RESEARCH DOSSIER
Religious and Spiritual Assessment in Clinical Practice
Abstract. Religious and spiritual assessment in clinical practice is a structured, patient-directed process for identifying the meanings, affiliations, practices, conflicts, sources of support, and care preferences associated with religious and spiritual life when these matters bear on psychological formulation and treatment. This monograph examines the construct's history, conceptual foundations, interview frameworks, psychometric instruments, research on patient preferences, cultural and diagnostic context, clinician competencies, ethical governance, implementation, and evidence gaps. Its method is a critical narrative synthesis of identifiable original studies, instrument-development papers, clinical field trials, systematic and scoping reviews, and professional guidance, with distinctions between the evidential strength of communication feasibility, construct measurement, diagnostic utility, and improved patient outcomes. The synthesis supports the clinical relevance of asking permission, exploring individually defined meaning, identifying resources and distress, integrating findings into ordinary formulation, and preserving patient choice. It also establishes that the extensive diffusion of spiritual-history frameworks has outpaced rigorous demonstrations of comparative effectiveness, diagnostic improvement, or long-term benefit. Accordingly, the scientifically defensible unit of practice is a contextual and revisable clinical assessment, supported by cultural competence, transparent documentation, proportionate referral, and outcome-oriented research.
Keywords: religious assessment; spiritual history; clinical psychology; cultural formulation; FICA; HOPE; religious and spiritual struggles; shared decision-making; psychometrics; mental health; diagnostic assessment; patient autonomy; spiritual care; clinical ethics
The Clinical Research Object
Religious and spiritual assessment in clinical practice is the purposeful collection, interpretation, and clinically appropriate use of information about a patient's religious or spiritual meanings, commitments, experiences, relationships, practices, preferences, and conflicts. Its unit of analysis is the particular person's situation in a particular episode of care. The clinical aim is a better warranted understanding of the person's problems, resources, values, and decisions. This understanding is provisional: new information, contextual shifts, and the patient's own revised account may change its interpretation.
The object has several distinguishable components. A history establishes how a person's tradition, community, practices, or worldview came to matter. A current-status inquiry establishes whether these matters influence symptoms, coping, relationships, treatment preferences, or ethical decisions. An assessment of distress and function identifies tensions, coercion, support, and possible impairment. Clinical formulation then places those observations alongside conventional diagnostic interviewing, risk evaluation, developmental history, medical information, and the person's stated goals. A referral decision follows only if a defined need falls within another professional's expertise and the patient agrees, except where independent safeguarding requirements apply.
Religion and spirituality often overlap, but their extension varies by person and culture. A clinician can ask about affiliation and participation without assuming belief; can ask about transcendence without assuming organized religion; and can ask about meaning, purpose, and moral belonging without treating those topics as evidence that a patient endorses any spiritual identity. A person may describe a secular orientation as central to dignity, treatment decisions, and coping. An assessment sensitive to religious diversity must therefore be equally capable of recording that religion is irrelevant, unwanted as a topic, or experienced primarily as a source of harm.
This dossier investigates assessment processes rather than the development of every religiosity scale or the effectiveness of spiritually integrated psychotherapy. The neighboring scientific objects of instrument construction, treatment adaptation, and differential diagnosis of specific psychiatric syndromes remain related but independent. Here the central question is whether clinicians can obtain relevant information accurately, ethically, and with demonstrable consequences for clinical understanding.
Clinical practice includes outpatient psychiatry, clinical psychology, counseling, integrated medical care, palliative care, rehabilitation, and community mental health. Setting shapes what information matters, who should ask, what consent is required, and which follow-up resources exist. A brief history may be proportionate at intake; a longer exploration may be appropriate where the patient identifies a spiritual conflict as central to treatment. An evidence-based approach therefore specifies the indication, not a universal scripted duration.
How Spiritual Assessment Entered Clinical Discourse
Historically, religious and moral interpretations of distress preceded modern psychiatric classification, and clinical institutions developed partly through debates about the proper relationship between spiritual authority and medical explanation. The contemporary assessment literature belongs to a more specific period: the expansion of patient-centered medicine, palliative care, multicultural counseling, and psychiatric cultural formulation in the late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries. Researchers and clinicians increasingly asked whether standard history-taking omitted influences on coping, values, access to support, and adherence to treatment.
The Puchalski and Romer (2000) account of taking a spiritual history articulated a rationale for attending to the person's spiritual world as part of comprehensive medical understanding. Its associated FICA framework grew from clinical teaching and communication practice. In parallel, Anandarajah and Hight (2001) published the HOPE questions for spiritual assessment in family medicine. These contributions were historically important because they turned an otherwise vague injunction to “address spirituality” into teachable sequences of questions and patient-centered topics. Their publication did not itself establish psychometric validity or therapeutic efficacy.
A second lineage developed through cultural psychiatry. The Outline for Cultural Formulation associated with DSM-IV aimed to contextualize diagnosis within identity, explanatory models, psychosocial surroundings, clinician–patient relationships, and culture-related care. Lewis-Fernández et al. (2014) described the process by which the DSM-5 Cultural Formulation Interview (CFI) operationalized cultural information through a structured interview and supplementary modules. Religion can be relevant to several of these domains, yet the CFI is a broader cultural assessment; it is not a substitute for a focused spiritual history when one is indicated.
Meanwhile, psychological research advanced beyond treating religious affiliation as a single predictor of mental health. Work on coping distinguished multiple ways of interpreting adversity; research on spiritual struggles examined conflict, doubt, moral guilt, relationships, and meaning. Exline et al. (2014) formalized six domains in a measure explicitly concerned with struggles. This history matters clinically because a person's sacred commitments can be a resource, a stressor, both, or neither, and the direction depends on psychological processes and circumstances.
The field now possesses practical interview models, preliminary validation studies, patient-preference reviews, cultural field trials, and professional competence proposals. Its expansion has also created a recurring inference error: counting educational use, clinical adoption, or citations as if they constituted evidence that a given interview improves outcomes. The Sleeth et al. (2025) HOPE scoping review is particularly useful for examining the distance between broad dissemination and direct effectiveness testing. Understanding the field's history requires retaining both achievements.
The rise of standardized spiritual-care frameworks also reflected organizational debate about the place of nonmedical professionals. In palliative care, the Puchalski et al. (2009) consensus conference considered spiritual care as a dimension of comprehensive practice and differentiated levels of professional responsibility. The Puchalski et al. (2014) subsequent international consensus account expanded the interdisciplinary discussion. These works are influential expert and consensus contributions. Their authority concerns articulated principles and coordinated standards, rather than controlled evidence that a particular interview improves an individual mental health outcome.
A further historical strand concerned physicians' perspectives. Curlin et al. (2007) compared psychiatrists' and other physicians' interpretations and approaches using a survey of United States physicians. Such studies establish that the assessor's professional role and beliefs can influence discussion practices. They should not be read as unbiased observation of patients' experiences, because clinician self-report may differ from actual interview behavior.
Religion, Spirituality, Meaning, and Clinical Relevance
For clinical assessment, religion is a person's participation in, identification with, or relationship to traditions, communities, institutions, doctrines, and practices described as religious. Spirituality refers to orientations and experiences that persons understand through questions of ultimate concern, the sacred, transcendence, existential connection, or deep meaning. These operational definitions are deliberately linked to patient language. Researchers may employ narrower constructs, and cultural settings can place very different activities under these terms. The clinician should record the person's own categories before translating them into an assessment framework.
Religious affiliation, practice frequency, subjective importance, coping, meaning-making, spiritual experience, and conflict are different variables. Affiliation may reflect family ancestry rather than active practice. Frequency of attendance can reflect transportation, health, social opportunity, or community expectation. A high importance rating says little about whether a belief currently relieves distress or heightens it. A report of prayer is an observable account of behavior, while its experienced effects and interpretation are additional empirical questions.
A clinically relevant fact has an identifiable pathway to the person's presentation or preferences. A ritual schedule may influence sleep, medication timing, family conflict, or access to social support. A belief about suffering may affect self-blame, help-seeking, or expectations of treatment. A congregation may provide material aid and also impose pressure. A perceived loss of meaning may be central to suicidal despair or may represent a reflective, nonpathological phase of life change. The evaluation turns on the person's account, contextual evidence, timing, consequences, and functional change.
A distinction between moral values and clinical symptoms is equally important. The same thought may be experienced as a freely endorsed commitment, an intrusive obsession, a culturally shared teaching, or an imposed threat, depending on its form, flexibility, distress, coercion, and effect on functioning. An assessment that identifies a religious term without examining these characteristics offers little clinical understanding.
Religious and spiritual variables also resist a simple beneficial-versus-harmful classification. A practice that usually offers comfort may become burdensome during illness; a community that provided identity may become unsafe after disclosure of personal information; a secular reinterpretation may be stabilizing or destabilizing at different moments. Clinical relevance is a relationship among person, context, mechanism, and outcome rather than an intrinsic property of a religious label.
A Critical Method for Evaluating Assessment Research
This monograph uses a critical, source-linked narrative review, grounded in directly identifiable primary publications and relevant evidence syntheses. It is not a systematic review, meta-analysis, or clinical practice guideline: no exhaustive search protocol, formal duplicate screening, comprehensive risk-of-bias instrument, or pooled reanalysis has been performed. It distinguishes the claims supported by the full text of accessible open-access publications from those supported only by publicly available abstracts or bibliographic metadata. The point of this distinction is to protect the scientific scope of the conclusions.
The evidence can be ordered by the question each design is capable of answering. A conceptual or educational paper may establish what a framework instructs clinicians to ask and why its developers considered those questions relevant. A descriptive interview study may establish feasibility or reported acceptability in a defined sample. A construct-validation study may provide factor-analytic or convergent evidence for a questionnaire. A multisite field trial may test transportability or implementation under varied conditions. A randomized trial may identify effects of a particular assessment procedure, provided allocation, comparators, outcomes, missingness, and analysis support the inference. A systematic review can synthesize specified populations and methods; a scoping review primarily maps an evidence field.
Four outcomes require separate scrutiny. Information yield concerns the number, quality, or clinical relevance of newly elicited facts. Patient experience concerns comfort, perceived respect, burden, and willingness to disclose. Clinical utility concerns whether clinicians' formulations, decisions, or referrals change appropriately. Patient benefit concerns symptoms, functioning, safety, alliance, quality of life, or longer-term health. An instrument can perform well at an earlier level and remain unproven at the next.
The methodological problem of criterion validity is substantial. No single external gold standard exists for “an adequate spiritual history” across populations. Self-report may reflect expectations of the clinician, memory, demand characteristics, or concerns about confidentiality. Clinician ratings of usefulness may improve through enthusiasm or experience. Repeated interviews could themselves alter the patient's narrative. The appropriate response is triangulation: patient report, independent observation, longitudinal outcomes, and clear description of what the procedure changed.
The evidence discussed here is thus weighed by sampling and setting; the operational definition of spirituality; the intervention or instrument used; measurement reliability; cultural adaptation; the strength of a comparison group; outcome timing; and possible conflicts between declared intent and observed behavior. Claims are not upgraded simply because a publication describes a recommended clinical procedure.
Patient Preference and the Right to Decline
The patient's preference is a primary measurement target, not a courtesy added after data collection. Inquiry into religion and spirituality can touch experiences of belonging, grief, shame, persecution, sexuality, family loyalty, migration, personal doubt, and previous institutional harm. These subjects can affect willingness to participate in care. An ethically defensible assessment therefore begins by explaining why the topic might be relevant and asking whether the patient wishes to discuss it.
The Best et al. (2015) systematic literature review assembled 54 studies involving 12,327 patients and found that many regarded spiritual discussion as appropriate in at least some medical circumstances. Across included studies, estimates varied widely, and the authors emphasized a mismatch between patient and physician understandings of what such conversations involved. The result supports asking about preference and relevance; it cannot support an inference that a single approach is desired by every patient or that assessment improves clinical outcomes.
Preference is dynamic and conditional. A patient may decline a discussion in an initial appointment and welcome it after trust develops, or agree to describe a community relationship while withholding belief details. Some patients want a clinician to inquire; others prefer that their religion not enter treatment; others want only a chaplain or a designated community representative to discuss spiritual concerns. The assessment should record both the patient's response and the boundaries of the invitation.
A neutral opening might explain that beliefs, communities, or personal sources of meaning sometimes affect coping or care and ask whether any of these matters are relevant for this patient. The formulation is an example of consent-sensitive communication rather than a validated clinical test. Follow-up can remain open-ended, with options for declining particular questions. Where language or interpretation is uncertain, the clinician should ask what a patient means by their words instead of assigning standard doctrinal content to them.
The right to decline includes the right to disclose selectively, change one's mind, have personal interpretations accurately represented, and receive equivalent clinical attention regardless of belief. Clinician confidence should never be mistaken for patient consent. Documenting “declined discussion” as a neutral preference, without pathologizing refusal, helps preserve autonomy while leaving later inquiry possible.
Clinical Questions and Levels of Inquiry
A clinically useful assessment can be organized around a sequence of questions rather than a rigid schedule. Does the patient consider religion, spirituality, or a broader life philosophy relevant to present care? Which commitments, practices, relationships, or experiences currently matter? Are these associated with support, distress, conflict, or changing functioning? Do they influence treatment choices or practical needs? Is additional professional input wanted, and if so from whom? The sequence can be shortened, expanded, or deferred according to clinical indication.
A brief first-level inquiry establishes relevance and permission. It is generally more proportionate during time-limited intake or urgent stabilization, when immediate safety evaluation takes precedence. A second level explores specific meanings, practices, resources, stressors, and relationships. A third level integrates findings with diagnosis, risk, functional assessment, treatment planning, and referral. Increasing depth is justified by clinical utility and patient interest rather than by the clinician's desire to complete a questionnaire.
Each question should be linked to an observable or reportable construct. “Is faith important?” is ambiguous unless the person defines importance. “Has a belief affected whether you seek care?” requests a concrete connection to behavior. “When you describe a spiritual experience, how did it unfold, who else understands it similarly, and what happened afterward?” examines context and function. “Would you like these preferences considered when we discuss options?” translates information into shared decision-making.
Open questions require attentive follow-up. Asking about a community without considering coercion may miss an important stressor. Asking about suffering without exploring self-blame may miss a mechanism of distress. Asking about unusual perceptions without establishing sleep, substance use, trauma, mood, medical conditions, and cultural norms risks false clinical inference. Conversely, spiritual narratives should not automatically displace ordinary medical evaluation.
Clinical questions must also reflect scope of competence. A mental health clinician can assess the role of a religious concern in a patient's functioning and symptoms without adjudicating theological truth. A chaplain or community specialist may offer tradition-specific assistance when requested, with clear boundaries concerning confidentiality, informed consent, and the psychological treatment plan. The patient remains the coordinating authority for elective disclosure.
What Counts as an Adequate Spiritual History
An adequate spiritual history is proportionate, accurate, consented to, clinically interpretable, and available for revision. Its content can include the patient's preferred words for religion or spirituality; current participation and practices; community and familial relationships; protective routines; experiences of exclusion; religious or existential interpretations of symptoms; perceived conflicts; and treatment-relevant preferences. The actual record should prioritize facts that alter formulation or care, rather than attempting an ethnography of the patient's entire worldview.
The interviewer's responsibility is to distinguish the account from its clinical interpretation. A statement such as “prayer is my main source of strength” is a report of a perceived resource. It does not establish that prayer has caused symptom improvement. A statement that illness represents punishment is an account of meaning and potentially of guilt. Its significance depends on intensity, rigidity, personal history, cultural context, and effects on behavior. Accurate documentation preserves these levels separately.
Adequacy can be judged by whether the interview allows the clinician to explain: why the topic was introduced; what the patient wanted to discuss; which relevant influences were identified; how these were integrated into the case formulation; what remained uncertain; and what patient-approved action followed. A single framework does not guarantee any of these outcomes. Conversely, an unscripted interview may be adequate if it yields the necessary information and protects autonomy.
The Pargament and Krumrei (2009) treatment of clinical spirituality assessment describes a broader clinical task involving spiritual problems, resources, and changing circumstances. This supports a longitudinal view: a spiritual history should be reconsidered after bereavement, diagnosis, displacement, religious conversion, loss of community, or changes in treatment goals. Such transitions can change the relevant objects of assessment without implying clinical deterioration.
Documentation is an ethical intervention in its own right. It shapes who may later encounter the information, what shorthand becomes attached to the patient, and whether a culturally embedded belief is retrospectively misconstrued as pathology. An adequate history requires neutral language, controlled access consistent with local regulation, and explicit differentiation between the patient's statements and professional interpretation.
FICA: Structure, Evidence, and Limits
FICA is a framework for eliciting a patient's faith or spiritual identity, the importance or influence of that orientation, community connections, and the way the patient wishes these matters to be addressed in care. The familiar initials refer to Faith or beliefs, Importance or influence, Community, and Address in care. This sequence gives the clinician a map of potential relevance rather than a standardized score. Its primary output is a conversation and a context-rich history.
The early exposition by Puchalski and Romer (2000) located the spiritual history within comprehensive understanding of patients, particularly in serious illness. The model was designed to be usable by health professionals who are not specialist spiritual-care practitioners. Its conversational structure makes room for varying answers: one patient's most important community is religious, another's is secular, and a third may experience community as a site of rejection. Good practice preserves these differences instead of treating the four headings as predetermined positive attributes.
Borneman et al. (2010) evaluated FICA with patients with solid tumors in an outpatient oncology setting. Their study documented the instrument's clinical use and associations with dimensions of patients' quality-of-life reports. It provides evidence relevant to feasibility and what clinicians may learn in that setting. It is not a definitive randomized comparison showing that FICA improves psychiatric diagnosis, functioning, or recovery. Neither does an oncology study establish measurement invariance in child psychiatry, religious minorities, or involuntary mental health care.
The structure can be interrogated at four points. Faith questions may be interpreted as presuming theism unless secular possibilities are explicit. Importance questions may elicit polite agreement or culturally expected expressions unless contextualized. Community questions should include exclusion, exploitation, and unwanted social control alongside support. Address-in-care questions require a genuine option to refuse accommodations, referrals, or further discussion. An implementation that omits these considerations can reproduce the assumptions that the interview was intended to address.
For scientific evaluation, FICA's apparent accessibility should be treated as an implementation property, while reliability and validity demand independent evidence. Interrater studies could compare how different clinicians identify clinically consequential themes from the same interview; randomized studies could examine whether the resulting information changes care beyond an equally empathic general history. Patient-centered outcomes should include acceptability for nonreligious and minority patients as well as those who actively seek spiritual discussion.
HOPE: A Patient-Centered Communication Model
The HOPE model, presented by Anandarajah and Hight (2001), directs the clinician first toward sources of hope, strength, comfort, meaning, and connection; next toward organized religion; then toward personal spiritual beliefs and practices; and finally toward the possible effects of these orientations on care and end-of-life decisions. This order begins with broadly understandable resources and avoids making denominational identity the first required answer.
The first element matters clinically because a person can identify meaningful relationships, music, personal rituals, moral values, nature, or secular commitments without adopting religious vocabulary. The subsequent questions allow concrete religious membership or practices to be described where relevant. The final element establishes why a spiritual history belongs in a medical encounter: there may be consequences for treatment decisions, practical accommodations, or referrals. For mental health practice, effects can include coping behavior, help-seeking, medication beliefs, contact with community leaders, or responses to diagnostic language.
The original HOPE paper is a conceptual and educational clinical contribution. Its authors expressly presented a pragmatic tool, and its publication should not be interpreted as an original psychometric validation trial. Distinguishing the design history from later empirical evaluation is particularly important because users often mistake an acronym's longevity for validation.
The Sleeth et al. (2025) scoping review mapped HOPE's international dissemination, applications, and evaluations over more than two decades. The review demonstrates substantial adoption and interest in the model, including its utility as a shared language for training and communication. The authors also describe the limited consolidated evidence of clinical effectiveness. A scoping review's coverage of publications is informative about the existence and distribution of research but does not by itself estimate the causal effect of a HOPE assessment on symptoms or health care outcomes.
For psychiatric assessment, HOPE's resource-first framing may reduce the social pressure of a direct religion question. Yet this remains a hypothesis requiring study against appropriate comparators. Clinicians should also recognize that the word “hope” can carry a very different emotional weight in severe depression, suicidal crisis, grief, or coercive environments. A patient who cannot currently identify hope is giving clinically important information, not failing the interview. The clinician's responsibility is to respond to that information within ordinary risk and support assessment rather than insist on a positive spiritual answer.
Cultural Formulation and Explanatory Models
Religious narratives are one component of cultural meaning, and cultural information may be relevant even when the patient rejects religious identification. Clinical assessment benefits from exploring how the person names a problem, what they believe caused it, what others in their environment think, which responses are expected, and what forms of care seem acceptable or threatening. These questions correspond to the broader aim of cultural formulation: making psychiatric reasoning responsive to local meanings while retaining the evaluation of symptoms, severity, and function.
Lewis-Fernández et al. (2014) described the development of the DSM-5 Cultural Formulation Interview and its operational relationship to the earlier Outline for Cultural Formulation. The CFI is not a religion scale. Its relevance lies in the practice of eliciting patient-defined explanations instead of assuming that diagnostic categories supply the complete account of distress. Its questions can reveal when religious identity, migration, family expectations, or discrimination are central to the encounter.
An international mixed-methods field trial by Lewis-Fernández et al. (2017) evaluated CFI use with 318 psychiatric outpatients and 75 clinicians across six countries. Patients and clinicians generally regarded it as feasible, acceptable, and useful, although clinicians initially rated feasibility less favorably than patients, and experience improved some implementation ratings. Such findings support the practicality of structured cultural inquiry under those study conditions; they do not show that any particular religious-history tool is superior or that the interview eliminates diagnostic error.
A clinical encounter may contain several distinct explanatory systems. A patient might use a medical account to discuss sleep and medication, a religious account to interpret suffering, and a family account to explain shame or obligation. These systems can coexist, conflict, or change over time. The assessor should clarify how the patient moves among them and which beliefs inform decisions. Treating cultural explanation as a single static identity obscures this negotiation.
Cross-cultural interpretation requires care in two directions. Clinicians can misclassify culturally familiar practices as abnormal when unaware of the relevant tradition; they can also overlook severe distress because an experience is religiously expressed. Appropriate assessment examines phenomenology, context, flexibility, impairment, and risk alongside culturally informed understanding. When interpreters, cultural consultants, or religious specialists participate, roles and confidentiality limits must be explicit.
Screening, Interviewing, and Formal Measurement
Screening, history-taking, and psychometric measurement answer different questions. A screening prompt asks whether a topic warrants further inquiry. A clinical interview generates a narrative and checks the relation between this narrative and the current presentation. A standardized measure estimates a prespecified construct using items with documented scoring and empirical properties. A clinician can use all three methods without conflating them.
A screening question such as whether beliefs or communities affect treatment can identify possible relevance with low burden. Its scientific utility would depend on a clear reference standard, sensitivity to concerns that matter clinically, specificity for cases that need follow-up, and evidence that false positives and false negatives are acceptable. A positive response does not diagnose spiritual distress; a negative response may reflect privacy, mistrust, lack of language, or genuine irrelevance.
Conversational frameworks such as FICA and HOPE structure inquiry and therefore require assessment primarily of information yield, feasibility, acceptability, and decision impact. They should not be reported as if they generated quantitative scores with established clinical cutoffs. An interviewer who converts a patient's answer into an unvalidated composite “spirituality score” has constructed a new measure without the necessary development research.
Standardized questionnaires can be useful for research and follow-up when the intended construct is explicit. Their reliability requires evidence of stability or internal consistency as appropriate; their validity requires evidence concerning content, structure, relations to other variables, response processes, and consequences of use. Translation requires more than linguistic equivalence. The same item about guilt, ritual practice, divine punishment, or spiritual community can function differently in populations with different traditions or secular orientations.
Measurement also introduces an ethical asymmetry. An institution may find it easy to administer a scale, while the patient may struggle to recognize their experience in its categories. A high score can invite a clinical interpretation unsupported by the person's own account. The assessment should retain the narrative as a check on what the numerical response represents. Repeated measures should be interpreted in light of life events, changes in religiosity, treatment, and the instrument's tested sensitivity to change.
Because spiritual life involves highly personal information, a minimum-necessary principle is preferable to routine accumulation of every available scale. The clinician should choose an instrument only after specifying which decision it would inform and whether evidence supports its use in the present population. A tool whose reference population is undergraduate students, oncology patients, or a single national sample requires explicit caution when transported to other clinical groups.
Coping scales and domain specificity. The Pargament et al. (2011) describes a fourteen-item instrument developed for religious coping in stressful circumstances. Its two broad sets of positive and negative religious coping items concern appraisals and strategies within a particular research model. Their interpretation is different from that of a spiritual-history interview, and they should not be turned into a global clinical diagnosis. A person with little religious identification may have no meaningful response to particular items even while experiencing severe psychological distress. Study populations and item content therefore constrain use.
The Portillo-Gil et al. (2026) systematic review identified forty-three validated spirituality instruments in adults with chronic or advanced illness and palliative care. The authors reported considerable differences in psychometric rigor and limited evidence for some forms of validity, especially predictive validity. They also raised the problem of item contamination: scales may incorporate affective or general psychological content that overlaps with an outcome they are then used to predict. This is a current methodological reason to specify a construct before selecting an instrument.
For example, an item asking whether a person “feels peaceful” may reflect spiritual well-being, current depressive symptoms, comfort in the interview, or a combination of these. If a spirituality scale is built partly from emotional well-being items, a correlation with emotional health can be inflated through overlapping definitions. Stronger research needs item-level analysis, discriminant validity evidence, and tests of whether a measure predicts a clinically meaningful event beyond established symptom and coping instruments.
The presence of many published scales signals research activity, not the existence of an agreed universal measure. A clinically justified selection should identify the target construct, the population in which the tool was validated, the intended inference, and the possibility of misleading scores. For many encounters, an accurate narrative with explicit patient preference offers a more defensible starting point than an unvalidated threshold.
Religious and Spiritual Struggles in Formulation
Religious and spiritual struggle refers to distress or conflict centered on sacred relationships, religious communities, moral obligations, doubts, supernatural interpretations, or ultimate meaning. It can arise from internal disagreement, changing beliefs, interpersonal conflict, bereavement, perceived punishment, coercion, or the collision of faith-based and medical explanations. Its clinical meaning varies with the patient's own interpretation, functioning, and goals.
Exline et al. (2014) developed the 26-item Religious and Spiritual Struggles Scale, examining divine, demonic, interpersonal, moral, doubt, and ultimate-meaning struggles. Their development program included two adult samples of 400 and 483 participants and a confirmatory study of 1,141 undergraduates. The factor-analytic evidence supports treating these dimensions as analytically distinguishable in the studied populations. It does not convert any subscale into a psychiatric diagnostic category.
The six domains help prevent a single generic label from hiding different mechanisms. Divine struggle may involve perceived abandonment by God and associated hopelessness. Interpersonal struggle may reflect rejection or betrayal by religious peers. Moral struggle may involve guilt and self-judgment. Doubt may be painful because it threatens belonging, family relationships, or personal identity. An ultimate-meaning struggle may overlap with depression or grief while remaining meaningful on its own terms. The domain of demonic struggle requires careful examination of cultural meaning, distress, and psychiatric context; the mere presence of spiritually framed language is not an adequate diagnostic criterion.
Assessment must examine timing. A struggle that predates an episode of depression may contribute to vulnerability, be independent of symptoms, or represent a long-standing identity conflict. A struggle emerging during an episode could be a consequence or expression of illness. A third variable, such as recent bereavement, may influence both. Cross-sectional association does not determine which pathway is present.
The clinician should ask how the patient understands the struggle and whether support or pressure from others changes it. A patient may wish to discuss the issue in therapy, may need protection from abuse, may request contact with a compatible religious professional, or may prefer to address it privately. The appropriate response follows the patient's goals and relevant clinical risk, not an assumption that more religious participation is the remedy.
Scale scores can supplement these judgments but should not replace them. High struggle may be a research indicator of distress requiring further inquiry. Intervention decisions must still depend on independently assessed symptoms, safety, psychosocial context, and consent.
Coping, Appraisal, and the Interpretation of Resources
Coping is the set of cognitive, emotional, behavioral, and relational efforts through which a person manages demands or adversity. Religious coping adds practices and interpretations that the person understands through religion or spirituality. These can include prayer, communal support, forgiveness, ritual participation, reliance on a trusted leader, sacred meaning-making, or perceptions of punishment and abandonment. Their effects depend on the situation and on the form of coping, not simply on the presence of religion.
The Pargament and Krumrei (2009) clinical assessment framework treats spiritual resources and problems as potential components of the therapeutic process. This perspective invites concrete questions: What does the patient actually do when distressed? Does a practice increase or decrease isolation? Does community involvement produce material support or demands? Does a belief encourage participation in treatment, provide comfort while symptoms continue, or lead to withdrawal from needed medical care?
It is useful to distinguish a reported resource from an outcome that has been independently established. When someone says religious community makes treatment possible, the clinician can document perceived support and explore practical examples. A causal conclusion about attendance or symptom reduction would need further evidence. Similar caution applies to practices whose associations with health are shaped by age, physical ability, social resources, or selection into participation.
An intervention-oriented interpretation should avoid assuming that every religious activity benefits every patient. Rituals may be essential to identity and also time-consuming, exhausting, or entwined with compulsions. A community may provide belonging while exposing someone to stigma. Forgiveness may be meaningful yet be pressured by an abusive environment. The assessment should record the balance the patient experiences and identify whether any clinically significant conflict needs attention.
A person's coping repertoire extends beyond religion. Friendship, art, political community, nature, science, reflection, and other meaningful commitments can be central. When religious assessment is embedded within broader evaluation of coping, the clinician can compare resource pathways without privileging a supernatural framework. This comparability matters for equitable practice across religious and nonreligious patients.
Evidence from Mental Health Settings
Clinical evidence for religious or spiritual assessment should be separated from evidence about religious affiliation and mental health outcomes in observational studies. An association between religiosity and depression does not establish that asking about religion changes psychiatric care. Nor do studies of spiritually adapted therapy establish the effect of the initial assessment that might precede such therapy. The relevant causal object is the assessment procedure and its consequences.
A focused randomized study by Huguelet et al. (2011) examined spiritual assessment in outpatients with schizophrenia, gathering patients' and clinicians' experiences. Its importance lies in studying an actual clinical procedure rather than only attitudes toward religion. The study nevertheless examined a particular clinical setting and relatively small groups, so its patient-acceptability findings should not be taken as proof of broad effectiveness or generalizability to all psychiatric conditions.
The Best et al. (2015) review concerns general medical consultations rather than psychiatric assessment specifically. Its large aggregate sample clarifies why consent and preference cannot be omitted, yet it cannot determine the best screening strategy for severe mental illness. Such distinctions between clinical populations are essential because distress, involuntary treatment, cognitive limitations, stigma, and therapeutic alliance can alter disclosure.
The 2023 Brazilian Psychiatric Association guidance on spiritual history and differential diagnosis, reported by Mosqueiro et al. (2023), drew on a structured review of existing studies and recommended incorporating spiritual history into sensitive mental health care. The guidance offers a clinically organized interpretation of evidence. Its recommendations remain professional judgments based on an evidence review, and the reviewed literature contains methodological limitations; a guideline should not be mistaken for a new randomized trial.
The CFI international field trial supplies a useful neighboring form of evidence: structured cultural interviewing can be acceptable and feasible in psychiatric outpatients across several countries (Lewis-Fernández et al. (2017)). It does not independently validate all spiritual-history instruments. Together these studies support careful, clinically indicated inquiry and demonstrate the need for stronger comparative research on what assessment changes in care.
The next generation of research should therefore identify whether structured spiritual assessment improves clinically salient information beyond skilled ordinary interviewing; whether it alters diagnostic formulation, accommodation or referral appropriately; whether outcomes improve; whether harms are recorded; and whether findings replicate across religious, secular, cultural, and psychiatric subgroups. Until these links are established, claims of universal clinical efficacy exceed the available evidence.
Clinician variables as a source of measurement bias. An assessment is jointly produced by the patient's account and the interviewer's questions, attention, assumptions, and role. The physician survey reported by Curlin et al. (2007) demonstrates that mental health specialists and other physicians do not always interpret spiritual-health connections in the same way. Another survey by Curlin et al. (2007) explored how physicians perceived the influence of religion and spirituality on health. These studies address professional perceptions rather than the validity of any patient's reported spiritual experience.
The distinction matters because clinical information yield depends partly on what questions a clinician feels willing or qualified to ask. A self-reported low rate of inquiry might represent a training gap, disagreement about professional role, time constraints, patient preference, or a combination of factors. Interventions designed only to increase clinician frequency of inquiry risk replacing one problem with another if they fail to measure consent, relevance, and quality.
Empirical work should assess interviewer variability directly. Audio-recorded and appropriately consented interviews can be rated for neutral phrasing, interruptions, response to refusal, accuracy of summaries, and incorporation into case formulation. Patient evaluation should include people with religious commitments, people with nonreligious commitments, and people reporting harmful prior contact with religious authorities. Such sampling would reveal whether an apparently efficient protocol distributes its benefits equitably.
Assessment of Distress, Risk, and Function
Religious and spiritual language becomes clinically consequential when it connects to distress, safety, functioning, treatment behavior, or a person's expressed preferences. The basic assessment task is to establish the nature, intensity, duration, timing, and consequences of an experience while preserving its personal significance. Standard mental health questions about mood, anxiety, psychosis, trauma, substance use, sleep, medical illness, cognition, and immediate risk remain essential; religious vocabulary supplies additional context and sometimes an explanation the patient finds central.
A patient's belief that suffering has moral meaning may coexist with adaptive coping, severe shame, depressive self-blame, or coercive pressure. Asking what the belief means, how strongly it is held, whether it changes, and what the patient does because of it helps clarify mechanism. For example, declining treatment could arise from a well-considered value judgment, mistaken information about medical risks, fear of community sanctions, a compulsive ritual, or impaired reasoning during an acute episode. The response differs with the underlying pathway.
Safety assessment is particularly important when a person describes a spiritual demand to harm themselves or others, dangerous fasting or deprivation, violent coercion, or threats from an institution or family member. The clinician should address the actual behavior, intent, capability, context, and immediacy of risk. Religious attribution is part of the patient's reported account; the clinical response follows established safeguarding and emergency procedures where risk warrants them.
The assessment can also identify protective relationships and practices. The existence of a supportive community does not automatically mean it is accessible during a crisis. The clinician should ask whom the person can contact, what concrete support has been provided, whether the relationship is safe, and whether contact might expose them to further harm. Protective factors should be documented as available capacities and relationships, rather than presumed from group membership.
Function can be described behaviorally: sleep, nutrition, self-care, education, employment, family participation, access to care, and social contact. A spiritually interpreted experience that does not disrupt these domains and is shared within an appropriate cultural setting requires a different analysis from one accompanied by escalating disorganization or dangerous actions. Functional evidence should be reviewed longitudinally because temporary distress and persistent impairment are different phenomena.
Clinical Differentiation of Unusual Experiences
Reports of hearing a voice, sensing a presence, receiving revelation, performing repetitive rituals, or confronting a supernatural threat require phenomenological inquiry before diagnostic judgment. Such reports can occur in ordinary religious practice, grief, intense stress, trauma-related states, sleep transitions, substance-related conditions, neurological illness, mood episodes, and psychotic disorders. The presence of sacred language is not by itself enough to determine which explanation is appropriate.
The relevant clinical questions concern awareness and orientation, voluntary control, insight, flexibility, duration, associated distress, disorganization, risk, level of functioning, and the degree to which the experience fits a person's community and biography. Clinicians also need standard psychiatric history, medical assessment where indicated, and collateral information acquired with appropriate consent. They should examine the patient's own description before translating it into symptom terminology.
The Mosqueiro et al. (2023) reviews the task of differentiating religious or spiritual experiences from psychiatric symptoms and emphasizes functional impairment and other relevant clinical signs, including disorganization. It is helpful as a structured discussion of the clinical question, although its underlying evidence includes observational and nonexperimental studies. Culture-informed inquiry can reduce errors, but the evidence cannot furnish a single universal diagnostic rule.
A patient who reports a religiously meaningful voice may have intact everyday functioning and share a culturally familiar interpretive framework. Another may report commands combined with disorganized thinking, sleep deprivation, deteriorating self-care, and dangerous behavior. The assessment must investigate the complete constellation of features. It also needs to be open to mixed cases: a person's religious tradition may shape the interpretation of an experience that has an independently identifiable psychiatric or medical component.
Similarly, repetitive acts may be ordinary observances or be driven by intrusive anxiety, inflexible rules, time consumption, and distress when prevented. Assessment of possible obsessive-compulsive symptoms should examine the function and phenomenology of repetition. It should also identify cultural norms and whether the behavior is experienced as chosen, comforting, compelled, or feared. Specific diagnostic protocols belong to the neighboring dossier on clinical interpretation of spiritual experiences; the present study establishes how a spiritually informed history contributes evidence to ordinary diagnostic work.
The assessment should record uncertainty where evidence is genuinely incomplete. Labeling a religious experience as a psychiatric symptom too quickly can damage trust and produce inappropriate care. Treating any spiritually framed experience as automatically healthy can obscure serious illness. Accurate practice maintains a developing formulation that can change as further evidence becomes available.
Developmental and Life-Course Assessment
Religious and spiritual commitments develop through relationships, education, cultural participation, identity exploration, and experiences of adversity and change. They can be stable for decades or shift abruptly after bereavement, illness, migration, discrimination, family conflict, or conversion. Clinical assessment therefore requires developmental chronology: when a belief or practice emerged, what it meant at different ages, how it was transmitted, and whether its present meaning differs from earlier experience.
In childhood, religious language may be acquired through caregivers and schooling before the child has developed the same abstract understanding as adults. The clinician needs developmentally appropriate questions and must distinguish the child's own experience from parental interpretation. In adolescent mental health care, religious affiliation or disaffiliation can intersect with autonomy, peer belonging, sexuality, identity, and family conflict. The young person's confidentiality rights and guardianship arrangements vary by jurisdiction, and clinical practice must follow the relevant legal and professional rules.
Emerging adulthood can bring experimentation with beliefs and communities, withdrawal from family traditions, or intensified commitments. These processes may provide belonging and meaning but can also coincide with interpersonal loss. A change in religious participation should not be automatically classified as a psychiatric symptom or marker of recovery. The clinical question is how it relates to distress, functioning, agency, and care preferences.
In later adulthood, spiritual history may be linked to generativity, bereavement, caregiving, illness, mortality, or end-of-life decisions. HOPE's inclusion of possible effects on medical and end-of-life care is therefore relevant to clinical settings where these topics are directly present (Anandarajah and Hight (2001)). The salience of these issues is individual: older age does not entitle a clinician to presume greater religiosity or a particular stance toward death.
Longitudinal inquiry is more informative than a one-time label. Changes in beliefs or practices may precede symptoms, follow them, or occur through shared circumstances. The history can document the order of events while remaining cautious about causal interpretation. This developmental perspective also clarifies why clinical formulations should be revisited rather than copied uncritically across episodes of care.
Cultural Diversity and Measurement Transportability
The clinical meaning of religion and spirituality depends on cultural and linguistic context. The word “spiritual” may carry positive, negative, vague, or unfamiliar meanings. Some traditions emphasize communal observance rather than private belief; others emphasize relationships to ancestors, land, ritual practice, ethical duty, or sacred texts. Minority communities may use religious language as a form of identity and protection against exclusion. Secular patients may organize meaning through philosophical, ethical, or relational commitments without identifying with a spiritual category.
A scale developed within one cultural environment may fail when transported to another. An item about a personal relationship with God may exclude nontheistic understandings; attendance may be constrained by disability or migration; an item about punishment may operate differently in traditions emphasizing collective rather than individual responsibility. Psychometric transportability requires examination of translation, response processes, factor structure, and measurement invariance, not simply a back-translation and similar average scores.
The Exline et al. (2014) development study established an interpretable multidimensional scale in specified samples, including a large undergraduate confirmatory sample. It cannot establish equivalent properties across every religious tradition, cultural region, age group, or psychiatric population. Where construct meaning differs, comparisons of raw scores can be misleading. Qualitative interviews and community-informed cognitive testing are appropriate complements to quantitative validation.
Cultural humility also involves examining the clinician's assumptions. A practitioner may view religious participation as protective, harmful, irrelevant, or inherently unfamiliar, depending on their own history. These assumptions can influence which examples they pursue, whether they attribute symptoms to culture, and the degree of curiosity they show about patient-defined meanings. Reflection and supervision are therefore part of assessment quality, not merely professional etiquette.
The Lewis-Fernández et al. (2017) international CFI evaluation provides evidence that structured cultural inquiry can be incorporated into psychiatric practice across several settings. This finding is an argument for testing contextual interview methods with culturally diverse patients, not a claim that one English-language spiritual-history script is culturally universal. Transportable practice requires translation, adaptation, training, and empirical evaluation in the receiving population.
Clinicians should also consider structural influences. Immigration status, discrimination, economic deprivation, institutional exclusion, and unequal access to interpreters can affect what patients disclose and which supports are available. These realities are part of clinical context and can be mistaken for individual religious attitudes when social conditions are left unexamined.
Trauma, Coercion, and Institutional Harm
Religious institutions, leaders, and communities can be sources of care, meaning, solidarity, and material support. They can also be settings of coercion, abuse, humiliation, exclusion, or threats. An assessment limited to beliefs and practices may overlook the power relations through which a patient experiences religion. A clinically complete history therefore asks whether participation is voluntary, whether rules are enforced through fear, whether relationships are safe, and whether the person has access to independent support.
Religious or spiritual struggle can arise after moral injury, betrayal by trusted figures, exposure to violence, or forced conformity. The interpersonal and moral dimensions identified in the Exline et al. (2014) offer research categories for understanding some of these experiences. The scale is not a trauma diagnostic instrument and cannot independently establish abuse. Detailed assessment should follow established trauma-informed clinical methods, taking account of the patient's pacing, safety, memory, and consent.
A clinician may encounter threats involving family ostracism, forced disclosure, loss of housing, or community sanctions after changes in belief or identity. These are concrete interpersonal and social risks that can become central to mental health. Their impact can be especially strong where religious membership is bound to family or community survival. Clinical responses should address safety, reliable social support, safeguarding duties, and practical resources appropriate to the jurisdiction.
Trauma-informed assessment requires careful handling of shame. A patient may avoid disclosing harm because of loyalty to a community, threats by an authority, or fear that a clinician will stereotype their tradition. The interviewer should make room for both positive and harmful experiences and avoid treating the disclosure as evidence about all members of a religious group. Documentation must distinguish an allegation, the patient's report of its effects, and independently established facts.
Referral introduces additional complexity. A community leader or spiritual-care professional may be an appropriate collaborator when chosen by the patient and when the relationship is safe. The same contact may be harmful if it returns private information to a coercive institution. Assessment should therefore establish the patient's wishes, the recipient's role, the possible consequences of contact, and any reporting duties before disclosure occurs.
Therapeutic Alliance, Confidentiality, and Professional Boundaries
The therapeutic alliance is shaped by the patient's perception that the clinician can understand important experiences without coercion, ridicule, or imposed belief. Religious and spiritual inquiry may contribute to that perception when it follows patient-defined needs and the clinical purpose is clear. It may also reduce trust when conducted as a ritual checklist or when the clinician offers unsolicited doctrinal advice. Respect for autonomy is observable in what the clinician asks, what the patient can refuse, and what happens after refusal.
Ethically, clinical assessment is governed by informed consent, professional competence, confidentiality, avoidance of harm, and appropriate role boundaries. The APA (2017) addresses professional conduct and applies independently of the patient's religious status. These general responsibilities should guide whether inquiry is indicated, how data are recorded, and how cultural or spiritual consultation is arranged. Local laws, professional regulations, emergency duties, and institutional policy may add specific requirements.
An assessor should explain why a question is being asked and what use will be made of the answer, especially when collecting sensitive personal information. The right to refrain is particularly important for patients whose experiences include stigma or coercion. A clinically appropriate refusal should not be framed as resistance to treatment merely because a clinician values holistic assessment.
Confidentiality is a practical issue because religious information can reveal family history, minority identity, community conflict, trauma, or a vulnerable social position. Electronic health records can circulate information among professionals who were not present at the initial interview. Documentation should be accurate, limited to clinically relevant material, and subject to access and retention rules. If an interpreter or chaplain is involved, the patient should understand the participant's obligations and any limits of confidentiality.
Professional boundaries become blurred when a clinician's role as assessor turns into attempted spiritual instruction. Mental health professionals can help patients clarify their beliefs, values, conflicts, and choices within psychological care. They should not exploit the therapeutic relationship to convert a patient, undermine their religion, or establish themselves as religious authority. A clinician's private beliefs are not a warrant to direct a patient's spiritual decisions.
The relationship may need repair after misunderstanding. If a clinician incorrectly interprets a ritual or dismisses a sacred experience, acknowledging and correcting the error can improve the accuracy of subsequent information. The ability to revise an interpretation is a scientific and relational competency, particularly where cultural differences are substantial.
Competencies, Training, and Interprofessional Collaboration
Clinical competence in religious and spiritual assessment is not defined by personal religiosity or theological literacy alone. It involves recognizing when the subject is relevant, asking permission, eliciting patient-defined meaning, identifying resources and distress, distinguishing clinical and doctrinal questions, detecting coercion and risk, and using the information appropriately in formulation and care. Competence also includes knowing when consultation or referral is needed.
Vieten and Lukoff (2022) surveyed the domain of spiritual and religious competencies in psychology and argued that professional multicultural preparation often leaves religion and spirituality underrepresented. Their work offers a framework for education and practice, but a competency framework is not itself proof that a specific training course improves diagnostic accuracy. The relevant empirical outcomes must be measured directly.
Training can be organized around simulated interviews, direct observation, case formulation, and feedback from patients and supervisors. Assessment should examine whether trainees can obtain consent without pressure, accurately summarize the patient's language, recognize uncertainty, and identify both resources and harms. Measures of self-rated confidence alone are insufficient because clinicians may become more confident without becoming more accurate or acceptable to patients.
Interprofessional collaboration may involve psychologists, psychiatrists, primary-care physicians, nurses, chaplains, cultural consultants, social workers, interpreters, and community providers. Each professional contributes a different kind of knowledge. A chaplain may understand tradition-specific practices and spiritual distress; a clinician assesses psychiatric symptoms, impairment, risk, and treatment; a social worker may clarify support and access needs. Collaboration is justified when these forms of expertise address a defined care problem.
Referral should be tailored to patient preference and evaluated for safety. A chaplaincy service might be suitable for a person seeking spiritual support during illness. A secular meaning-centered resource may better match another person's goals. A client experiencing coercion by their religious institution may specifically require a referral independent of that institution. A good referral process is documented, consented to, and followed up when clinically important.
Competence should also be evaluated at an organizational level. Clinics need policies that permit respectful inquiry without indiscriminate collection of sensitive data; access to appropriate interpreters and consultants; procedures for responding to reported harm; and mechanisms for obtaining patient feedback. These conditions are essential for turning an interview tool into responsible clinical practice.
Research Designs for Clinical Utility
The principal methodological challenge is to determine what spiritual assessment adds beyond competent ordinary clinical interviewing. This question requires studies that specify the intervention and the comparator. An intervention described merely as “spiritual assessment” can involve a one-question screen, a FICA or HOPE interview, a detailed structured narrative, standardized scales, or referral to a spiritual-care specialist. These procedures differ in time, professional competence, data yield, and possible consequences. Their effects cannot be pooled conceptually without identifying these differences.
A useful randomized trial would compare clearly described procedures in a defined care setting. One arm might use a structured permission-based spiritual history and another an equally time-intensive, patient-centered general history. Such a design could distinguish any specific contribution of religious inquiry from attention, warmth, and additional interview time. Allocation concealment, outcome registration, clinician training, missing data, and analysis by initial assignment would need documentation. Clinicians and patients often cannot be blinded to the topic of the interview, so independent rating of formulation quality and prespecified patient outcomes become particularly valuable.
Information yield should be operationalized before analysis. Possible endpoints include detection of patient-reported values that alter treatment decisions, identification of previously unrecognized coercion or spiritual struggle, documentation of requested accommodations, and agreement between patient and clinician summaries. An endpoint based only on the number of spiritual themes recorded would reward longer questioning even if it produced no useful change.
Clinical utility has a more demanding standard. Investigators could examine whether the assessment improves the accuracy of case formulation, the suitability of referrals, patient participation in decisions, adherence to mutually agreed plans, or satisfaction with communication. These outcomes have different causal pathways and should be evaluated separately. For example, better identification of a preference may be valuable even when symptom scores do not change; conversely, a referral based on an inaccurate assumption may be harmful despite producing more recorded activity.
Patient outcomes require longer follow-up. Depending on the setting, studies could assess therapeutic alliance, symptoms, functioning, quality of life, care access, adverse experiences, and unwanted disclosure. Trials should report the possibility of harm, including distress from intrusive inquiry or pressure from a referral, alongside potential benefit. Heterogeneity by setting and patient preference should be anticipated in design rather than treated as an inconvenient finding after analysis.
Implementation studies are necessary because even an effective interview can fail in ordinary practice. Relevant dimensions include how often permission is requested, clinician fidelity to neutral questioning, visit length, referral availability, training needs, documentation burden, and whether professional boundaries are maintained. A program can increase the frequency of assessments while decreasing patient comfort, or increase satisfaction in one population while producing distrust in another. Both possibilities belong in the evaluation plan.
Qualitative studies provide an indispensable complement. Patient interviews can identify why a question felt respectful, how meanings changed in conversation, and what participants wished clinicians had understood. Observational coding can examine interruptions, leading questions, unsolicited self-disclosure, and the handling of refusal. Multisite sampling can expose differences across organizations, cultural groups, and resource environments. A strong research program combines these methods with transparent protocols and appropriate quantitative estimates.
A stepped or cluster-randomized implementation design might be considered when teams rather than individuals receive training, but the analysis must account for clustering and contamination. A longitudinal cohort can test whether changes in spiritual struggle precede or follow symptom change, although causal explanations remain vulnerable to unmeasured confounding. A psychometric study can test invariance and responsiveness, but it cannot alone establish that the instrument changes care. A coherent evidence program assigns each design the question it can answer.
Evidence Appraisal and Unresolved Problems
The present literature gives reasonably direct support for the proposition that religious and spiritual information can be relevant to some patients' understanding of illness and care. It includes descriptive clinical studies, culturally informed psychiatric research, developmental measurement work, patient-preference syntheses, and guidelines based on literature review. The crucial unresolved issue is how much additional benefit systematic assessment provides, for whom, in which settings, and at what opportunity cost.
The HOPE evidence offers a useful example of this distinction. Sleeth et al. (2025) show that the model has been discussed and used across professional and national settings for more than twenty years. This breadth supports a claim of dissemination. It cannot be converted into a pooled estimate of effectiveness, because a scoping review maps different uses and studies rather than establishing a single causal intervention effect. The right future question concerns comparisons that identify the model's incremental value.
FICA likewise has direct evidence of evaluation in a particular oncology population (Borneman et al. (2010)). The study does not provide an all-settings validity certificate, and its findings should be interpreted alongside the population's clinical needs, treatment context, and selected outcome measures. The absence of evidence for broader effectiveness is a substantive research gap; it does not logically show that respectful inquiry is ineffective.
The Exline et al. (2014) scale demonstrates the methodological value of defining and measuring distinct forms of religious struggle. Its adult development and undergraduate confirmation samples establish a specific empirical foundation. Important next steps involve transportability to clinical patients, minority traditions, nonreligious populations where the items are meaningful, and longitudinal changes across treatment. Clinical utility must be separately tested from factor structure.
Patient-preference evidence has its own limitation. The Best et al. (2015) review synthesizes heterogeneous consultations and clinical circumstances. Its result that preferences vary is robustly relevant to practice. It cannot determine a single universal timing or phrasing for intake, and a stated willingness to discuss spirituality in a survey is not identical to informed consent in an actual therapeutic encounter.
Cultural interview research supplies more context than a spiritual-specific efficacy claim. The Lewis-Fernández et al. (2017) evaluated feasibility and utility judgments across six countries, which is stronger evidence of implementation beyond one local clinic than an isolated anecdotal report. Its observational and mixed-methods endpoints remain distinct from diagnosis or symptom improvements attributable to spiritual-history assessment. The study supports building cultural context into methods and validating interviews in receiving populations.
The Huguelet et al. (2011) psychiatric trial is directly relevant because it studies spiritual assessment in mental health care. Its comparatively narrow setting means replication is important before inferring a general standard for psychosis, mood disorders, trauma clinics, or primary care. Randomization strengthens internal inference only for the measured comparison and outcomes; it does not automatically extend to unmeasured benefits.
Professional recommendations also merit a separate evidence label. The Mosqueiro et al. (2023) guideline combines literature identification, appraisal, and expert interpretation. It supports structured attention to spiritual history and cultural differentiation in psychiatric care. The guideline's recommendations can inform practice while leaving open empirical questions about optimal frequency, instrument selection, patient selection, and causal effects.
Several broad research problems recur. Construct definitions are inconsistent: some studies label all existential meaning as spirituality, while others focus on specific religious affiliation or belief. Sampling often privileges religious majorities and medical settings. Many instruments were developed in languages and institutions that differ from the clinical environments to which they are subsequently exported. Outcomes are often short-term, self-reported, or centered on satisfaction rather than diagnostic accuracy and functioning. Comparator conditions are frequently weak or absent. Adverse events, unwanted discussion, coercion, and confidentiality consequences are insufficiently specified.
An additional challenge concerns professional incentives. Institutions may adopt a tool because it is easy to teach, auditors may reward completion rates, and clinicians may view spiritual inquiry as evidence of compassionate practice. These incentives can produce documentation divorced from patient needs. Evaluations should therefore report clinically meaningful negative findings and the experience of patients who decline discussion. A patient-centered assessment system must be capable of demonstrating that a refusal is respected.
A defensible evidence hierarchy distinguishes findings rather than assigning a single quality score to a diverse field. FICA and HOPE are established communication models. The Religious and Spiritual Struggles Scale has specified construct-validation evidence. The CFI has multisite implementation evidence concerning broader cultural assessment. The patient-preference review summarizes heterogeneous but substantial reported preferences. Clinical guideline recommendations draw from evidence reviews and expert judgment. Strong claims about the magnitude of benefit from routine spiritual assessment across psychiatric populations remain insufficiently established.
Consensus standards and empirical performance. The interdisciplinary whole-person-care consensus described by Puchalski et al. (2014) has been influential in framing spiritual care as a responsibility shared among general clinicians and specialists. For a research assessment, the implications of consensus should be specified precisely: it identifies what professional participants regard as appropriate practice and what institutional collaboration might require. Independent studies are needed to test whether implementing its procedures improves clinical decisions and patient outcomes.
The most recent broad instrument synthesis considered here, Portillo-Gil et al. (2026), is especially instructive because it differentiates the existence of instruments from their psychometric strength. A review of validated scales can reveal deficiencies in construct clarity and predictive validity even within a literature that routinely reports acceptable internal consistency. Reliability is necessary for some interpretations but insufficient for truth, discrimination, or usefulness.
For the next research generation, an efficient design sequence is construct clarification, cognitive interview development, validation in the intended population, comparative trial of the assessment procedure, and measurement of implementation and adverse consequences. Results at each step should be reported in their own evidential category. This approach can improve both scientific precision and clinical safety.
Research Synthesis for the Artificial Era
The Artificial Era introduces new interfaces through which people describe distress, seek information, obtain support, and formulate questions about meaning. Digital intake systems, conversational agents, electronic records, and decision aids may mediate clinical assessment. Their involvement changes how religious and spiritual information is elicited, stored, summarized, interpreted, and passed to clinicians. The scientific object of this dossier remains the patient's psychological experience and the reliability and ethics of the assessment process.
Artificial systems could, as a research hypothesis, help patients formulate preferences before meeting a clinician or make optional culturally adapted prompts available in accessible formats. They could also intensify familiar problems: suggesting a religious identity the patient never endorsed, overinterpreting culturally unfamiliar language, producing unwarranted diagnostic certainty, or disclosing sensitive information to inappropriate recipients. These possibilities require empirical testing and explicit governance rather than presumed benefit.
A digital interface should make clear what it asks, why it asks, who will view the answer, and how the patient can decline or correct the record. Automatic summaries should distinguish quotations from inference and preserve uncertainty. If a patient describes an experience as sacred, an algorithm should not silently translate that report into a psychiatric symptom or a theological claim. The same standard of interpretive restraint applies to human clinicians, although automated scale and propagation introduce distinct risks.
Research on artificial-mediated assessment can use the same methodological questions developed here: What information does the interface elicit beyond ordinary intake? Does it improve patient understanding or access? Does it lead to correct clinical action? Can it be used safely across traditions and secular orientations? What errors occur for minority and vulnerable populations? Does clinician review detect and repair them? Is there evidence of improved outcomes, or only evidence of efficient data collection?
The philosophical framework of Artificial Era · From Homo to Artificial provides an interpretive horizon for examining changes in the institutions and instruments of psychological knowledge. Claims about any particular artificial system's psychological capacities require independent operational definitions and evidence. In a clinical setting, the controlling practical obligations are patient consent, cultural accuracy, clinician accountability, careful provenance, and demonstrable utility.
Conclusion
Religious and spiritual assessment in clinical practice is a contextual process of understanding the relevance of beliefs, practices, relationships, meaning, and conflict to a particular person's psychological care. Its scientific foundation is the convergence of patient-centered history-taking, cultural formulation, construct research, and the clinical evaluation of functioning and risk. An adequate assessment begins with an invitation that can be declined, follows the patient's own language, identifies resources and harms, and connects findings to a transparent and revisable formulation.
The history of the field explains why FICA and HOPE became influential: they make an elusive domain discussable through usable clinical questions. Research on religious and spiritual struggles demonstrates why that domain cannot be collapsed into a single positive or negative variable. International cultural-formulation studies show that structured inquiry into meaning and context can be feasible in psychiatric settings. Patient-preference research requires clinicians to recognize diversity of interest and explicit boundaries. The available psychiatric and medical studies support the clinical relevance of the subject while leaving substantial uncertainty about comparative effectiveness and long-term outcomes.
A rigorous standard should therefore specify what an assessment is intended to discover, how that information will be used, what patient choice governs the encounter, and which evidence supports each inference. Clinical competence entails recognizing both sources of support and sites of coercion, distinguishing reported experience from diagnosis, and collaborating with other professionals only when appropriate. Research should measure clinical decision quality, patient experience, downstream consequences, and possible harms with the same seriousness as information yield.
The resulting conclusion is practical and testable. Religious and spiritual assessment has a legitimate place within comprehensive, culturally responsive clinical inquiry when the patient and clinical context make it relevant. Its refinement depends on comparative studies, transportable measures, transparent documentation, meaningful outcomes, and sustained respect for individual autonomy.
References
- American Psychological Association. (2017). Ethical principles of psychologists and code of conduct (2002, amended effective June 1, 2010, and January 1, 2017). https://www.apa.org/ethics/code/
- Anandarajah, G., & Hight, E. (2001). Spirituality and medical practice: Using the HOPE questions as a practical tool for spiritual assessment. American Family Physician, 63(1), 81–89. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11195773/
- Best, M., Butow, P., & Olver, I. (2015). Do patients want doctors to talk about spirituality? A systematic literature review. Patient Education and Counseling, 98(11), 1320–1328. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pec.2015.04.017
- Borneman, T., Ferrell, B., & Puchalski, C. M. (2010). Evaluation of the FICA tool for spiritual assessment. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management, 40(2), 163–173. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2009.12.019
- Curlin, F. A., Lawrence, R. E., Odell, S., Chin, M. H., Lantos, J. D., Koenig, H. G., & Meador, K. G. (2007). Religion, spirituality, and medicine: Psychiatrists' and other physicians' differing observations, interpretations, and clinical approaches. American Journal of Psychiatry, 164(12), 1825–1831. https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ajp.2007.06122088
- Curlin, F. A., Sellergren, S. A., Lantos, J. D., & Chin, M. H. (2007). Physicians' observations and interpretations of the influence of religion and spirituality on health. Archives of Internal Medicine, 167(7), 649–654. https://doi.org/10.1001/archinte.167.7.649
- Exline, J. J., Pargament, K. I., Grubbs, J. B., & Yali, A. M. (2014). The Religious and Spiritual Struggles Scale: Development and initial validation. Psychology of Religion and Spirituality, 6(3), 208–222. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0036465
- Huguelet, P., Mohr, S., Betrisey, C., Borras, L., Gillieron, C., Marie, A. M., Rieben, I., Perroud, N., & Brandt, P.-Y. (2011). A randomized trial of spiritual assessment of outpatients with schizophrenia: Patients' and clinicians' experience. Psychiatric Services, 62(1), 79–86. https://doi.org/10.1176/ps.62.1.pss6201_0079
- Lewis-Fernández, R., Aggarwal, N. K., Bäärnhielm, S., Rohlof, H., Kirmayer, L. J., Weiss, M. G., Jadhav, S., Hinton, L., Alarcón, R. D., Bhugra, D., Groen, S., van Dijk, R., Qureshi, A., Collazos, F., Rousseau, C., Caballero, L., Ramos, M., & Lu, F. (2014). Culture and psychiatric evaluation: Operationalizing cultural formulation for DSM-5. Psychiatry, 77(2), 130–154. https://doi.org/10.1521/psyc.2014.77.2.130
- Lewis-Fernández, R., Aggarwal, N. K., Lam, P. C., Galfalvy, H., Weiss, M. G., Kirmayer, L. J., Paralikar, V., Deshpande, S. N., Díaz, E., Nicasio, A. V., Boiler, M., Alarcón, R. D., Rohlof, H., Groen, S., van Dijk, R. C. J., Jadhav, S., Sarmukaddam, S., Ndetei, D., Scalco, M. Z., … Vega-Dienstmaier, J. M. (2017). Feasibility, acceptability and clinical utility of the Cultural Formulation Interview: Mixed-methods results from the DSM-5 international field trial. British Journal of Psychiatry, 210(4), 290–297. https://doi.org/10.1192/bjp.bp.116.193862
- Mosqueiro, B. P., Costa, M. de A., Caribé, A. C., Oliveira e Oliveira, F. H. A., Pizutti, L., Zimpel, R. R., Baldaçara, L., da Silva, A. G., & Moreira-Almeida, A. (2023). Brazilian Psychiatric Association guidelines on the integration of spirituality into mental health clinical practice: Part 1. Spiritual history and differential diagnosis. Brazilian Journal of Psychiatry, 45(6), 506–517. https://doi.org/10.47626/1516-4446-2023-3056
- Pargament, K. I., & Krumrei, E. J. (2009). Clinical assessment of clients' spirituality. In J. D. Aten & M. M. Leach (Eds.), Spirituality and the therapeutic process: A comprehensive resource from intake to termination (pp. 93–120). American Psychological Association. https://doi.org/10.1037/11853-005
- Pargament, K. I., Feuille, M., & Burdzy, D. (2011). The Brief RCOPE: Current psychometric status of a short measure of religious coping. Religions, 2(1), 51–76. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel2010051
- Portillo-Gil, M. Á., Lucchetti, G., & De Diego-Cordero, R. (2026). Instruments for assessing spirituality in patients with chronic or advanced illnesses: A systematic review of the last 15 years. Healthcare, 14(8), Article 1013. https://doi.org/10.3390/healthcare14081013
- Puchalski, C., Ferrell, B., Virani, R., Otis-Green, S., Baird, P., Bull, J., Chochinov, H., Handzo, G., Nelson-Becker, H., Prince-Paul, M., Pugliese, K., & Sulmasy, D. (2009). Improving the quality of spiritual care as a dimension of palliative care: The report of the Consensus Conference. Journal of Palliative Medicine, 12(10), 885–904. https://doi.org/10.1089/jpm.2009.0142
- Puchalski, C. M., Vitillo, R., Hull, S. K., & Reller, N. (2014). Improving the spiritual dimension of whole person care: Reaching national and international consensus. Journal of Palliative Medicine, 17(6), 642–656. https://doi.org/10.1089/jpm.2014.9427
- Puchalski, C., & Romer, A. L. (2000). Taking a spiritual history allows clinicians to understand patients more fully. Journal of Palliative Medicine, 3(1), 129–137. https://doi.org/10.1089/jpm.2000.3.129
- Sleeth, G., Gottlieb, P., Srinivasan, A., Thaddeus, U., Mennillo, M., & Anandarajah, G. (2025). Evaluation of the HOPE spiritual assessment model: A scoping review of international interest, applications and studies over 20+ years. BMC Palliative Care, 24, Article 191. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12904-025-01809-z
- Vieten, C., & Lukoff, D. (2022). Spiritual and religious competencies in psychology. American Psychologist, 77(1), 26–38. https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0000821