RESEARCH DOSSIER
Psychological Sense of Community
Abstract. Psychological sense of community denotes the experienced relationship between a person and a meaningful, specified collectivity, encompassing membership, mutual influence, integration and fulfillment of needs, and shared emotional connection. This fundamental research monograph critically synthesizes the historical development of the construct, the McMillan–Chavis theoretical framework, major competing and complementary explanations, early and contemporary measurement instruments, field investigations, qualitative studies, and cross-cultural psychometric analyses. Particular attention is given to the Sense of Community Index, the Brief SCI, the Brief Sense of Community Scale, SCI-2, factor-structure disputes, referent ambiguity, and limits on comparing scores across populations and settings. Evidence from neighborhoods, schools, participation studies, communities of interest, and online networks is analyzed alongside research on imposed group membership, inequality, cultural diversity, and potentially adaptive negative sense of community. The synthesis distinguishes subjective belonging from institutional participation, neighborhood cohesion, loneliness, social capital, and collective efficacy; it evaluates causal identification, measurement invariance, and generalizability. Future research addresses longitudinal change, equitable community intervention, and mediated human–Artificial relations in the Artificial Era. The work is a critical narrative research synthesis of published scholarship; it reports neither original experimental data nor a newly conducted systematic review or meta-analysis.
Keywords: psychological sense of community; PSOC; sense of community; McMillan–Chavis theory; membership; mutual influence; fulfillment of needs; shared emotional connection; community psychology; sense of belonging; Sense of Community Index; SCI-2; Brief Sense of Community Scale; psychometric validity; community participation; negative sense of community; cultural relativity; online community; community responsibility; social ecology
Introduction: Community as a Psychological Relationship
Psychological sense of community (PSOC) is the experienced relationship through which people recognize a meaningful collectivity as a setting of membership, mutual influence, shared resources, and emotional connection. It is investigated in neighborhoods, schools, workplaces, voluntary associations, dispersed interest groups, and communities formed through political or digital participation. The central research problem concerns the conditions under which persons perceive themselves as connected to a specified community and the consequences of that experience for participation, well-being, social boundaries, and responses to collective change. The classic theory provides an organized account of the construct while later studies show that the community selected as a referent, the measurement instrument, and the social setting can materially alter findings McMillan & Chavis (1986) Long & Perkins (2003).
The object of inquiry is a subjective, socially situated evaluation. It does not simply count acquaintances or measure the geographic proximity of residents. A person can feel connected to a network extending across continents, remain detached from a residential neighborhood, or experience support within a stigmatized association. Psychological sense of community is therefore analytically distinct from objective network density, social capital, formal group membership, generalized loneliness, collective efficacy, and satisfaction with a place. These neighboring constructs often covary and may mediate one another, but evidence about one does not automatically establish the other. Research must name the relevant collectivity before interpreting the respondent's assessment Obst et al. (2002) Carpiano & Hystad (2011).
This monograph offers a critical narrative synthesis of original theory papers, instrument-development studies, observational field research, qualitative investigations, measurement critiques, and contemporary cross-cultural validation. It asks how the experience of community was conceptualized, how its components have been operationalized, which empirical findings withstand design scrutiny, when belonging becomes protective or coercive, and what methodological program can distinguish community experience from its causes and consequences. The review is evidence-led but is not a registered systematic review or a quantitative meta-analysis. Conclusions are stated at the level supported by each study, and speculative extensions are identified as research questions Chipuer & Pretty (1999) Nowell & Boyd (2010).
Historical Formation of the Research Problem
The development of community psychology made experienced connection a central concern during the twentieth century. Seymour Sarason's 1974 book, The Psychological Sense of Community: Prospects for a Community Psychology, helped locate the phenomenon within a discipline concerned with persons in social environments. The original 1974 edition, published by Jossey-Bass, established a conceptual reference point for subsequent community-psychology writing Sarason (1974). Its intellectual significance lies in elevating belonging, mutual dependence, and shared life above exclusively individual indicators of adjustment. David McMillan subsequently offered an early formulation in 1976, and the 1986 McMillan–Chavis article translated that program into a four-element theory with explicit mechanisms. This sequence, documented by the authors, provides a more precise history than treating a single scale as the origin of the concept McMillan & Chavis (1986) McMillan (1996).
The 1986 Journal of Community Psychology special issue paired conceptual consolidation with empirical operationalization. McMillan and Chavis described the dynamics of community experience, while Chavis, Hogge, McMillan, and Wandersman studied cues and judgments associated with it. The experimental ambition at this stage was modest: to establish discriminable manifestations and develop measures suited to real social settings. Their work provided a productive common vocabulary, yet it also left the field with the question of whether four conceptual ingredients correspond to four statistically separable latent dimensions. Later factor-analytic evidence made this question unavoidable Chavis et al. (1986) Long & Perkins (2003).
The research tradition then expanded beyond its early North American neighborhood emphasis. Studies addressed adolescent school settings, residents' organizations, imposed ethnic categories under apartheid, voluntary communities of interest, and networked online groups. This diversification altered what counted as a community and revealed that membership can be voluntary, externally assigned, overlapping, or contested. The historical trajectory thus contains both theoretical continuity and an expanding inventory of cases that test the original model's boundaries. Community psychology gains explanatory precision by preserving that historical plurality rather than reading all subsequent findings as a simple confirmation of the founding model Pretty et al. (1994) Sonn & Fisher (1996) Obst et al. (2002).
The Four-Element Framework
McMillan and Chavis organized psychological sense of community around membership, influence, integration and fulfillment of needs, and shared emotional connection. Membership names an experienced boundary around belonging: identification with the group, emotional safety, investment, and recognition by others. Influence concerns the expectation that members matter to the community and that the community can shape members' conduct. Integration and fulfillment of needs addresses the social and material rewards of membership. Shared emotional connection emerges through interaction, common events, emotional investment, and the significance assigned to collective history. The elements form a theory of reciprocal relations, rather than four independent checklist items McMillan & Chavis (1986).
The framework's dynamic character deserves emphasis. Expectations of mutual influence can encourage participation; participation creates encounters that may reinforce common history; shared history increases the value of membership; and valued membership can motivate continued exchanges of assistance. The same sequence may weaken if perceived voice disappears, gatekeepers withdraw recognition, or collective resources become inaccessible. Each proposed link is a mechanism to be studied rather than a universally established causal chain. Survey correlations between influence and belonging are compatible with reciprocal causation, selection into congenial settings, or an unmeasured common cause. Disentangling them requires repeated observations or credible intervention designs Chavis & Wandersman (1990) Nowell & Boyd (2010).
The theory's influence extends beyond its original dimensions because it defines community as a relationship partly constituted by experience. Its conceptual usefulness does not imply that a four-factor scale will always provide the best empirical representation. Chipuer and Pretty identified weaknesses in the internal consistency and factor structure of early index subscales; Long and Perkins later reported poor confirmatory fit for the intended structure using original neighborhood data. Peterson, Speer, and McMillan presented a brief scale with a better-specified four-dimensional structure. The body of evidence supports continued investigation of the four elements while requiring measurement models to be justified for each population and setting Chipuer & Pretty (1999) Long & Perkins (2003) Peterson et al. (2008).
Membership, Influence, Needs, and Emotional Connection in Practice
Membership becomes psychologically salient when boundaries carry consequences. A neighborhood association may distinguish recognized volunteers from occasional residents, while a virtual community may rely on shared norms, repeated interaction, and reputational recognition. Boundaries can increase predictability and trust for insiders and impose exclusionary costs on outsiders. Identification with a group and experienced acceptance should therefore be measured separately wherever possible. Formal enrollment provides evidence of administrative membership; lived recognition provides evidence of psychological membership. Their divergence can be central to understanding alienation inside a group or affiliation without formal status McMillan & Chavis (1986) Townley et al. (2011).
Influence has two directions: perceived personal voice in collective affairs and the capacity of the collective to shape one's expectations and actions. These directions can reinforce or strain each other. A cohesive organization may strongly influence members while allowing little reciprocal voice; participants might report loyalty, pressure, resentment, or selective withdrawal. A survey item that asks whether members have influence over the community is not interchangeable with an item asking whether group norms influence the respondent. Research designs must make this distinction explicit, especially when studying unequal authority, exclusion, or institutional governance. The responsibility perspective additionally asks how collective obligations are internalized Nowell & Boyd (2010) Mannarini & Fedi (2009).
Fulfillment of needs connects membership to perceived resources and symbolic recognition, while shared emotional connection ties present relationships to interpreted histories. Needs may include practical assistance, information, belonging, personal significance, or opportunities for joint activity. A collective's capacity to provide assistance is an environmental property; the individual's expectation of receiving meaningful benefit is a psychological judgment. Similarly, common exposure to an event does not guarantee a shared emotional narrative. The meaning of a community's history can be negotiated, contested, and stratified by position. These distinctions make the four elements suitable for rich qualitative inquiry as well as questionnaire design Chavis et al. (1986) Sonn & Fisher (1996).
Defining the Community Referent and Its Boundaries
Every measurement of sense of community has an implicit or explicit answer to the question 'community of what?' Researchers may refer to a street block, school, occupational group, neighborhood, cultural minority, nation, network, or transnational interest community. The psychological judgment changes with the referent. An adolescent might feel attached to a school peer group while experiencing limited neighborhood connection; an adult might identify with a cross-border interest group despite weak local ties. Combining such ratings as though they represented one stable attribute would confuse distinct experiences. Referent specification is accordingly a foundational design decision, not a minor instruction inserted before a scale Pretty et al. (1994) Obst et al. (2002).
Community boundaries are often multiple and porous. Individuals can belong simultaneously to family networks, religious or cultural associations, professional communities, neighborhoods, and virtual groups. Perceived membership may also vary across subgroups within one institution, producing different experiences of safety, recognition, and influence. Mannarini and Fedi's interviews demonstrated that the meaning people attribute to community is connected to civic participation and that participants express heterogeneous relationships to the idea of community. Such findings recommend collecting participants' own definitions and affiliations before imposing a single researcher-defined unit Mannarini & Fedi (2009).
Boundaries can be externally produced. Sonn and Fisher interviewed people who had been assigned a racialized category under apartheid and later lived in Australia; their analysis distinguished imposed group membership from socially constructed forms of belonging. This work shows why a community label, even a historically powerful one, cannot substitute for members' accounts of identification, positive ties, or coercive classification. Studies that sample groups through administrative categories should test the match between assigned category and experienced community. Otherwise estimates may combine people whose relationships to the presumed community are fundamentally different Sonn & Fisher (1996) Townley et al. (2011).
From Early Community Measures to the Sense of Community Index
Measurement preceded any settled agreement about whether sense of community was a unified disposition, a set of related experiences, or a property of the relationship between residents and local institutions. Buckner developed a neighborhood-cohesion instrument in 1988 that addressed attraction to neighborhood, neighboring, and psychological sense of community in residential settings. This is an important adjacent instrument, but its neighborhood cohesion should not be treated as an interchangeable name for every subsequent PSOC scale. Neighborhood density, interpersonal interaction, and global community appraisal can be modeled as distinct indicators or explanatory variables according to the research question Buckner (1988) McMillan & Chavis (1986).
The original Sense of Community Index was widely adapted as a practical measure rooted in the McMillan–Chavis account. Its brief items made field administration feasible across neighborhoods and other settings, and its language became influential in program evaluation. This accessibility also encouraged researchers to use total scores across differently defined communities, sometimes assuming that the intended four elements emerged from the responses. Chavis and colleagues' early work examined the relation between cues to community and experienced belonging, establishing an empirical point of departure, but not settling the psychometric status of all subdimensions or the comparability of different populations Chavis et al. (1986) Chipuer & Pretty (1999).
The distinction between a theoretical element and an observed factor is central. Membership and emotional connection may be distinguishable in conceptual analysis yet produce overlapping item responses within a particular sample. Reversed questions, ambiguous referents, and wording about liking an area can introduce additional method variance. A total score can also obscure differences between a person who feels valued but has little institutional voice and one who perceives influence without emotional attachment. A well-designed study begins with a construct map, defines its community referent, specifies whether a general or multidimensional score is required, and then estimates the score's reliability and construct validity in that use Chipuer & Pretty (1999) Long & Perkins (2003).
Construct Validity and the Factor-Structure Debate
Chipuer and Pretty's 1999 methodological review assembled evidence about the Sense of Community Index's use, internal consistency, and factor structure. Its significance is the demonstration that a measure's popularity and conceptual pedigree do not guarantee adequate subscale performance. Internal consistency estimates and factor solutions differed across applications, undermining unqualified comparisons of the index's nominally distinct elements. A researcher who reports four component scores must therefore demonstrate that each score supports the proposed interpretation, preferably through factor analysis, model-fit comparisons, reliability estimates, and external validation against theoretically appropriate outcomes Chipuer & Pretty (1999).
Long and Perkins reexamined the index using confirmatory factor analysis and presented a brief alternative. Their findings challenged the adequacy of commonly assumed single-factor and original four-factor models in the residential samples they analyzed. The lesson concerns model fit under a specified dataset and wording configuration. It would be equally misleading to assert that the original theoretical dimensions are universally false or to disregard contrary measurement evidence because the theory is historically important. A measurement instrument operationalizes a theoretical claim through indicators; competing instruments can reveal different structures without settling the entirety of the underlying social process Long & Perkins (2003) McMillan & Chavis (1986).
Construct validation requires several complementary questions. Content validity asks whether items represent reciprocal influence, recognition, need fulfillment, and emotional history rather than generic friendliness. Structural validity asks whether the proposed dimensions adequately explain observed covariance. Discriminant validity asks whether the scale can be distinguished from loneliness, social participation, neighborhood cohesion, and social capital. Predictive or concurrent validity examines specified relationships without presuming direction. Invariance testing examines whether items function comparably across communities or populations. The enduring measurement problem is therefore to determine what score interpretation is warranted for each study, not simply to select the most familiar index Peterson et al. (2008) Carpiano & Hystad (2011) Yu et al. (2022).
The Brief Sense of Community Scale and SCI-2
Several brief measures emerged in response to structural and field-administration difficulties. Long and Perkins developed a Brief SCI in 2003 in connection with their confirmatory analyses; its instrument lineage and empirical factor solution should be distinguished from the later Brief Sense of Community Scale validated by Peterson, Speer, and McMillan in 2008. Peterson and colleagues' eight-item BSCS was explicitly designed to represent the four principal theoretical dimensions. The instruments may share an abbreviation in informal discussion, but a scholarly methods section must identify the authors, year, exact item set, response scale, target referent, and scoring procedure. Names alone are insufficient for reproducibility Long & Perkins (2003) Peterson et al. (2008).
Peterson and colleagues examined the BSCS as a concise way of measuring need fulfillment, group membership, influence, and shared emotional connection. Their validation supplied evidence for the proposed configuration in their study conditions and offered a practical alternative to instruments with problematic structures. The result should be evaluated in relation to the population, the number of indicators per latent dimension, and the possible cost of reducing complex domains to only a few questions. Brief instruments improve respondent burden, but their apparent simplicity increases the importance of checking how respondents interpret each item in a particular organization, neighborhood, or cultural setting Peterson et al. (2008) Townley et al. (2011).
The Sense of Community Index 2, described by Community Science, expands measurement to twenty-four items distributed over the four proposed elements and supplies explicit administration and scoring materials. Its development reflects efforts to more adequately sample the theoretical content than the early short index. The existence of a longer scale does not itself establish measurement invariance, causal interpretation, or universal superiority. Researchers should consult the developer's current materials, observe applicable use conditions, document any modification, and report appropriate reliability and fit statistics. In particular, findings from SCI-2 cannot be assumed equivalent to BSCS or other SCI variants merely because their labels refer to the same theory Community Science (n.d.) Chipuer & Pretty (1999).
Cross-Cultural Equivalence and Measurement Invariance
Translation changes more than vocabulary when constructs involve belonging, membership, obligation, and influence. Expectations about speaking in community decisions, accepting collective obligations, and interpreting family or institutional boundaries differ across contexts. A translated item can be grammatically accurate but represent a different social claim. Cross-cultural validation should therefore begin with locally meaningful referents and cognitive interviews, followed by tests of factor structure, item functioning, and score comparability. Invariance is a graded empirical question, with configural, metric, and scalar properties supporting progressively stronger interpretations of cross-group differences Townley et al. (2011) Sonn & Fisher (1996).
Yu and colleagues' 2022 Japanese validation of a brief sense-of-community measure provides an example of localized psychometric examination. The reported analyses of reliability and construct structure are relevant to Japanese respondents under the particular wording and sampling conditions investigated. A successful translated measurement model in one national sample does not by itself establish equivalence between that sample and the original American development sample. Cross-national differences in observed means cannot be given substantive psychological interpretations until investigators examine whether the groups understand the items and response categories comparably. Local validity and cross-national invariance are separate evidentiary achievements Yu et al. (2022) Peterson et al. (2008).
Historical and political circumstances complicate the problem further. Sonn and Fisher's investigation of a politically constructed group illustrates the divergence between identity imposed by institutions and community actively built through shared experience. When researchers recruit through administrative ethnic labels, school attendance, residence, or platform participation, the sampling frame may organize people who do not recognize a common psychological community. Comparisons should record the mechanism of group assignment, the degree of voluntary participation, and relevant power relations. Qualitative accounts can reveal failures of measurement that are difficult to detect from total scores alone Sonn & Fisher (1996) Mannarini & Fedi (2009).
Research Design and the Interpretation of Community Scores
Cross-sectional studies efficiently estimate co-occurrence among perceived community connection, perceived support, participation, and well-being. Their main inferential limit is the uncertainty of causal ordering. Residents who experience belonging may become more engaged; participation may produce belonging; both may arise from favorable institutions, stable housing, prior friendships, or selective residence. The appropriate analysis uses a clear temporal framework, measures likely confounders, reports uncertainty, and avoids treating a statistically significant regression coefficient as proof of intervention efficacy. Studies of neighborhood participation have long demonstrated the value of jointly examining physical and social context Perkins et al. (1990) Chavis & Wandersman (1990).
Multilevel models are often appropriate because respondents share schools, blocks, organizations, or online spaces. Ignoring clustering can exaggerate precision, while aggregate neighborhood indicators can misrepresent individual experience when within-area variation is substantial. Investigators should distinguish the individual perception of community from a between-community characteristic inferred through aggregation. Aggregated ratings require adequate respondents per setting and evidence of within-setting agreement and between-setting variation. Sampling procedures should include people who are disconnected, dissatisfied, recently arrived, or excluded, rather than recruiting only active members at community events Perkins et al. (1990) Carpiano & Hystad (2011).
Longitudinal studies can assess within-person change and lagged associations, though they remain sensitive to unmeasured changing circumstances and attrition. Natural experiments and interventions potentially strengthen causal inference when assignment or exposure mechanisms are credible. Qualitative research is essential for identifying the content of a boundary, the meaning of mutual obligation, and the experience of recognition among those who reject official labels. A mature measurement program combines these designs and triangulates scale scores with behavioral participation, network changes, decision-making authority, and independently observed community conditions. Each source contributes a different type of evidence Mannarini & Fedi (2009) Nowell & Boyd (2010) Chavis & Wandersman (1990).
Neighborhood Relations and Local Social Organization
Neighborhood studies made psychological sense of community visible as a feature of everyday social organization. The relevant environment includes repeated encounters, mutual recognition, shared facilities, perceived safety, informal networks, and opportunities to act collectively. Buckner's work on neighborhood cohesion treated residential connectedness as an empirical construct associated with local ties, while Perkins and colleagues studied participation in relation to the social and physical environments of urban residential blocks. These investigations make clear that neighborhood community is experienced through interactions with actual settings and institutions, rather than deduced from an address or assumed from residence alone Buckner (1988) Perkins et al. (1990).
Cross-sectional neighborhood differences can arise through several processes. Street design, public meeting spaces, housing stability, neighborhood organizations, patterns of segregation, and exposure to crime may influence opportunities for familiarity. Residents may also select locations that fit their preferences and resources, or choose whether to participate in organizations after moving. Surveys administered to established association members therefore risk overestimating neighborhood connection. Longitudinal comparisons and representative residential sampling help distinguish community-level variation from selective involvement, although residential mobility, institutional restructuring, and changing survey participation remain important limitations Perkins et al. (1990) Long & Perkins (2003).
Perceived community itself can operate differently across residents living in the same block. A long-standing household, a tenant facing displacement, a recent migrant, and someone excluded by prevailing social norms may assign different meanings to local solidarity. Aggregated neighborhood cohesion can be informative for community development, but subgroup analysis is required when access to resources and voice is uneven. Objective conditions and lived evaluations should be measured separately; an observed association between neighborhood attachment and participation does not establish that participation resulted from attachment. The research object is the patterned relationship between people and their local ecology, with heterogeneity central to interpretation Chavis & Wandersman (1990) Townley et al. (2011).
Participation, Reciprocity, and Collective Action
Participation is one of the most important behavioral correlates of psychological sense of community. Chavis and Wandersman's account proposed that residents' sense of community may act as a catalyst for participation and local development. The word 'catalyst' describes a plausible process in which attachment and perceived influence increase willingness to contribute. However, residents who volunteer, attend meetings, or organize collective activities may acquire stronger bonds through those very experiences. Observational relationships cannot distinguish selection, reciprocal reinforcement, and unmeasured contextual causes without additional evidence Chavis & Wandersman (1990) Perkins et al. (1990).
Mutual influence helps explain why participating in a community is more than expressing an individual preference. In participatory settings, residents can see that other people recognize their efforts and that collective decisions remain responsive. Those experiences may connect social belonging to perceived efficacy, but the two constructs require separate indicators. A community can feel emotionally close while acting ineffectively on public problems; conversely, coordination can occur among people who share little intimacy. Research into collective efficacy and informal social control examines expectations of coordinated action, whereas psychological sense of community examines the experienced relationship to a collectivity. Their causal relations are empirical questions McMillan & Chavis (1986) Nowell & Boyd (2010).
Mannarini and Fedi examined how participants described community and its relation to civic and political participation, exposing considerable diversity in the meanings people attach to the term. This evidence helps explain why questionnaires administered with an unspecified referent may yield ambiguous findings. Volunteering can be motivated by obligation, solidarity, moral commitments, friendship, personal development, or instrumental benefit. Strong communal identification is one possible source of involvement, while institutional expectations and availability of opportunities may shape behavior independently. Research should therefore report both perceived community and actual forms of participation, identifying their temporal sequence whenever possible Mannarini & Fedi (2009) Chavis & Wandersman (1990).
Adolescent Development and School Communities
Adolescence is an instructive setting because communities change as young people move among families, peer groups, schools, neighborhoods, and online networks. Pretty, Andrewes, and Collett investigated the relationship between adolescents' sense of community and loneliness. This work established an early empirical basis for asking how young people's perceived attachment to social settings relates to their experience of isolation. Its observational designs warrant interpretations in terms of measured associations. Reduced loneliness may accompany stronger belonging, but personal circumstances, friendship formation, and the school environment can shape both experiences, and their temporal ordering remains to be established Pretty et al. (1994).
School-based community includes recognition by peers and educators, institutional fairness, participation opportunities, shared events, and collective identities. A student may feel close to classmates but excluded from school decision-making or, conversely, feel accepted by a school institution without having a supportive peer network. Distinguishing these levels avoids treating school belonging as a uniform perception. Developmental research benefits from repeated measures across transitions, especially school entry, changes of peer group, and movement between educational systems. Such designs can reveal whether a change in referent, rather than an underlying decline in social capacity, explains apparent changes in community feeling Pretty et al. (1994) McMillan & Chavis (1986).
The use of a community scale among adolescents must account for developmental language and the meaning of influence. A question about 'having a say in community decisions' may refer to school governance for some respondents and peer norms for others. Family status, disability, migration, and institutional rules can condition opportunities to participate independently of perceived attachment. For substantive cross-group comparisons, investigators need age-appropriate wording, cognitive interviewing, reliability assessments, and tests of measurement equivalence. Findings from adult neighborhood scale validation cannot automatically be transferred to school populations, and standardized scores should be interpreted alongside actual social participation Chipuer & Pretty (1999) Yu et al. (2022).
Well-Being, Loneliness, and Health Associations
Psychological sense of community is frequently investigated in relation to perceived support, subjective well-being, loneliness, and health. The proposed pathways include access to social resources, confidence that others will help, social recognition, and opportunities to contribute to a meaningful collective. These mechanisms can connect community experience to health-relevant environments, but the constructs and timescales are different. Loneliness concerns a discrepancy between desired and experienced relationships; a community score concerns a particular collectivity. Individuals can report many meaningful community memberships while remaining lonely in intimate life, or maintain a close personal relationship while feeling detached from their neighborhood Pretty et al. (1994) Carpiano & Hystad (2011).
Carpiano and Hystad analyzed the construct labeled 'sense of community belonging' in health survey contexts and questioned what aspect of social capital it actually captured. Their work emphasizes that an item used in epidemiological surveys may have different conceptual breadth from a multidimensional scale grounded in community psychology. The association of a belonging indicator with health should not automatically be interpreted as demonstrating the influence of network resources, reciprocal norms, or the McMillan–Chavis dimensions. Investigators should separate neighborhood-level exposure, individual perceived belonging, and health outcomes when specifying hypotheses and adjusting for structural conditions Carpiano & Hystad (2011).
Claims of a universally protective community experience require special caution. Social support may be unevenly distributed, intensive community involvement may impose obligations, and belonging to an exclusionary group can generate risks for outsiders. Psychological processes also change with chronic illness, mobility restrictions, discrimination, and loss of place. Studies that treat a high total score as equivalent to a healthy environment may overlook these mechanisms. The more useful research question identifies which forms of membership, influence, support, and emotional connection are associated with which outcomes, in which population, and through what temporal or causal process Townley et al. (2011) Nowell & Boyd (2010).
Negative Sense of Community and Adaptive Distance
Brodsky's 1996 qualitative research on resilient single mothers in risky neighborhoods gave a prominent account of negative psychological sense of community. In a hazardous or stigmatizing environment, maintaining distance from local norms and networks may form part of an adaptive protective strategy. The finding challenges any assumption that strong affiliation with every geographically assigned community is invariably beneficial. A respondent may reject a neighborhood as a source of identity while sustaining meaningful ties in family, friendship, occupational, or cultural networks. An unfavorable appraisal of one setting must be interpreted in relation to opportunities and constraints in that setting Brodsky (1996).
Negative psychological sense of community may involve distrust of prevailing norms, emotional distance, concern about personal security, or rejection of a socially imposed identity. Researchers should distinguish these experiences from simple low scores on a positive-belonging scale. A low average might indicate indifference, recent arrival, limited opportunity for involvement, or active distancing for self-protection. These conditions can have different behavioral implications. A measurement program should therefore study valence, reasons for distance, community alternatives, and structural threats, using open-ended interviews where preselected response items conceal motivations Brodsky (1996) Sonn & Fisher (1996).
The policy implication is to evaluate the quality and fairness of community conditions before treating greater attachment as an intervention goal. A neighborhood intervention that increases social pressure while leaving exclusion or insecurity intact may produce more formal engagement without producing an environment members experience as safe or meaningful. Equally, inviting formerly excluded residents into decision-making can change experienced recognition before it changes the number of friendships. Researchers need to distinguish positive connection, justified disidentification, and institutional opportunity. Brodsky's analysis remains a conceptual counterweight to community-development approaches that equate cohesion with benefit for every resident Brodsky (1996) Townley et al. (2011).
Power, Imposed Group Membership, and Historical Oppression
Power structures determine who can claim a community, who is treated as a legitimate member, and whose preferences shape its rules. Membership by administrative assignment is analytically different from freely cultivated affiliation. Sonn and Fisher's investigation of a politically constructed group showed how collective identity can be imposed through historical institutions while meaningful communal connections develop under very different social conditions. This distinction is essential for studies of racialized, migrant, displaced, and politically marginalized populations: the category used to recruit respondents must not be mistaken for the experience being measured Sonn & Fisher (1996).
A community may also distribute influence unequally. Longstanding residents can monopolize neighborhood decisions, senior members can define acceptable identities, and institutional authorities can describe compliance as cohesion. In these settings, a high collective average may coexist with the marginalization of people whose experiences differ from the dominant subgroup. Measuring personal recognition, voice, institutional access, and reasons for withdrawal helps identify these differences. Townley and colleagues argued that community psychology must consider the relation between sense of community, human diversity, and cultural relativity when advancing interventions; a uniform increase in cohesion is not automatically an equitable goal Townley et al. (2011) Nowell & Boyd (2010).
Historical oppression influences what emotional connection can mean. Common experiences of injustice can support solidarity, but histories also include conflict over representation, memory, and mutual obligations. The emotional narrative of a community need not be identical among all its members. Research must document which people are permitted to tell the group's story and which experiences are excluded. In qualitative inquiry, competing accounts are substantive evidence about community organization rather than measurement error. An analysis that treats an institutional label as a transparent description of belonging risks reinforcing the very power relations it seeks to understand Sonn & Fisher (1996) Mannarini & Fedi (2009).
Cultural Heterogeneity and the Ethics of Belonging
Community belonging presents a recurring tension between stability and diversity. Familiar expectations, shared norms, and common symbols can support mutual recognition, but the same expectations can penalize dissent or create barriers to newly arriving members. Townley and colleagues examined these issues through human diversity, cultural relativity, and sense of community, demonstrating that the social value of belonging depends in part on how a group handles difference. Communities can develop forms of solidarity that preserve plural perspectives, and researchers should assess inclusiveness, access, and procedural fairness alongside subjective attachment Townley et al. (2011).
The cultural meaning of obligation varies. In one context, helping an unfamiliar neighbor may be a normatively expected duty; in another, similar assistance may be understood as exceptional friendship or organized volunteering. A questionnaire measuring 'shared values' can confound normative agreement, respectful coexistence, and compelled conformity. Local interpretation matters when transferring instruments across national settings or comparing communities of different institutional structure. Mannarini and Fedi's interview study found multiple meanings of community, strengthening the case for mixed methods that examine participants' own language before imposing a standardized operational definition Mannarini & Fedi (2009) Yu et al. (2022).
An ethical research program also recognizes the legitimacy of distance. Membership boundaries can offer safety, while disengagement from an unsafe group can preserve agency. Brodsky's research on negative sense of community shows why interventions cannot treat universal affiliation as the preferred outcome. Researchers must distinguish community cohesion from democratic participation, reciprocity from coerced obligation, and consensus from exclusion. These distinctions are especially important when evaluations use satisfaction or belonging scores to judge programs serving people with unequal power. An effective community initiative may improve fair access or safety before it changes mean perceived attachment Brodsky (1996) Townley et al. (2011).
Communities of Interest and Multiple Affiliations
Territorial proximity is one route to repeated interaction, not an exhaustive definition of community. Obst, Zinkiewicz, and Smith examined science fiction fandom as an international community of interest, extending psychological sense of community research to groups organized around shared practices and meanings rather than common residence. Such communities may support sustained mutual recognition even when members rarely meet physically. This evidence establishes the importance of specifying the referent and mode of interaction; it does not imply that a global fandom and a residential block have equivalent governance, resource access, or social obligations Obst et al. (2002) McMillan & Chavis (1986).
Multiple memberships can distribute psychological needs across distinct settings. A person may seek practical help locally, intellectual recognition in a professional network, emotional safety in a small friendship group, and participatory voice in a civic association. These functions can overlap, but the strongest sense of community may attach to only one of these networks. Researchers who ask about 'my community' without defining it risk pooling respondents who are evaluating different targets. Multiple-referent designs can instead ask participants to name their salient communities and rate each separately, allowing analyses of complementarity, conflict, and changes in affiliation Obst et al. (2002) Mannarini & Fedi (2009).
Organizational and territorial boundaries may also intersect. A local sports club, workplace, or volunteer group can supply membership and emotional connection within a neighborhood while excluding other residents. The causal influence of the club on neighborhood attachment is therefore a distinct hypothesis: members may already have strong local ties, or the organization may create new encounters that broaden them. Studying such processes requires measures of prior affiliation, institutional openness, actual participation, and evolving networks. The four-element theory can guide predictions, while the community-of-interest literature prevents residential geography from becoming a hidden assumption Obst et al. (2002) Perkins et al. (1990).
Online Community and Mediated Social Presence
Digital environments create opportunities for repeated interaction without permanent physical proximity. Blanchard and Markus analyzed the experienced sense of a virtual community and the characteristics and processes that supported it. Their work provides a foundation for studying interpersonal recognition, identity, informational exchange, and interaction histories in mediated settings. A community that exists through an online forum or platform can be experienced as meaningful when participants build recognizable relationships and expectations. However, membership counts, message volume, and platform engagement are operational indicators of activity, not direct evidence of psychological sense of community Blanchard & Markus (2004).
Digital community boundaries are shaped by platform design. Moderation practices, identity persistence, recommendation systems, visibility rules, and access restrictions affect who encounters whom and how influence is distributed. These features may change the opportunities for emotional connection, but their psychological impact requires direct study rather than inference from technical affordances alone. A useful design combines a carefully specified community referent with self-reported recognition, perceived influence, interaction histories, and evidence of governance procedures. The research questions concern the relationship between mediated architecture and lived community experience, including why two spaces with similar traffic can be perceived very differently Blanchard & Markus (2004) Nowell & Boyd (2010).
Online participation can be geographically dispersed, intermittent, pseudonymous, or layered across services. Members may carry recognizable identities and relationships from one forum to another, while administrators retain the power to remove access or change rules. Accordingly, stability and continuity should be measured at the level of relationships and practices, not inferred from the survival of a platform name. Community-of-interest research and virtual-community studies suggest a broader research program that examines how belonging is maintained through repeated mediated interaction and how disruption, moderation, or migration changes that experience. A 2024 scoping review by Lardier and colleagues screened literature on virtual communities of practice in education and health fields, identifying thirteen included articles and persistent measurement gaps. Its scope concerns professional communities of practice, so its findings refine rather than replace evidence from informal social or fandom communities. These remain setting-dependent questions requiring longitudinal evidence Obst et al. (2002) Blanchard & Markus (2004) Lardier et al. (2024).
Institutional Communities, Responsibility, and Obligation
Schools, workplaces, associations, and public institutions can generate community through repeated roles and shared expectations. These environments provide opportunities for influence, but they also create formal hierarchies, duties, and uneven access to decisions. The four-element PSOC framework addresses membership, need fulfillment, influence, and connection, while the responsibility perspective broadens attention to the obligations individuals perceive toward a collective. Nowell and Boyd argued that community may be experienced as a responsibility as well as a resource. This theoretical distinction offers testable predictions about participation motivated by collective duty even when personal benefits are modest Nowell & Boyd (2010).
Responsibility should not be conflated with compulsory conformity. A person can care deeply about institutional welfare while criticizing leadership or refusing an unfair demand. Organizational engagement can also be strategic rather than affectionate: members may contribute to shared goals out of professional commitments or moral principles without high emotional identification. A measurement approach that captures only need satisfaction could underestimate such forms of involvement. Future work should evaluate whether responsibility-based measures predict behaviors beyond resource-based PSOC measures after adjusting for role requirements, political opportunity, and prior participation Nowell & Boyd (2010) Peterson et al. (2008).
The distinction between experienced community and institutional performance matters for practical evaluation. An organization may score highly on perceived fellowship while restricting minority voices; another may provide effective avenues for participation despite limited social intimacy. Investigators should therefore combine psychological measures with independent indicators of representation, service provision, fairness, and participation outcomes. The analytical goal is to explain how particular institutional arrangements support or constrain meaningful community experience and collective responsibility. That question preserves community psychology's ecological orientation and yields interventions more specific than general campaigns to increase belonging Townley et al. (2011) Chavis & Wandersman (1990).
Longitudinal Change and Causal Identification
A causal study of psychological sense of community begins by specifying which relationship is expected to change. An investigator may hypothesize that increased voice produces stronger belonging, that shared emotional connection increases participation, or that participation produces stronger emotional connection. These hypotheses involve different temporal sequences and interventions. A cross-sectional association between a community score and a participation indicator cannot decide among them. The neighborhood research tradition demonstrates the value of measuring social environments and resident conduct together, while also exposing the risk of selection: more engaged people can report stronger ties because they were already attracted to the setting Perkins et al. (1990) Chavis & Wandersman (1990).
Longitudinal panels improve the situation when they observe participants before and after relevant institutional or personal changes. Repeated measures should assess the same specified community, record membership transitions, and separate changes within people from compositional changes in a neighborhood or organization. Attrition and moving away are particularly consequential because those who withdraw may have lower community attachment or experience exclusion. Cross-lagged regression, fixed-effects approaches, and multilevel longitudinal analyses may help answer targeted questions, but each depends on assumptions about unmeasured confounding, timing, measurement stability, and the distinction between individual and community-level effects Long & Perkins (2003) Carpiano & Hystad (2011).
Stronger designs can take advantage of credible changes to institutional representation, access to meeting spaces, participation procedures, or other community conditions. Randomized interventions, when ethically and practically feasible, can distinguish an assigned opportunity to participate from self-selected attendance; natural experiments can sometimes exploit exogenous institutional changes. The outcome must remain explicit. Increased meeting attendance, improved social support, and increased perceived belonging are different dependent variables. A finding about one may support a mechanism but does not establish that the full psychological construct changed. Qualitative follow-up can help interpret why an intervention had heterogeneous effects Nowell & Boyd (2010) Townley et al. (2011).
Intervention Research and Community Design
Community interventions often seek to expand participation, improve access to shared resources, and create occasions for meaningful interaction. The four-element framework generates distinct intervention targets: facilitate recognition and membership; widen reciprocal voice; make beneficial resources reliably available; and support valued shared experiences. Each proposed mechanism requires its own observable indicators. For example, offering residents a genuine decision-making role is a more specific manipulation of perceived influence than a generic campaign announcing that neighborhood spirit is important. Intervention theory should identify how the changed opportunity is expected to be experienced and by whom McMillan & Chavis (1986) Chavis & Wandersman (1990).
Designing for stronger attachment without attending to institutional power can reinforce exclusion. If meetings are inaccessible to caregivers, tenants, people with disabilities, or linguistic minorities, an intervention may increase the participation of already influential residents while widening social differences. Townley and colleagues' diversity analysis supports evaluating fair inclusion and heterogeneity as outcomes alongside community attachment. Similarly, Brodsky's work warns that strengthening identification with a dangerous setting is an inappropriate universal objective. Improved personal safety or legitimate disengagement may be an important beneficial outcome even when average neighborhood PSOC stays unchanged Townley et al. (2011) Brodsky (1996).
Evaluation should therefore include baseline measures, clear eligibility criteria, appropriate comparisons, reliable instruments, follow-up intervals, and assessment of adverse or inequitable effects. When random assignment is unavailable, evaluators can articulate plausible rival explanations and use observational designs that test them. Combining psychometric indicators with participation records, institutional responsiveness, and qualitative evidence strengthens the interpretation of changes. Reports should describe the actual intervention and the community referent rather than using 'community building' as an undifferentiated mechanism. The evidence base warrants targeted theory-driven experimentation and careful reporting of uncertainty Peterson et al. (2008) Nowell & Boyd (2010).
Critical Evidence Appraisal and Theoretical Tensions
The field's foundational advantage is a coherent account of experienced membership, influence, needs, and emotional connection. Its persistent difficulty is that the theoretical breadth of these concepts exceeds the resolution of many short scales. Chipuer and Pretty's review and Long and Perkins' confirmatory analyses showed that presumed factor structures cannot simply be read from the conceptual model. Peterson and colleagues later provided favorable validation evidence for another instrument, and the Japanese adaptation supplied additional local psychometric support. These findings are compatible when interpreted as results concerning different measures, populations, and specifications. They do not constitute a universal factorial verdict Chipuer & Pretty (1999) Long & Perkins (2003) Peterson et al. (2008) Yu et al. (2022).
A second difficulty is the coexistence of beneficial belonging and potentially harmful boundaries. Common identity can support recognition and shared help, yet it can coexist with status hierarchy, coerced conformity, or hostility toward outsiders. Negative PSOC may be adaptive under dangerous conditions. Studies focused only on community means or correlations with generic well-being can miss these patterns. The field needs models that represent variation within a collectivity, distinguish positive and negative relationships, and test whether communal obligations are willingly accepted or enforced through exclusion. Cultural and political histories alter the meaning of membership, and their effects should be observed rather than assumed away Brodsky (1996) Sonn & Fisher (1996) Townley et al. (2011).
A third problem concerns causal inference and transportability. A neighborhood study may identify a relationship between cohesion and local participation without establishing whether the same relationship holds in a dispersed online group, an authoritarian institution, or a newly assembled volunteer network. Sampling frames, measurement referents, exposure opportunities, and institutional constraints all change. Multiple methods are therefore complementary: psychometrics examines score meaning, ethnography examines lived interpretation, panel research examines within-person development, and intervention designs test particular mechanisms. The scientifically defensible synthesis is a conditional, context-sensitive account rather than an assertion that community connection has one uniform cause or consequence Carpiano & Hystad (2011) Blanchard & Markus (2004) Mannarini & Fedi (2009).
Research Frontiers in the Artificial Era
Digital mediation raises questions about how communities persist when communication, identity continuity, and governance are distributed across platforms and technical systems. Existing work on virtual communities demonstrates that social connection can develop through mediated interactions, and communities of interest research shows that geographic co-residence is not required. The next analytical task is to identify which aspects of platform architecture are consequential for recognition, reciprocal influence, trust, and shared history. These mechanisms should be investigated through human reports, observable interactions, and organizational evidence. Technical interaction frequency alone cannot establish psychological connection Blanchard & Markus (2004) Obst et al. (2002).
Artificial systems introduce further research questions in the Artificial Era. Automated moderation, recommendation, conversational agents, and artificial collaborators may alter opportunities for human participation and interpretations of belonging. Their effects may include continuity of interactions, reshaping of norms, redistribution of attention, and altered perceptions of social presence. These are empirically testable hypotheses about human–Artificial relations. Applying an individual human PSOC scale directly to an artificial system would require independent justification of the measured construct and its observable indicators; the existing human community literature offers no direct warrant for treating machine-generated reports as equivalent to human experience. Separating structural operation, expressed self-description, and experimentally observed social effects is essential Nowell & Boyd (2010) Blanchard & Markus (2004).
Future research should address longitudinal changes when communities migrate across platforms, when members interact with both people and artificial agents, and when governance decisions are partly automated. Appropriate methods include carefully controlled participation experiments, network analysis, audit of system decisions, and interviews documenting recognition, trust, and exclusion among human participants. The same ethical principles apply: identify whose sense of community is measured, who can influence collective rules, and who bears the costs of membership boundaries. Artificial Era research expands the situations in which community experience can be studied while preserving the need for verifiable constructs and transparent causal claims Townley et al. (2011) Nowell & Boyd (2010).
Conclusion
Psychological sense of community is a scientifically important relationship between a person and a meaningful, specified collectivity. The McMillan–Chavis framework organizes the construct through membership, reciprocal influence, fulfillment of needs, and shared emotional connection. A half century of conceptual development, measurement work, field research, and cultural analysis shows the value of this organization while also demonstrating that no questionnaire or single communal setting exhausts it. The relevant scientific object is the experience of community in particular social conditions, with explicit attention to the identity and boundaries of the community being evaluated McMillan & Chavis (1986) Long & Perkins (2003).
Empirical findings establish that community experience can be measured and is related to participation, social connections, loneliness, and other context-dependent outcomes. They also establish important limitations: factor structures differ across instruments, sampling and causal ordering can be uncertain, and the social value of belonging varies across settings and members. Qualitative studies of politically imposed membership, diverse interpretations, and adaptive negative sense of community provide essential corrections to accounts focused exclusively on average positive attachment. A serious theoretical synthesis must therefore include cultural context, power, and the legitimate possibility of disengagement Brodsky (1996) Sonn & Fisher (1996) Townley et al. (2011).
The next research program is methodologically integrated. It defines the referent, establishes measurement validity within the population, distinguishes perceived connection from institutional and behavioral properties, and uses longitudinal or intervention evidence for causal questions. It examines membership alongside responsibility, voice, equality, and collective opportunity. These principles apply to residential, organizational, cultural, and mediated communities and provide a foundation for investigating emerging human–Artificial social environments. Psychological sense of community remains a dynamic, empirically investigable form of social life whose interpretation depends on what the community is, how it is constituted, and whose experience is counted Nowell & Boyd (2010) Peterson et al. (2008).
References
- Blanchard, A. L., & Markus, M. L. (2004). The experienced “sense” of a virtual community: Characteristics and processes. ACM SIGMIS Database, 35(1), 64–79. https://doi.org/10.1145/968464.968470
- Brodsky, A. E. (1996). Resilient single mothers in risky neighborhoods: Negative psychological sense of community. Journal of Community Psychology, 24(4), 347–363. https://doi.org/10.1002/%28SICI%291520-6629%28199610%2924%3A4%3C347%3A%3AAID-JCOP5%3E3.0.CO%3B2-R
- Buckner, J. C. (1988). The development of an instrument to measure neighborhood cohesion. American Journal of Community Psychology, 16(6), 771–791. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00930892
- Carpiano, R. M., & Hystad, P. W. (2011). “Sense of community belonging” in health surveys: What social capital is it measuring? Health & Place, 17(2), 606–617. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.healthplace.2010.12.018
- Chavis, D. M., Hogge, J. H., McMillan, D. W., & Wandersman, A. (1986). Sense of community through Brunswik’s lens: A first look. Journal of Community Psychology, 14(1), 24–40. https://doi.org/10.1002/1520-6629%28198601%2914%3A1%3C24%3A%3AAID-JCOP2290140104%3E3.0.CO%3B2-P
- Chavis, D. M., & Wandersman, A. (1990). Sense of community in the urban environment: A catalyst for participation and community development. American Journal of Community Psychology, 18(1), 55–81. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00922689
- Chipuer, H. M., & Pretty, G. M. H. (1999). A review of the sense of community index: Current uses, factor structure, reliability, and further development. Journal of Community Psychology, 27(6), 643–658. https://doi.org/10.1002/%28SICI%291520-6629%28199911%2927%3A6%3C643%3A%3AAID-JCOP2%3E3.0.CO%3B2-B
- Community Science. (n.d.). About the Sense of Community Index. https://senseofcommunity.com/soc-index/
- Lardier, D. T., Jr., Dickson, E. L., Hackett, J. M., & Verdezoto, C. S. (2024). A scoping review of existing research between 1990 and 2023: Measuring virtual communities of practice across disciplines. Journal of Community Psychology, 52(1), 198–225. https://doi.org/10.1002/jcop.23092
- Long, D. A., & Perkins, D. D. (2003). Confirmatory factor analysis of the Sense of Community Index and development of a Brief SCI. Journal of Community Psychology, 31(3), 279–296. https://doi.org/10.1002/jcop.10046
- Mannarini, T., & Fedi, A. (2009). Multiple senses of community: The experience and meaning of community. Journal of Community Psychology, 37(2), 211–227. https://doi.org/10.1002/jcop.20289
- McMillan, D. W., & Chavis, D. M. (1986). Sense of community: A definition and theory. Journal of Community Psychology, 14(1), 6–23. https://doi.org/10.1002/1520-6629%28198601%2914%3A1%3C6%3A%3AAID-JCOP2290140103%3E3.0.CO%3B2-I
- McMillan, D. W. (1996). Sense of community. Journal of Community Psychology, 24(4), 315–325. https://doi.org/10.1002/%28SICI%291520-6629%28199610%2924%3A4%3C315%3A%3AAID-JCOP2%3E3.0.CO%3B2-T
- Nowell, B., & Boyd, N. (2010). Viewing community as responsibility as well as resource: Deconstructing the theoretical roots of psychological sense of community. Journal of Community Psychology, 38(7), 828–841. https://doi.org/10.1002/jcop.20398
- Obst, P., Zinkiewicz, L., & Smith, S. G. (2002). Sense of community in science fiction fandom, Part 1: Understanding sense of community in an international community of interest. Journal of Community Psychology, 30(1), 87–103. https://doi.org/10.1002/jcop.1052
- Perkins, D. D., Florin, P., Rich, R. C., Wandersman, A., & Chavis, D. M. (1990). Participation and the social and physical environment of residential blocks: Crime and community context. American Journal of Community Psychology, 18(1), 83–115. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00922690
- Peterson, N. A., Speer, P. W., & McMillan, D. W. (2008). Validation of a brief sense of community scale: Confirmation of the principal theory of sense of community. Journal of Community Psychology, 36(1), 61–73. https://doi.org/10.1002/jcop.20217
- Pretty, G. M. H., Andrewes, L., & Collett, C. (1994). Exploring adolescents’ sense of community and its relationship to loneliness. Journal of Community Psychology, 22(4), 346–358. https://doi.org/10.1002/1520-6629%28199410%2922%3A4%3C346%3A%3AAID-JCOP2290220407%3E3.0.CO%3B2-J
- Sarason, S. B. (1974). The psychological sense of community: Prospects for a community psychology. Jossey-Bass. https://openlibrary.org/books/OL5426369M/The_psychological_sense_of_community
- Sonn, C. C., & Fisher, A. T. (1996). Psychological sense of community in a politically constructed group. Journal of Community Psychology, 24(4), 417–430. https://doi.org/10.1002/%28SICI%291520-6629%28199610%2924%3A4%3C417%3A%3AAID-JCOP9%3E3.0.CO%3B2-Q
- Townley, G., Kloos, B., Green, E. P., & Franco, M. M. (2011). Reconcilable differences? Human diversity, cultural relativity, and sense of community. American Journal of Community Psychology, 47(1–2), 69–85. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10464-010-9379-9
- Yu, K.-R., Asai, K., Hiraizumi, T., & Wakashima, K. (2022). Japanese version of the Brief Sense of Community Scale: Construct validity and reliability. BMC Psychology, 10, Article 301. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40359-022-01017-x