Psychology by BogdanovaThe Encyclopedia of Psychology for the Artificial Era

RESEARCH DOSSIER

Psychological Responses to Sport Injury and Return-to-Sport Readiness

Abstract. Sport injury can alter emotional experience, athletic identity, motivation, perceived competence, and the perceived risks of returning to competition. This fundamental research monograph examines the historical and conceptual foundations of injury-response psychology; integrated appraisal models; self-efficacy and self-determination; fear of reinjury; psychological measurement and clinical assessment; original longitudinal and experimental research; and the distinction between returning to participation, sport, and performance. Particular attention is given to the ACL Return to Sport after Injury scale and to systematic reviews assessing return outcomes and psychological-readiness trajectories. Evidence from ACL reconstruction is evaluated alongside concussion, recurrent injury, youth, elite, community, and Para sport contexts. Critical analysis distinguishes psychometric validity, prospective association, causal intervention evidence, and the injury-specific criteria required for clinical clearance. The synthesis identifies substantial heterogeneity and weaknesses in prognostic evidence, proposes priorities for rigorous trials and longer follow-up, and emphasizes autonomous athlete choice, safe sustainable participation, and ethically governed monitoring. This work is a critical narrative scientific synthesis, not an original clinical trial or a registered systematic review.

Keywords: sport injury psychology; psychological readiness; return to sport; return-to-sport decision; sport injury rehabilitation; fear of reinjury; ACL-RSI; anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction; self-efficacy; self-determination theory; athletic identity; coping; psychological interventions; concussion; sports medicine; rehabilitation adherence; sport participation; clinical decision-making

Scientific Overview and Research Questions

Psychological responses to sport injury comprise the changing appraisals, emotions, motivations, beliefs, actions, and interpersonal experiences that follow an injury capable of disrupting athletic participation. Return-to-sport readiness concerns an athlete's perceived and demonstrated capacity to resume chosen sporting activities under their particular physical, psychological, and social demands. These constructs are consequential throughout rehabilitation: an athlete may regain isolated physical capacities while remaining apprehensive about a cutting maneuver, contact with an opponent, the expectations of a coach, or renewed loss of identity. Conversely, enthusiasm to compete may coexist with inadequate tissue recovery, persistent symptoms, or unsafe exposure. The scientific object is therefore a time-dependent adjustment and decision process embedded in an injury, a sporting task, and a social environment. An influential integrated account places personal and situational factors upstream of cognitive appraisals and subsequent emotional and behavioral responses. Wiese-Bjornstal et al. (1998) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

This monograph asks how injured athletes interpret events; which processes shape adherence, distress, confidence, fear, and hope; how these responses change before, during, and after return; what psychometric measures capture; whether readiness predicts participation, performance, and recurrent injury; and what experimental evidence supports psychological assistance. It compares theories of stress appraisal, self-efficacy, self-determination, athletic identity, and risk perception with cohort studies, instrument-validation research, intervention trials, systematic reviews, and clinical consensus statements. The best-developed measurement and longitudinal evidence concerns anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury and reconstruction. That concentration is itself a major limitation when conclusions are transferred to concussions, stress fractures, hamstring strains, chronic tendon problems, disability sport, and different levels of competition. Webster et al. (2008) Sell et al. (2024) van Haren et al. (2025)

The method is a structured critical narrative synthesis organized by the inferential questions posed by each source. Original studies are examined for design, setting, measurement, follow-up, and alternative explanations; systematic reviews are used to identify broader patterns and weaknesses; consensus guidance is interpreted as expert synthesis rather than a substitute for intervention evidence. No original participant study, prespecified exhaustive systematic search, or independent meta-analysis was conducted for this monograph. Psychological readiness is treated as a multidimensional, context-dependent construct whose clinical interpretation must remain integrated with sport medicine, physical rehabilitation, athlete preferences, and safeguarding. The 2024 expert consensus divides sport-injury psychology into injury risk, rehabilitation, and return to sport, a useful organizing continuity for evaluating this literature. Tranaeus et al. (2024) Ardern et al. (2016)

Definitions, Research Boundaries, and Outcome Distinctions

An injury is a health event or developing condition that alters participation, causes symptoms, or requires modification of loading and activity; injury definition must specify the relevant surveillance or clinical criteria. Psychological response refers to observable or reported changes in appraisal, affect, intention, regulation, conduct, and relationships temporally associated with that event. Psychological readiness refers more narrowly to perceived emotional and cognitive preparedness to meet the anticipated demands of sport. Return to participation, return to sport, and return to performance describe distinct milestones. The Bern consensus specifies that an athlete may first resume modified activities, subsequently participate in their sport, and only later reach or exceed prior performance; a single binary returned/not-returned variable erases these differences. Ardern et al. (2016)

Researchers frequently combine divergent outcomes under the abbreviation RTS. Resuming training, completing a competitive match, recovering preinjury competitive level, continuing participation for a subsequent season, and avoiding reinjury require different observation windows and denominators. The ACL reconstruction meta-analysis by Ardern and colleagues found substantially different proportions for any sport, preinjury-level sport, and competitive sport, illustrating how the answer changes with the operational definition. An athlete may elect a lower-risk sport and remain satisfied with the choice, even when a study records failure to return to the previous sport. Personal preference, access, employment, family priorities, and changing goals must accompany performance outcomes when interpreting psychological adaptation. Ardern et al. (2011) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

Readiness must also be separated from symptom severity, clinical diagnostic status, exercise adherence, fear of reinjury, athletic identity, objective performance capacity, and the medical authorization to resume activity. These domains interact but are not interchangeable. A high questionnaire score represents an answer to a specific set of items at a specific time; it is not evidence that a reconstructed ligament, symptomatic brain, or recovering muscle is safe for a given exposure. Likewise, low readiness may reflect realistic recognition of an unresolved problem rather than psychopathology. A useful empirical framework therefore records the injury and treatment context, objective task demands, the athlete's goals, subjective readiness, actual sporting exposure, subsequent well-being, and adverse outcomes as distinct variables. Webster et al. (2008) Ardern et al. (2016) van Haren et al. (2025)

Historical Development of Sport-Injury Psychology

The psychological study of injured athletes emerged within sports medicine, health psychology, rehabilitation research, and applied sport psychology. Earlier injury management tended to foreground biological healing and physical function, while accounts of athlete experience increasingly addressed disruption, stress, identity, social context, and behavioral engagement in rehabilitation. Stress-and-coping research supplied tools for understanding why objectively similar events produce varied meanings and responses. Lazarus and Folkman's transactional account, published in 1984, conceptualized stress through assessments of demand and resources, allowing injury to be studied as an encounter whose significance changes over time. In subsequent sport-injury applications, these appraisals became central to explaining fear, perceived loss, motivation, and coping. Lazarus & Folkman (1984) Wiese-Bjornstal et al. (1998)

Wiese-Bjornstal, Smith, Shaffer, and Morrey's 1998 integrated model brought cognitive appraisal, emotion, and behavior into one dynamic conceptual scheme while explicitly incorporating personal and situational moderators. It challenged the assumption that all injured athletes follow a mandatory fixed sequence of grief-like reactions. The model remains historically influential because it formulates interaction among prior injury history, social position, sporting expectations, appraisal, emotional experience, and behavioral rehabilitation responses. Yet a broad integrative model is an explanatory architecture, not proof of a single causal chain. Its components require longitudinal tests with clearly measured timing and plausible controls for severity, prior mental health, and training environment. Wiese-Bjornstal et al. (1998)

Research then developed measurement instruments and prospective outcome studies around return decisions. Webster, Feller, and Lambros introduced the ACL Return to Sport after Injury scale in 2008 to evaluate psychological impact following reconstruction; subsequent work examined a shorter version and broader validation. Ardern and colleagues' 2011 synthesis brought attention to the gap between surgical reconstruction and sporting restoration, while their 2013 prospective analysis examined psychological associations with actual return. Consensus initiatives reframed RTS as a graduated process, and the 2024 injury-psychology consensus integrated decades of work into recommendations across prevention, rehabilitation, and return. Contemporary scholarship is increasingly concerned with measurement bias, the strength of prognostic inference, and the limits of ACL-dominated evidence. Webster et al. (2008) Ardern et al. (2011) Ardern et al. (2013; cohort) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

The Integrated Psychological Response Model

In the integrated model, individual characteristics and situational influences shape the evaluation of an injury and the resulting patterns of emotion and behavior. Relevant individual variables include previous injuries, coping experience, perceived competence, sporting commitments, and beliefs concerning recovery. Situational variables include injury severity, access to health care, role in a team, economic dependence on performance, pressures surrounding selection, and rehabilitation relationships. An athlete's response to a setback is therefore intelligible only with reference to what that setback threatens or makes possible in the athlete's particular context. This principle supports contextual assessment rather than reliance on isolated trait scores. Wiese-Bjornstal et al. (1998) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

The central dynamic is reciprocal. Pain and reduced function may alter appraisal; appraisal can shape attention, sleep, affect, rehabilitation effort, and communication; these behaviors may influence perceived progress and subsequently revise appraisal. A clinician's explanation, the appearance of swelling, a first successful jump, or a teammate's reaction may change threat appraisal within a single day. Such recurrence explains why average readiness trajectories do not describe every athlete and why a questionnaire administered at one rehabilitation milestone is an incomplete account. A study that measures distress only after participants have resumed sport also risks reversing the direction of explanation: successful participation may increase confidence as much as prior confidence facilitates return. Wiese-Bjornstal et al. (1998) Sell et al. (2024)

The model is most useful when translated into testable predictions. Investigators can repeatedly assess injury-related beliefs and affect, measure task-specific exposure and physical recovery independently, record therapeutic and coaching contexts, and estimate within-person lagged relations. The strongest designs separate between-athlete differences from changes occurring within the same athlete and distinguish a predictor measured before the decision from a retrospective explanation collected afterward. The historical model provides conceptually grounded candidate variables, while credible conclusions about intervention mechanisms require manipulation, comparison conditions, adequate follow-up, and sensitivity analyses for confounding. Tranaeus et al. (2024) van Haren et al. (2025)

Stress Appraisal, Threat, and Injury Meaning

Primary appraisal concerns the significance of the injury for personally important goals; secondary appraisal concerns perceived ability and resources to respond. Loss of a championship opportunity, uncertainty over scholarship eligibility, concern about the ability to work, and interruption of an emotionally sustaining routine can each make an identical diagnosis psychologically different. Acute pain, injury uncertainty, and communication from clinicians may amplify or attenuate appraised threat. Appraisal changes with evidence of healing, complications, new goals, and experiences during graded activity. Transactional theory makes these interpretations legitimate research variables without assuming that the interpretation alone determines biological recovery. Lazarus & Folkman (1984) Wiese-Bjornstal et al. (1998)

Threat can concern bodily integrity, professional livelihood, identity, relationships, or public evaluation. Prospective loss matters particularly when the athlete sees the injury as jeopardizing team selection or a narrow competition window. Fear of reinjury is often operationalized as concern about another injury during demanding movement, while generalized anxiety and depressive symptoms have broader diagnostic and temporal meanings. A protective response to medically unsafe movement may be adaptive; generalized avoidance after adequate physical recovery may constrain valued participation. The distinction depends on clinical examination, actual task demands, risk information, and the athlete's expressed goals. Ardern et al. (2016) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

Research on appraisal faces an important inference problem: perceived threat and objective severity are correlated through symptoms, function, and professional advice. A severe injury may prolong absence from sport while simultaneously increasing fear, thereby creating a statistical association between fear and nonreturn that does not uniquely identify fear as a cause. Time-varying exposure to rehabilitation, prior injury history, access to treatment, and social demands can create additional confounding. Longitudinal models, prospective measurement before decisions, and carefully defined interventions are needed to distinguish the direct influence of appraisal from the influence of the injury itself. Ardern et al. (2013; cohort) van Haren et al. (2025)

Emotional Trajectories Across Rehabilitation

Sport injury may be accompanied by sadness, anger, grief, relief, uncertainty, frustration, determination, pride, fear, loneliness, or changing mixtures of these experiences. The pattern often shifts around diagnosis, surgery or initial treatment, early loading, first high-demand movement, clearance, and actual return to competition. Neither the intensity nor the timing of these experiences can be presumed from an injury label. The integrated response account and the later consensus describe such reactions as changing in relation to appraisal and environment, rather than a required sequence of universal stages. Persistent severe distress warrants qualified assessment, while ordinary fluctuations may remain compatible with sustained rehabilitation. Wiese-Bjornstal et al. (1998) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

A period of apparently positive affect may express confidence, relief at obtaining a diagnosis, or a strategic effort to maintain hope. It may also coexist with unresolved fear that becomes visible only during contact, sprinting, or other sport-specific activity. Researchers should differentiate transient state emotion, sustained mood, clinically significant symptoms, and the athlete's functional conduct. Self-reports from a single clinic visit miss changes occurring when athletes face actual sporting cues. Qualitative longitudinal work by Podlog and Eklund illustrates that returning athletes negotiate psychological demands through lived participation, changing expectations, and relationships beyond the rehabilitation room. Podlog & Eklund (2006) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

The emotional consequences of a return decision can extend beyond the first game. Continued playing below a former standard, reluctance to attempt a particular movement, or renewed symptoms may reopen doubts about competence and belonging. Conversely, choosing to reduce participation, change sports, or retire may represent deliberate preference revision rather than a failed psychological recovery. Studies that equate well-being with return frequency obscure these distinctions. Meaningful outcomes include distress, quality of life, perceived autonomy, participation satisfaction, safe exposure, and sustainable sporting engagement, observed across sufficiently long follow-up periods. Ardern et al. (2016) Podlog & Eklund (2010)

Fear of Reinjury, Movement Avoidance, and Risk Appraisal

Fear of reinjury is an anticipated negative outcome associated with a particular sporting situation, movement, symptom, or exposure. It may involve catastrophic expectations about tissue failure, attention to bodily cues, avoidance of specific tasks, or reluctance to enter competition. The concept overlaps with kinesiophobia and fear-avoidance ideas developed in pain psychology, but sport imposes distinct physical and social contingencies: a collision, unanticipated pivot, competitive fatigue, or rapidly changing playing surface may expose an athlete to risks that are absent in a controlled rehabilitation session. Readiness assessment should identify which anticipated scenarios concern the athlete and whether those concerns correspond to clinically meaningful hazards. Tranaeus et al. (2024) Ardern et al. (2016)

Fear may influence behavioral exposure by discouraging rehabilitation movements and competitive attempts, and participation experiences may reciprocally influence fear. This feedback relationship complicates inference from cross-sectional associations. In ACL research, measures of emotional responses and reinjury risk appraisal form part of the ACL-RSI construct. Such scores may predict who ultimately returns, yet that association also reflects individual injury severity, physical capacity, social support, and opportunities to play. It remains inappropriate to turn a population-level threshold into a guarantee about individual tissue integrity or reinjury prevention. Webster et al. (2008) van Haren et al. (2025)

Clinically meaningful distinctions include willingness to encounter ordinary uncertainty, accurate appreciation of exceptional hazards, and persistent avoidance of tasks after adequate physical preparation. An athlete asking for additional graded practice may be engaging in effective self-management; the same athlete can experience harmful pressure if confidence-building is mistaken for an obligation to accept exposure. Shared decision-making requires clear injury-specific information, consent, and opportunities to revise the plan. Psychological support can explore anticipated consequences and build coping strategies while the sports medicine team independently evaluates physical progression. Tranaeus et al. (2024) Ardern et al. (2016)

Self-Efficacy, Confidence, and Perceived Competence

Self-efficacy refers to a person's belief in their capacity to perform actions required for a particular situation. In injury rehabilitation, the relevant action may be completing prescribed exercises, tolerating graded running, executing a change of direction, or participating under competitive pressure. Confidence should therefore be measured at a task-specific level rather than inferred from broad assertions that an athlete is mentally strong. Bandura's account emphasized mastery experiences, vicarious learning, social persuasion, and interpretations of physiological information as sources of efficacy beliefs; injury care can influence each source through supervised success, communication, and progressive exposure. Bandura (1977) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

Readiness and efficacy are related but conceptually distinct. A person may believe they can perform a jump while feeling emotionally unprepared to endure the consequences of possible reinjury. Another may feel eager to return while overestimating their current technical capability. Perceived confidence can be influenced by pain fluctuations, exercise performance, comparisons with teammates, and uncertainty concerning clearance criteria. The ACL-RSI explicitly assesses confidence among other domains, whereas objective strength and movement tests address related but different constructs. Their combination enables a richer description of return decisions than either source alone. Webster et al. (2008) Ardern et al. (2016)

Self-efficacy research demands careful attention to directionality and calibration. A participant reporting greater confidence after a successful return may show an outcome of participation, not merely a cause of it. An intervention that increases confidence without improving physical capacity might create discrepancies requiring management rather than automatic benefit. Investigators can improve inference by assessing efficacy before a standardized task, documenting task success and symptoms, and examining how updates to confidence correspond to actual performance. The desirable clinical objective is informed, situation-specific competence with realistic risk appraisal. Bandura (1977) van Haren et al. (2025)

Autonomy, Motivation, and Psychological Needs

Self-determination theory explains motivated engagement partly through satisfaction of autonomy, competence, and relatedness. Autonomy concerns perceived volition, competence concerns effectiveness in meaningful actions, and relatedness concerns connection and recognition. During injury rehabilitation, an athlete may lose control over training schedules, selection, travel, and daily routines; repeated unsuccessful tasks may undermine perceived competence; separation from the team may weaken social belonging. These experiences can influence participation in treatment and the eventual desirability of return. The recent sport-injury consensus explicitly organizes return-to-sport needs using this theoretical language. Ryan & Deci (2000) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

Research distinguishes autonomous reasons for returning, such as enjoyment, mastery, and valued team membership, from controlled reasons, including fear of losing status, pleasing authorities, or avoiding financial punishment. In a study of professional footballers, Podlog and Eklund investigated scenarios surrounding returning to competition and considered the psychological consequences of autonomy-supportive versus pressuring conditions. This research provides a framework for studying social context; it does not establish a universal effect size for all sports or injury categories. Team selection rules, scholarship structures, employment conditions, and the possibility of freely declining return form an important part of the causal environment. Podlog & Eklund (2010)

Autonomy-supportive practice involves accessible explanations of rehabilitation decisions, meaningful choice where medically appropriate, collaborative goals, and recognition of conflicting feelings. Supporting autonomy also permits a decision to change competitive level or leave the sport. Relatedness may be sustained by continued team inclusion or trusted peer contact, but the quality and voluntariness of those interactions matter. A coach's frequent communication can be reassuring to one athlete and experienced as surveillance by another. Research designs should measure perceived climate, practical opportunities, reasons for participation, and later well-being separately from raw exercise attendance. Ryan & Deci (2000) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

Athletic Identity, Role Disruption, and Life Reorganization

Athletic identity describes the importance of sporting participation to a person's self-understanding and social recognition. Injury can challenge routines, status, relationships, time structure, and anticipated futures. This disruption may be especially consequential when sport is a primary source of livelihood or social belonging. At the same time, a strongly valued athletic role can support purposeful engagement with rehabilitation. The direction of association therefore depends on whether identity commitments are flexible, supported, and compatible with other valued domains. The injury-response literature treats personal characteristics and sporting context as interacting influences rather than fixed predictors of favorable or unfavorable adjustment. Wiese-Bjornstal et al. (1998) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

Role disruption often extends beyond lost training time. The athlete may cease traveling with teammates, lose a starting position, experience changes in educational or contractual security, or face public discussion of rehabilitation progress. A youth athlete may have limited alternative social circles, while a professional may confront uncertainty about occupational continuity. Psychological inquiry should ask about identity narratives and practical consequences, and avoid assuming that successful adjustment requires permanent preservation of an unchanged sporting identity. A decision to redefine one's relation to sport can be adaptive even if performance never returns to a prior benchmark. Podlog & Eklund (2006) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

Athletic identity is also a potential source of measurement distortion when participants perceive that disclosing fear or sadness may jeopardize selection. Underreporting may coexist with outward compliance and ambitious return goals. Confidential psychological assessment and clear boundaries between therapy, sports medicine, and selection decisions help improve both ethical care and research validity. Identity-related distress belongs in differential assessment when impairment persists or significant clinical symptoms emerge, yet the presence of grief after a meaningful loss alone does not specify a mental disorder. Tranaeus et al. (2024) Reardon et al. (2026)

Coping, Emotion Regulation, and Rehabilitation Engagement

Coping denotes changing cognitive and behavioral efforts to manage demands appraised as taxing. After injury, coping may include seeking information, setting attainable goals, emotion regulation, drawing on relationships, seeking professional care, managing pain-related uncertainty, or revising expectations. A coping strategy's effectiveness depends on the controllability and timing of the problem. Planning may be helpful for exercise scheduling, whereas acceptance of an unavoidable waiting period may serve a different function. These processes should be judged through actual circumstances and outcomes rather than by assigning universal positive or negative labels to one style. Lazarus & Folkman (1984) Wiese-Bjornstal et al. (1998)

Adherence is commonly measured through attendance, exercise completion, or clinician ratings, yet those measures capture different behaviors. A missed appointment may reflect transportation access, work responsibilities, insurance limits, discouragement, or a medical complication. An athlete can attend all sessions without undertaking sport-specific exposure, and another can progress through an appropriately modified home program despite fewer clinical visits. The psychological evidence base benefits from separating opportunity, capability, intention, behavior, and response to treatment. Such separation prevents individual blame when structural constraints restrict rehabilitation. Tranaeus et al. (2024)

Emotional regulation techniques may include reframing interpretations, attentional strategies, controlled breathing, relaxation, imagery, and communication. Their effectiveness requires intervention-specific evidence rather than extrapolation from plausible mechanisms. The randomized pilot trial of guided imagery after ACL repair is an example of directly testing a psychological intervention, but a small pilot cannot establish routine efficacy across injury categories, long-term reinjury prevention, or all rehabilitation stages. Practitioners should use matched goals and reassess whether an intervention improves the intended outcome without interfering with clinically indicated physical progression. Maddison et al. (2012) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

Social Support, Coaching Pressure, and Rehabilitation Climate

Sport injury takes place within relationships. Athletic trainers, physiotherapists, surgeons, psychologists, coaches, teammates, peers, and family members may each influence the interpretation of symptoms, the feasibility of rehabilitation, and the desire to return. Support has informational, emotional, and practical components. A clinician may provide understandable risk information, a teammate may sustain belonging, and a family member may help with transport or finances. The relevance of any form depends on the athlete's needs and the quality of the relationship. The integrated injury-response model gave these situational factors explicit explanatory importance. Wiese-Bjornstal et al. (1998) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

Social contact can also carry pressure. A coach might communicate that selection will be lost unless return occurs by a particular game, or teammates may frame cautious progression as disloyalty. Such messages can influence self-report, consent, rehabilitation pacing, and willingness to report symptoms. High-stakes sports environments require specific safeguards against coercion and conflicts of interest, particularly for minors and athletes whose education or income depends on availability. A collaborative clearance decision should distinguish medical judgment from competitive selection and respect athlete participation without converting it into an obligation to return. Ardern et al. (2016) Podlog & Eklund (2010)

Researchers should examine support as a process rather than a single total score. The amount of contact, perceived helpfulness, relational trust, power asymmetry, and confidentiality may predict different outcomes. Longitudinal observation can identify whether support precedes improvements in well-being or increases after emerging distress. The return-to-sport consensus highlights competence, autonomy, and relatedness, suggesting that social conditions can affect readiness through multiple mechanisms. However, establishing mediation requires repeated measures, defensible temporal ordering, and control of common causes. Tranaeus et al. (2024) Ryan & Deci (2000)

Operationalizing Psychological Readiness

The construct of psychological readiness can be operationalized through emotional confidence about participation, perceived ability to execute sport-specific actions, judgments about the likelihood and consequences of another injury, and willingness to encounter competitive demands. An operational definition must specify the sport, injury, anticipated context, and assessment time. Readiness to run alone during rehabilitation differs from readiness to sprint in an unpredictable match or to accept contact while fatigued. A measure that omits these contextual distinctions captures a generalized perception whose interpretation may shift as the athlete advances. The ACL Return to Sport after Injury scale represents a major instrument in the ACL literature, designed around emotions, confidence in performance, and risk appraisal. Webster et al. (2008)

Readiness may be treated as a continuous self-report variable or classified using a predetermined cut score, yet categorization trades information for apparent simplicity. Any threshold should be validated against a clearly defined outcome and population, including calibration, measurement error, sensitivity, specificity, and the costs of misclassification. A high questionnaire score cannot replace independent medical assessment. A low score may be informative without demonstrating which intervention would help. Its interpretation also depends on whether respondents are contemplating return, actively participating, or have already resumed their sport. Combining athletes at different stages introduces construct and selection problems. Webster & Feller (2018) van Haren et al. (2025)

Future measurement requires finer separation among psychological willingness, situational confidence, risk tolerance, clinical distress, and the preference to return at all. An athlete who freely prefers another activity may score as unready under a questionnaire that presumes return to the original sport is desirable. Researchers should therefore record individual goals and reasons for nonreturn alongside instrument scores. Decision-relevant validity means establishing that the measure contributes useful information beyond physical function, prior sport level, time since injury, social opportunity, and the actual demands of the proposed exposure. Ardern et al. (2016) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

The ACL-RSI Scale and Its Measurement Properties

Webster, Feller, and Lambros introduced the ACL-RSI scale in 2008 through development and preliminary validation among people who had undergone ACL reconstruction. The original instrument addressed emotions, confidence, and risk appraisal as facets of readiness for return. Its value was to make psychological considerations measurable within a field long organized around tissue recovery and functional tests. The scale is injury-specific, and its construct is shaped by language about knee injury and sporting activity. Reliability and validity findings from one sample or linguistic adaptation must not automatically be attributed to all ages, treatment pathways, cultures, or sports. Webster et al. (2008)

Webster and Feller's 2018 study developed and validated a shorter, six-item ACL-RSI version, intended to reduce assessment burden while preserving essential information. Shorter forms may facilitate repeated measurement but require renewed analysis of item functioning, score comparability, and sensitivity to change. Differences in factor structures, administration schedules, and case mix complicate direct comparisons of studies that use original and abbreviated forms. Neither instrument functions as a standalone test of biological healing or concussion recovery. Webster & Feller (2018)

The 2024 systematic review and meta-analysis by Sell and colleagues examined ACL-RSI scores over time across 83 studies. The authors judged most included studies at high risk of bias and rated evidence certainty weak or limited. Pooled means rose from approximately 44.4 before reconstruction to 61.5 at three to six months afterward, with higher values in the longest follow-up grouping; heterogeneity was substantial. These averages describe the studies' sampled populations and assessment times, not a universal individual recovery curve. Bias and selection matter because participants reaching late assessment may differ from those lost to follow-up or no longer seeking sport. Sell et al. (2024)

Validity, Reliability, and Measurement Invariance

Internal consistency concerns how items relate within a questionnaire; test–retest reliability concerns stability under conditions where the construct is expected to remain stable; construct validity concerns whether the score behaves as the intended psychological attribute should. None of these alone establishes clinical decision utility. Prediction of return may partly reflect item content that directly asks about return intentions, creating conceptual overlap with the endpoint. Likewise, when respondents see successful performance as proof of readiness, the score may track previous exposure rather than explain future exposure. Measurement should be tested against independent behavioral and medical outcomes. Webster et al. (2008) Webster & Feller (2018)

Researchers should evaluate whether items retain their meaning across sex, age, competitive level, language, injury type, treatment path, and sport. A concern about contact in rugby may differ substantially from a concern about repetitive load in distance running. Cultural norms about disclosing fear and institutional penalties for admitting uncertainty may influence responses independent of underlying experience. Longitudinal invariance matters because perceptions of readiness may change qualitatively between hospitalization, strength training, return to practice, and competition. Without evaluating such shifts, an increase in score can reflect new interpretation of an item as well as actual change. Sell et al. (2024) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

Meaningful interpretation also requires reporting missing-data handling, score distribution, floor and ceiling effects, relevant uncertainty, and the time between the measurement and actual return decision. Aggregating heterogeneous instruments through uncritical standardized scores can conceal different constructs. The evidence reviews of ACL readiness and prognostic factors underscore limitations in study design and the need for stronger evidence about predictive accuracy. A research program should distinguish the psychometric question of what a score measures from the decision question of whether acting on that score improves safety or valued participation. Sell et al. (2024) van Haren et al. (2025)

Prospective Cohorts, Prediction, and Causal Identification

Prospective cohorts are particularly important because they measure candidate predictors before subsequent outcomes are known. In a study after ACL reconstruction, Ardern and colleagues reported that psychological responses were associated with return to preinjury sporting level. Such findings brought attention to beliefs and emotions as potential markers of return. They remain observational: athletes with stronger perceived readiness may differ in functional recovery, preinjury competition level, insurance coverage, rehabilitation access, or motivations that also influence return. An association should not be translated into a claim that manipulating one questionnaire score will necessarily produce sporting return. Ardern et al. (2013; cohort)

Time-varying confounding deserves special attention. Athletes who progress through demanding physical tasks become more confident; this confidence may then influence opportunities for further practice. Pain changes, rehabilitation intensity, family pressure, and team selection affect both readiness and subsequent participation. Standard regression measured at a single time point cannot fully reconstruct these feedback pathways. Repeated assessments linked to objectively recorded exposures improve temporal resolution. Suitable methods may include longitudinal multilevel analysis, target-trial emulation with explicit assumptions, and causal models that distinguish mediation from confounding. Such methodological choices are research recommendations rather than findings already established by any single source. Ardern et al. (2013; cohort) van Haren et al. (2025)

The 2025 systematic review by van Haren and colleagues identified physical, psychological, and demographic prognostic factors for return after ACL reconstruction, but rated confidence in the evidence very low. Their findings illustrate why apparent prediction and reliable clinical forecasting differ. Model performance requires external validation in new populations, discrimination, calibration, and decision-curve usefulness, as well as transparent handling of missing outcomes and selective follow-up. When return itself depends on a coach's selection, opportunity must be measured as part of the outcome process. A model can predict who is selected without isolating underlying ability or willingness. van Haren et al. (2025)

Return-to-Sport Rates and the Definition of Success

One of the field's most cited syntheses is the 2011 systematic review and meta-analysis by Ardern and colleagues. Across eligible ACL reconstruction studies, the review reported approximate proportions of 82% returning to some form of sport, 63% returning to their preinjury sporting level, and 44% returning to competitive sport. These figures were based on heterogeneous studies and definitions, and do not constitute an individualized prognosis or a current rate for every surgical technique and population. Their durable methodological lesson concerns denominator discipline: a high any-sport proportion can coexist with a much smaller share resuming former competitive demands. Ardern et al. (2011)

A return endpoint must specify timing, continuity, level, subjective satisfaction, and whether exposure was available. A person who returns for one short practice and stops because of symptoms has a different outcome from a person who safely sustains a season. Studies that recruit only athletes who elect surgery or actively seek return can exclude people who choose a different pathway. Competitive level and sport type shape physical demands and opportunity. Reporting only group means also hides variation in those who recover sooner, later, or change goals. Ardern et al. (2011) Ardern et al. (2016)

Research should distinguish medical clearance, athlete decision, actual attendance, effective participation, performance restoration, and later reinjury. These are successive possible events rather than a single inevitable trajectory. A sport-participation outcome should be accompanied by the athlete's experienced value of that participation, since returning under external pressure with enduring distress may be an unfavorable result. Conversely, a person who shifts to a different sport while retaining health and meaningful engagement may experience a successful rehabilitation despite missing a narrow preinjury performance endpoint. Ardern et al. (2016) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

Physical Recovery, Functional Testing, and Psychological Assessment

Return decisions involve the integration of medical findings, injury-specific rehabilitation criteria, strength, range of motion, movement control, symptom response, task exposure, and psychological preparation. The 2016 return-to-sport consensus explicitly frames decision-making as complex and shared rather than based on a calendar alone. Psychological measurement can identify concerns, confidence, and readiness beliefs that are invisible to isolated biomechanical tests, while physical assessment detects limitations that enthusiasm may mask. The components answer different questions and are most useful when interpreted jointly. Ardern et al. (2016)

The Delaware–Oslo ACL cohort study by Grindem and colleagues examined reinjury in relation to participation timing and functional criteria after reconstruction. Its findings are frequently cited in discussions of delaying return and obtaining adequate quadriceps strength and hop performance. Because the research is an observational cohort in a particular population and treatment context, its title's estimate of risk reduction must not be presented as a universally proven causal effect. The study illustrates that psychological readiness must remain situated within a broader safety decision that includes exposure level, muscular function, and time since surgery. Grindem et al. (2016)

Physical function and self-reported readiness may diverge meaningfully. Individuals who meet standard clinic tests can remain unprepared for unpredictable sport exposure; individuals eager to return can still lack capacity for repeated high-speed actions. Graded exposure under professional supervision provides information about both movement and perceived risk. Yet a high score after supervised performance cannot substitute for sustained competition monitoring, and any clinical readiness decision must account for specific injury pathology. The most defensible approach is a structured discussion of convergent and discordant evidence, with further assessment when important uncertainty persists. Ardern et al. (2016) van Haren et al. (2025)

Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury as an Evidence-Rich Case

ACL injury has become a central research setting because rehabilitation is often prolonged, sport-specific pivoting demands are conspicuous, and reconstruction does not automatically restore competitive participation. Clinical follow-up permits repeated physical testing and use of the ACL-RSI. Consequently, this literature provides a detailed window into changing fear, confidence, expectations, and willingness to return. The research domain nevertheless combines surgically and nonsurgically managed injuries, varying concomitant damage, different sports, and changing rehabilitation protocols. Interpretation requires accurate specification of which population a reported outcome concerns. Webster et al. (2008) Ardern et al. (2011)

The prospective studies and meta-analyses establish that psychological scores correlate with return outcomes, while systematic appraisal reveals significant risk of bias and heterogeneity. In Sell and colleagues' review, the trajectory of average ACL-RSI scores was examined across multiple postoperative periods, but evidence certainty was consistently weak or limited. The 2025 prognostic review similarly identified higher readiness among candidate predictors while finding very low certainty across analyzed factors. These syntheses support psychological assessment as a clinically relevant information source and leave open how much adding a given scale improves decisions relative to standardized physical tests and individual goals. Sell et al. (2024) van Haren et al. (2025)

Research conclusions should specify the sequence from injury through treatment, rehabilitation, clinical clearance, actual return, and sustained performance. Otherwise psychological scores measured after athletes have resumed participation can be misinterpreted as causes of the return. ACL research is also shaped by sport and demographic selection: a collegiate athlete eager to regain a scholarship and a recreational athlete reconsidering the costs of competitive sport may respond differently to identical testing. Distinguishing readiness to return from the preference to return is essential for scientifically coherent comparison. Ardern et al. (2013; cohort) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

Concussion and Neurological Safety as a Distinct Return Context

Sport-related concussion involves neurological and systemic symptoms whose evaluation and management differ from those of isolated ligament or muscle injuries. The psychological experience may include uncertainty about symptom persistence, apprehension about repeated head impacts, frustration with cognitive limitations, and concerns about academic or occupational functioning. Mood and anxiety symptoms can overlap with concussion-related symptom reports, creating diagnostic challenges. Readiness in this context must therefore incorporate validated concussion-specific assessment and medical protocols; an ACL-RSI score cannot establish neurological recovery or appropriate return after a suspected concussion. Patricios et al. (2023)

The 2022 Amsterdam concussion conference consensus, published in 2023, emphasizes individualized clinical assessment and a staged return process with symptom-sensitive progression and appropriate medical oversight. Psychological factors may influence reported symptoms, recovery experiences, and willingness to disclose impairment, but the scientific interpretation remains dependent on injury-specific neurological evidence. Any sport-injury psychology synthesis that extrapolates simple confidence-building techniques to concussion clearance risks conflating subjective comfort with biological risk management. Patricios et al. (2023)

Special ethical concerns arise when playing time, employment, peer approval, or competitive pressure discourages accurate symptom reporting. A culture that treats self-reported confidence as proof of safety can induce misclassification. Good research records the independent medical criteria used for clearance, time since injury, symptom fluctuations, exposure demands, and whether psychological measures were completed confidentially. Athletes should have access to qualified professional evaluation when symptoms persist, worsen, or involve significant mental-health concerns. Those clinical decisions are beyond the scope of a generic return-readiness questionnaire. Patricios et al. (2023) Reardon et al. (2026)

Muscle, Tendon, Bone Stress, and Recurrent Injury

The consequences of muscle strain, tendinopathy, stress injury, and recurrent joint sprain depend on their distinct tissue processes and sporting demands. A distance runner may fear return of pain after graded volume increases; a sprinter may fear explosive acceleration; a gymnast may worry about landings or equipment-specific movements. Recurrence can alter risk appraisal because prior recovery attempts supply experiences of both success and setback. General psychological principles such as appraisal and efficacy remain relevant, but the evidence required to demonstrate a treatment effect must be gathered in the target injury population. Wiese-Bjornstal et al. (1998) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

A common methodological problem is borrowing ACL-derived thresholds for cases with different rehabilitation lengths and meanings. A measure sensitive to fear of knee pivoting may fail to capture fears about load accumulation or repeated muscle failure, while return itself has different definitions across team and individual sports. Task-based interviews, repeated assessments of anticipated contexts, and injury-specific function measures can identify important mechanisms that generalized instruments overlook. These tools need formal validation before researchers claim normative values or cross-injury equivalence. Webster et al. (2008) Webster & Feller (2018)

Pain or hesitation is not a single psychological signal. Continued symptoms can indicate a medically relevant problem, a sensitivity influenced by expectation and experience, or multiple interacting processes. Clinicians should evaluate the injury and load response before interpreting movement avoidance as psychological resistance. Long-term outcomes require information about exposure dose and recurrence, because the number of new injuries depends partly on how much sport an athlete actually performs. Comparisons of reinjury risk among returners and nonreturners are therefore vulnerable to exposure and selection bias. Tranaeus et al. (2024) Ardern et al. (2016)

Age, Developmental Stage, and Youth Sporting Environments

In youth sport, injury occurs while self-regulation, autonomy, educational roles, and athletic opportunities are still developing. Young athletes may depend on parents and coaches for transportation, treatment access, and permission to participate, while social belonging may be concentrated in one team. Their understanding of recurrence probability and long-term consequences can differ from that of adults. These features justify developmentally appropriate explanation, confidential opportunities to express concerns, and a balance between safeguarding and participation in decisions. The general injury response framework predicts variation according to personal and situational factors; it does not validate adult questionnaire norms for children. Wiese-Bjornstal et al. (1998) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

Early specialization and selective competition can increase the perceived cost of absence even when the injury itself is medically uncomplicated. A youth athlete may fear disappointing adults or losing a place in a competitive pathway, and such pressure can distort reported readiness. Researchers should record age, pubertal or developmental status where relevant, level of sport, parental expectations, school obligations, and the quality of the rehabilitation environment. Consent, assent, and professional safeguarding processes require specific attention. Tranaeus et al. (2024) Reardon et al. (2026)

Longitudinal research must distinguish return to the same age-group team from continued participation over subsequent developmental transitions. A teenager may recover, choose a new sport, and remain physically active while a narrow outcome records nonreturn. Quality of life, sustainable participation, educational engagement, and self-determined goals should accompany competitive metrics. Claims about treatment effectiveness in youth require age-specific evidence and sensitivity to the practical constraints of family and school environments. Ardern et al. (2016) Ryan & Deci (2000)

Sex, Gender, Culture, and Unequal Access to Care

Studies of psychological readiness sometimes report average differences by sex, age, or competitive setting, but those differences can reflect injury distributions, exposure, treatment access, measurement functioning, and social roles as well as psychological experience. Sell and colleagues identified possible demographic associations in time-stratified ACL-RSI analyses while emphasizing weak evidence quality and large between-study heterogeneity. Findings should therefore be described as provisional associations in sampled cohorts, without inferring universal sex-specific mental strengths or deficits. Sell et al. (2024) van Haren et al. (2025)

Sporting cultures differ in norms concerning pain disclosure, stoicism, emotional communication, professional dependence, and the acceptable pace of return. Translation alone does not establish that a psychological scale measures the same construct across linguistic and cultural groups. Testing measurement invariance and consulting athletes about whether questions reflect their lived choices are important components of responsible adaptation. Economic inequality may determine access to surgery, specialist rehabilitation, psychological services, and time away from work; consequently apparent psychological readiness differences can be partly produced by material conditions. Tranaeus et al. (2024) Webster et al. (2008)

An adequate explanatory model must document who was included and who was missing. Studies recruiting participants from specialized sport clinics may underrepresent athletes without insurance, rural athletes, and people who leave organized sport after an injury. Differential attrition can raise the average readiness score among remaining participants when discouraged or financially constrained athletes are more likely to disappear from follow-up. The proper response is transparent sampling, retention analysis, accessible data collection, and outcome measures incorporating athlete-valued recovery rather than merely selection for competition. Sell et al. (2024) van Haren et al. (2025)

Elite, Recreational, Para Sport, and Occupational Pressures

Elite and professional athletes may confront employment contracts, scholarships, team selection, public scrutiny, and financial incentives that amplify the psychological meaning of return decisions. Yet recreational athletes can experience equally profound disruption when sport structures friendships, emotional well-being, and identity. Differences in performance expectation and available medical resources should be measured rather than inferred solely from the elite or recreational label. Research on self-determination and social context emphasizes why perceived choice matters even when sporting participation carries substantial external rewards. Podlog & Eklund (2010) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

Para sport introduces additional diversity in baseline mobility, adaptive equipment, classification systems, access to facilities, and the meaning of new injury relative to preexisting impairment. A return assessment must respect the athlete's actual sport, function, support systems, and stated goals. Functional comparison with a generic nondisabled benchmark may be inappropriate. Psychological well-being and safe participation can be affected as much by access to coaches and equipment as by individual fear or confidence. Evidence developed in standard ACL reconstruction populations requires separate evaluation before transfer to these settings. Tranaeus et al. (2024) Ardern et al. (2016)

Across every level, power relations can impair the validity of readiness reports. Athletes who fear loss of opportunities may overstate their confidence or conceal symptoms. Professional and organizational policies should make clear who sees psychological disclosures, how health data affect selection, and whether the athlete can withdraw consent for a planned return. Ethical research procedures and clinical safeguards are part of the conditions under which psychologically meaningful data can be obtained. Reardon et al. (2026) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

Psychological Interventions and Evidence of Effectiveness

Interventions intended to support recovery include structured psychoeducation, collaborative goal setting, psychological skills training, imagery, relaxation, self-talk, emotion regulation, and access to individual clinical treatment when indicated. Their targets are not equivalent. An intervention might reduce distress, improve rehabilitation engagement, increase movement confidence, or help the athlete make a preferred decision about return, with no necessary change in injury biology. A rigorous evaluation must specify the intended effect, comparator, treatment dose, concurrent physical care, and a time point suitable for the outcome. Plausible mechanisms and practitioner consensus offer reasons for testing a procedure but do not establish clinical effectiveness. Tranaeus et al. (2024) Maddison et al. (2012)

Maddison and colleagues conducted a randomized pilot study of guided imagery after ACL repair, directly investigating functional outcomes in an intervention context. As a pilot, the study informs feasibility and the design of further trials; its results cannot establish population-wide effectiveness, longer-term reinjury reduction, or equivalence to rehabilitation. Research that bundles multiple psychological practices also has difficulty identifying which component accounts for an outcome. If intervention participants receive more contact or attention than controls, nonspecific support and expectancy differences can create apparent benefits. Blinding is challenging when participants know the psychological technique they receive. Maddison et al. (2012)

The recent field consensus supplies practical principles for integrating psychological knowledge into sport injury care while acknowledging that no complete evidence-based consensus had previously existed. This assessment is important: recommendations to communicate supportively, recognize fear, and examine motivation can be reasonable without presenting every technique as proven by large randomized trials. Future studies should prioritize preregistration, appropriate active controls, injury-specific protocols, independent outcome assessors, intention-to-treat analysis, and follow-up after real sporting exposure. Outcomes should include athlete-valued function, distress, participation, and harms, not exclusively improvement in self-report readiness. Tranaeus et al. (2024)

Graded Exposure, Mastery Experiences, and Relearning Sport

Graded exposure describes progressive encounters with movements or contexts that an athlete must perform, accompanied by assessment of physical capacity, symptoms, and perceived confidence. The rationale overlaps with mastery-based self-efficacy: successful execution of relevant actions can update expectations of competence. However, graded return in sports medicine is fundamentally an injury-specific rehabilitation procedure with psychological consequences, and the progression of load must be determined by qualified clinical judgment. Exposure to fear-provoking activity without adequate tissue recovery or neurological clearance would be inappropriate. Bandura (1977) Ardern et al. (2016)

A progression might move from controlled strength and balance tasks to predictable sport techniques, then to more variable demands and actual competition, with each stage designed for the particular injury. Psychological assessment can capture how the athlete interprets performance and whether successful tasks generalize to different settings. An athlete who confidently performs isolated movements may still be apprehensive about fatigue, opponents, or the possibility of public failure. Graded exposure is therefore better studied through repeated task-specific beliefs and behavior than through a single score after the last clinic appointment. Webster et al. (2008) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

Research designs should distinguish the effect of increasing physical capacity from the effect of changing risk expectations. A trial of a psychological component added to otherwise matched rehabilitation could compare confidence, sport participation, symptoms, and recurrence without withholding medically necessary care. Clinical monitoring must permit individualized modification when complications arise. The scientific question is whether an added psychological intervention improves valued outcomes above the physical progression that would have occurred anyway; this cannot be answered solely by observing that confidence rises during successful rehabilitation. Ardern et al. (2016) van Haren et al. (2025)

Goal Setting, Communication, and Shared Decisions

Goal setting structures a long recovery into attainable tasks, but clinically relevant goals are specific to the athlete's injury, present capability, and preferred future. A return goal may involve restoring everyday function, training with teammates, resuming an occupational requirement, or meeting a particular competition demand. Goals can support motivation when their rationale is understood and accepted; they can also become coercive when another person's deadline overrides symptoms or individual preferences. Autonomy-supportive communication helps clarify why rehabilitation milestones matter and which choices remain open. Ryan & Deci (2000) Podlog & Eklund (2010)

Shared return decisions require an explicit exchange among the athlete, clinicians, and relevant sport personnel. Medical risk assessment, physical testing, personal values, and sporting consequences are distinct inputs. Athletes need understandable information about uncertainty and the ability to communicate apprehension or changing objectives without punishment. The Bern return-to-sport consensus places decision-making within a continuum and recognizes multiple stakeholders, while maintaining responsibility for appropriate medical and rehabilitation criteria. Ardern et al. (2016)

A scientifically evaluable communication intervention could compare standardized decision support with usual care while collecting athlete understanding, perceived autonomy, decisional conflict, safety outcomes, and subsequent participation. Measurement should consider whether team power relations allow genuine choice. Satisfaction with a decision is informative but insufficient if medical harms increase; conversely, conservative risk decisions may be experienced as disappointing while still protecting health. Ethical evaluation must retain both autonomy and clinical safety as independently meaningful outcomes. Tranaeus et al. (2024) Reardon et al. (2026)

Mental Health Screening, Referral, and Clinical Boundaries

Psychological distress following sport injury deserves attention because interruption of activity and identity can coincide with symptoms of depression, anxiety, sleep disturbance, and other mental health concerns. The 2026 International Olympic Committee consensus states that athlete mental health should be systematically considered through screening, monitoring, care access, and organizational prevention, with attention to environmental stressors. Injury is among the contexts in which sporting performance and mental health interact. Such guidance supports professional assessment rather than treating every emotional reaction as a disorder or expecting a generic readiness scale to serve as a diagnostic instrument. Reardon et al. (2026)

A validated clinical screening instrument can help identify people needing further evaluation, but a positive screen is not equivalent to a diagnosis. Clinicians should differentiate pain and injury-related symptoms from more general mental health symptoms, examine duration and impairment, and use appropriate referral processes. Concussion may involve neurocognitive or mood symptoms requiring particular clinical assessment. In high-risk presentations or significant persistent distress, qualified professionals should determine appropriate care. Research monographs should document the consensus and trial evidence without issuing individualized diagnoses or treatments. Reardon et al. (2026) Patricios et al. (2023)

Confidentiality matters particularly when athletes suspect that disclosures may affect selection or contracts. Health records, readiness questionnaires, and team availability reports serve different purposes and may require distinct access controls. Monitoring systems should make informed consent, data minimization, and referral pathways explicit. There is no qualified external medical reviewer credited for this monograph; the clinical material is a population-level analysis of published guidance and research rather than a clinical practice protocol. Reardon et al. (2026)

Multidisciplinary Rehabilitation and Coordinated Care

Sport injury rehabilitation commonly involves orthopedic or sports physicians, physical therapists, athletic trainers, coaches, and where appropriate psychologists and mental health clinicians. Each profession contributes different observations: biological healing and injury complications, strength and load tolerance, task execution, motivation and fear, social pressures, and the athlete's life context. Coordination supports a more coherent understanding of the same athlete, provided that confidentiality and professional scopes are respected. An apparently unmotivated rehabilitation participant may be facing pain, unclear instructions, grief, transport problems, or exposure to a coercive sporting culture. Ardern et al. (2016) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

A multidisciplinary approach also requires attention to disagreement. An athlete may want to return before the medical team judges the exposure safe; a coach may want availability on an accelerated timetable; a clinician may seek further physical or neurological assessment even when the athlete reports high confidence. Transparent decision criteria and explicit responsibility help prevent personal incentives from replacing medical evidence. The return-to-sport continuum invites ongoing reevaluation rather than a single irrevocable clearance event. Ardern et al. (2016) Patricios et al. (2023)

Research can evaluate coordination through communication quality, adherence opportunities, patient-reported understanding, rehabilitation continuity, return decisions, and long-term welfare. However, causal attribution is difficult when high-resource teams offer both better interdisciplinary care and superior physical facilities. Comparative studies should document staffing, access, treatment intensity, insurance context, and baseline injury severity. Multidisciplinary care is an organizing principle whose specific added benefits should still be tested under transparent research designs. Tranaeus et al. (2024) van Haren et al. (2025)

Safety, Ethical Practice, and the Possibility of Nonreturn

The option not to return to a previous sport is a legitimate outcome of informed deliberation. An athlete may judge the possible physical consequences unacceptable, experience altered priorities, face barriers outside their control, or prefer a different form of exercise. Research frequently records these pathways under nonreturn, a category that can conceal successful adaptation and autonomous choice. A scientifically coherent outcome assessment should record reasons for nonreturn, alternative participation, psychological well-being, and whether the athlete's current choices align with their values. Ardern et al. (2016) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

Preventing avoidable harm requires recognition of institutional pressure, conflicts of interest, and the limits of self-report. Return should not be accelerated solely because psychological questionnaires show enthusiasm, nor delayed mechanically because a self-report score falls below an arbitrary population cut point. The athlete's views matter, and clinical risk assessment remains injury-specific. In concussion, the distinction is particularly important because symptom disclosure and medically guided stages are central to appropriate recovery. Patricios et al. (2023) Ardern et al. (2016)

Research and practice should include accessible reporting processes for coercion and safeguard younger or dependent athletes. The 2026 IOC mental health consensus treats organizational conditions as relevant to prevention and care. Durable rehabilitation success includes safe participation, psychological dignity, freedom to express uncertainty, and sustained capacity to make choices about sporting life. Such an endpoint may be more informative than an isolated return percentage whenever participation quality and personal autonomy are central to the clinical question. Reardon et al. (2026) Podlog & Eklund (2010)

Early Studies of Reinjury Fear and Its Interpretation

Kvist, Ek, Sporrstedt, and Good's 2005 follow-up study examined fear of reinjury among people after ACL reconstruction using the Tampa Scale of Kinesiophobia, knee-related outcomes, and activity reports. Of 87 individuals approached several years after surgery, 62 responded; people who had not returned to their preinjury activity level reported more fear. This investigation was influential because it connected a measurable psychological variable to sporting participation. Its retrospective, cross-sectional design and modest respondent sample limit causal interpretation, and fear and functional limitations may influence each other. Kvist et al. (2005)

Ardern, Taylor, Feller, and Webster investigated fear among 209 people already participating in sport two to seven years after reconstruction in a 2012 cross-sectional case series. In this selected group, participants generally reported relatively low fear, while those who had resumed the preinjury level reported less fear than those playing at a lower level. The study's sampling condition is critical: athletes who never resumed sport were outside the analyzed population. These findings are compatible with readiness changing after return and illustrate why fear levels among successful returners cannot be projected onto all injured athletes. Ardern et al. (2012)

The earlier systematic review of return-related psychological factors by Ardern and colleagues in 2013 included 11 studies and 983 athletes. It described preliminary links between confidence, motivation, fear, and RTS, and grouped relevant findings through competence, autonomy, and relatedness. This review connected isolated empirical findings into a coherent research agenda while acknowledging the tentative state of the evidence. It should be read as an important historical synthesis, with later reviews supplying more rigorous warnings about heterogeneous samples and bias. Ardern et al. (2013; review) van Haren et al. (2025)

Foundational Experiments in Psychological Rehabilitation

Cupal and Brewer's 2001 randomized clinical trial studied relaxation and guided imagery during rehabilitation after ACL reconstruction. Thirty participants were assigned among intervention, supportive placebo, and control conditions. The authors reported differences in reinjury anxiety, pain, and knee strength at follow-up. The design offers more direct intervention evidence than a simple association between fear and sport participation, yet small sample size, allocation and blinding limitations, and uncertainty about the generality of effects constrain the inference. The trial provides a historical foundation for testing psychological components during rehabilitation rather than demonstrating an established universal treatment protocol. Cupal & Brewer (2001)

The 2012 Maddison and colleagues randomized pilot also investigated guided imagery after ACL repair. Read together, the two studies illuminate both a plausible mechanism and a persistent evidence gap. Psychological support might change emotional responses or engagement, but the studies differ in delivery, endpoints, and rehabilitation context; neither isolates an injury-general process that can simply be transferred to all athletes. The correct experimental question concerns the added value of a specified intervention under a clearly defined rehabilitation pathway, with reproducible instructions and prospective follow-up. Maddison et al. (2012) Cupal & Brewer (2001)

Methodological appraisal should attend to attention-matched comparators, researcher expectations, participant retention, and clinical endpoints whose assessors are insulated from group assignment. A statistically significant result from a pilot can be imprecise and vulnerable to selective outcome reporting. Trials should identify whether reductions in fear precede functional improvement and whether outcomes persist after real competitive exposure. Continued evaluation is scientifically justified because the emotional and practical costs of injury are substantial, while the available evidence remains specific to studied techniques and samples. Tranaeus et al. (2024) Cupal & Brewer (2001)

Preinjury Stress, Injury Risk, and Temporal Boundaries

The psychology of sport injury also includes prospective examination of psychosocial factors before injury occurs. Ivarsson and colleagues' 2017 meta-analyses assessed relationships among stress history, stress responses, sport injury incidence, and injury-prevention intervention research. Their results linked stress-related variables with injury outcomes across the included studies, while the analysis combined heterogeneous observational and intervention evidence. This domain is theoretically connected to injury-response psychology through appraisal and attention, but its causal question differs: what predicts the occurrence of an injury, rather than how athletes interpret or recover from an injury that has occurred? Ivarsson et al. (2017)

Maintaining this boundary prevents a common conceptual error. Stress before injury can influence injury risk without establishing that distress after injury necessarily slows tissue healing or causes failure to return. Similarly, an athlete reporting low stress while injured is not demonstrably protected from recurrent injury. The direction of time, mediating behaviors, competition exposure, injury mechanism, and relevant confounders must be modeled separately. An integrated field account can span prevention, rehabilitation, and return while preserving different outcome variables for each phase. Ivarsson et al. (2017) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

Research can examine whether preinjury experiences shape recovery responses through previous coping practices, social resources, and threat expectations. Such work requires baseline measures collected before injury and sufficient prospective follow-up, something many rehabilitation cohorts cannot supply. The absence of genuine preinjury baselines should be acknowledged when authors interpret an injured athlete's reported personality or coping as a prior cause. Wiese-Bjornstal et al. (1998) Ivarsson et al. (2017)

Identity Vulnerability and Critical Appraisal of Psychological Mechanisms

Brewer's 1993 investigation of self-identity and vulnerability to depressed mood explored the general hypothesis that disruptions to self-defining activity can be associated with depressed mood. Its historical importance for sport injury lies in suggesting that identity investment can affect the significance of losing participation. It does not imply that strong athletic identity is intrinsically pathological, that all injuries produce depression, or that the causal architecture has been fully established in contemporary athlete cohorts. Context, alternative roles, and adaptive identity development remain central empirical considerations. Brewer (1993)

Studies examining psychological responses often rely on related scales administered within the same session. Shared wording and response tendencies can inflate correlations among self-efficacy, anxiety, readiness, and perceived recovery. Some items ask directly whether the athlete expects to return, which overlaps with subsequent reported return intentions. A research design should establish discriminant validity and use independent functional measures and future observed participation wherever possible. Mechanisms such as avoidance, effort, or expectancy change should be assessed separately from both predictor and endpoint. Webster et al. (2008) Webster & Feller (2018)

When clinical studies observe a relationship between a psychological variable and outcome, several explanations compete: the variable may influence behavior, reflect underlying injury severity, respond to earlier rehabilitation success, or arise from common social causes. Theory helps name those possibilities, while temporal designs and intervention studies determine which explanations the available evidence can distinguish. The scientifically productive position is precise explanatory pluralism supported by operational definitions and transparent limits of inference. Wiese-Bjornstal et al. (1998) van Haren et al. (2025)

Evidence Hierarchy, Confounding, and Contradictory Results

Sport injury psychology integrates phenomenological accounts, cross-sectional surveys, prospective cohorts, psychometric validation, randomized interventions, systematic reviews, and professional consensus. Each supports different inferences. Qualitative interviews explain how athletes experience threats and relationships; they do not estimate treatment effectiveness. Cohorts estimate temporal associations and possible prognostic information; they remain susceptible to confounding and selection. Randomized studies can test an assigned intervention under their particular implementation conditions, but often struggle with small samples, adherence variation, and incomplete blinding. Consensus statements organize expert interpretation and should be examined for methodology rather than treated as direct experimental proof. Tranaeus et al. (2024) Maddison et al. (2012)

The most striking quantitative finding may be the limits of the quantitative evidence itself. In the 2024 ACL-RSI trajectory review, 78% of included studies were assessed at high risk of bias and certainty was described as weak or limited. In the 2025 ACL return prognosis review, the certainty of candidate prognostic factors was very low. These assessments constrain interpretation of statistically significant associations or visually compelling mean trajectories. They also warn against prescribing a universal ACL-RSI threshold as though it were independently established to prevent reinjury. Sell et al. (2024) van Haren et al. (2025)

Contradictory findings can arise from legitimate differences in injury pathways, sport demands, outcome definitions, rehabilitation systems, scale versions, or follow-up times. They can also reflect reverse causation, missing data, selective publication, or inadequate adjustment for initial injury severity. A critical synthesis should identify the design producing each result and avoid resolving contradictions by averaging concepts with different meanings. The appropriate conclusion often concerns the precise limits of evidence rather than a numerical pooled answer to a question that studies did not uniformly investigate. Ardern et al. (2011) van Haren et al. (2025)

Reproducibility, Missing Data, and Selective Sport Exposure

Athletes who are injured, stop participating, or leave rehabilitation services may be harder to recontact, increasing the possibility that follow-up samples disproportionately represent people with successful returns. Late measures of readiness can then appear high because the study retains those willing and able to continue, not solely because every athlete's psychological state improved. Selective availability of competition can similarly distort the endpoint: selection decisions made by others determine opportunities to demonstrate return. Reporting participant flow, missingness, reasons for nonreturn, and changes in sport exposure is therefore essential. Sell et al. (2024) Ardern et al. (2016)

Reinjury analyses require accounting for actual exposure. Athletes who never return cannot sustain some forms of sport-related recurrent injury, while athletes who participate intensively accumulate more opportunities for recurrence. Comparing simple proportions without exposure time may make reduced participation appear protective for reasons unrelated to recovery quality. Additionally, conditioning an analysis on having returned can create selection bias because physical capacity, readiness, coaching decisions, and access all help determine membership in the selected group. The Delaware–Oslo cohort contributes valuable observational evidence but does not abolish these general causal concerns. Grindem et al. (2016)

Reproducibility improves through preregistered hypotheses, public instruments, consistent injury and RTS definitions, detailed handling of treatment variation, and sharing anonymized analytic procedures subject to data protection. Multisite studies should report both pooled and site-specific findings to detect contextual dependence. Replication must be assessed independently of repeated citations to the same underlying cohort. When several analyses share participants, treating them as independent confirmation artificially inflates apparent confidence. van Haren et al. (2025) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

Clinical Decision Thresholds and Prediction Transportability

A prognostic model may distinguish athletes likely to resume sport without being accurate enough to dictate an individual clearance decision. Discrimination, often summarized by the area under a receiver-operating-characteristic curve, concerns relative ranking, while calibration concerns whether predicted probabilities agree with actual outcomes. Clinical usefulness also depends on the benefits and harms of false reassurance, unnecessary delay, and treatment diversion. A readiness questionnaire can provide valuable information even when its exact cut score varies across populations; interpretation should preserve the uncertainty of the model and the independent medical criteria involved. van Haren et al. (2025)

Transportability is especially uncertain when a model derived from adults following ACL reconstruction is applied to adolescent athletes, nonoperative care, contact sports, Para athletes, or neurological injury. Differences in baseline risk, opportunity to return, treatment access, and athlete goals can change both the probability of return and the role of psychological variables. Independent external validation and periodic recalibration are required before a score can be used confidently in a new setting. Even well-performing prediction does not establish that intervening on the predictor will change the outcome. Webster et al. (2008) van Haren et al. (2025)

An ideal decision study would compare outcomes under clearly specified approaches to integrating physical tests, clinician judgment, athlete preferences, and psychological measures. It would prospectively assess safe participation and subsequent welfare, rather than testing only retrospective score separation. Such evidence would answer a practical question that current associations leave unresolved: does measuring readiness and using it in a structured shared decision improve valued outcomes compared with existing care? Ardern et al. (2016) Sell et al. (2024)

Digital Monitoring, Wearable Data, and Artificial Systems

Digital questionnaires, training logs, mobile symptom reports, and wearable devices can capture rehabilitation experiences between clinic visits. They may make changes in confidence, symptoms, sleep, and activity visible over time while pairing psychological reports with physical exposure. However, sensor measurements quantify selected movement or physiological signals, not mental readiness itself. An automated index formed from movement data and questionnaire answers remains a model whose construct validity, clinical calibration, and population transportability require demonstration. Artificial systems can support data organization without acquiring independent authority to clear athletes for sport. van Haren et al. (2025) Ardern et al. (2016)

Frequent monitoring can produce useful within-person information, but it may also impose burdens, encourage self-surveillance, or threaten confidentiality. A professional athlete may respond differently when data are seen only by treating clinicians than when coaches and employers receive the same information. Ethical deployment requires explicit consent, data minimization, transparent access controls, and opportunities to correct misleading data. Questions about whether automated scores improve patient-centered outcomes call for prospective evaluation with real-world harm monitoring. Reardon et al. (2026)

Within the horizon of the Artificial Era, the substantive research question concerns the distribution of assessment and action among athletes, clinicians, institutions, and technical systems. A validated artificial predictor may assist a shared deliberation, but predictions are conditioned by training cohorts, prior selection practices, and historically available care. Biased data can reproduce inequitable patterns of access and sporting opportunity. Psychological agency therefore remains an operational matter of whose goals are represented, whose information counts, and who retains effective control over the return decision. This final conceptual application is an interpretive synthesis rather than a demonstrated new psychological mechanism. Ryan & Deci (2000) van Haren et al. (2025)

Research Priorities and Unresolved Scientific Questions

The first priority is to clarify the construct and time course of readiness beyond ACL-dominated populations. Studies should distinguish the desire to return, situational confidence, risk appraisal, avoidance, clinically significant anxiety, and task-specific competence. They should examine how these variables interact with injury pathology and clinical milestones, and test measurement invariance across age, sex, language, sporting level, and rehabilitation setting. Repeated measurement can determine whether apparent group trajectories represent within-person change or selective retention of athletes with favorable outcomes. Webster & Feller (2018) Sell et al. (2024)

The second priority concerns causal intervention research. Trials should test psychological practices with clearly defined control conditions and equal attention, preserve safe injury-specific medical treatment, and prospectively measure objective and athlete-valued endpoints. Where ethics permit, pragmatic designs can evaluate integrated assessment pathways rather than merely comparing questionnaire scores. Researchers should report potential harms, dropout, longer-term participation, and the degree to which an intervention enhances genuine choice. The pilot imagery literature and broad expert recommendations make the research questions concrete while leaving intervention certainty appropriately open. Maddison et al. (2012) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

A third priority is equitable and ecological generalization. Large samples from elite sport clinics cannot stand in for youth, community, Para sport, or people with limited rehabilitation access. Studies should measure organizational power, opportunity to return, sporting demands, exposure, personal goals, and the sustainability of participation. Prospective collaboration with athletes can refine endpoints that matter to their lives. Future models must show their usefulness under external validation, especially when artificial prediction tools are introduced into emotionally consequential clearance decisions. Reardon et al. (2026) van Haren et al. (2025)

Integrated Scientific Synthesis

Across theories and empirical designs, sport injury emerges as a changing encounter among bodily condition, personal goals, social context, and opportunities for action. The integrated response model locates appraisals, emotions, and behavior in this relationship, self-efficacy explains task-specific confidence, and self-determination research clarifies why autonomy, competence, and belonging shape the experience of return. These explanations operate at related but distinguishable levels. Their empirical value is greatest when each construct is operationalized separately and tested against future observations rather than treated as one composite of positive mentality. Wiese-Bjornstal et al. (1998) Bandura (1977) Ryan & Deci (2000)

Psychological readiness carries useful information about emotions, confidence, and anticipated risk, especially in ACL rehabilitation, and deserves attention alongside physical evaluation. Its association with participation is supported by multiple studies, while risk-of-bias assessments show that certainty concerning individual prognosis remains limited. A readiness scale is not a diagnostic test of tissue healing, a measure of injury severity, or a general medical clearance instrument. Ethical return decisions therefore combine injury-specific clinical assessments, progressive task exposure, athlete preferences, and transparent communication. Ardern et al. (2013; cohort) Sell et al. (2024) van Haren et al. (2025)

The strongest cross-disciplinary conclusion is that the quality of return matters alongside whether return occurs. Sustainability, safety, psychological well-being, freedom from coercion, and alignment with individual goals can diverge from a simple competitive attendance measure. Scientific progress depends on repeated observations, credible causal designs, explicit consideration of selection and exposure, and outcome definitions that respect different sporting lives. The 2024 psychology-of-injury consensus and the 2026 IOC mental health consensus provide complementary scholarly perspectives for developing this agenda. Tranaeus et al. (2024) Reardon et al. (2026)

Conclusion

Psychological responses to sport injury encompass appraisals of threat and loss, emotional adjustments, confidence, perceived competence, motivation, relationships, and behavioral choices unfolding throughout rehabilitation and beyond the first sporting return. These processes are shaped by specific injury pathology and the athlete's personal and institutional circumstances. Historical models supplied a dynamic account of appraisal, emotion, and behavior; contemporary research adds prospective cohorts, standardized readiness instruments, intervention studies, and expert consensus. Together they establish the relevance of psychological functioning to return decisions while requiring careful distinction among association, prognostic information, and evidence of intervention effects. Wiese-Bjornstal et al. (1998) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

ACL research offers the most developed measurement tradition, particularly through the ACL-RSI and related return outcome studies. Yet systematic evaluations reveal marked heterogeneity, high risk of bias, and weak or very low certainty in several important analyses. The evidence supports comprehensive assessment and further validation rather than a universal cut score or simplified promise that increasing confidence prevents injury. Injury-specific safety criteria, staged rehabilitation, professional responsibility, and the athlete's autonomous preferences must remain visible in both clinical interpretation and research design. Sell et al. (2024) van Haren et al. (2025) Ardern et al. (2016)

The next generation of research should expand beyond knee reconstruction; follow psychological and physical recovery longitudinally; compare properly controlled, athlete-centered interventions; assess sustainable exposure and mental health; and investigate the consequences of social power, unequal access, and digital monitoring. Return-to-sport readiness is best understood as one component in a multidimensional process of making a meaningful and medically informed decision about sporting participation. Successful scholarship advances when its constructs, evidence limitations, and ethically significant outcomes are explicitly articulated. Reardon et al. (2026) Tranaeus et al. (2024)

References

  • Ardern, C. L., Webster, K. E., Taylor, N. F., & Feller, J. A. (2011). Return to sport following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction surgery: A systematic review and meta-analysis of the state of play. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 45(7), 596–606. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsm.2010.076364
  • Ardern, C. L., Taylor, N. F., Feller, J. A., & Webster, K. E. (2012). Fear of re-injury in people who have returned to sport following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction surgery. Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport, 15(6), 488–495. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsams.2012.03.015
  • Ardern, C. L., Taylor, N. F., Feller, J. A., Whitehead, T. S., & Webster, K. E. (2013). Psychological responses matter in returning to preinjury level of sport after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction surgery. The American Journal of Sports Medicine, 41(7), 1549–1558. https://doi.org/10.1177/0363546513489284
  • Ardern, C. L., Taylor, N. F., Feller, J. A., & Webster, K. E. (2013). A systematic review of the psychological factors associated with returning to sport following injury. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 47(17), 1120–1126. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2012-091203
  • Ardern, C. L., Glasgow, P., Schneiders, A., Witvrouw, E., Clarsen, B., Cools, A., Gojanovic, B., Griffin, S., Khan, K. M., Moksnes, H., Mutch, S. A., Phillips, N., Reurink, G., Sadler, R., Grävare Silbernagel, K., Thorborg, K., Wangensteen, A., Wilk, K. E., & Bizzini, M. (2016). 2016 consensus statement on return to sport from the First World Congress in Sports Physical Therapy, Bern. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 50(14), 853–864. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2016-096278
  • Bandura, A. (1977). Self-efficacy: Toward a unifying theory of behavioral change. Psychological Review, 84(2), 191–215. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.84.2.191
  • Brewer, B. W. (1993). Self-identity and specific vulnerability to depressed mood. Journal of Personality, 61(3), 343–364. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-6494.1993.tb00284.x
  • Cupal, D. D., & Brewer, B. W. (2001). Effects of relaxation and guided imagery on knee strength, reinjury anxiety, and pain following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Rehabilitation Psychology, 46(1), 28–43. https://doi.org/10.1037/0090-5550.46.1.28
  • Grindem, H., Snyder-Mackler, L., Moksnes, H., Engebretsen, L., & Risberg, M. A. (2016). Simple decision rules can reduce reinjury risk by 84% after ACL reconstruction: The Delaware-Oslo ACL cohort study. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 50(13), 804–808. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2016-096031
  • Ivarsson, A., Johnson, U., Andersen, M. B., Tranaeus, U., Stenling, A., & Lindwall, M. (2017). Psychosocial factors and sport injuries: Meta-analyses for prediction and prevention. Sports Medicine, 47(2), 353–365. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40279-016-0578-x
  • Kvist, J., Ek, A., Sporrstedt, K., & Good, L. (2005). Fear of re-injury: A hindrance for returning to sports after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy, 13(5), 393–397. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00167-004-0591-8
  • Lazarus, R. S., & Folkman, S. (1984). Stress, appraisal, and coping. Springer Publishing Company. https://books.google.com/books?id=8_F9AAAAMAAJ
  • Maddison, R., Prapavessis, H., Clatworthy, M., Hall, C., Foley, L., Harper, T., Cupal, D., & Brewer, B. (2012). Guided imagery to improve functional outcomes post-anterior cruciate ligament repair: Randomized-controlled pilot trial. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports, 22(6), 816–821. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1600-0838.2011.01325.x
  • Patricios, J. S., Schneider, K. J., Dvorak, J., Ahmed, O. H., Blauwet, C., Cantu, R. C., Davis, G. A., Echemendia, R. J., Makdissi, M., McNamee, M., Broglio, S., Emery, C. A., Feddermann-Demont, N., Fuller, G. W., Giza, C. C., Guskiewicz, K. M., Hainline, B., Iverson, G. L., Kutcher, J. S., . . . Meeuwisse, W. (2023). Consensus statement on concussion in sport: The 6th International Conference on Concussion in Sport–Amsterdam, October 2022. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 57(11), 695–711. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2023-106898
  • Podlog, L., & Eklund, R. C. (2006). A longitudinal investigation of competitive athletes' return to sport following serious injury. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 18(1), 44–68. https://doi.org/10.1080/10413200500471319
  • Podlog, L., & Eklund, R. C. (2010). Returning to competition after a serious injury: The role of self-determination. Journal of Sports Sciences, 28(8), 819–831. https://doi.org/10.1080/02640411003792729
  • Reardon, C. L., Gouttebarge, V., Kroshus-Havril, E., Miller Aron, C., Bahr, R., Blauwet, C., Castaldelli-Maia, J. M., Cheng, C., Currie, A., Derevensky, J. L., Edwards, C., Fussek, S., Gorczynski, P., Grandner, M., Han, D. H., Hitchcock, M. E., Lu, F., Massey, A., McDuff, D., . . . Hainline, B. (2026). Mental health in elite athletes: International Olympic Committee consensus statement (2026). British Journal of Sports Medicine, 60(15), 1083–1130. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2025-111514
  • Ryan, R. M., & Deci, E. L. (2000). Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social development, and well-being. American Psychologist, 55(1), 68–78. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.55.1.68
  • Sell, T. C., Zerega, R., King, V., Reiter, C. R., Wrona, H., Bullock, G. S., Mills, N., Räisänen, A., Ledbetter, L., Collins, G. S., Kvist, J., Filbay, S. R., & Losciale, J. M. (2024). Anterior cruciate ligament return to sport after injury scale (ACL-RSI) scores over time after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: A systematic review with meta-analysis. Sports Medicine - Open, 10, Article 49. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40798-024-00712-w
  • Tranaeus, U., Gledhill, A., Johnson, U., Podlog, L., Wadey, R., Wiese Bjornstal, D., & Ivarsson, A. (2024). 50 years of research on the psychology of sport injury: A consensus statement. Sports Medicine, 54(7), 1733–1748. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40279-024-02045-w
  • van Haren, I. E. P., van der Worp, M. P., van Rijn, R., Stubbe, J. H., van Cingel, R. E. H., Verbeek, A. L. M., van der Wees, P. J., & Staal, J. B. (2025). Return to sport after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction - Prognostic factors and prognostic models: A systematic review. Annals of Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine, 68(3), Article 101921. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rehab.2024.101921
  • Webster, K. E., Feller, J. A., & Lambros, C. (2008). Development and preliminary validation of a scale to measure the psychological impact of returning to sport following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction surgery. Physical Therapy in Sport, 9(1), 9–15. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ptsp.2007.09.003
  • Webster, K. E., & Feller, J. A. (2018). Development and validation of a short version of the anterior cruciate ligament return to sport after injury (ACL-RSI) scale. Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine, 6(4), Article 2325967118763763. https://doi.org/10.1177/2325967118763763
  • Wiese-Bjornstal, D. M., Smith, A. M., Shaffer, S. M., & Morrey, M. A. (1998). An integrated model of response to sport injury: Psychological and sociological dynamics. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 10(1), 46–69. https://doi.org/10.1080/10413209808406377