmental construction of competence in such languages through accessible interaction and linguistic experience. A sign language has conventional lexical items, productive grammatical constructions, and community-specific patterns; American Sign Language (ASL), British Sign Language (BSL), and other national or regional sign languages are distinct languages rather than manual versions of the surrounding spoken language. This dossier examines the psychological architecture of their comprehension, production, and development, taking language experience, sensory access, and communicative ecology as measurable variables. Stokoe (1960) Lillo-Martin & Henner (2021)

The primary questions concern how dynamic visual input yields structured linguistic representations, how lexical candidates are selected, how manual and facial information contribute to sentence interpretation, and how acquisition unfolds under different histories of access to fluent signers. A further question is which mechanisms are shared with spoken-language processing and which depend on the visual-manual modality. These questions require comparisons within signing populations as well as carefully designed cross-modal studies. Hearing status, age of first accessible language, age of sign exposure, proficiency, literacy, and socioeconomic context can covary; interpreting a contrast without distinguishing them risks attributing an effect to modality that instead follows from language history. MacSweeney et al. (2008) Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025)

The monograph is a critical narrative synthesis of original psycholinguistic studies, developmental experiments, typological investigations, psychometric resources, and neuroimaging and electrophysiological work. Its evidence is evaluated at the level of task, participant population, inference, and alternative explanation. It reports no original experiment and makes no claim to a preregistered systematic-review search. The scientific subject is conventional signed language, with homesign and emergent community languages examined as comparative conditions for explaining linguistic organization. General co-speech gesture, nonlinguistic pantomime, and hearing impairment as a medical condition remain adjacent research subjects rather than substitutes for the language under investigation. Goldin-Meadow & Mylander (1998) Brentari et al. (2012)

Historical Formation of Sign Language Science

The modern descriptive foundation includes William Stokoe's 1960 analysis of the formal structure of ASL. Its decisive methodological move was to identify recurrent contrastive components in signs and to treat signed expressions as analyzable linguistic forms. Earlier Deaf communities already possessed extensive language traditions; the scientific contribution of this work was a particular analytic apparatus for showing structural organization to an academic audience. A history that begins with the scholarly recognition of signed-language grammar would erase the social and intergenerational language practices on which scholarship depended. Historical explanation therefore distinguishes the existence of language from the dates of its formal description. Stokoe (1960)

Research subsequently developed methods for studying recognition over time, grammatical development, cerebral processing, and the emergence of linguistic conventions. Work by Emmorey and Corina tested how sign structure influences lexical identification, while Petitto and Marentette investigated patterned infant hand activity under early signing exposure. Mayberry and colleagues then demonstrated the importance of the timing of accessible first-language experience for later linguistic outcomes. Neuroimaging opened a different question: how languages transmitted through visually organized articulators recruit perceptual systems and language-sensitive cerebral networks. These traditions converge on sign languages as evidence about human linguistic capacities under distinct sensory and motor conditions. Emmorey & Corina (1990) Petitto & Marentette (1991) Mayberry (1993) MacSweeney et al. (2008)

A further historical step came from studying homesign and recently emerging sign languages. Research on Nicaraguan Sign Language traced the development of more systematic combinatorial expression across interacting cohorts of signers. It offered a rare longitudinal view of how learning biases, community transmission, and linguistic structure interact. Such studies resist a simple origin story in which a fully formed language appears at one instant: individual homesign systems, community conventions, social institutions, and successive learner cohorts have distinct roles. Modern cross-community work adds evidence that the structure of a new language also depends on network size, contact, and shared social practices. Senghas et al. (2004) Brentari et al. (2024)

Linguistic Structure and the Units of Psychological Analysis

At the sublexical level, signs can be analyzed through handshape, location, movement, orientation, and nonmanual articulations. Contrast between forms is a linguistic property when it differentiates conventional expressions within a community; visual resemblance alone is insufficient. Sign phonology thus concerns the organization of contrastive form, even though its basic units do not consist of sound. The term phonology is useful because theories can compare combinatorial restrictions, permissible configurations, and patterns of similarity across signed and spoken modalities. A research task must also recognize that many features of a sign unfold simultaneously, creating different temporal dependencies from those of speech. Stokoe (1960) Brentari et al. (2012) Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025)

Above these units are lexical representations, morphological alternations, syntactic dependencies, discourse referents, and pragmatic conventions. A single visible movement may combine lexical content with inflectional or spatially organized information. Signers can employ locations in signing space to establish and reidentify referents; directionality of some verbs may express relations among them. Nonmanual markers can distinguish constructions or serve information-structural functions. The psychologist's challenge is to establish whether a response reflects recognition of a lexical form, interpretation of a morphological distinction, compositional understanding, or memory for a discourse referent. Experiments can dissociate these levels by manipulating one property while keeping others comparable. Lillo-Martin & Henner (2021) Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025)

Several terminological distinctions matter. A sign language is a community language; a fingerspelled sequence represents letters through conventional manual forms and may participate in both borrowed vocabulary and lexical access; a classifier construction involves structured depiction and language-specific conventions; gesture can accompany signed or spoken discourse while also functioning independently. Boundaries between gesture and language can be empirically investigated rather than assumed from whether hands move. The homesign comparison shows that organized expression can arise without ordinary linguistic input, while communal transmission provides additional conditions for stabilization and expansion. Goldin-Meadow & Mylander (1998) Brentari et al. (2012) Brentari et al. (2024)

Perceptual Ecology of Visual–Manual Communication

The input to a signer is a dynamically changing scene whose relevant information extends across hands, arms, face, torso, and spatial loci. A viewer must sample foveal and peripheral visual input, track hand motion, discriminate articulation, and associate the unfolding signal with a lexical or grammatical interpretation. Unlike an isolated still image, natural signing often combines several concurrent articulators. A design showing individual signs against a neutral background therefore isolates selected operations while leaving out the demands of conversational comprehension. Perceptual explanation needs to specify visual presentation conditions, signal timing, face visibility, viewing distance, and the participant's linguistic competence. Emmorey (2002) Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025)

Eye-tracking research illustrates the distinction between retinal fixation and information uptake. In a live ASL comprehension experiment, native and beginning signers predominantly looked at the face, while their exact fixation distributions differed. Native signers could acquire relevant hand information without continuously fixing their eyes directly upon the hands. The study used small groups, and its significance lies in the precise behavioral contrast rather than in a population-wide percentage assumed to apply to all conversations. Looking at the eyes, mouth, or hands depends partly on what the signer is saying, the observer's proficiency, and whether gaze itself has a communicative role. Emmorey et al. (2009)

Evidence from visual-search paradigms suggests that experience with signing may redistribute covert attention toward lower regions of the visual field. Comparisons including deaf signers, hearing signers, and hearing nonsigners help isolate a potential contribution of sign-language practice from auditory status alone. Yet these are group comparisons; auditory experience, acquisition histories, and participation environments can still complicate causal interpretation. The resulting model is one of flexible, experience-dependent coordination between fixation and peripheral attention. A full ecological account should test comprehension and attentional performance together rather than inferring understanding directly from fixation maps. Stoll & Dye (2019)

Research Designs and Evidence Classification

Scientific claims about signed-language processing arise from diverse designs with distinct strengths. Gating studies progressively reveal segments of signs and ask when identification becomes possible. Lexical decision and priming assess effects of familiarity, form similarity, and competition. Eye-tracking measures the time course of attention during comprehension. Event-related potentials provide temporal markers associated with processing differences, while functional MRI reveals spatially distributed activation under defined contrasts. Naturalistic observation, longitudinal recordings, and caregiver reports address language development. Each method requires a clear link between an observable variable and the construct claimed to explain it. Emmorey & Corina (1990) Carreiras et al. (2008) Caselli et al. (2020)

Evidence should be interpreted along a hierarchy of questions rather than a rigid ranking of instruments. A lexical priming effect establishes facilitation or interference under particular timing and task conditions; it does not alone identify the neural code for a word. Brain activation during signing demonstrates participation of a network under the tested contrast, not the necessity of every activated region. Longitudinal developmental change documents temporal ordering, while causal identification needs interventions or informative natural experiments that limit alternative explanations. The strongest synthesis triangulates task behavior, linguistic analysis, developmental history, and neural measurements without allowing one methodology to stand in for another. MacSweeney et al. (2008) Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025)

Measurement is additionally sensitive to stimulus and participant norms. Vocabulary frequencies, neighborhood densities, rated iconicity, and age-of-acquisition estimates influence experimental interpretation. ASL-LEX supplies calibrated lexical resources, and the ASL-CDI 2.0 supports research on early vocabulary in ASL. These instruments have defined populations and are not interchangeable with tests developed for unrelated sign languages. Transparent reports should describe recruitment, sign variants, regional communities, participant language histories, video production parameters, coder agreement, exclusion criteria, and analytic uncertainty. The goal is construct validity at the level of a signed language, not simply a replication of a spoken-language task with manual stimuli. Caselli et al. (2017) Caselli et al. (2020)

Comparative Framework: Modality, Experience, and Language

Comparisons between signed and spoken languages should distinguish modality-general operations from modality-sensitive realizations. Mapping perceptual input to lexical identity, combining expressions into larger units, and building discourse meaning occur across modalities. The input channels, temporal distribution of articulatory cues, demands on visual attention, and available spatial mappings differ. The relevant scientific claim is therefore conditional: a shared functional organization may appear through distinct sensory routes, while a local processing cost can depend on how a particular language expresses information. MacSweeney et al. (2008) Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025)

Deaf native signers, deaf late first-language learners, hearing native bimodal bilinguals, hearing adult second-language signers, and sign-naïve observers form populations with different experiential profiles. Collapsing these groups makes age-of-acquisition effects difficult to interpret. An adult who learns ASL after a fully accessible spoken first language brings a linguistic foundation that differs from the history of a deaf adult whose first fully accessible language began much later. Comparisons between those histories provide especially important evidence about sensitive periods, linguistic transfer, and the developmental cost of limited language access. Mayberry (1993) Cormier et al. (2012)

This monograph accordingly treats modality, first-language access, linguistic proficiency, and social opportunity as related but separable variables. It examines signed languages as a plural typological domain, not as one globally uniform code. Conclusions drawn from ASL should be tested against BSL, Spanish Sign Language, German Sign Language, emerging languages, and other community systems before they are generalized. Cross-modal research is most informative when it explains both common linguistic functions and observable differences in their implementation. Carreiras et al. (2008) Brentari et al. (2024)

Time Course of Sign Recognition and Lexical Access

Recognizing a moving sign requires converting changing visual features into a stable lexical candidate. The recognition process can begin before the complete articulation ends, but the amount of useful information available at each moment differs among signs. In their original gating experiments, Emmorey and Corina manipulated when parts of an ASL form became visible and examined the recognition of simple and morphologically complex signs. Their findings linked identification time to the temporal availability of parameters and to morphological structure. The experiment remains an important challenge to models that presume speech-like sequential phonemes as the only route to incremental lexical processing. Emmorey & Corina (1990)

Lexical access is influenced by both the visual signal and the statistical organization of a language's lexicon. When multiple lexical items share articulatory properties, similarity can support early activation while also introducing competition among candidates. The relevant outcome depends on whether the experiment asks for detection, categorization, recognition, or semantic access. In Spanish Sign Language, Carreiras and colleagues found effects of familiarity and phonological neighborhood in deaf signers. These effects establish psychologically meaningful sublexical structure; their magnitude and direction must be interpreted in relation to the specific task and sign inventory. Carreiras et al. (2008)

A useful processing architecture separates initial visual feature extraction, formation of a linguistically plausible sign representation, competition among lexical candidates, and retrieval of meaning. These stages are explanatory distinctions rather than a claim that comprehension always unfolds through isolated serial modules. Coarticulation, context, and anticipatory information can shape interpretation before a sign is completed. Studies with natural narrative input need to examine whether behavioral sensitivity to an early cue truly signals lexical identification or only a prediction about a likely continuation. Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025) Caselli et al. (2017)

Phonological Neighborhoods, Priming, and Lexical Competition

Phonological neighbors are signs sharing specified form parameters with a target. A lexical neighborhood measure is only interpretable after researchers define which properties count as shared and which vocabulary inventory is used. ASL-LEX provides structured sign-level data that allow researchers to estimate such relationships, distinguish ratings of iconicity and familiarity, and improve stimulus balancing. Neighborhood density in one lexicon cannot be transferred mechanically to another language, and the most frequent signs available to one community may differ across generations and regions. Caselli et al. (2017)

Priming experiments offer a way to separate candidate facilitation from interference. Electrophysiological investigations of ASL phonological priming report that overlap in handshape and location can affect the N400 response, and that some effects change with the task. These findings are consistent with partially distinct roles for form parameters and lexical competition. An N400 difference indexes sensitivity to experimental context; it does not by itself prove a unique, language-independent neurophysiological representation for handshape or location. Comparing semantic and repetition tasks is valuable precisely because a representation may facilitate one operation while competing with another. Meade et al. (2021)

A better model of signed lexical recognition must capture the spatial distribution of features, their timing, lexical probability, morphological complexity, and the signer's expectations. A static inventory of phonological neighbors supplies important constraints but cannot describe the entire continuous stream. Testing model predictions requires preregistered manipulations where feasible, stimulus-level random effects, and robustness across independent signer samples. When findings disagree across paradigms, the question is whether the dependent variables represent identical processing stages, not whether one result is arbitrarily correct. Emmorey & Corina (1990) Carreiras et al. (2008) Meade et al. (2021)

Morphology, Simultaneity, and Combinatorial Representation

Signed morphology can package distinctions through movement, orientation, repetition, spatial loci, and concurrent articulations. Complex signs may incorporate information that is arranged successively in a spoken-language expression, although both spoken and signed languages use mixtures of sequential and simultaneous organization. The psychological implication is that lexical recognition and morphological decomposition may overlap in time. In early experiments, morphologically complex ASL signs were identified differently from matched simple forms, demonstrating the importance of morphological structure to recognition. It does not follow that all sign morphology is represented by the same mental operation. Emmorey & Corina (1990)

Directional verbs and spatial classifier constructions illustrate the need for linguistic analysis of form and meaning. A movement may be related to an entity's trajectory in the described scene, while the distribution of forms and their grammatical interpretation are shaped by community conventions. Children learning these constructions must coordinate lexically stored knowledge, grammatical regularities, and reference to locations established in discourse. The degree to which iconic transparency makes acquisition easier is a question for controlled studies; apparent depictiveness to an adult researcher cannot substitute for evidence that a child understands a grammatical distinction. Lillo-Martin & Henner (2021) Brentari et al. (2012)

Computational accounts can encode multiple interacting features rather than assuming one linear stream of discrete signs. A model should predict response time and accuracy for matched simple and complex items, generalize to unfamiliar sign combinations, and distinguish genuine sensitivity to grammatical form from visual pattern matching. Such models require natural video datasets, accurate annotations of manual and nonmanual articulation, and consideration of sociolinguistic variation. When an account succeeds only for one narrow stimulus inventory, its generality across languages and discourse conditions remains to be established. Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025) Brentari et al. (2024)

Sentence Comprehension, Syntactic Relations, and Nonmanual Marking

Sentence-level comprehension combines lexical content, grammatical dependencies, visual timing, and discourse context. Sign languages may express questions, negation, conditional clauses, and argument relations using patterned manual sequences together with facial and body articulations. The interpretation of a facial movement depends on its linguistic timing, the construction in which it occurs, and the signer's discourse intention. Consequently, an experiment that removes facial information changes the visible linguistic input as well as the social properties of the display. Neural and behavioral tests should differentiate the specific grammatical cues removed or preserved. Lillo-Martin & Henner (2021) Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025)

Boudreault and Mayberry used timed grammaticality judgments spanning several ASL syntactic structures to study age of first-language acquisition. Their design compared grammatical and ungrammatical sentences, including negative, agreement, question, and other structures. The major implication is that linguistic experience during early development bears on later ability to interpret grammatical constructions. Timed judgments, however, combine comprehension with decision demands, and they do not establish that every construction develops through identical steps. Errors can arise from lexical access, morphosyntactic integration, processing speed, or unfamiliarity with the tested variety. Boudreault & Mayberry (2006)

Cross-modal comparison reveals higher-level convergence without making all grammatical representations identical. A signer interpreting a spatial locus must maintain an association between a position and its discourse referent; a speaker may use nominal or pronominal expressions with a different perceptual burden. Both systems support interpretation of who did what to whom. To identify language-specific computations, researchers need grammatical contrasts that are meaningful in the respective languages, controls for attention and task difficulty, and tests extending beyond single isolated sentences to ongoing interaction. MacSweeney et al. (2008) Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025)

Semantic Processing, Iconicity, and Conceptual Access

A sign may resemble aspects of the object, action, or relation it denotes. Such iconicity is graded and language-specific: it depends on which features a community's conventional form makes available and on the observer's prior knowledge. Iconicity can shape learning or picture naming under some conditions while remaining irrelevant to other recognition tasks. An iconic sign is therefore simultaneously a conventional lexical form and a potentially informative perceptual analogy. The useful experimental question is whether rated iconicity predicts performance after familiarity, frequency, semantic domain, and form similarity have been controlled. Caselli et al. (2017) Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025)

The association between sign form and conceptual meaning can be probed through semantic judgments, priming, and neural response measures. Yet success on a semantic matching task may reflect interpretation of the picture, retrieval of the sign, or a mapping between their visible features. The direction of processing and response modality matter. The presence of semantic effects in a familiar signing population should be compared with non-signing observers to establish whether the effect requires lexical knowledge. Such contrasts are especially important when a gesture-like form appears transparent to an experimenter but has different meanings in another signing community. Carreiras et al. (2008) Brentari et al. (2024)

Iconicity can also interact with acquisition. Learners might use a visually motivated cue to remember a sign after learning its referent, while another sign requires convention-based mapping. Observed advantages may depend on development, linguistic knowledge, and elicitation format. The appropriate theoretical synthesis is that iconicity is one of several pathways through which form can organize experience, and its contribution must be separated from accessible input and opportunities to use the language. Recent longitudinal evidence on vocabulary composition demonstrates why frequency and exposure quality require simultaneous consideration. Becker et al. (2026) Lillo-Martin & Henner (2021)

Discourse Processing, Reference, and Interactive Meaning

Natural language comprehension extends beyond the sign currently visible. A viewer integrates what has been said with evolving discourse representations, participant identities, referential loci, and shared attention. Signers can establish locations for individuals or events and subsequently reuse those spatial indices. The same physical region may support a different reference in another discourse, so interpretation cannot be reduced to the geometry of a gesture. Psychological accounts must track how linguistic conventions connect current signals to a memory of the interaction. Lillo-Martin & Henner (2021) Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025)

Conversational comprehension involves multiple agents who monitor one another's attention and can clarify a referent, repeat an expression, or adjust the visibility of a sign. Visual attention is therefore both a perceptual resource and a communicative action. The face and gaze supply information relevant to the linguistic structure of some utterances, while conversational gaze can regulate the exchange itself. Empirical research is best served by distinguishing grammar-related nonmanual markings from interpersonal gaze behavior rather than attributing both to an undifferentiated social channel. Emmorey et al. (2009) Stoll & Dye (2019)

For research, ecologically valid tasks should include continuous conversation, natural turn transitions, and repair sequences where participants genuinely exchange information. Replaying the same video to all observers supports experimental control but removes opportunities for mutual adjustment; interactive designs introduce greater realism but require additional controls for partner behavior. Combining these approaches can reveal whether a processing effect established with isolated signs persists when signers understand a narrative, coordinate reference, or negotiate an ambiguity in real time. Emmorey (2002) Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025)

Infant Perception, Manual Babbling, and Early Language Exposure

Development begins with accessible visual interaction before a child can produce mature grammatical signs. Infants must learn to attend to linguistic movement, faces, gaze, and interactional timing while gradually organizing their own manual activity. Early exposure to fluent signing offers ordinary opportunities for the development of shared reference, early lexical knowledge, and combinatorial expressions. Petitto and Marentette's classic report of manual babbling among deaf infants exposed to signing provided evidence that patterned prelexical production can occur in a visual-manual language environment. Such activity must be distinguished from every repetitive infant hand movement; researchers require form, timing, and developmental criteria. Petitto & Marentette (1991) Lillo-Martin & Henner (2021)

Manual and vocal babbling are informative because they challenge a theory tying all linguistic preproduction to maturation of vocal articulation. Their similarities suggest cross-modal developmental processes, but they do not establish that the neural circuitry, sensory demands, and perceptual feedback are identical. Observational data also depend on caregiver opportunities, the child's vision and motor development, and the definition of a babbling unit. Replication across different sign languages and longitudinal samples would help establish how broadly observed patterns extend. The most useful causal question concerns the relation between linguistic experience and the emergence of organized, communicatively relevant production. Petitto & Marentette (1991)

Infant language access is a social and environmental fact as well as a developmental variable. A deaf child living with fluent signers can encounter a fully structured language from birth, while another child may encounter restricted accessible input for years. The resulting trajectories should not be attributed simply to deafness. The broad review by Lillo-Martin and Henner emphasizes that accessible signed-language input from birth supports milestones in broadly comparable developmental windows to spoken-language acquisition, while timing and quality of exposure strongly affect later outcomes. An empirical account must therefore describe access to the actual language used by caregivers. Lillo-Martin & Henner (2021)

Vocabulary Growth and the Measurement of Early Signs

Early vocabulary acquisition involves connecting visible linguistic forms with objects, actions, social roles, and recurring events. Recognition and production develop under somewhat different constraints because a child can understand a sign before consistently producing its full articulatory form. Caregiver reports allow researchers to describe the growth of known signs across a larger sample than laboratory tasks alone can ordinarily accommodate. The ASL-CDI 2.0 is an adapted inventory designed for early ASL comprehension and production, including video-based presentations that represent sign forms more directly than written glosses. Such tools make systematic assessment possible without treating English vocabulary as a proxy for ASL knowledge. Caselli et al. (2020)

A measurement instrument is valid only for the construct and population it samples. Parental report depends on the caregiver's ability to recognize the sign, opportunities to observe it, and the language varieties available in the family. Researchers should distinguish comprehension from production, separately identify fingerspelled forms where relevant, and avoid assuming equivalence between a printed English translation and a sign's semantic range. Psychometric questions include how items are chosen, whether performance is comparable at different ages, how sign variants are handled, and which reference population anchors normative interpretation. Caselli et al. (2020) Caselli et al. (2017)

Recent evidence adds a nuanced view of vocabulary learning under variable access. Becker, Pyers, and Caselli examined deaf children whose caregivers differed in fluency and language-learning histories. The study reports slower vocabulary development when children and hearing caregivers were learning a sign language together, while multiple influences on vocabulary composition appeared similar across exposure groups. Frequent signs were relatively more attainable than rare signs in conditions of less consistent exposure. This finding supports a distinction between the opportunity to accumulate vocabulary and the learning relationships that organize which words are acquired. Its conclusions are tied to the sampled children and operational measures, not to an assumption that all deaf children experience identical access. Becker et al. (2026)

Combinatorial Development and Productive Grammar

As vocabulary grows, children begin combining signs into increasingly flexible expressions. Development includes patterns of word order, pragmatic reference, negation, question formation, agreement, and the use of spatial locations for discourse entities. The early emergence of combinations provides an opportunity to distinguish a child's productive application of rules from repetition of frequently encountered sequences. The review of signed-language acquisition reports both broad developmental parallels with speech and modality-sensitive demands, especially for articulatory form, spatial reference, and some agreement patterns. These are different developmental questions and should be measured separately. Lillo-Martin & Henner (2021)

Verb agreement presents a demanding case because the child must associate a location with a participant and then construct a linguistically appropriate movement or orientation. Longitudinal studies indicate that productive control can emerge during early childhood, with apparent age differences across samples and definitions of required agreement contexts. A form that looks like a real-world trajectory may still have language-specific grammatical restrictions. Developmental coding must therefore assess the discourse context, possible referent assignment, and accuracy of the grammatical form rather than assuming that meaningful movement is a mature agreement construction. Lillo-Martin & Henner (2021)

Grammatical competence develops through experience with both lexical patterns and communicative interaction. A child may correctly understand a construction without yet producing it reliably, or may produce a familiar form but fail to extend it to new referents. Carefully chosen comprehension tasks, elicited production, and naturalistic corpora provide complementary evidence. Researchers should report which grammatical phenomenon they measure and avoid reducing all developmental differences to a single global language score. This specificity is especially important when comparing early signers with learners whose first exposure was delayed. Boudreault & Mayberry (2006) Cormier et al. (2012)

Timing of First-Language Acquisition and Sensitive Periods

The age at which an individual first has sustained access to a fully usable language is a major variable in signed-language acquisition research. Mayberry and Eichen studied deaf adults with long signing experience whose initial access occurred at different childhood ages, and observed enduring associations between age of acquisition and language-processing performance. Mayberry's later comparison further distinguished adults first acquiring ASL after childhood from adults acquiring ASL as a second language following an earlier spoken-language foundation. These studies demonstrate why chronological age of learning ASL cannot be interpreted without considering whether ASL was the individual's first accessible language. Mayberry & Eichen (1991) Mayberry (1993)

A sensitive-period account proposes that the developmental efficiency of constructing a first linguistic system changes with age. Evidence supporting this account includes persistent differences in sentence recognition, grammaticality judgments, and lexical organization despite years of later experience. Boudreault and Mayberry investigated grammatical judgments across multiple ASL syntactic structures in adults with different first-language acquisition histories. Their pattern points toward an enduring effect of early access. Nevertheless, natural-group studies cannot assign exposure timing randomly, and cumulative differences in educational opportunity, input, social interaction, and literacy also require evaluation. The scientific conclusion concerns observed developmental constraints and their plausible explanations, not an exact universal age cutoff. Boudreault & Mayberry (2006)

Cormier and colleagues examined grammaticality judgment in BSL while adjusting for English reading ability and nonverbal intelligence. The relationship between age of BSL acquisition and performance differed by learner history, underscoring that late sign learning may involve either delayed first-language development or second-language acquisition supported by an already established linguistic system. This distinction is critical for ethical interpretation and for research design. Children benefit from early exposure to accessible language; the existing evidence does not license an expectation that a later learner lacks learning potential or that one score captures the whole range of communication abilities. Cormier et al. (2012) Lillo-Martin & Henner (2021)

First-Language Delay and Online Lexical Organization

Developmental effects can be investigated in real-time language processing rather than only broad achievement measures. Lieberman and colleagues studied the recognition of ASL signs in adults with contrasting first-language exposure histories, using time-sensitive measures relevant to the organization of lexical candidates. Their results link delayed first-language experience to differences in the organization and activation of the mental lexicon. This kind of evidence matters because familiar vocabulary may be recognized correctly while the temporal dynamics of competition differ from those of early-exposed signers. Accuracy alone can conceal processing differences. Lieberman et al. (2015)

The psychological interpretation requires clarity about lexical activation, attention, task demands, and differences in language practice. If two groups select the same referent but differ in the time at which their eyes move toward it, that timing may reflect how lexical candidates become active, how a visual scene is scanned, or both. Studies should therefore balance lexical familiarity, sign form, semantic competition, and the visual properties of displays. Comparisons ideally include individual measures of language history rather than categorical native-versus-late labels alone. Lieberman et al. (2015) Caselli et al. (2017)

The interaction of online processing and development also reframes the debate over sensitive periods. If later exposure alters several processing components, improved vocabulary knowledge may coexist with persistent differences in automatic recognition or grammatical integration. Conversely, a group difference in one task does not show that every component of language is permanently constrained. Longitudinal and intervention-sensitive designs can help identify the domains that remain plastic. The hypothesis worth testing is that early access shapes the efficiency and integration of representations throughout a developing system, with outcomes moderated by the quality and continuity of subsequent exposure. Mayberry (1993) Becker et al. (2026)

Second-Language Signing, Bimodal Bilingualism, and Educational Context

Many people learn a sign language after acquiring a spoken language. For hearing signers, acquisition commonly involves new visual categories, manual motor skills, sensitivity to simultaneous articulations, and productive use of space. A learner may bring general experience with lexical meanings, grammar, and communicative interaction while still needing to develop sign-specific perceptual and articulatory expertise. This makes signed second-language acquisition valuable for separating the learning of a first linguistic system from the learning of a new modality. The results should be analyzed by proficiency, first-language background, amount of sustained use, and learning context. Mayberry (1993) Cormier et al. (2012)

Bimodal bilinguals can use signed and spoken languages in overlapping or coordinated ways, creating research questions about attention, code selection, and interference that differ from those of two spoken languages. They may also encounter fingerspelling, mouth actions, and written language during communicative activity. The presence of simultaneous channels does not make the two languages one system. A study of language dominance must measure competence and habitual use in each language; generic bilingual labels obscure the variables needed to explain a processing result. Emmorey (2002) Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025)

Educational comparisons require particular care. Deaf students differ in the accessibility of spoken input, the availability of fluent signing, timing of educational support, literacy instruction, and membership in language communities. Learning outcomes cannot be causally attributed to a schooling label without examining those conditions. Language provision has implications for social participation and the capacity to acquire academic knowledge, but research should separate directly measured outcomes from broader policy inferences. The central developmental principle is a child's opportunity to engage with accessible, sufficiently rich language across everyday relationships and educational settings. Lillo-Martin & Henner (2021) Becker et al. (2026)

Neural Architecture of Signed Language Comprehension

The signing brain converts a moving visual scene into language-sensitive representations through a network involving occipital, posterior temporal, parietal, and frontotemporal regions. Sensory and motor transformations are modality-sensitive, while higher-level combinatorial operations recruit regions that also contribute to spoken-language comprehension. The 2025 review by Terhune-Cotter and Emmorey organizes this evidence into a processing sequence from visual information and phonological representations toward lexical meaning and sentence interpretation. This account is a synthesis of experimental findings, and its subdivisions are anatomical-functional hypotheses rather than direct observations of discrete processing stages in a single brain. Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025)

Earlier studies comparing BSL and audiovisual English established the value of cross-modal contrasts for disentangling language processing from auditory or visual signal analysis. Investigations of native and later ASL users further showed that age of language exposure can affect the distribution of recruitment in language tasks. Interpretation of hemispheric differences must specify whether the stimuli are words, sentences, meaningless motion, or grammatical contrasts and whether deafness and language experience have been controlled. It is scientifically unwarranted to treat a whole hemisphere as uniquely belonging to a signed or spoken language. MacSweeney et al. (2002) Newman et al. (2002) MacSweeney et al. (2008)

Current models therefore distinguish processes that construct a linguistic representation from the sensory operations that make particular inputs available. Overlapping frontotemporal activity provides evidence of shared neural machinery; distinct occipitotemporal and parietal contributions reflect additional requirements of visual motion, form discrimination, and spatial processing. Overlap in a functional imaging map does not entail complete equivalence of the computations executed within a region. More demanding evidence would include task-specific connectivity, localizer-defined comparisons, individual variability, and causal perturbation where possible. Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025)

Electrophysiology, Timing, and Neural Interpretation

Electrophysiological methods provide temporal evidence that complements the spatial information of functional imaging. Event-related potentials can be aligned to meaningful sign events, including the emergence of form cues, lexical recognition points, and sentence-level manipulations. The temporal structure of signing complicates alignment because the onset of a visible gesture, the moment a lexical distinction becomes identifiable, and the duration of a sustained sign may differ substantially. A study must justify its time-locking event and report whether it reflects initial visual movement, a diagnostic phonological parameter, or contextual disambiguation. Meade et al. (2021) Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025)

N400 effects in sign-language experiments support the presence of context-sensitive semantic and form-related processing, but the waveform is sensitive to many aspects of expectancy, stimulus repetition, and task requirements. The study of ASL phonological priming found effects that depended on shared parameters and the behavioral task, suggesting a dynamic interaction between form overlap and lexical competition. This complexity argues against assigning an N400 decrease to a single automatic stage of recognition without convergent evidence. Meade et al. (2021)

A strong combined design links electrophysiological time courses with behavioral decisions and well-controlled linguistic stimuli. Individual variation in language history and linguistic knowledge is particularly important because a brain signal may reflect additional perceptual effort rather than a deficit in grammatical representation. Researchers should distinguish a neural response in an early visual region to biological movement from a response specifically modulated by meaningful signed language. Cross-task replication and transparency of analysis windows are more informative than attractive activation images viewed without their contrasts. MacSweeney et al. (2008) Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025)

Signed Language, Deafness, and Experience-Dependent Plasticity

Deafness changes some aspects of sensory experience, while language exposure and signing practice can shape attention and representation through partly distinct mechanisms. Studies that compare deaf signers only with hearing nonsigners confound these dimensions. Hearing fluent signers offer an informative comparison because they receive auditory input and also engage with visual-manual language. A comparison including deaf signers, hearing signers, and hearing nonsigners can help isolate the contribution of linguistic experience, although differences in amount of practice and age of acquisition remain. Stoll & Dye (2019)

The link between language experience and neural development also extends to the timing of first accessible input. Newman and colleagues found differences in right-hemisphere recruitment for ASL comprehension when comparing native and later learners in a study of hearing participants. Such results demonstrate sensitivity of neural responses to experience but should not be universalized into a simple claim that all native signers recruit the same bilateral regions. The distinction between linguistic processing, visual imagery, and task demands remains important, as does the limited range of participant histories within any single imaging experiment. Newman et al. (2002)

Neuroplasticity should be studied through pathways and functions rather than assessed as one global trait. A redistribution of visual attention may benefit perception of signing under particular conditions, while a neural language network may show altered load when language learning begins late. These processes operate over different developmental timescales. Behavioral outcomes, accessibility of input, and task-specific brain activity must be connected through explicit hypotheses. Better longitudinal evidence would estimate how sustained changes in access, proficiency, and everyday language use contribute to functional reorganization. Stoll & Dye (2019) Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025)

Homesign, Community Formation, and Language Emergence

Homesign is a structured communicative system developed by individuals who have limited access to an established signed or spoken community language. It offers evidence about the capacities and constraints of individual language-like construction. Goldin-Meadow and Mylander compared gesture systems created by deaf children in different cultural environments and found similarities in semantic organization and sentence-like patterning. The evidence demonstrates that individual communicators can impose structure on their expressive systems. It does not establish that those systems have every conventional grammatical property of an established language or that individual invention alone can explain the growth of a full community language. Goldin-Meadow & Mylander (1998)

Nicaraguan Sign Language provides a different kind of evidence because multiple people developed and transmitted a shared signing system across educational and social networks. Senghas, Kita, and Özyürek examined how learners across cohorts segmented and reorganized expression of complex events. Such patterns suggest that child learning and repeated transmission can promote systematic combinatorial structure. The observed changes occurred within specific historical institutions and social relations; universal claims about language emergence require comparison with other settings. Linguistic structure arises through interactions of individual learning, community size, interactional need, and intergenerational access. Senghas et al. (2004)

Recent comparisons of Nicaraguan Sign Language with Central Taurus Sign Language make clear that small emerging language communities need not follow identical pathways. Brentari and colleagues examined both phonological inventories and the organization of agency and number in predicates, identifying variation across languages and cohorts. Their results support a more detailed account of how contact networks and sociocultural arrangements shape the forms available to successive learners. The emergence literature is therefore best understood as a family of natural experiments with valuable but limited comparability, not a single replicable developmental chronology. Brentari et al. (2024)

The Boundary Between Gesture, Homesign, and Established Sign Languages

All humans use bodily actions to communicate, and visible iconic expression can occur in gesture, homesign, and conventional sign languages. The central scientific distinction concerns how forms become conventionalized, contrastive, combinatorial, and subject to linguistic regularities. Brentari and colleagues compared handshape complexity in signers, homesigners, and gesturers to investigate when particular phonological patterns appear. Their approach makes it possible to test language-organization hypotheses with measurable form properties rather than classifying expressions by appearance alone. Brentari et al. (2012)

A conventional sign can contain an iconic element without losing its status as a language item. Equally, a co-speech gesture can convey rich meaning while depending on a concurrent spoken utterance for its interpretation. Homesign can support structured meaning across recurring communicative routines while differing from a system used by a wider language community. These phenomena should be compared on explicit dimensions such as stability across occasions, combinatorial productivity, contrastive form, shared conventions, and independence from other communication channels. Goldin-Meadow & Mylander (1998) Brentari et al. (2024)

The psychological value of these comparisons lies in distinguishing cognitive predispositions, interactive coordination, and cultural transmission. If a form pattern appears in solitary homesign, it may reflect an individual learning or production bias; if it is strengthened across successive cohorts, transmission and conventionalization become candidate mechanisms. Researchers must examine both possibilities under appropriate sampling. This framework also discourages the assumption that all sign-language features follow from the mechanics of the hand, because conventional systems may reorganize the resources available to manual expression. Senghas et al. (2004) Brentari et al. (2012)

Cross-Linguistic Diversity and Limits of Universality

The visual-manual modality creates recurring affordances across sign languages, but languages differ in lexicon, grammar, patterns of iconicity, nonmanual marking, and discourse practices. Data from ASL are therefore valuable as language-specific evidence; general claims require comparative confirmation. Research in BSL and Spanish Sign Language has already demonstrated lexical and grammatical phenomena through paradigms that are not limited to ASL, while emerging languages highlight the historical contingency of some structural patterns. Carreiras et al. (2008) Cormier et al. (2012) Brentari et al. (2024)

Researchers frequently confront typological and sampling challenges. Some languages have extensively documented video corpora and lexical norms, while smaller communities may lack standardized inventories and broad research infrastructure. A language's documentation history is not a measure of its linguistic complexity. Comparisons should also distinguish regional variants, age cohorts, different education histories, and the status of an expression as a language form or a translation gloss. Consistent cross-linguistic annotation is useful only when it preserves constructions that differ in their local grammatical roles. Caselli et al. (2017) Lillo-Martin & Henner (2021)

A balanced explanatory theory proposes general principles at the level warranted by the evidence. Humans learn conventional mappings, organize complex expressions, track discourse, and can develop language through visually available systems. The forms in which these functions occur are shaped by particular communities, historical contexts, and sensory experiences. A productive research agenda systematically maps where a common function has comparable behavior across languages, where different patterns represent distinct grammatical resources, and where apparent universals are artifacts of privileged sampling. Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025) Brentari et al. (2024)

Lexical Resources, Measurement Equivalence, and Psychometric Validity

The quality of signed-language research depends on the correspondence between a linguistic construct and the instrument designed to measure it. A written English gloss is not a faithful representation of all the grammatical, morphological, and semantic properties of a sign. Video-based stimulus banks, lexical frequency estimates, phonological descriptions, familiarity ratings, and community consultation therefore support the validity of experiments. ASL-LEX provided a standardized resource for sign properties, and the ASL-LEX 2.0 project expanded the available lexicon. These resources make reproducible stimulus sampling possible while leaving open the problem of how corpus and rating distributions reflect usage among different ASL communities. Caselli et al. (2017) Sevcikova Sehyr et al. (2021)

Measurements also need linguistic comparability. The British Sign Language norms of Vinson and colleagues addressed familiarity, iconicity, and age of acquisition within BSL, illustrating why values from ASL cannot simply be applied to another sign language. Age-of-acquisition ratings obtained from adults have different strengths and biases from longitudinal observations of children's first uses. If a researcher compares lexical access across groups, sign familiarity, regional variety, age of acquisition, and visual complexity must be reported or modeled. The consequence is a science of language-specific measurement integrated with broader theories of word recognition. Vinson et al. (2008) Carreiras et al. (2008)

The ASL-CDI 2.0 addresses a different construct: the development of young children's receptive and productive vocabulary. The inventory depends on caregiver observation, appropriate age ranges, and the linguistic environment in which a child's signs are used. Scores from early vocabulary measurement, adult lexical decision, and brain imaging therefore describe distinct levels of linguistic organization. An effective cumulative research program links those levels through explicit predictions and separately tests the reliability, measurement invariance, and generalizability of each tool. Caselli et al. (2020) Becker et al. (2026)

Integrating Experimental, Developmental, and Naturalistic Evidence

Experimental control is strongest when one feature is varied while the others are held stable. A gating study of individual signs can reveal when lexical information becomes sufficient for identification, and a grammaticality-judgment task can probe sensitivity to a defined construction. Each paradigm also restricts communication: isolated video tokens omit ordinary discourse, and explicit decisions impose metalinguistic demands. Naturalistic narratives and interactional corpora preserve the unfolding distribution of cues, mutual gaze, and communicative repair. An adequate theory must make predictions across these situations rather than treat laboratory performance as a complete account of signing. Emmorey & Corina (1990) Boudreault & Mayberry (2006) Emmorey et al. (2009)

Longitudinal evidence can determine the sequence in which constructions emerge and how variation in exposure precedes changes in measured competence. Cross-sectional comparisons can sample more ages and language histories but are sensitive to cohort effects and recruitment. Emerging-language studies supply an additional naturalistic perspective: contrasts among cohorts can reveal changing conventions as a language is transmitted. They require detailed attention to community networks, educational institutions, and the possibility that cohort differences reflect social opportunity. Evidence about one young sign language does not automatically provide a developmental law for all sign languages. Senghas et al. (2004) Brentari et al. (2024)

Triangulation is most convincing when different methods constrain the same explanatory claim. If lexical neighborhood structure predicts priming, eye-movement timing, and electrophysiological sensitivity under independent stimuli, the case for a psychologically meaningful representation strengthens. Conversely, a neural difference between groups cannot establish a deficit in lexical competence unless comprehension and task conditions support that inference. Future studies should publish stimulus annotations, transparent inclusion criteria, accessible analysis scripts, and participant-characterization variables while protecting the privacy of smaller signing communities. Meade et al. (2021) Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025) Sevcikova Sehyr et al. (2021)

Evidence Strength, Confounding, and Replicability

A recurrent confound in sign-language science is the statistical association of early sign exposure, Deaf-community participation, educational history, and hearing status. When these factors differ together, a between-group effect cannot isolate a single causal mechanism. Studies that compare native signers, later first-language learners, and hearing signers improve interpretation by creating more informative contrasts. Yet individual histories may still differ in cumulative input, literacy, language dominance, and access to fluent conversational partners. Analyses should avoid interpreting absence of a statistically significant difference as proof of population equivalence. Mayberry (1993) Cormier et al. (2012) Stoll & Dye (2019)

The signed-language literature often relies on relatively small samples recruited from language communities that cannot be treated as homogeneous statistical populations. Inferences therefore depend on uncertainty estimates, transparent exclusion rules, stimulus-level variation, and replication across regions. A large number of repeated trials does not eliminate uncertainty about generalization to new participants or a different language; mixed-effects models need defensible random structures and meaningful distributional checks. Studies that use different definitions of a native signer or of vocabulary proficiency can produce apparently inconsistent findings even when their underlying behavioral mechanisms are compatible. Carreiras et al. (2008) Emmorey et al. (2009) Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025)

The evidence for early accessible language has converging developmental, grammatical, lexical, and neural strands. Nevertheless, much of the timing evidence comes from observational histories rather than randomized manipulation, which would be inappropriate and unethical. Causal explanations must therefore compare plausible confounders and use the best available natural variation. Claims about specific neural networks, meanwhile, should be based on contrasts that identify linguistic composition apart from movement perception and general task demand. A responsible synthesis describes which mechanisms are directly measured and which remain theoretical explanations of a documented effect. Mayberry & Eichen (1991) Boudreault & Mayberry (2006) MacSweeney et al. (2008)

Recent Research and the Current Scientific Frontier

The review by Terhune-Cotter and Emmorey published in 2025 advances an anatomically informed account of sign-language comprehension linking visual analysis to phonological, lexical, and combinatorial operations. Its research contribution lies in organizing an evidence base that often separated perceptual, psycholinguistic, and neural questions. The comparison with spoken-language networks supports hypotheses about modality-general language functions implemented through additional visual and sensorimotor routes. Such a synthesis remains open to testing with individual-level localization, temporal measurements, and naturalistic comprehension rather than serving as definitive proof of a single neural pathway. Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025) MacSweeney et al. (2008)

The 2026 vocabulary study by Becker, Pyers, and Caselli emphasizes that the quantity and distribution of accessible input can alter the pace of lexical acquisition while some relationships governing vocabulary composition remain recognizable across differing experiences. This finding has particular value because it moves developmental research beyond a binary contrast between native and late signers. It supports predictions about word frequency and learning environments that can be investigated longitudinally with calibrated child vocabulary instruments. Generalization depends on the sample, caregiver histories, and the measurement of exposure; replication across sign languages and educational environments would test its broader significance. Becker et al. (2026) Caselli et al. (2020)

A 2025 observational eye-gaze study examined how deaf signers adjust their gaze when confronted with an unfamiliar sign language. This research direction tests the flexibility of visual sampling and draws attention to a distinction between processing a familiar lexical system and orienting to potentially informative motion. Future experiments can combine comprehension outcomes, dynamic eye tracking, continuous-video annotations, and formal tests of sign familiarity. The frontier is increasingly a multimethod, cross-community account of how interpretable linguistic structure emerges from visual experience across time. Sander et al. (2025) Stoll & Dye (2019)

Language Access, Educational Relevance, and Ethical Interpretation

The strongest practical implication of this body of research is the developmental importance of dependable access to language. Deaf children need sustained opportunities to communicate and acquire a complete natural language, and families differ greatly in their initial sign-language resources. Research documents that late acquisition of a first fully accessible language may carry enduring consequences for some linguistic operations. Such findings motivate close attention to early communication environments and to the distribution of educational resources. They must not be recast as deterministic judgments about individual capacity or as a claim that every child follows an identical developmental trajectory. Mayberry (1993) Lillo-Martin & Henner (2021)

Assessment in educational and developmental settings needs to distinguish what a child knows from what the test makes accessible. A written English item can require literacy beyond the targeted ASL construct; a video assessment may be more direct but still demand an unfamiliar variant or culturally specific vocabulary. Caregiver reports also depend on how often a child's skills can be observed. Language histories, communication preferences, multilingual context, and participation in Deaf communities should inform the choice and interpretation of measures. The ASL-CDI instruments and ASL-LEX resources are valuable for particular research populations and need appropriate adaptation before cross-language use. Caselli et al. (2020) Sevcikova Sehyr et al. (2021)

The ethics of research include partnership with signing communities, accurate linguistic identification, accessible consent, respectful publication, and protection from the reidentification risks of visual recordings. Science gains when Deaf participants are treated as users of languages with varied experiences rather than as a uniform diagnostic category. For researchers and educators, the central practical question is how to make communication environments sufficiently rich and measurable to support learning, participation, and generalization. Where clinical or language-policy recommendations are drawn from this literature, they require assessment of the relevant population, current professional guidance, and the evidence beyond a single experimental effect. Lillo-Martin & Henner (2021) Becker et al. (2026)

Open Problems and Research Priorities

Several important problems remain unresolved. Researchers need dynamic, language-specific accounts of how simultaneously distributed features combine into incremental recognition; cross-language models of phonological neighborhood and morphology; and stronger identification of the relation between iconicity, conventional lexical representation, and early learning. They also need tasks that preserve the referential, interpersonal, and visual conditions of natural communication while supporting controlled comparisons. Standardized videos alone provide repeatability but cannot capture the interactive adjustment of signer and viewer. The next generation of research should connect formal linguistic annotations to time-resolved behavioral and neural evidence. Emmorey & Corina (1990) Caselli et al. (2017) Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025)

Developmental priorities include measuring the timing, continuity, and quality of accessible first-language input, including variation among caregivers and across educational settings. Cohort and community comparisons can identify hypotheses about transmission and language emergence, but they also require careful historical and demographic descriptions. Cross-linguistic work should expand substantially beyond the most heavily studied signing communities and report exactly which forms and grammatical functions are being compared. Progress will depend on constructing resources whose categories arise from each language's linguistic organization instead of imposing one English-based translation inventory. Becker et al. (2026) Brentari et al. (2024) Vinson et al. (2008)

Questions about machine understanding of signing arise in the Artificial Era because automatic recognition systems can identify visible articulations and sometimes approximate textual translations. These engineering outputs do not themselves establish human-equivalent lexical, grammatical, or social processing. A psychologically meaningful comparison would separately measure visual recognition, compositional generalization, referential continuity, robustness across signers, and the relation of training data to real-world competence. Any claim about an artificial system's language acquisition requires specified training histories, tests for novel utterances, and evaluation within authentic languages. Signed languages offer a demanding case for studying how general representational functions depend on material embodiment, accessible interaction, and linguistic community. Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025) Brentari et al. (2024)

Conclusion

Signed language processing and acquisition establish that complex human linguistic organization operates through conventional visual-manual systems. Their phonological contrasts, lexical competition, morphological structure, syntax, discourse reference, and developmental pathways reveal a language capacity expressed through a distinctive combination of visual attention, articulatory dynamics, interaction, and social transmission. The experimental evidence supports important commonalities in linguistic organization across modalities while documenting modality-dependent demands and language-specific structures. The scientific object is accordingly defined by linguistic form, comprehension, production, and development in actual signing communities. Stokoe (1960) Lillo-Martin & Henner (2021) Terhune-Cotter & Emmorey (2025)

Historical and contemporary research jointly demonstrate the value of combining linguistic analysis with gating, priming, eye-tracking, grammar judgments, caregiver reports, longitudinal observation, and neuroscience. Evidence about early language access is especially consequential because delayed first-language experience can predict persistent differences in measured processing despite later opportunities to learn. Community-emergence research further shows that individuals and cohorts contribute differently to the formation of shared grammatical systems. Each conclusion has a defined evidentiary scope, and a careful synthesis distinguishes association from causal identification, and a task-specific neural response from an architecture-wide claim. Mayberry (1993) Senghas et al. (2004) Boudreault & Mayberry (2006)

The next scientific advance lies in measurement standards that recognize signed languages on their own terms and in collaborative research that integrates the diversity of sign languages and their users. This dossier identifies a coherent psychological research program: the study of how language-bearing visual movement is recognized, combined into meaning, learned across a lifetime, and sustained through communities. Its implications connect psycholinguistics, developmental psychology, cognitive neuroscience, linguistic typology, accessibility research, and the broader comparative understanding of language in the Artificial Era. The account remains grounded in primary studies and clearly testable questions about representation, learning, and communication. Brentari et al. (2024) Becker et al. (2026)

References

  • Becker, A. A., Pyers, J. E., & Caselli, N. E. (2026). Mechanisms of vocabulary acquisition persist under variable language experience. Developmental Science, 29(3), e70169. https://doi.org/10.1111/desc.70169
  • Boudreault, P., & Mayberry, R. I. (2006). Grammatical processing in American Sign Language: Age of first-language acquisition effects in relation to syntactic structure. Language and Cognitive Processes, 21(5), 608–635. https://doi.org/10.1080/01690960500139363
  • Brentari, D., Coppola, M., Mazzoni, L., & Goldin-Meadow, S. (2012). When does a system become phonological? Handshape production in gesturers, signers, and homesigners. Natural Language & Linguistic Theory, 30(1), 1–31. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11049-011-9145-1
  • Brentari, D., Ergin, R., Senghas, A., & Coppola, M. (2024). Typological comparisons and considerations: Phonological and morphological evidence from sign language creation. Sign Language Studies, 25(1), 8–52. https://doi.org/10.1353/sls.2024.a950716
  • Carreiras, M., Gutiérrez-Sigut, E., Baquero, S., & Corina, D. (2008). Lexical processing in Spanish Sign Language (LSE). Journal of Memory and Language, 58(1), 100–122. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jml.2007.05.004
  • Caselli, N. K., Sevcikova Sehyr, Z., Cohen-Goldberg, A. M., & Emmorey, K. (2017). ASL-LEX: A lexical database of American Sign Language. Behavior Research Methods, 49(2), 784–801. https://doi.org/10.3758/s13428-016-0742-0
  • Caselli, N. K., Lieberman, A. M., & Pyers, J. E. (2020). The ASL-CDI 2.0: An updated, normed adaptation of the MacArthur Bates Communicative Development Inventory for American Sign Language. Behavior Research Methods, 52(5), 2071–2084. https://doi.org/10.3758/s13428-020-01376-6
  • Cormier, K., Schembri, A., Vinson, D., & Orfanidou, E. (2012). First language acquisition differs from second language acquisition in prelingually deaf signers: Evidence from sensitivity to grammaticality judgement in British Sign Language. Cognition, 124(1), 50–65. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cognition.2012.04.003
  • Emmorey, K., & Corina, D. (1990). Lexical recognition in sign language: Effects of phonetic structure and morphology. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 71(3_suppl), 1227–1252. https://doi.org/10.2466/pms.1990.71.3f.1227
  • Emmorey, K. (2002). Language, cognition, and the brain: Insights from sign language research. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. https://www.routledge.com/Language-Cognition-and-the-Brain-Insights-From-Sign-Language-Research/Emmorey/p/book/9780805833980
  • Emmorey, K., Thompson, R., & Colvin, R. (2009). Eye gaze during comprehension of American Sign Language by native and beginning signers. Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education, 14(2), 237–243. https://doi.org/10.1093/deafed/enn037
  • Goldin-Meadow, S., & Mylander, C. (1998). Spontaneous sign systems created by deaf children in two cultures. Nature, 391(6664), 279–281. https://doi.org/10.1038/34646
  • Lieberman, A. M., Borovsky, A., Hatrak, M., & Mayberry, R. I. (2015). Real-time processing of ASL signs: Delayed first language acquisition affects organization of the mental lexicon. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 41(4), 1130–1139. https://doi.org/10.1037/xlm0000088
  • Lillo-Martin, D., & Henner, J. (2021). Acquisition of sign languages. Annual Review of Linguistics, 7, 395–419. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-linguistics-043020-092357
  • MacSweeney, M., Woll, B., Campbell, R., McGuire, P. K., David, A. S., Williams, S. C. R., Suckling, J., Calvert, G. A., & Brammer, M. J. (2002). Neural systems underlying British Sign Language and audio-visual English processing in native users. Brain, 125(7), 1583–1593. https://doi.org/10.1093/brain/awf153
  • MacSweeney, M., Capek, C. M., Campbell, R., & Woll, B. (2008). The signing brain: The neurobiology of sign language. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 12(11), 432–440. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tics.2008.07.010
  • Mayberry, R. I., & Eichen, E. B. (1991). The long-lasting advantage of learning sign language in childhood: Another look at the critical period for language acquisition. Journal of Memory and Language, 30(4), 486–512. https://doi.org/10.1016/0749-596X(91)90018-F
  • Mayberry, R. I. (1993). First-language acquisition after childhood differs from second-language acquisition: The case of American Sign Language. Journal of Speech and Hearing Research, 36(6), 1258–1270. https://doi.org/10.1044/jshr.3606.1258
  • Meade, G., Lee, B., Massa, N., Holcomb, P. J., Midgley, K. J., & Emmorey, K. (2021). The organization of the American Sign Language lexicon: Comparing one- and two-parameter ERP phonological priming effects across tasks. Brain and Language, 218, 104960. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bandl.2021.104960
  • Newman, A. J., Bavelier, D., Corina, D., Jezzard, P., & Neville, H. J. (2002). A critical period for right hemisphere recruitment in American Sign Language processing. Nature Neuroscience, 5, 76–80. https://doi.org/10.1038/nn775
  • Petitto, L. A., & Marentette, P. F. (1991). Babbling in the manual mode: Evidence for the ontogeny of language. Science, 251(5000), 1493–1496. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.2006424
  • Sander, J., Meister, N.-K., Finkbeiner, T. A., Rowland, C. F., Steinbach, M., Friederici, A. D., Zaccarella, E., & Trettenbrein, P. C. (2025). Deaf signers adapt their eye gaze behaviour when processing an unknown sign language. In D. Barner, N. R. Bramley, A. Ruggeri, & C. M. Walker (Eds.), Proceedings of the 47th Annual Meeting of the Cognitive Science Society (pp. 1998–2005). Cognitive Science Society. https://escholarship.org/uc/item/018384xx
  • Senghas, A., Kita, S., & Özyürek, A. (2004). Children creating core properties of language: Evidence from an emerging sign language in Nicaragua. Science, 305(5691), 1779–1782. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1100199
  • Sevcikova Sehyr, Z., Caselli, N., Cohen-Goldberg, A. M., & Emmorey, K. (2021). The ASL-LEX 2.0 project: A database of lexical and phonological properties for 2,723 signs in American Sign Language. Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education, 26(2), 263–277. https://doi.org/10.1093/deafed/enaa038
  • Stokoe, W. C., Jr. (1960). Sign language structure: An outline of the visual communication systems of the American deaf. Department of Anthropology and Linguistics, University of Buffalo. https://glottolog.org/resource/reference/id/718600
  • Stoll, C., & Dye, M. W. G. (2019). Sign language experience redistributes attentional resources to the inferior visual field. Cognition, 191, 103957. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cognition.2019.04.026
  • Terhune-Cotter, B., & Emmorey, K. (2025). The neural network for sign language comprehension. Language and Linguistics Compass, 19(4), e70018. https://doi.org/10.1111/lnc3.70018
  • Vinson, D. P., Cormier, K., Denmark, T., Schembri, A., & Vigliocco, G. (2008). The British Sign Language (BSL) norms for age of acquisition, familiarity, and iconicity. Behavior Research Methods, 40(4), 1079–1087. https://doi.org/10.3758/BRM.40.4.1079