RESEARCH DOSSIER
Religious and Spiritual Struggles: Conflict, Guilt, and Doubt
Abstract. Religious and spiritual struggles are experiences of conflict, tension, and distress involving beliefs, relationships, moral commitments, sacred expectations, or ultimate meaning. This research monograph synthesizes the history of the construct; six empirically identified dimensions; social, developmental, cognitive, moral, and clinical mechanisms; validated measurement; longitudinal evidence; heterogeneous cultural applications; and research priorities. Its scientific method is a critical narrative synthesis of identifiable original studies, longitudinal analyses, systematic reviews, psychometric investigations, and professional guidance, with attention to differences between association, prospective prediction, and causal inference. A central finding is that spiritual struggle is multidimensional and often intertwined with psychological distress, yet its meaning, functional significance, and possible resolution depend on a person's background, social environment, clinical context, and time course. The evidence supports assessment of spiritual conflict as a clinically relevant dimension of experience while leaving important questions about causal pathways, cultural generalization, treatment specificity, and measurement invariance unresolved.
Keywords: religious and spiritual struggles; religious guilt; religious doubt; spiritual conflict; divine struggle; demonic struggle; moral struggle; ultimate meaning; religious coping; spiritual distress; scrupulosity; religious identity; longitudinal research; clinical assessment.
Scientific Overview and Research Questions
Religious and spiritual struggle arises when a person experiences a painful tension involving what they regard as sacred, ultimately meaningful, religiously obligatory, or spiritually authoritative. The relevant psychological object is an individual's conflict as experienced and organized through interpretation, emotion, behavior, and relationships. This includes an adherent who feels betrayed by God, a person troubled by perceived moral failure, a believer negotiating incompatible religious authorities, a doubter who fears the social consequences of uncertainty, and a nonreligious person whose previously sacred commitments have lost their organizing power. The psychological analysis must attend to the structure and effects of these experiences without deciding the truth of a religious doctrine. The six domains established by Exline et al. (2014) Exline (2014) provide the main empirical taxonomy, while Bockrath et al. (2022) Bockrath (2022) and later prospective research investigate their temporal associations with adjustment.
The organizing questions are how such struggles arise, how their dimensions overlap, how conflict becomes persistent or resolves, which personal and institutional conditions alter the course, how measurement distinguishes ordinary questioning from disabling distress, and what the evidence permits clinicians and researchers to infer. Religious intensity alone supplies an incomplete explanation: a highly engaged person may feel secure and supported, or may face a severe challenge precisely because a threatened commitment is central to identity. Likewise, low formal affiliation does not establish the absence of a sacred value system. The research object is therefore conflict in sacred meaning rather than any given religious institution or percentage of religious participation.
This is an evidence-based critical narrative monograph rather than a preregistered systematic review or a newly conducted meta-analysis. It compares studies with different populations, follow-up periods, scales, clinical settings, and inferential limits, deliberately retaining conceptual questions that quantitative correlations cannot settle. The scope includes anxiety, depression, suicidal ideation, and obsessive-compulsive symptoms when the evidence connects them with struggles; it does not assign diagnosis on the basis of doubt or religious guilt alone. Neighboring subjects—religious coping, religiosity measurement, clinical assessment, and broader mental health outcomes—remain separate research objects.
Historical Formation of the Construct
Early psychology of religion treated religious lives as psychologically complex, allowing experiences of comfort, anguish, conversion, and discontinuity to appear together in personal reports. The later empirical tradition developed a more differentiated language for religious orientation, religious strain, and coping under adversity. In contemporary psychological science, struggles came to be framed as tensions in relation to the sacred and as phenomena whose consequences could be tested, measured, and followed over time. The key transition was from describing religious distress as a vague adverse attitude toward religion to measuring particular appraisals, relationships, moral conflicts, and threats to meaning.
The religious coping program of Pargament, Koenig, and Perez (2000) Pargament (2000) contributed a major operational advance. It differentiated constructive or supportive responses from alienation, punitive divine appraisals, and forms of discontent with the sacred. The subsequent 14-item Brief RCOPE, evaluated by Pargament, Feuille, and Burdzy (2011) Pargament (2011), made such coping patterns easier to incorporate into studies of illness, transition, and stress. These measures tracked ways people respond to adverse events; they did not yet provide the same detailed taxonomy of religious or spiritual struggle as a wider feature of psychological life. A person could experience ongoing anger, fear, doubt, or moral conflict even in periods without a clearly identified new stressor.
An early direct test of religious strain and psychological symptoms by Exline, Yali, and Sanderson (2000) Exline (2000) examined a student sample and a psychotherapy outpatient sample. The study associated religious guilt, alienation, and interpersonal conflict with indices of depression and suicidality, helping shift research attention toward problematic experiences otherwise concealed by global measures of religious comfort. Subsequent work by Exline, Park, Smyth, and Carey (2011) Exline (2011) documented anger toward God across the general population, students, bereaved individuals, and cancer survivors. The significance of these research programs is historical and methodological: they allowed spiritual distress to be investigated as a patterned psychological experience instead of presuming that religious involvement has one uniform psychological direction.
The Sacred as a Psychological Organizing Value
In this field, the sacred refers to things people regard as possessing extraordinary meaning, ultimate authority, or spiritual importance. Within religious traditions these may include a deity, covenant, moral order, scripture, community, ritual, or anticipated salvation. For some people, a noninstitutional spiritual orientation or a deeply held ultimate commitment provides the relevant referent. The word sacred operates as a reported category of meaning and value; scientific measurement addresses the person's interpretations and their consequences. A psychometric scale cannot adjudicate whether any supernatural presence exists.
Sacred commitments organize attention, anticipation, self-judgment, and relationships. The psychological force of a struggle depends partly on how densely those commitments connect to the rest of life. If the threatened belief informs family bonds, vocation, sexuality, daily ritual, and personal worth, a single conflict may reverberate across many domains. Park (2005) Park (2005) situates religion within systems of global meaning that influence how adversity is interpreted. The discrepancy between what a person expected of the world and what they experienced can initiate attempts at meaning making, reinterpretation, or withdrawal.
An analysis of sacred importance also needs to distinguish commitment from coercion. A belief experienced as freely chosen may provide a different motivational context from a demand maintained through threat, dependence, or fear of social exclusion. Identical questionnaire responses may conceal unlike situations: moral regret for a voluntarily accepted value, fear following interpersonal control, and the repetition of intrusive obsessional thoughts can all be expressed as guilt. The aim of a rigorous account is to identify the generative context and trajectory of the experience before assigning a single interpretation to the score.
Six Empirical Dimensions of Religious and Spiritual Struggle
The 26-item Religious and Spiritual Struggles Scale developed by Exline et al. (2014) Exline (2014) identifies divine, demonic, interpersonal, moral, doubt, and ultimate-meaning dimensions. In the original research, exploratory factor analyses in two adult samples and confirmatory factor analysis in an undergraduate sample provided evidence for differentiation among these dimensions. Their correlations also show that a person struggling in one domain may be struggling in another. The domains describe related experiences and measurement factors; they are not psychiatric diagnoses or six discrete types of people.
Divine struggles involve anger, disappointment, abandonment, or perceived punishment in relation to God. Demonic struggles involve interpreting adverse experiences through threats from malevolent supernatural beings or forces. Interpersonal struggles concern religiously charged disagreement, betrayal, exclusion, authority conflicts, or institutional maltreatment. Moral struggles include guilt, perceived sin, or difficulty aligning conduct with important principles. Doubt struggles involve distress around uncertain or challenged spiritual beliefs. Ultimate-meaning struggles express fears that one's life lacks purpose, significance, or coherence. The same individual may move between dimensions as events unfold.
This six-part arrangement has strong descriptive utility because it identifies the subject of the conflict and the psychological tensions accompanying it. However, the taxonomy does not specify the cause of each struggle, distinguish transient questioning from chronic distress, or guarantee identical meanings across cultures. A demonic attribution can be part of a culturally ordinary belief system, while a moral worry can reflect actual wrongdoing, a disproportionate self-accusation, or compulsive uncertainty. Interpretation requires contextual interviews and convergent evidence. Smith et al. (2026) Smith (2026) suggests that a general struggle dimension and domain-specific factors may both be psychometrically informative.
Divine Struggles: Relationship, Anger, and Abandonment
Divine struggle has a relational structure whenever a person experiences the deity as a personally meaningful agent. Suffering, bereavement, illness, or unanswered prayer can appear as evidence of neglect, unfairness, punishment, or broken trust. These experiences invite interpersonal psychological concepts—attribution, expectation, protest, attachment, and perceived responsiveness—although they concern a relationship understood by the individual in religious terms. Exline, Park, Smyth, and Carey (2011) Exline (2011) examined anger toward God using multiple research populations, showing why negative affect within religious life deserves direct empirical attention.
Anger toward God is not equivalent to disbelief. Individuals may express strong anger precisely while continuing to regard God as real, attentive, and morally important. Equally, they may fear that disclosing anger is itself a forbidden act, adding guilt and social silence to the primary grievance. The survey reported by Exline and Grubbs (2011) Exline (2011) found that disclosure sometimes attracted supportive responses and sometimes judgment, shame, and discouragement. Consequently the social interpretation of protest is part of the struggle's evolution: the initial difficulty may be intensified or moderated by how significant others respond.
Longitudinal research offers a way to test whether divine conflict predicts subsequent functioning beyond concurrent distress. In a U.S. midlife cohort of 4,041 participants, Cowden, Pargament, and Wilkinson (2025) Cowden (2025) assessed later outcomes after substantial covariate adjustment, including earlier outcomes, and reported generally very small prospective associations with poorer functioning across selected domains. Such findings strengthen temporal description, but causal explanation remains uncertain because spiritual appraisals, prior suffering, social resources, and mental health can reciprocally influence one another.
Demonic Struggles: Threat Appraisal and Cultural Interpretation
Demonic struggle refers to personally distressing interpretations that evil spirits or comparable malevolent powers are attacking, obstructing, or causing misfortune. This is a self-reported appraisal of experience within a belief environment. Investigators must separate the cultural legitimacy of a particular religious explanation from the intensity of the fear, the behavior that follows, and the person's capacity to function. The Exline et al. (2014) Exline (2014) domain captures experiences that may be rare or difficult to report in secular samples yet highly salient in particular traditions.
Fear-based attribution can alter perceived controllability and threat monitoring. When an adverse event is interpreted as evidence of supernatural hostility, ordinary uncertainty may acquire urgent moral or spiritual meaning. Alternatively, shared ritual and communal interpretation may provide reassurance or coordinated coping. These are possible pathways requiring empirical distinction rather than universal laws. Cross-cultural samples are indispensable because a translated item about demonic attack may function differently where the category is widely accepted, marginal, metaphorical, or absent.
Clinical interpretation becomes especially delicate when an unusual belief, a culturally shared spiritual account, an intrusive thought, and a psychotic symptom appear verbally similar. Diagnosis depends on wider evidence including distress, function, context, behavior, insight, and symptom organization. The five-item screening tool developed by Salcone et al. (2025) Salcone (2025) deliberately omits demonic items, a design decision that makes it less appropriate for research seeking comprehensive description of the original six domains. Researchers must choose a measure according to the scientific question, document the omitted domain, and resist treating the short form as an exhaustive account.
Interpersonal Struggles: Community, Authority, and Betrayal
Interpersonal religious struggles arise when a person experiences tension with family, clergy, peers, institutions, or a wider community over beliefs and practices understood as sacred. The conflicts may concern belonging, doctrine, gender roles, life decisions, ritual observance, or the exercise of authority. Some involve ordinary disagreement among people who maintain reciprocal respect; others involve social coercion, intimidation, humiliation, exclusion, or abuse. Their psychological consequences depend on relational power and access to alternatives as well as the intensity of disagreement.
Religious communities often furnish social support, practical help, roles, and a language for suffering. The same dense networks can carry high costs of dissent, particularly when departure threatens family stability, livelihood, or identity. Because the community may also be the person's principal support network, injury within it can reduce the very resources otherwise available for coping. A measurement strategy that asks only about participation or attendance would miss this double function. The interpersonal domain of Exline et al. (2014) Exline (2014) captures a subset of these experiences, while interviews and institutional histories are needed to reconstruct how the conflict developed.
Institutional harm should be investigated at the level of identifiable acts, policies, authority structures, and outcomes. Broad language about spiritual abuse requires careful operationalization: perceived betrayal, coercive control, unwanted exposure, sexual or psychological victimization, and subsequent symptoms are distinguishable events. Kanter, Hoffman, and Hassija (2025) Kanter (2025) investigated religious and spiritual struggle in a sample of U.S. Christian women reporting intimate partner sexual violence; its cross-sectional associations cannot establish the mediation process as a proven causal pathway. Such studies nevertheless highlight the importance of documenting power, trauma exposure, and the person's actual choices rather than reducing distress to a theological disagreement.
Moral Struggles: Guilt, Shame, and Self-Evaluation
Moral struggle occurs when a person's conduct, thoughts, desires, or life circumstances appear to violate deeply held religious or spiritual standards. Guilt usually focuses on a perceived action or omission, whereas shame involves a broader negative assessment of the self. These conceptual tendencies help interpret experience, although self-report wording and cultural vocabularies do not always cleanly separate them. Moral distress can motivate restitution, reconciliation, or changed behavior; it can also take the form of repetitive condemnation, pervasive worthlessness, or immobilizing fear.
A complete analysis must distinguish the content of a moral concern, the process by which it recurs, and the social forces that enforce it. Questions include whether a discernible action occurred, whether a standard is self-endorsed, what sanctions are anticipated, and whether reassurance or confessional repetition temporarily reduces anxiety. In Exline, Yali, and Sanderson (2000) Exline (2000), religious fears and guilt were associated with suicidality in the studied samples, including fears about an unforgivable sin. That association deserves careful clinical attention without converting every moral or religious regret into evidence of suicidality.
Moral injury research partly overlaps with this area. VanderWeele et al. (2025) VanderWeele (2025) develops distinctions among moral distress, morally injurious events, and their possible emotional, relational, and spiritual aftermath. Moral injury may involve betrayal, coercion, victimization, or the violation of central expectations, and its evaluation requires more than a guilt item. The wider category is useful for examining religious trauma and conscience, yet spiritual struggle and moral injury remain separate constructs with partially overlapping indicators. Studies should evaluate discriminant validity and avoid counting similar items twice as independent evidence of different conditions.
Doubt Struggles: Uncertainty and Epistemic Conflict
Religious doubt becomes a struggle when uncertainty about a sacred proposition, authority, practice, or tradition is experienced as threatening, shameful, consequential, or difficult to tolerate. A person may doubt the coherence of a doctrine while remaining committed to a community. Another may experience contradictions between personal experience and the teachings of trusted authorities. A third may face intense pressure to affirm certainty despite private ambiguity. The research concern is the suffering, behavior, and possible change associated with uncertainty rather than the mere presence of questioning.
Doubt interacts with epistemic trust. When religious beliefs are supported by valued witnesses, family narratives, or institutional interpretation, contradictory evidence can threaten one's confidence in relationships as well as propositions. This helps explain why belief revision sometimes carries a larger emotional cost than the cognitive act of changing an opinion. Longitudinal designs should differentiate questions that remain active, occasions when people suppress questions, and eventual changes of conviction. The Exline et al. (2014) Exline (2014) doubting domain captures troubled uncertainty, but measures of belief strength, identity, and social cost are necessary to specify the underlying process.
Doubt also deserves separation from obsessive doubt. In compulsive patterns, a person may search repeatedly for certainty that they have believed correctly, prayed correctly, or committed no offense. The goal of the behavior may be immediate relief from an intrusive possibility rather than exploration of a doctrine. Conversely, sustained theological questioning without repetitive neutralization is compatible with ordinary intellectual development. The measurement of distress intensity alone cannot separate these patterns; clinicians and investigators must examine triggers, responses, recurrence, flexibility, and impairment.
Ultimate-Meaning Struggles and Existential Disorientation
Ultimate-meaning struggle involves concern that life has little significance, coherent purpose, lasting value, or connection to a sacred horizon. Such concerns may intensify after a death, serious illness, institutional betrayal, departure from a tradition, or a major change in identity. Meaning may be threatened at several levels: the expected order of events, the worth of one's actions, the continuity of a life narrative, and the confidence that one's future remains intelligible. Park (2005) Park (2005) gives a theoretical account of how global meaning frameworks and situational appraisal interact during adversity.
This dimension is particularly important because it can be expressed through religious language or through nonreligious existential vocabulary. A person abandoning a former faith may experience both liberation and grief, or may relocate ultimate value to relationships, work, art, ethical commitments, or a different spiritual orientation. The relevant empirical question is whether meaning becomes disrupted and how coherence is subsequently reconstructed. A binary distinction between religion and nonreligion can obscure continuity in the psychological functions of meaning systems.
Ultimate-meaning struggle may co-occur with depression, but the constructs should not be merged. A person can question the meaning of life while remaining otherwise psychologically engaged, and depressive symptoms can occur without spiritual struggle. The time course matters: existential disruption may precede symptoms, arise from illness and depressed mood, or share a third cause. Prospective research such as Cowden et al. (2022) Cowden (2022) supports evaluating competing temporal accounts instead of declaring one direction inevitable.
Intersections and a General Struggle Dimension
The six dimensions share a common feature: perceived disruption in a spiritually important domain. They also differ in their object, social context, typical appraisals, and likely behaviors. Moral guilt may combine with divine punishment; doubt may follow institutional betrayal; loss of ultimate meaning may emerge after departure from a community. A multidimensional assessment can reveal such configurations without creating a separate diagnostic label for every combination.
Psychometric evidence has sharpened the debate between a correlated six-factor model and models including a broad general struggle factor. The original Exline et al. (2014) Exline (2014) validation showed substantial support for six domains. The later synthesis by Smith et al. (2026) Smith (2026) aggregated psychometric evidence from 66 studies and reported strong pooled internal consistency, while finding tentative support for higher-order or bifactor interpretations. A total score may be useful for estimating overall burden, yet the factor solution depends on instrument wording, sampling, model constraints, and the purpose of measurement.
General distress presents an additional measurement problem. If the scale of spiritual struggle relies heavily on emotional suffering, a correlation with depression or anxiety may partly reflect shared negative affect. Establishing that spiritual content adds explanatory value requires controls for prior symptoms, item-overlap audits, and prospective assessment. The important question is whether particular sacred appraisals or social events contribute information beyond generic distress and beyond stable individual differences. Factor fit alone cannot demonstrate that a broad spiritual struggle mechanism has been identified.
Stress Appraisal, Coping, and Reciprocal Processes
Stress and coping theories explain spiritual struggle through perceived demands, available resources, and interpretations of difficult events. Pargament, Koenig, and Perez (2000) Pargament (2000) demonstrates that religious coping is a set of practices and appraisals rather than a single disposition. Responses such as seeking spiritual support and benevolent reinterpretation may accompany adaptive adjustment, whereas punitive reappraisal and spiritual discontent may accompany poorer outcomes. The associations depend on context and measurement. Researchers should specify whether coping is an immediate response to a stressor, a recurring interpretive habit, or an enduring struggle that predates that stressor.
The longitudinal investigation by Pirutinsky (2024) Pirutinsky (2024) followed 397 participants across six occasions over three years and found both relatively stable variation in negative religious coping and elevations under stressful life conditions. Its results indicate that cross-sectional negative-coping scores may conflate a standing vulnerability with stress-responsive change. The distinction matters for theory: an individual with long-standing spiritual alienation may score similarly to someone whose struggle began during a recent illness, yet the two trajectories suggest different mechanisms and temporal dependencies.
A reciprocal model is plausible whenever emotional symptoms change how a person interprets sacred experience and spiritual conflict, in turn, affects coping, social contact, and self-appraisal. Cowden et al. (2022) Cowden (2022) tested primary, secondary, and complex explanations using three waves of data from 302 adults with chronic health conditions. Cross-lagged models provide more temporal information than a single survey, but they remain vulnerable to unmeasured confounding and differences between stable persons and within-person change. Future studies should include strong baseline measurement, multiple follow-ups, time-varying covariates, and theoretically specified feedback paths.
Identity, Belonging, and Conflicts Across Roles
Religious and spiritual struggles often become salient at moments when identities collide. A person may experience tension between family obligation and independent conviction, community membership and sexual identity, religious vocation and perceived inadequacy, or inherited doctrine and an emerging ethical position. The resulting distress is shaped by the value attached to each identity and by the actual social consequences of choosing among roles. Identity integration refers to developing a workable way of holding multiple meaningful commitments, not necessarily dissolving their differences.
In a study of religious gay men, Anderson and Koc (2020) Anderson (2020) investigated identity integration as a correlate of guilt and shame. The work demonstrates the importance of measuring how a person organizes potentially conflicting identifications rather than relying on a global religiosity score. Longitudinal evidence from Lefevor and Skidmore (2025) Lefevor (2025) followed sexual and gender minority individuals raised in the Latter-day Saint tradition over two to four years; several characteristics, particularly self-compassion, internalized homonegativity, and authentic religious engagement, were informative about subsequent depression or conflict resolution in the reported analyses. Population-specific evidence should not be transferred automatically to other religions or cultural groups.
A person may resolve a struggle through reinterpretation, continued engagement on revised terms, changing communities, leaving a tradition, or developing a plural identity. Psychological functioning cannot be inferred from which doctrinal conclusion is reached. A scientifically adequate outcome model measures autonomy, distress, relationships, safety, coherence, and functioning. The researcher may examine how a choice was made, what resources supported it, and what costs followed, without positioning religious retention or religious departure as the sole desirable endpoint.
Development, Socialization, and Life-Course Change
Children encounter religious ideas through family practices, narratives, institutions, and norms about acceptable questions. During adolescence, the development of abstract thought, autonomy, peer relationships, and identity can change how previously accepted claims are evaluated. Religious or spiritual tension can therefore shift in its content and significance over the life course. However, research must avoid treating age as a complete explanation: parental authority, social conditions, community membership, and major life events all shape what questioning entails.
A 2026 two-wave adolescent study by Lisonbee, Dyer, and Hardy (2026) Lisonbee (2026) modeled transitions in profiles of interpersonal, doubt-related, and divine struggles alongside psychological well-being indicators in a Western U.S. sample. Such latent-transition studies can help characterize heterogeneity, showing why a single developmental average obscures divergent profiles. Nevertheless, profiles depend on chosen indicators, their reliability, and sample retention; a statistically classified transition need not represent a discrete developmental stage.
An investigation of 535 seminary students by Upenieks and Eagle (2026) Upenieks (2026) tested whether childhood religiosity modified the relationship between spiritual struggles and depressive symptoms. In that specialized population, greater childhood religious immersion strengthened the observed association. This finding is consistent with an identity-threat interpretation and also illustrates the possibility that familiarity with religious practices can coexist with vulnerability to threat against highly central commitments. It is a conditional association in a distinctive educational and religious setting rather than a universal developmental law.
Culture, Religious Traditions, and Nonreligious Perspectives
Religious struggle is studied across cultural settings, but the distribution of dimensions and the meanings of items cannot be assumed constant. In Muslim contexts, some appraisals may be articulated using specific concepts of divine intention, moral obligation, and spiritual forces; in Jewish settings, communal identity and distinct theological traditions may shape response processes. Abu-Raiya et al. (2015) Abu-Raiya (2015) and Abu-Raiya et al. (2016) Abu-Raiya (2016) are foundational examinations that extend the RSS framework beyond its original U.S. sampling frame. The Israeli-Jewish study included 164 university students and reported differing correlates for moral, divine, and doubt struggles. This is evidence of contextual variability, not proof that all individuals within a religious tradition share one psychological profile.
The same item may signal unusual distress in one setting and a culturally available way of naming hardship in another. Translation accuracy alone cannot resolve this issue. Researchers need cognitive interviews, differential item functioning tests, measurement invariance analyses, and locally appropriate qualitative study. Country and religion should be treated as intersecting but distinct dimensions; language, migration, social class, gender, and exposure to discrimination may further shape responses.
Nonreligious persons can experience spiritual conflict when relationships, histories, or former commitments remain salient. Former believers may struggle with family rejection, moral residue from prior teachings, uncertainty about meaning, or ambivalence toward a community they have left. Others may understand spiritual experience independently of institutional membership. A measure whose items presuppose belief in God will be partly inapplicable to these participants, while other domains may remain meaningful. The task is to determine when comparison across backgrounds is valid rather than forcing apparent numerical equivalence.
Clinical Symptoms, Distress, and Functional Impairment
A spiritual conflict becomes clinically significant when its relation to emotional symptoms, safety, daily functioning, or severe impairment merits clinical attention. Correlates include anxiety, depression, guilt, and suicidal ideation, yet none is implied automatically by a score on a spirituality scale. Exline, Yali, and Sanderson (2000) Exline (2000) linked religious strain with distress in early clinical and nonclinical samples, and the longitudinal meta-analysis by Bockrath et al. (2022) Bockrath (2022) expanded the inquiry to prospective adjustment. These findings justify clinical awareness while requiring continued assessment of ordinary psychiatric symptoms and circumstances.
The contrast between religious struggle and global religious involvement is informative. A broader longitudinal meta-analysis of religion and mental health by Garssen, Visser, and Pool (2021) Garssen (2021) reported a small pooled association for religion/spirituality indicators and later mental health. That synthesis included different religious constructs and should not be reinterpreted as an effect size specific to spiritual struggle. The more coherent inference is that supportive religious resources and distressing spiritual tensions can coexist, and analyses that collapse them into a single religiousness variable may conceal meaningful associations.
Clinical interpretation also has to account for the direction of influence. Fatigue, anhedonia, low mood, and anxiety may change the perceived availability of divine or communal support; theological disorientation may also worsen the burden of illness. In a nine-year outcome-wide analysis, Cowden, Pargament, and Wilkinson (2025) Cowden (2025) identified small prospective associations despite extensive adjustment, showing that temporal prediction should be read with its magnitude and confidence limits. Neither an observed association nor a prospective coefficient alone identifies a therapeutic target without additional evidence.
Scrupulosity and Obsessive-Compulsive Mechanisms
Scrupulosity describes religious or moral content in obsessional fear and compulsive responses, generally considered in the clinical context of obsessive-compulsive disorder. A person may experience recurring intrusive worries about sin, blasphemy, ritual correctness, moral contamination, or certainty of forgiveness. Attempts to neutralize doubt can include reassurance-seeking, repeated prayer or confession, checking intentions, mentally reviewing acts, or avoiding triggers. The clinical emphasis is the repetitive distress-and-response pattern and its impairment rather than the specific religious proposition.
Ordinary devotion, moral reflection, and spiritual struggle can include prayer, confession, or uncertainty without forming a compulsive syndrome. The decisive questions concern involuntary recurrence, inability to disengage, time costs, functional impairment, and the short-lived relief associated with ritualized reassurance. The systematic review by Toprak and Özçelik (2024) Toprak (2024) found a limited and heterogeneous treatment literature, including conceptual and measurement inconsistencies. Conclusions about interventions specifically for scrupulosity should therefore be proportionate to the size and design of that evidence.
For OCD more generally, NICE guidance CG31 National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. (2005; su (n.d.) recommends cognitive behavioral treatment with exposure and response prevention according to the patient's needs and functional impairment. Applying that framework to religious obsessions requires clinical expertise, appropriate cultural sensitivity, and collaboration when the patient wishes; it is not a mandate to disregard faith or intentionally violate sincerely endorsed values. The research dossier does not provide personalized treatment instructions. Differential clinical assessment also considers depression, trauma, anxiety, and related disorders when symptoms overlap.
Trauma, Moral Injury, and Institutional Harm
Religious and spiritual struggle may follow events that are themselves psychologically harmful: interpersonal violence, sexual exploitation, coercion, humiliation, discrimination, family rupture, or the betrayal of trusted leaders. In these cases, spiritual content reflects how the injury intersects with moral and sacred expectations. Repeated questioning of why suffering occurred, whether the victim bears blame, or whether community support can be trusted may become entangled with shame and fear. The assessment must preserve the difference between the occurrence of an event, the person's interpretation, and subsequent symptoms.
Kanter, Hoffman, and Hassija (2025) Kanter (2025) studied experiences involving intimate partner sexual violence, purity culture beliefs, moral injury, and religious or spiritual struggles in a particular sample of Christian women. The study's mediation models indicate statistical relationships within a cross-sectional design; they do not demonstrate that a temporal sequence has been established. The broader definitional work by VanderWeele et al. (2025) VanderWeele (2025) also illustrates why moral injury requires clear distinctions among exposure, appraisal, guilt, shame, betrayal, and loss of trust.
Institutional harm is especially difficult to investigate where participants depend on religious authorities for housing, belonging, safety, education, or emotional support. Confidential recruitment, protection against retaliation, trauma-informed interviewing, and transparent conflict-of-interest safeguards are essential methodological and ethical concerns. Researchers should also avoid framing survivors' distress as solely a failure of personal coping, which can erase organizational causes and unequal power. The scientific record is strengthened by combining individual reports with independently documented institutional practices where feasible.
Physical Health, Illness, and Mortality Research
Serious illness can evoke divine abandonment, punishment interpretations, heightened prayer, and conflict between expectations of healing and actual outcomes. In a longitudinal cohort of 596 hospitalized older patients, Pargament et al. (2001) Pargament (2001) reported an association between religious struggle and increased mortality over two years after adjustment for measured baseline factors. This historically influential study showed that religious struggle might be relevant beyond immediate mood symptoms, but the result is observational and may be affected by illness severity, residual confounding, health behavior, and selection into the sampled clinical population.
The method for analyzing such outcomes must specify what was measured, which outcome occurred first, and what rival explanations remain. A religious struggle measure may index unrecorded severity, pain, social isolation, fear, or access to care. Later work such as Cowden, Pargament, and Wilkinson (2025) Cowden (2025) used extensive covariate adjustment and showed generally very small prospective associations with broader functioning. The literature therefore does not justify broad claims that particular beliefs directly prolong or shorten life.
Clinical interpretation should keep the focus on patient experience and autonomy. When a patient wants to discuss spiritual conflict, it can form part of a biopsychosocial and cultural assessment without replacing medical evaluation, conventional symptom monitoring, or appropriate medical treatment. No causal medical recommendation follows from this dossier's synthesis. Future evidence requires more diverse populations, repeated measurement before and after clinical events, careful handling of terminal illness, and transparent testing of alternate explanations.
Research Designs and Causal Inference
Cross-sectional studies identify co-occurrence and estimate conditional associations. Their interpretive limits are especially important when distress and spiritual struggle are measured at the same interview: negative affect can influence both responses, and the temporal origin of the struggle may be unknown. Prospective cohorts introduce ordering, while cross-lagged panel approaches estimate relationships after adjustment for prior measurements. However, none automatically removes all confounding, measurement error, or between-person differences. Cowden et al. (2022) Cowden (2022) provides a direct illustration of competing temporal models; Pirutinsky (2024) Pirutinsky (2024) illustrates the value of repeated assessments of stress and coping.
Stronger designs would measure spiritual struggle and general psychological symptoms before important life events, then follow individuals at intervals appropriate to the proposed mechanism. Intensive longitudinal sampling could test short-term variations in appraisal, shame, avoidance, communal support, and behavior. Natural experiments might evaluate institutional changes or exogenous shocks, provided their assumptions are examined explicitly. Ethically appropriate intervention studies could test whether a specified psychological process changes and whether symptom reduction follows.
Causal claims also require careful operationalization. An intervention aimed at shame, reassurance-seeking, or social support may change several processes at once; improvements do not demonstrate which was decisive unless the research design isolates mechanisms. Selection into therapy, expectancy, treatment allegiance, and differential attrition can bias outcomes. Meta-analytic pooling should therefore account for heterogeneity in baseline distress, tradition, scale version, intervention content, and follow-up. Replication across independent teams and samples remains a substantive requirement.
Psychometrics, Scale Selection, and Invariance
The original 26-item RSS measure by Exline et al. (2014) Exline (2014) was designed to distinguish six domains. Its initial validation used adult and student samples and evaluated convergent, discriminant, and predictive validity. The later RSS-5 developed by Salcone et al. (2025) Salcone (2025) selected five domains and tested its short form in samples including depressed adults, undergraduates, and a clinical care population. Reported alpha coefficients of .77 to .85 supported the shorter tool's internal consistency in those samples. Screening utility should be distinguished from a complete six-domain profile or a diagnostic interview.
The 2026 synthesis by Smith et al. (2026) Smith (2026) covered 66 studies and reported a pooled total-score internal consistency coefficient of .937. This impressive reliability estimate describes average covariance among items in the reviewed samples; it does not by itself establish measurement invariance, causal importance, or a universally valid cutoff. The synthesis also examined higher-order factor possibilities, reminding researchers that the apparent simplicity of a total score is a substantive model choice.
For cross-cultural comparisons, investigators should test whether respondents understand items similarly, whether loadings and thresholds behave comparably, and whether the item content covers the local phenomenon. When groups differ on a score, measurement artifacts must be considered before making psychological claims. The same applies to longitudinal change: a decline in endorsement might reflect symptom improvement, altered religious language, changed self-disclosure, or changing meanings of items. Mixed methods, cognitive interviewing, and transparent missing-data analysis strengthen construct validity.
Patterns in the Longitudinal Evidence
The longitudinal meta-analysis by Bockrath et al. (2022) Bockrath (2022) is a central source for evaluating whether religious and spiritual struggles forecast later adjustment. It aggregates studies that meet defined prospective criteria, thereby providing a more informative basis than isolated cross-sectional associations. Yet longitudinal datasets differ in follow-up length, adjustment for prior symptoms, type of struggle, and sampled population. The question of causation remains open even when several prospective studies point in a similar direction.
The study by Cowden et al. (2022) Cowden (2022) of adults with chronic health conditions tested whether struggles precede distress, distress precedes struggles, or reciprocal pathways occur. Cowden, Pargament, and Wilkinson (2025) Cowden (2025) examined whole-person functioning in a large U.S. cohort and found generally small effects for later functioning. Upenieks and Eagle (2026) Upenieks (2026) studied moderation by early religious experience in a highly selected educational population. Such findings can coexist because different studies estimate different quantities in different populations and time windows. The correct scientific synthesis places design and effect magnitude beside direction of association.
An unresolved issue concerns heterogeneity of trajectories. Some individuals may move from conflict toward reintegration, another tradition, or secular meaning; others may experience repeated episodes of guilt and doubt linked with chronic anxiety. Averages cannot identify these subgroups without adequate temporal measurement. Time-series data, person-centered trajectory models, preregistered interaction analyses, and multi-population replication are promising routes toward explaining which circumstances predict improvement, stability, or worsening.
Responses, Resolution, and Psychological Adaptation
A spiritual struggle may be approached through active inquiry, reevaluation of beliefs, disclosure to trustworthy people, social support, negotiation of boundaries, changes of community, revised moral understanding, or clinical treatment of overlapping psychiatric symptoms. These are observed or theoretically plausible forms of adaptation, not a single prescribed therapeutic sequence. A satisfactory endpoint can vary: reconciliation within a tradition, a reformulated faith, a new spiritual identity, or a coherent nonreligious worldview.
Responses should be evaluated by outcomes beyond adherence. Reduced suffering, improved functioning, safe relationships, autonomy, acceptance of uncertainty, and durable meaning are relevant psychological indicators. Social pressure can produce outward conformity while distress persists, and departure from a harmful environment can entail temporary grief despite improved safety. A research design that measures only belief retention may therefore misclassify outcomes.
Exline and Grubbs (2011) Exline (2011) demonstrated the significance of reactions to sharing anger toward God; supportive and unsupportive interpersonal responses can coexist. Lefevor and Skidmore (2025) Lefevor (2025) shows how self-compassion, identity-related stigma, and authentic engagement can be investigated longitudinally in one vulnerable population. Such work supports studying relational conditions and personal agency as possible resources, while the direct evidence for specific interventions targeting spiritual struggle remains uneven. Researchers should avoid promising that conflict must produce growth or that any one path guarantees recovery.
Psychotherapy, Spiritual Assessment, and Ethical Boundaries
A clinician's initial task is to understand whether spiritual matters are important to the patient and whether conflict in that domain is related to presenting concerns. Relevant questions may address changes in affiliation, current distress, community relationships, values, unwanted religious thoughts, and sources of support. Asking permission and following the patient's terminology helps preserve autonomy. The choice to involve a spiritual adviser, leader, or family member belongs within informed consent and must account for possible coercion or confidentiality risks.
The clinical literature supports attending to spiritual struggle as a potentially meaningful aspect of mental health care, while trials isolating its specific treatments remain comparatively limited. Salcone et al. (2025) Salcone (2025) examines a screening-oriented short instrument; Toprak and Özçelik (2024) Toprak (2024) documents limitations in the scrupulosity psychotherapy evidence. For patients with obsessive-compulsive symptoms, the condition-specific evidence represented by NICE guidance CG31 National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. (2005; su (n.d.) is more directly relevant than generalized assurances about spiritual growth. When depression, trauma, or suicide risk are present, established clinical assessment and safety procedures retain priority.
Scientifically defensible care remains plural in its explanatory language. The clinician may work with the patient's religious interpretations without affirming or attacking metaphysical claims. A formulation might identify shame, threats of exclusion, reassurance cycles, or loss of meaning as psychological targets while respecting a person's right to hold or revise sacred commitments. Claims of specialist review, diagnostic reliability, or superior efficacy should be made only after those activities have occurred and have been appropriately documented.
Research Ethics and the Study of Vulnerable Participants
Spiritual conflict often concerns private convictions and social identities with substantial reputational consequences. Research disclosure may risk rejection by family, congregation, employer, or educational institution. Consent materials and recruitment procedures should therefore make clear how responses will be protected, who will see them, and whether a community authority has any access. Especially in small religious groups, anonymity cannot be presumed from removal of names alone because narrative details may identify a participant.
Participants reporting trauma, compulsive guilt, suicidal ideation, or coercive control may need additional research protections and access to appropriate support. Researchers must distinguish a participant's report from independent verification of events and avoid treating religious or nonreligious self-description as evidence of clinical pathology. Qualitative analyses require attention to translation, interviewer position, reflexivity, and differences between emic categories and the researcher's coding frame.
The ethical challenge extends to interpretation and publication. Findings should not be used to rank traditions by presumed psychological health based on nonrepresentative student samples, improperly equated scales, or uncontrolled confounding. Studies that recruit survivors through advocacy networks or adherents through institutional gatekeepers may each have distinct selection biases. Clear reporting of sampling, comparison groups, conflicts of interest, missing data, and limitations serves scientific validity and the dignity of those who share difficult experiences.
Artificial Era: Digital Mediation of Sacred Conflict
In the Artificial Era, human spiritual struggles may increasingly unfold through digital communities, automated information systems, and conversational artificial agents. Individuals can encounter conflicting interpretations, seek reassurance, disclose private doubts, and receive responses framed as morally or spiritually authoritative. The psychological concepts of epistemic trust, attribution, reassurance, and identity threat provide a relevant basis for investigating those encounters. Their application to artificial systems is a prospective research program that requires separate empirical study.
A conversational system that generates religious advice could become a perceived source of support or a catalyst for repeated certainty-seeking. The outcome would depend on user expectations, the system's actual behavior, transparency about its authority, and the availability of human relationships. Researchers can test whether exposure to system responses changes doubt, distress, compulsive reassurance, perceived autonomy, or use of professional services. Such hypotheses do not imply that present evidence for person-to-person religious conflict has already established corresponding effects in human–artificial encounters.
Artificial Era research should also examine whether automated advice reproduces institutional power asymmetries, discloses sensitive material, or treats one cultural interpretation as universal. The framework of this dossier remains the psychology of human religious and spiritual struggle. Questions about artificial agency or artificial consciousness belong to their independent theoretical and empirical domains; here, they matter insofar as observable technology-mediated interaction affects human experience.
Critical Discussion: Convergent Evidence and Competing Explanations
Across historical, psychometric, and longitudinal studies, the evidence converges on the descriptive validity of religious and spiritual conflict as a multidimensional phenomenon relevant to psychological functioning. Exline et al. (2014) Exline (2014) establishes a reproducible vocabulary for types of struggle. Bockrath et al. (2022) Bockrath (2022) brings together longitudinal findings. Smith et al. (2026) Smith (2026) evaluates accumulating measurement data, while Pirutinsky (2024) Pirutinsky (2024) demonstrates that apparently similar negative coping scores may index both stable distress and stress-responsive processes. These contributions support scientific study of spiritual conflict as more than a peripheral theme in the psychology of religion.
Several competing explanations must remain simultaneously testable. Psychological distress may generate pessimistic spiritual interpretations; spiritual alienation may reduce coping resources; common social adversity may produce both; and general negative affect may contribute to scale overlap. Religious involvement can supply social resources while reinforcing severe sanctions for uncertainty. A person may become healthier as they renegotiate beliefs, yet this pattern may depend on external relationships or personal circumstances rather than belief revision alone.
The literature also displays limits in sample diversity, cultural measurement, temporal resolution, and intervention identification. Student, seminary, and therapy samples illuminate mechanisms in particular circumstances but cannot establish population prevalence without representative designs. Comparisons involving minoritized identities need contextual evidence about discrimination and constraints. A psychologically precise research agenda therefore treats mechanisms, settings, and individual trajectories as linked questions instead of inferring a universal pathway from overall correlations.
Unresolved Problems and Future Research
A priority is distinguishing spiritual struggle from generalized distress with stronger construct-validation designs. Investigators should evaluate whether item wording overlaps with anxiety and depression, test predictive contributions after prior symptom adjustment, and model general and domain-specific factors across independent populations. Cross-religious and nonreligious measurement work should include item-level invariance tests and qualitative interviews capable of identifying categories absent from an existing scale.
A second priority concerns temporal structure. High-frequency ecological measurement, cohort studies beginning before major transitions, and analyses separating between-person from within-person differences could clarify whether an individual’s struggle fluctuates with adverse events or reflects persistent alienation. Studies should preregister which pathways are expected and compare plausible alternative models. Long follow-up is useful, but it must be combined with measurements timed to the hypothesized process.
A third priority is intervention evidence. Researchers need clearly described approaches, ethically suitable comparators, validated outcomes, independent replication, and follow-up adequate to detect relapse or delayed effects. Clinical programs that target obsessive reassurance, shame, traumatic betrayal, or social support should be evaluated on their own mechanisms and target populations. Research must remain sensitive to coercion and avoid treating adherence to one religious view as an outcome measure imposed on participants.
Finally, historical and institutional analyses should be integrated with contemporary psychological methods. The same pattern of guilt or doubt may have different meanings under voluntary spiritual exploration, family dependence, institutional sanction, or traumatic experience. Only careful integration of life history, cultural context, social organization, and repeated psychological measurement can establish when such conflicts are harmful, adaptive, transformative, or enduringly unresolved.
Conclusion
Religious and spiritual struggles are structured conflicts in the domain of sacred meaning and attachment. Their six major measured dimensions—divine, demonic, interpersonal, moral, doubt, and ultimate meaning—provide a useful research map, while their intersections, trajectories, and contexts explain why any single dimension or global religiousness score is inadequate for a full psychological account. The most persuasive evidence links detailed conceptualization with psychometric validation and longitudinal investigation, while preserving uncertainty about the direction and magnitude of causal effects.
The scientific synthesis establishes three enduring requirements. Research must identify the actual subject of the person's conflict and distinguish it from general distress. Empirical inference must be proportionate to design, population, measurement, and temporal evidence. Clinical interpretation must take seriously autonomy, cultural meaning, social power, and existing condition-specific standards. Religious guilt, uncertainty, and existential struggle are meaningful psychological experiences whose outcomes depend on their organization and setting. Their systematic investigation is essential to a comprehensive psychology of religion and spirituality.
References
- Abu-Raiya, H., Exline, J. J., Pargament, K. I., & Agbaria, Q. (2015). Prevalence, predictors, and implications of religious/spiritual struggles among Muslims. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 54(4), 631–648. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.1111/jssr.12230
- Abu-Raiya, H., Pargament, K. I., Weissberger, A., & Exline, J. (2016). An empirical examination of religious/spiritual struggle among Israeli Jews. The International Journal for the Psychology of Religion, 26(1), 61–79. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.1080/10508619.2014.1003519
- Anderson, J. R., & Koc, Y. (2020). Identity integration as a protective factor against guilt and shame for religious gay men. The Journal of Sex Research, 57(8), 1059–1068. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.1080/00224499.2020.1767026
- Bockrath, M. F., Pargament, K. I., Wong, S., Harriott, V. A., Pomerleau, J. M., Homolka, S. J., Chaudhary, Z. B., & Exline, J. J. (2022). Religious and spiritual struggles and their links to psychological adjustment: A meta-analysis of longitudinal studies. Psychology of Religion and Spirituality, 14(3), 283–299. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.1037/rel0000400
- Cowden, R. G., Pargament, K. I., & Wilkinson, R. (2025). Divine struggles and whole person functioning: A 9-year longitudinal study of middle-aged U.S. adults. Psychology & Health, 40(7), 1225–1242. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.1080/08870446.2024.2309162
- Cowden, R. G., Pargament, K. I., Chen, Z. J., Davis, E. B., Lemke, A. W., Glowiak, K. J., Rueger, S. Y., & Worthington, E. L., Jr. (2022). Religious/spiritual struggles and psychological distress: A test of three models in a longitudinal study of adults with chronic health conditions. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 78(4), 544–558. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.1002/jclp.23232
- Exline, J. J., & Grubbs, J. B. (2011). If I tell others about my anger toward God, how will they respond? Predictors, associated behaviors, and outcomes in an adult sample. Journal of Psychology and Theology, 39(4), 304–315. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.1177/009164711103900402
- Exline, J. J., Pargament, K. I., Grubbs, J. B., & Yali, A. M. (2014). The Religious and Spiritual Struggles Scale: Development and initial validation. Psychology of Religion and Spirituality, 6(3), 208–222. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.1037/a0036465
- Exline, J. J., Park, C. L., Smyth, J. M., & Carey, M. P. (2011). Anger toward God: Social-cognitive predictors, prevalence, and links with adjustment to bereavement and cancer. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 100(1), 129–148. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.1037/a0021716
- Exline, J. J., Yali, A. M., & Sanderson, W. C. (2000). Guilt, discord, and alienation: The role of religious strain in depression and suicidality. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 56(12), 1481–1496. Permanent source https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11132565/
- Garssen, B., Visser, A., & Pool, G. (2021). Does spirituality or religion positively affect mental health? Meta-analysis of longitudinal studies. The International Journal for the Psychology of Religion, 31(1), 4–20. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.1080/10508619.2020.1729570
- Kanter, R. L., Hoffman, K. R., & Hassija, C. M. (2025). Moral injury: Religious and spiritual struggles among survivors of intimate partner sexual violence in the USA. Journal of Religion and Health, 64(3), 2101–2117. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.1007/s10943-025-02267-w
- Lefevor, G. T., & Skidmore, S. J. (2025). How can sexual and gender minority Latter-day Saints resolve identity conflict and improve their mental health? Results from a 2- to 4-year longitudinal study. Behavior Therapy, 56(3), 580–593. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.1016/j.beth.2024.08.006
- Lisonbee, D. B., Dyer, W. J., & Hardy, S. A. (2026). The role of parenting in changes in adolescent religious/spiritual struggles and psychological well-being: A latent transition analysis. The International Journal for the Psychology of Religion. Advance online publication. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.1080/10508619.2026.2670864
- National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. (2005; subsequent updates). Obsessive-compulsive disorder and body dysmorphic disorder: Treatment (CG31). Permanent source https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg31/chapter/Recommendations
- Pargament, K. I., Feuille, M., & Burdzy, D. (2011). The Brief RCOPE: Current psychometric status of a short measure of religious coping. Religions, 2(1), 51–76. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.3390/rel2010051
- Pargament, K. I., Koenig, H. G., & Perez, L. M. (2000). The many methods of religious coping: Development and initial validation of the RCOPE. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 56(4), 519–543. Permanent source https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10775045/
- Pargament, K. I., Koenig, H. G., Tarakeshwar, N., & Hahn, J. (2001). Religious struggle as a predictor of mortality among medically ill elderly patients: A 2-year longitudinal study. Archives of Internal Medicine, 161(15), 1881–1885. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.1001/archinte.161.15.1881
- Park, C. L. (2005). Religion as a meaning-making framework in coping with life stress. Journal of Social Issues, 61(4), 707–729. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-4560.2005.00428.x
- Pirutinsky, S. (2024). Negative religious coping versus spiritual struggles: Moderator or main effect? Journal of Clinical Psychology, 80(8), 1780–1796. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.1002/jclp.23694
- Salcone, S. G., Currier, J. M., McDermott, R. C., Davis, D. E., Raines, A. M., Lee, Y., Exline, J. J., & Pargament, K. I. (2025). Development and evaluation of the Religious and Spiritual Struggles Scale-5 (RSS-5). Journal of Psychopathology and Behavioral Assessment, 47, Article 8. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.1007/s10862-024-10182-9
- Sasson Shoshan, T., Chaki-Binon, H., & Abu-Raiya, H. (2024). The links between insecure attachment to God, divine struggles, and happiness and depressive symptoms among Muslims and Jews in Israel. Journal of Religion and Health, 63(4), 2501–2522. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.1007/s10943-024-02055-y
- Smith, H. L., Erford, B. T., Perales, S., & Cox, R. (2026). Psychometric synthesis of the Religious and Spiritual Struggles (RSS) Scale. Measurement and Evaluation in Counseling and Development, 59(1), 62–76. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.1080/07481756.2025.2536812
- Toprak, T. B., & Özçelik, H. N. (2024). Psychotherapies for the treatment of scrupulosity: A systematic review. Current Psychology, 43, 22361–22375. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.1007/s12144-024-06040-2
- Upenieks, L., & Eagle, D. (2026). Religious and spiritual struggles and depressive symptoms among seminary students: Childhood religiosity as boon or buffer? Pastoral Psychology, 75, 317–337. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.1007/s11089-026-01300-3
- VanderWeele, T. J., et al. (2025). Moral trauma, moral distress, moral injury, and moral injury disorder: Definitions and assessments. Frontiers in Psychology, 16, Article 1422441. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2025.1422441
- Wilt, J. A., Grubbs, J. B., Pargament, K. I., & Exline, J. J. (2017). Religious and spiritual struggles, past and present: Relations to the Big Five and well-being. The International Journal for the Psychology of Religion, 27(1), 51–64. Permanent source https://doi.org/10.1080/10508619.2016.1183251