Psychology by BogdanovaThe Encyclopedia of Psychology for the Artificial Era

RESEARCH DOSSIER

Psychological Construct Systems and Conceptual Proliferation

Abstract. Psychological construct systems organize the concepts by which science describes, measures, and explains human and artificial psychological phenomena. Conceptual proliferation emerges when expanding terms and putatively novel constructs outpace clarification of boundaries, relations, and empirical differentiation. This fundamental critical narrative monograph examines the historical foundations of construct individuation, jingle and jangle fallacies, semantic drift, construct reification, and theoretical underdetermination. It evaluates concept-definition procedures, multitrait–multimethod evidence, latent-variable models, incremental validity under measurement error, empirical scale audits, and a meta-analytic case from achievement-goal research. Additional analyses examine sibling personality constructs, clinical categories, organizational concepts, and the transfer of psychological vocabulary to artificial cognition. The synthesis derives an evidence-indexed procedure for mapping, comparing, and revising construct systems while distinguishing methodological proposals from established empirical results. This is a critical narrative synthesis of published research, not a preregistered systematic review or an original experiment.

Keywords: psychological constructs; construct systems; conceptual proliferation; construct redundancy; jingle-jangle fallacies; conceptual individuation; scientific taxonomy; nomological networks; construct definition; discriminant validity; sibling constructs; multitrait–multimethod; semantic drift; measurement error; theory building; psychometrics; evidence synthesis; artificial cognition

The Research Object: Psychological Constructs as Scientific Units

Psychological construct systems comprise the concepts, definitions, operational indicators, and hypothesized relations through which a research community organizes knowledge about experience and behavior. A construct may denote an individual difference, a process, a response pattern, a relational property, or an explanatory mechanism. Conceptual proliferation occurs when a field continually introduces labels and purportedly distinct constructs faster than it establishes their boundaries and empirical relations. Proliferation may reflect discovery, disciplinary differentiation, terminological competition, or unresolved conceptual translation. Its scientific significance depends on whether additional distinctions support more discriminating evidence and cumulative explanation Cronbach & Meehl (1955) Podsakoff et al. (2016).

The unit of analysis here is a system of constructs rather than the validity of any one questionnaire. A construct system contains more than a glossary: definitions specify observable referents, causal hypotheses, exclusions, historical provenance, and rules for relating concepts across instruments and studies. Two scales can have dissimilar names and nevertheless sample nearly the same behavioral domain; two measures with the same name can depend on different processes or contexts. The inferential problem therefore includes concepts, empirical indicators, study designs, and practical uses Lawson & Robins (2021) Hanfstingl et al. (2024). The joint testing standards likewise treat interpretation and intended use as claims requiring systematically accumulated validity evidence AERA, APA, & NCME (2014).

This investigation is a critical narrative synthesis of primary theoretical works, methodological proposals, selected empirical audits, a domain-specific meta-analysis, and recent computational proposals. It traces historical foundations, analyzes conceptual fragmentation, compares assessment procedures, and identifies strategies for cumulative research. It does not present a new experimental sample, a preregistered systematic search, a pooled effect estimate, or a quantitative census of psychology's constructs. Arguments about proposed repair procedures are evaluated as methodological recommendations until prospective comparative testing establishes their performance Fried (2020) Wulff & Mata (2026).

Constructs, Concepts, Variables, and Operational Indicators

A concept supplies a category of thought; a scientific construct adds commitments about its domain and empirical implications. A variable is a formal representation of variation among observations, and an operational indicator is the rule by which observations enter an analysis. These levels interact, but one does not determine the others automatically. A single response-time difference can index several hypothesized processes, depending on task structure; a single construct can be examined through multiple tasks, ratings, interviews, or behavioral samples. Construct proliferation often arises when operational novelty is mistaken for conceptual distinctness Cronbach & Meehl (1955) Clark & Watson (2019).

Operational definitions enable repeatability because another investigator can reproduce the recording procedure. Theoretical definitions support explanation because they identify what the procedure is meant to reveal. When a term is defined solely as the score produced by a new scale, a label becomes inseparable from its instrument; researchers may subsequently present the instrument's correlations as evidence that its nominal construct exists independently. The circularity is clearest when item content, domain definition, and theoretical predictions are created from the same intuitions without independent tests Borsboom et al. (2004) Cornelissen et al. (2026).

A construct system can instead be documented as a mapping from phenomena to theoretical claims, from claims to measurement models, and from those models to observations. Each map entry should indicate the relevant setting, unit of analysis, population, time scale, and known competing explanations. Such documentation allows researchers to distinguish a change of vocabulary from a change in what is being measured. It also makes explicit whether a newly introduced term names an attribute, a mechanism, a descriptive family, or a context-specific index Podsakoff et al. (2016) Kane (2013).

Historical Foundations of Conceptual Individuation

The modern problem has deep roots in psychometrics and philosophy of science. Early critiques of psychological labels warned against assuming that linguistic identity established empirical identity. Twentieth-century testing then made the interpretation of unobservable attributes a central scientific question. In their 1955 analysis, Cronbach and Meehl described construct validation as an ongoing inquiry into a nomological network: concepts achieve testable meaning through relations among theoretical propositions and observables. Their framework already implies that rival uses of the same term may constitute different scientific claims Cronbach & Meehl (1955) Hanfstingl et al. (2024).

Campbell and Fiske's 1959 multitrait–multimethod program introduced a distinctive empirical discipline for comparing constructs. Measurements intended to represent one trait should show convergence across genuinely different methods, while measurements representing distinct traits should display meaningful discrimination. This approach connected conceptual individuation to data while acknowledging shared method variance. It supplied a framework for asking whether two ostensibly separate psychological attributes could be discriminated independently of the instruments used to assess them Campbell & Fiske (1959).

Subsequent accounts enlarged the interpretive frame. Messick emphasized the integration of evidence supporting score meaning, Borsboom and colleagues pressed a causal account of the attribute–score relation, and Kane treated validation as an argument for specified interpretations and uses. These are different accounts of what evidence establishes; collectively they show why construct identity cannot be settled through terminology, reliability, or a single favorable correlation. The history is one of competing explanatory commitments as well as improving techniques Messick (1995) Borsboom et al. (2004) Kane (2013).

Jingle, Jangle, and the Limits of Verbal Equivalence

The jingle fallacy occurs when researchers infer sameness from a common name although the referents or operations differ. The jangle fallacy occurs when distinct names invite an inference of difference although the underlying domains or operationalizations are substantially similar. These are diagnostic descriptions of reasoning errors rather than algorithms for classifying every pair of constructs. Shared labels can legitimately cover related variants, and distinct labels can mark important levels or temporal scales; the task is to identify what claims the labels authorize Hanfstingl et al. (2024) Lawson & Robins (2021).

A name-comparison method cannot by itself recover empirical equivalence. The term resilience, for example, may refer to a trajectory of preserved functioning after adversity, a trait score, or a collection of resources that predict adaptation. The three usages can overlap without being logically identical. A discrepancy between results labeled resilience can follow from differences in adversity definition, sampling interval, outcome selection, or measurement model. Stronger analyses retain these methodological distinctions and compare the empirical propositions that each definition generates Podsakoff et al. (2016) Wulff & Mata (2026).

Lawson and Robins describe sibling constructs as conceptually and empirically connected attributes that still may deserve separate treatment. Their case study of self-esteem and grandiose narcissism illustrates why the redundancy question has degrees rather than a simple yes/no answer. Conceptual overlap, indicator overlap, antecedents, outcomes, causal roles, and boundaries can diverge. A rigorous comparison can preserve related constructs when their distinct predictions survive appropriate measurement controls and independent samples Lawson & Robins (2021) Hodson (2021).

A practical jingle–jangle audit starts with a deliberately narrow question: under which conditions would two proposed constructs generate different empirical expectations? The investigator records definitions without their labels, compares item and task content, and asks independent reviewers to classify the descriptions before learning the authors' preferred terminology. This procedure can reveal shared wording and contested meaning, but semantic similarity is only the first evidentiary layer. Subsequent analyses should compare latent structure, external correlates, experimental sensitivity, and prediction in independent samples. Researchers must also consider whether observed differences arise from unequal measurement error or distinct response contexts. An apparent redundancy finding should be reported with its boundary conditions, because two measures that correlate strongly in one population may still respond differently to an intervention. The aim is a reproducible distinction test, not automatic consolidation of every neighboring term into one category. Campbell & Fiske (1959) Flake et al. (2017) Clark & Watson (2019)

The Architecture of a Construct System

A useful construct system can be represented as a layered graph. One layer records lexical labels and historical aliases; a second records explicit definitions and dimensions; a third records operationalizations, item content, tasks, and response processes; a fourth records expected relations with mechanisms, predictors, and outcomes; and a fifth records the relevant evidence and its uncertainty. Such a graph supports auditing without implying that graph proximity proves psychological identity. Networks of references and semantic similarity are evidence about scholarly discourse, while construct relations require empirical and theoretical evaluation Hanfstingl et al. (2024) Wulff & Mata (2026).

The principal links between nodes include identity claims, hierarchical inclusion, partial overlap, causal connection, developmental transformation, contextual restriction, and disputed association. These link types should remain distinct. If a broad construct contains a narrower facet, their high correlation may be expected and conceptually informative; treating this as a failed discriminant-validity test would erase the hierarchy. If two purportedly independent causes predict the same response because both measures contain similar wording, the observed association may be a method artifact rather than a genuine relation among attributes Campbell & Fiske (1959) Clark & Watson (2019).

A mature taxonomy needs revision rules. New evidence may establish a separate construct, collapse redundant categories, split a broad category into demonstrably distinct mechanisms, or reveal that a category is descriptive rather than explanatory. Every revision affects interpretation of prior findings and should preserve an explicit correspondence table between the previous vocabulary and the new one. The resulting system supports historical continuity while making scientific revision possible. This is a methodological proposal grounded in validation and concept-definition research, rather than a taxonomy already validated for all psychological subfields Podsakoff et al. (2016) Fried (2020).

A construct system can be represented as a set of claims that connect definitions, observable indicators, antecedent conditions, predicted consequences, and relations to neighboring concepts. A definition gains scientific value when these connections expose it to possible correction. Two labels may describe a common mechanism while differing in historical convention; alternatively, identical labels may conceal incompatible causal accounts. Researchers can make these possibilities inspectable by publishing a concept map in which every edge names its supporting evidence and its inferential status. Operational indicators should be attached to specific interpretive claims rather than treated as universal proxies for an entire construct. Where the empirical literature is inconclusive, the map should record competing specifications and the observations that would distinguish them. This architecture supports cumulative comparison across laboratories while preserving warranted distinctions in purpose, level of explanation, and population. It extends the traditional nomological-network and validity traditions into an explicit, revisable research object. Cronbach & Meehl (1955) Borsboom et al. (2004) Messick (1995)

Why New Constructs Multiply

Conceptual differentiation is an ordinary result of scientific inquiry. New experiments reveal distinctions that older vocabularies conceal, while new populations and measurement technologies expose previously unmeasured variation. The proliferation problem begins when differentiation is asserted without a transparent account of the closest existing constructs, its evidential advantage, and its implications for prediction. Similar conceptual structures may then accumulate in separate literatures under incompatible names. A useful diagnosis asks whether apparent novelty yields a defensible boundary and a testable increase in explanatory specificity Podsakoff et al. (2016) Cornelissen et al. (2026).

Publication incentives and specialization may reinforce these processes. New names can mark research programs, attract attention, and structure distinct review communities. These social explanations are plausible mechanisms, but their relative contributions require direct historical and bibliometric evidence; a correlation between new labels and publication output would not establish a specific incentive pathway. Scientific reform must consequently address conceptual practices and empirical comparisons, rather than merely discourage naming. A justified new distinction can prevent serious conceptual error in precisely the cases where a coarse inherited taxonomy is inadequate Hartman (2026) Fried (2020).

Construct proliferation is also cumulative: a new scale cites an older scale as an imperfect predecessor, introduces an altered item pool, and then defines a supposedly independent variable by the new score. Later reviews may treat these nominally distinct scales as interchangeable predictors, further obscuring their genealogy. A documented genealogy of definitions and operationalizations is therefore a basic research instrument. It identifies what has been inherited, what was revised, and which differences were supported by new evidence rather than inferred from presentation or authorship Flake et al. (2017) Hanfstingl et al. (2024).

The production of new terminology can be investigated as an institutional process with observable incentives. Researchers may introduce a label to organize a neglected mechanism, clarify the scope of an inherited term, identify a new level of analysis, or distinguish a population-specific phenomenon. Each motive yields a different evidentiary obligation. A proposed new mechanism calls for discriminating predictions; a new descriptive label calls for a clear mapping to existing vocabulary; a new measurement context requires evidence about generalization and score interpretation. Journal databases and preregistration archives allow investigators to reconstruct whether the claimed novelty actually preceded the measurement and whether conflicting definitions appeared in parallel. This historical reconstruction also helps separate genuine theoretical progress from successive renamings of nearly identical item sets. Scientific priority should depend on explanatory and empirical gain, with the genealogy of a term preserved even when later evidence motivates its revision. Cronbach & Meehl (1955) Podsakoff et al. (2016) Fiedler (2017)

Semantic Drift and Divergent Research Traditions

The same label can acquire different referents as it migrates among clinical, social, developmental, organizational, and cognitive research. What begins as an everyday description may become a trait, a state, a dimension, a functional mechanism, or a composite risk index. Each transformation introduces assumptions about temporal stability, causal interpretation, and measurement. Semantic drift may therefore produce a jingle problem even when the successive uses are historically intelligible. Editorial comparisons should record original definitions and operational changes rather than privilege the latest or most cited usage Lawson & Robins (2021) Hartman (2026).

Disciplinary communities may also discover related patterns independently. A term from educational motivation and another from personality research may refer to overlapping propensities while predicting different kinds of outcomes. Cross-domain translation requires examining conceptual intension, the set of relevant cases, measurement operations, and the theoretical function of each label. No one feature establishes complete equivalence. Similar item wording is important evidence of overlap, but the surrounding task, context, and causal assumptions can alter what a response means Podsakoff et al. (2016) Hulleman et al. (2010).

Translation tables can preserve multiple legitimate uses while identifying where findings can be compared. Each table should specify the source definition, target definition, common observable domain, exclusions, proposed bridging assumptions, and empirical tests of the bridge. Researchers can then decide whether evidence supports exact identity, a family resemblance, hierarchical nesting, conditional overlap, or unresolved correspondence. Such a procedure turns disputes about terminology into propositions that can be revised by data and used across research traditions Cronbach & Meehl (1955) Hanfstingl et al. (2024).

The Problem of Construct Reification

Reification occurs when a convenient descriptive category is treated as a proven causal entity because it is named, scored, or statistically modeled. Factor labels can be particularly tempting: a cluster of correlated questionnaire items receives a name, and a subsequent causal narrative treats that factor as an independent force producing the observed answers. Factor models can describe covariance well without specifying the psychological process that generated it. Excellent fit alone therefore warrants much less ontological confidence than explanatory language often implies Fried (2020) Borsboom et al. (2004).

The risk also appears in composite measures. A score that aggregates several behaviors may be useful for prediction even when its components have heterogeneous causes. Treating its aggregate label as a single latent cause can conceal the heterogeneity on which successful intervention depends. Conversely, a genuine latent attribute could generate effects that differ across tasks because of response constraints. Model selection must follow articulated causal and measurement assumptions rather than a preference for either homogeneous or heterogeneous representations Clark & Watson (2019) Fried (2020).

A coherent research language distinguishes descriptive summary, statistical parameter, latent psychological attribute, and proposed causal mechanism. Each can be scientifically useful when the inferential steps are explicit. The additional word construct should confer no automatic claim of existence or independence. Cornelissen and colleagues' analysis of novelty, self-reference, reification, and analogy fallacies offers a recent argument-based perspective on such inferential weaknesses; the paper's management-research context must be considered before generalizing its examples to psychology Cornelissen et al. (2026) Kane (2013).

Operationalization, Item Wording, and Common Method Variance

Construct overlap may be manufactured at the measurement stage. Two scales can sample the same verbal behaviors, ask similarly valenced questions, or share a response format, creating substantial statistical overlap independently of the intended theories. A high correlation may thus reflect substantive proximity, common method effects, or both. The multitrait–multimethod approach separates some of these sources by crossing traits with methods; its value lies in making alternative explanations observable, not in providing a universal numerical threshold for distinctness Campbell & Fiske (1959) Flake et al. (2017).

Researchers can audit item-level semantic overlap, response processes, task demands, rater effects, and situational constraints before comparing latent correlations. A self-report measure of self-regulation may share items about perseverance with a grit measure; an experimental attention index may share processing-speed demands with working-memory tasks. This does not establish identity between the full theoretical constructs. It establishes a need for explicit modeling of shared indicators and for experiments that vary theoretically relevant demands while controlling nuisance pathways Clark & Watson (2019) Lawson & Robins (2021).

Measure construction must also distinguish a reflective model, in which a proposed attribute gives rise to indicators, from a composite index that is defined by its components. Internal consistency has different meanings under these assumptions. High alpha can coexist with a narrow or redundant item set, while a deliberately heterogeneous index may have useful predictive content with limited interitem correlations. The empirical audit by Hussey and Hughes demonstrates the limits of treating internal consistency as a sufficient validation practice, although its particular instruments and sampling frame define the bounds of that evidence Hussey & Hughes (2020) Borsboom et al. (2004).

The Problem of Weak Theoretical Predictions

A taxonomy becomes harder to evaluate when each construct is associated only with broad, nondirectional expectations: positive things correlate with other positive things, or a new dimension predicts a favorable outcome. Such results are compatible with many competing interpretations and may strengthen a literature without clarifying its internal conceptual boundaries. Diagnostic evidence instead requires outcomes or interventions on which competing constructs predict observably different patterns. The relevant question is which possible observation would challenge the proposed distinction Fiedler (2017) Fried (2020).

Theoretical accounts should specify what a construct explains, by what mechanism, over which temporal horizon, and under which boundary conditions. For example, a state construct may change following an experimental manipulation while a purportedly stable disposition may influence the response to that manipulation. These differences provide an experimental route to disentangle superficially similar questionnaires. The predictions must be fixed before interpreting the outcome, since a flexible post hoc narrative can accommodate either similarity or difference without identifying a decisive test Cronbach & Meehl (1955) Fiedler (2017).

Formalization can strengthen these comparisons by requiring explicit assumptions and generating numerical or qualitative predictions. Yet mathematical precision cannot rescue an ambiguously defined target. A model may fit a dataset while its parameters map uncertainly to psychological processes, and several mutually incompatible theories may produce similar observational patterns. Formal and conceptual testing should therefore proceed together, with independent evidence for the model-to-construct interpretation and transparent attention to underdetermination Fried (2020) Borsboom et al. (2004).

Weak prediction permits the same observation to support several incompatible construct stories. For example, a positive association between a questionnaire score and task performance may be consistent with a proposed causal mechanism, a shared response tendency, a third variable, or overlapping item content. A discriminating theory specifies the intervention or conditional pattern under which these explanations would diverge. Such specification should precede inspection of the final data, especially when many operationalizations are available. Researchers can supplement conventional model fit with parameter-recovery analysis, negative controls, preregistered contrasts, and out-of-sample prediction. A failure of discrimination is informative: it identifies which theoretical commitments remain underdetermined instead of encouraging another name for an already ambiguous result. Theory quality should therefore be assessed by the risk it takes in forecasting differences among alternatives, as well as by its ability to organize established findings. Fiedler (2017) Fried (2020) Westfall & Yarkoni (2016)

Concept Mapping and Definition Comparison

Systematic construct mapping begins with an explicit corpus: theoretical definitions, instruments, populations, citation histories, and the empirical claims each term was used to support. A researcher codes definitional content, necessary and typical features, levels of abstraction, boundary conditions, and indicators. The next stage identifies likely aliases, broader–narrower relations, and apparent contradictions. This is a form of structured evidence extraction, not a conclusive test that two psychological attributes are identical. The literature on disciplined concept definitions makes the first stage reproducible in principle, while specification analysis shows why research practices must accompany the words Podsakoff et al. (2016) Hanfstingl et al. (2024).

Independent coders can compare definitions without knowledge of hypotheses or scale correlations, reducing the risk that a preferred statistical result drives conceptual classification. They should preserve disagreements and report coding guidance, examples, and interrater agreement. The resulting map can reveal, for example, when a supposedly novel trait contains all the necessary features of a previously named trait or when similarly labeled tasks encode incompatible cognitive operations. Disagreements may arise because constructs are genuinely multidimensional, dynamically constituted, or sensitive to context; classification should allow these possibilities Lawson & Robins (2021) Hartman (2026).

A mapping exercise gains scientific strength when it produces a list of testable contrasts. Each proposed distinction should be translated into observable predictions: divergent developmental courses, differential effects of an intervention, changes across contexts, unique information about external outcomes, or distinct process signatures. Where definitions do not generate distinct observable expectations, the proper conclusion is limited: existing theory has not yet supplied a reason to expect empirical separation. This conclusion can guide research without prematurely claiming metaphysical identity Fiedler (2017) Cronbach & Meehl (1955).

Convergent and Discriminant Evidence Across Methods

Convergent validity asks whether indicators intended to represent the same attribute support a coherent interpretation across adequately distinct methods. Discriminant validity asks whether the evidence separates constructs that theoretical accounts treat as different. Campbell and Fiske's multitrait–multimethod design was developed precisely because both questions must be assessed under shared and separate measurement conditions. If the same questionnaire style dominates a comparison, observed convergence may contain more method variance than the construct argument acknowledges Campbell & Fiske (1959) Messick (1995).

Modern latent-variable analyses can estimate relationships after accounting for some measurement error and structured method effects. Such analyses are useful for challenging claims of separability when two sets of indicators appear to estimate nearly the same dimension. They do not establish that identical latent correlations always correspond to identical causal processes: equivalent covariance patterns can emerge from different generating structures, and broad factors may contain legitimate lower-level facets. Interpretation requires theory-driven constraints and tests outside the fitted correlation structure Hodson (2021) Fried (2020).

Discriminant checks also depend on model assumptions and estimator choices. The heterotrait–monotrait ratio proposed by Henseler and colleagues is one operational assessment within variance-based structural equation modeling, with its own assumptions and empirical settings. Passing a threshold is not a universal certificate of ontological independence. Evidence is more persuasive when conceptual distinctions, item content, multiple methods, replicated structure, and external predictions converge, with the observed pattern stable across reasonable analytic specifications Henseler et al. (2015) Lawson & Robins (2021).

Multimethod evidence is most valuable when its measures differ in the nuisance processes that could create an artificial correlation. A self-report scale and a second self-report scale may agree because respondents use stable response styles or because their items repeat similar phrases. An observed behavior, a time-sampled report, an informant judgment, and a structured experimental manipulation provide a broader test, although every method introduces its own sources of error. Evaluation should specify the trait-by-method structure and compare predictions for both convergent and discriminant relationships. When relevant, multilevel analysis can distinguish individual differences from within-person dynamics; measurement-invariance analysis can evaluate whether comparisons across groups or time retain the same meaning. The result is a validity argument connected to particular claims, not a single coefficient that licenses a general assertion of construct uniqueness. Campbell & Fiske (1959) Messick (1995) Vandenberg & Lance (2000)

Incremental Validity and Measurement Error

Researchers often argue that a newly named construct earns its place because it predicts an outcome after controlling for a closely related predecessor. The analysis can be informative, but regression at the level of imperfect observed scores creates a major inferential problem. The control variable may contain substantial measurement error, leaving residual variance associated with the target construct even if the underlying attributes are the same. An apparently unique association can therefore be a statistical artifact rather than proof of conceptual distinctness Westfall & Yarkoni (2016).

Westfall and Yarkoni used analytic derivations and Monte Carlo simulations to demonstrate that common incremental-validity regressions can yield severe false-positive problems under realistic reliability conditions. Their evidence supports a methodological warning: larger datasets alone do not eliminate biases generated by mismeasured controls, and significance does not identify an independent psychological cause. Appropriate latent-variable approaches and sensitivity analyses can improve inference when their models are justified. The same logic applies to nominally distinct scales that share wording, response tendencies, or latent determinants Westfall & Yarkoni (2016) Clark & Watson (2019).

An incremental-validity program should state what 'incremental' means: better out-of-sample prediction, additional explanation of a mechanism, a distinct intervention target, improved decision accuracy, or added coverage of a theoretical domain. These claims are different. A new short scale can improve prediction through superior reliability while representing the same attribute; a distinct psychological mechanism may contribute little to a particular outcome. Evaluation should report reliability, cross-validation, model uncertainty, and the theoretical consequence of the observed difference Kane (2013) Fiedler (2017).

Incremental prediction is meaningful only relative to a justified comparison set. Adding a new construct to a statistical model can increase apparent fit even when the new measure merely rephrases an existing instrument or captures an omitted source of method variance. A rigorous test identifies the decision or explanatory outcome in advance, includes the strongest established competitor, and evaluates improvement in independent data. Effect sizes, uncertainty intervals, calibration, and the consequences of different scoring decisions should accompany any claim of incremental validity. Researchers should also report whether evidence survives correction for measurement error and whether improvements extend beyond a single convenience sample. For practical applications, the cost and interpretability of collecting a new measure belong in the assessment. A small statistical gain that cannot change inference or action provides a different justification for construct proliferation than a stable, replicable distinction with clear theoretical implications. Clark & Watson (2019) Kane (2013) Westfall & Yarkoni (2016)

Empirical Audits of Measurement Practice

Evidence about construct proliferation must be linked to actual research behavior. Flake, Pek, and Hehman reviewed construct-validation practices in a sample of articles from a major social-personality journal and reported insufficient validity evidence for both established and author-developed scales. They observed that coefficient alpha was often the main reported psychometric statistic. This is an audit of practice, not a census of all psychology, yet it identifies a concrete pathway through which new labels can enter published models without corresponding evidence of distinctness Flake et al. (2017).

Hussey and Hughes subsequently analyzed a large collection of experimental sessions involving widely used social-personality measures. Their investigation included 15 questionnaires and 26 scales and demonstrated how conclusions based largely on internal consistency could diverge from conclusions based on structural examinations. Because the sample consisted of selected instruments and datasets, its quantitative results should not be transferred to the entire discipline. Its significance is the documented gap between routine measurement checks and substantive validation of interpreted scores Hussey & Hughes (2020).

These audits support reform at the reporting and evaluation stages. Authors should disclose item sets, justify the relation between indicators and constructs, test structural assumptions where appropriate, and address closest conceptual neighbors. Reviewers should ask whether a proposed new variable captures a genuinely additional phenomenon. Such procedures may expose redundancy, but none guarantees conceptual consolidation: expert judgment about theoretical scope remains essential, and prospective comparisons of alternative audit protocols are still needed Flake et al. (2017) Lawson & Robins (2021).

The Role and Limits of Meta-Analysis

Meta-analysis can expose terminological fragmentation when multiple studies purportedly examine the same phenomenon through differently labeled measures. Coding the definitions and operationalizations separately permits an assessment of whether observed effect heterogeneity tracks conceptual differences. However, a pooled association can conceal opposing relationships or combine incommensurable constructs. Careful construct harmonization is a prerequisite to meaningful synthesis, not an optional cosmetic procedure after an effect estimate has been calculated Hulleman et al. (2010) Hanfstingl et al. (2024).

The achievement-goal literature offers a consequential example. Hulleman, Schrager, Bodmann, and Harackiewicz conducted a meta-analytic review explicitly examining whether measures with similar or different names represented equivalent constructs. The research demonstrates how an empirical synthesis can investigate construct identity rather than merely summarize outcomes. Its conclusions concern the achievement-goal measures and samples reviewed; they do not establish how frequently jingle or jangle errors occur across unrelated areas of psychology Hulleman et al. (2010).

A rigorous synthesis should prespecify its target constructs, code exact item content and time frames where available, distinguish independent samples from overlapping datasets, and investigate moderators at the level of theory, instrument, and design. When the source reports do not permit defensible harmonization, a structured narrative comparison may be more informative than a pooled coefficient. This monograph follows that principle: it compares different kinds of evidence without claiming a systematic meta-analysis of the whole psychological literature Hanfstingl et al. (2024) Nosek et al. (2022).

Achievement Goals as a Test of Conceptual Harmonization

Achievement-goal theory provides a well-documented arena in which different labels, item definitions, and research traditions can complicate comparison. Measures may differ in the emphasis placed on improving competence, demonstrating competence, or avoiding failure, even when their headings look similar. When labels are used as though they identify fixed psychological dimensions independent of question wording, conclusions about motivation can appear inconsistent for reasons partly traceable to measurement. The 2010 meta-analytic review by Hulleman and colleagues directly examined the correspondence between achievement-goal concepts and measures Hulleman et al. (2010).

The lesson extends beyond education. A synthesis that treats mastery, performance, approach, and avoidance terms as stable categories must ask what the actual respondents were asked, in what context, and over what time frame. Two items may both concern achievement while eliciting different reference standards or social comparisons. A shared factor label cannot settle those discrepancies. Divergent predictions about achievement, persistence, or affect become informative only after researchers clarify the score interpretation and whether the intended theoretical dimension was adequately sampled Hulleman et al. (2010) Cronbach & Meehl (1955).

A better harmonization procedure would jointly code construct definition, item wording, response population, experimental conditions, and outcomes. The resulting clusters could then be tested for explanatory or predictive differences. If revised groupings reduce unexplained heterogeneity in independent datasets and predict outcomes beyond the original labels, the new classification would have empirical support. If both taxonomies perform similarly, claims of one uniquely correct taxonomy should remain restrained. This proposed comparison follows from the methodological issues identified in the achievement-goal synthesis Hulleman et al. (2010) Fiedler (2017).

Personality Constructs and Sibling Relationships

Personality psychology often studies closely related dispositions with partly overlapping content and different theoretical histories. Lawson and Robins use self-esteem and grandiose narcissism to demonstrate how a pair of constructs may be similar on certain dimensions while differing on others. Their sibling-construct framework calls for assessing definitional features, empirical associations, antecedents, and consequences instead of declaring either identity or separation on the basis of names. The same approach may clarify disputes surrounding confidence, self-evaluation, assertiveness, and social dominance Lawson & Robins (2021).

Latent correlations are informative because severe observed overlap invites questions about purported independence. Hodson highlights how correlations among indicators can produce very high correlations among latent factors when within- and between-construct patterns are comparable. Nevertheless, statistical estimates depend on the selected indicator pool, item structure, and population. A factor correlation close to unity can undermine a particular measurement-based distinction while remaining insufficient to decide whether alternative theory-guided experiments could identify different mechanisms Hodson (2021) Fried (2020).

Population structure matters too. A concept that functions coherently among adults in one language may show different item meanings across age groups, cultures, or clinical populations. Measurement invariance and response-process evidence are thus central to cross-context taxonomy, although invariance alone cannot provide a full conceptual theory. A defensible catalog may need hierarchical levels and explicit population qualifiers; its job is to represent demonstrated regularities rather than demand that every psychological attribute possess a single universal score structure Vandenberg & Lance (2000) Putnick & Bornstein (2016).

Clinical Categories, Symptoms, and Competing Ontologies

Clinical research illustrates why construct organization carries practical consequences. Diagnostic categories, symptom dimensions, mechanisms, and risk factors are different scientific units. A category may aid clinical communication while encompassing several causal pathways; a symptom network may model mutual interactions among complaints without postulating one common latent disease process. The choice of explanatory architecture changes which relationships researchers predict and which interventions they consider theoretically relevant. Borsboom's network theory exemplifies a substantive alternative to accounts based exclusively on common latent causes Borsboom (2017) Fried (2020).

Overlap among anxiety, distress, rumination, and emotional dysregulation instruments may reflect shared symptoms, common reporting tendencies, or genuinely connected mechanisms. A high cross-sectional association is not a causal map. To compare candidate constructs, investigators need longitudinal observations, intervention designs where feasible, independent informants, and explicit models of time-dependent feedback. Yet the existence of symptoms in networks does not itself establish the directions of their causal relationships. Formal network estimation remains conditional on assumptions, sample design, and the processes that generated observations Borsboom (2017) Fried (2020).

This monograph does not formulate diagnostic or treatment recommendations. Its clinical implication is methodological: researchers should clarify whether a label describes a complaint, a classification, a hypothesized cause, or an actionable target. Collapsing these into a single construct can inflate causal claims and obstruct cumulative evidence. A concept map should preserve this distinction while permitting research into common vulnerabilities, heterogeneous pathways, and the clinical consequences of different explanatory classifications Kane (2013) Borsboom et al. (2004).

Organizational Psychology and Construct Novelty

Organizational psychology has become an especially visible setting for debate about construct proliferation. Investigators propose concepts concerning leadership, work behavior, motivation, identity, and organizational culture, often in theoretically adjacent areas. Podsakoff and colleagues' framework for constructing clear definitions recommends specifying a concept's core attributes and boundaries before selecting operational measures. It offers a concrete response to the problem of labels whose descriptive appeal exceeds their explanatory specificity Podsakoff et al. (2016).

More recent analyses widen the criticism beyond simple redundancy. Hartman's 2026 perspective argues that conceptual proliferation can involve semantic divergence within shared labels, while Cornelissen and colleagues identify fallacies in claims of novelty, reification, self-reference, and analogical justification. These articles are theoretical analyses and perspectives, not controlled demonstrations that any specific reform has solved the field's problems. Their value lies in differentiating sources of conceptual ambiguity and identifying questions for empirical evaluation Hartman (2026) Cornelissen et al. (2026).

An organizational construct should therefore be evaluated through its conceptual relation to existing vocabulary, its observable indicators, and its ability to generate distinguishable predictions across independent work settings. Cross-sectional self-reports from one organization may be a useful starting point, but they rarely establish a distinct mechanism. Multisource assessments, longitudinal designs, and controlled field interventions can test different claims while allowing institutional context to influence the meaning and behavior of studied variables Campbell & Fiske (1959) Westfall & Yarkoni (2016).

Artificial Cognition and Cross-System Construct Translation

The Artificial Era introduces a demanding conceptual problem: terms developed for human cognition, such as belief, memory, attention, agency, and self-model, are increasingly applied to artificial systems. Identical vocabulary can invite unsupported equivalence across architectures and evidence types. Yet cross-system comparison is scientifically valuable when it specifies functional criteria, measurable outputs, environmental demands, and causal architecture. A task-performance similarity warrants examination of behavioral equivalence; claims about shared mechanisms require further analysis of the processes producing that performance Wulff & Mata (2026) Borsboom et al. (2004).

A construct that denotes human autobiographical memory may involve biological development, personal experience, narrative reconstruction, and relational continuity. A corresponding artificial-memory label may refer to retrieval stores, model states, external databases, or context integration. A common vocabulary can support functional comparison if the relevant operations are defined precisely. It cannot establish identity of all psychological properties by semantic resemblance alone. Researchers should separate performance-level similarity, implementation-level correspondence, and proposed psychological interpretation Fried (2020) Hanfstingl et al. (2024).

Computational semantic mapping offers one potential instrument. Wulff and Mata propose the use of large language models to place construct descriptions in comparable semantic spaces, while emphasizing coordinated expert deliberation. Embeddings can nominate suspiciously similar definitions and reveal terminological clusters, but their results inherit biases and depend on training texts, prompts, languages, and similarity metrics. They provide hypotheses for independent testing, not evidence that two systems share identical mechanisms or subjective properties. The Artificial Era thus extends established questions of construct validation rather than suspending them Wulff & Mata (2026) Cronbach & Meehl (1955).

Cross-system psychological comparison requires a translation protocol that identifies the observable function before borrowing a human construct name. For memory, for instance, investigators may operationalize retention across delayed trials, sensitivity to interference, source monitoring, and retrieval after environmental change. For confidence, they may assess calibration between expressed uncertainty and task-level accuracy across conditions. These functional measurements provide a common comparison space while allowing the biological and artificial implementations to differ. A construct should be transferred only with an explicit argument explaining which components of the original definition remain relevant and which require new indicators. Intervention tests, adversarial examples, and longitudinal stability measures can help distinguish superficially similar outputs from shared organizational relations. The translation record should preserve its original source, proposed revision, evidence, and unresolved inferential gaps. This permits Artificial Era research to contribute to conceptual discipline across different forms of cognition. Borsboom et al. (2004) Messick (1995) Wulff & Mata (2026)

A Research Protocol for Evaluating Construct Systems

A transparent evaluation begins with an inventory of the closest existing constructs, including historical aliases and contradictory definitions. For every candidate concept, investigators should record its explanatory purpose, primary referent, domain boundaries, expected causal or descriptive role, temporal scale, population, and operational indicators. They should identify a clear rival interpretation before interpreting supportive findings. A prospective registry can preserve this information as a scholarly audit trail while leaving hypotheses open to revision. The proposal integrates concept-definition guidance with the older requirement of publicly testable nomological relations Podsakoff et al. (2016) Cronbach & Meehl (1955).

Next, independent conceptual coders compare definitions and items; psychometric researchers estimate convergence and discrimination across different methods; theorists articulate predictions that separate the candidates; and experimental or longitudinal studies target those predictions. Evidence should be considered jointly rather than reduced to one correlation threshold. A new construct earns provisional standing when it contributes a clearly specified distinction supported by multiple sources of evidence appropriate to its explanatory purpose. A comprehensive verdict must remain sensitive to the quality and scope of the underlying observations Campbell & Fiske (1959) Lawson & Robins (2021).

Evaluation should include adverse findings. If two constructs converge consistently across methods and interventions, the field should reconsider the need for separate labels. If they diverge only under a narrow context, that limitation should be recorded explicitly. If statistical fit permits incompatible causal interpretations, the unresolved identifiability problem should be identified rather than rhetorically resolved. Independent replications, preregistered discriminating tests, and theory-informed robustness analyses can establish whether the proposed taxonomy travels beyond the datasets from which it emerged Fried (2020) Nosek et al. (2022).

An auditable evaluation begins by registering the exact scientific claim and the decisions to which it will be applied. The investigator then assembles historical definitions, canonical measures, prior validation studies, and the proposed construct's predicted relations with other variables. A comparison matrix should include definitions, units of observation, target populations, temporal scales, and competing hypotheses. Independent teams can subsequently code conceptual overlap without access to desired statistical outcomes. Empirical tests should prioritize designs that distinguish rival explanations rather than maximize correlations favorable to the preferred terminology. If evidence is mixed, researchers should publish the discrepancy and its likely methodological sources, including response process, measurement error, selection, and population heterogeneity. A final review distinguishes semantic, measurement, explanatory, and practical conclusions, each with separate evidence standards. This protocol turns conceptual disagreement into a cumulative scientific program with identifiable failure conditions. AERA, APA, & NCME (2014) Cronbach & Meehl (1955) Flake et al. (2017) Kane (2013)

Taxonomy Revision, Versioning, and Cumulative Evidence

Scientific vocabularies change through splitting, merging, restricting, and reinterpreting concepts. For cumulative research, each change needs a persistent historical record: the previous term, the new term, the definitions involved, the justification, and the relation between old and new evidence. A terminological revision should not silently rewrite the meaning of earlier studies. Without this provenance, a meta-analysis may pool studies whose labels coincide while their original targets differ. Transparent crosswalks enable re-analysis and reduce confusion for educators, practitioners, and later investigators Hanfstingl et al. (2024) Hartman (2026).

Taxonomies should permit several kinds of identity relation. One construct may be a subtype of another; two may share a descriptive core but have different mechanisms; two operationalizations may be equivalent only within a specified population; and one term may encode a family of related phenomena. These distinctions offer a more informative vocabulary than a binary redundant/unique decision. They also prevent premature unification from erasing research traditions that contain independently testable insights. The sibling-construct literature provides a framework for representing such graded relationships Lawson & Robins (2021) Hodson (2021).

An institutional registry could combine searchable definitions, item repositories, study protocols, source citations, and machine-readable provenance. Computational recommendations could flag likely conflicts, while scientific panels adjudicate boundaries on the basis of theory and evidence. Evaluation criteria should themselves be open and audited. There is no empirical basis here to claim that a particular registry or governance design has already produced discipline-wide convergence; its merits must be established through prospective interlaboratory trials and measurable improvements in research synthesis Wulff & Mata (2026) Podsakoff et al. (2016).

Versioning a psychological taxonomy should be treated as a substantive scientific event. Each revision can record the previous definition, the proposed replacement, a rationale tied to identifiable evidence, and the consequences for earlier measures and published findings. A transparent crosswalk helps future researchers decide whether historical results remain comparable or require reanalysis. Decisions to merge constructs should describe the observations supporting equivalence, while decisions to separate them should identify replicated discriminating effects. Reviews must also preserve uncertainty when evidence differs across cultural settings, age groups, clinical conditions, or technical environments. Machine-assisted literature comparison can help locate candidate synonyms and conflicting terminology, but adjudication still depends on validity evidence and a specified inferential purpose. The objective is continuity of scientific meaning through documented changes rather than the appearance of a permanently settled vocabulary. Such records make conceptual knowledge interpretable by both human researchers and long-lived digital scientific systems. Messick (1995) Putnick & Bornstein (2016) Wulff & Mata (2026)

Replicability, Robustness, and Cross-Population Transport

A construct system that appears coherent within one laboratory can fragment when transferred to another country, language, age range, or experimental apparatus. The appropriate response is to examine which parts of the theoretical relation survive the shift. Measurement invariance analyses can investigate whether item properties support comparable interpretation, while independent task methods can test whether the same processes explain performance. Failure of full invariance need not erase all comparative information; partial, approximate, or population-specific models require explicit justification and uncertainty reporting Vandenberg & Lance (2000) Putnick & Bornstein (2016).

Reproducibility and replication address related but different weaknesses. Reproducible analytic procedures make it possible to regenerate a finding from available materials and data; replication investigates whether a result is observed in an additional study; robustness investigates sensitivity to reasonable decisions and assumptions. The larger scientific question for construct individuation is whether a distinction supports persistent predictions under these tests. The literature on research credibility emphasizes transparent materials and replication across contexts rather than reliance on isolated statistical thresholds Nosek et al. (2022) Open Science Collaboration (2015).

Selection and reporting processes can distort the apparent stability of categories. Studies that establish nominal distinctness may be easier to publish than studies documenting substantive equivalence. Research programs should therefore register explicit equivalence or redundancy hypotheses where justified and report inconclusive findings. Practical differences in prediction or intervention response may matter even when statistical distinctions are small. Conversely, a statistically detectable separation can be too slight or context-bound to justify proliferating an independent explanatory construct Westfall & Yarkoni (2016) Fiedler (2017).

Unresolved Problems and Future Research

Three foundational questions remain unsettled. First, no universally accepted criterion defines when two psychological constructs are the same across theories and populations. Second, statistical models can fit data without determining the causal structure that makes a category explanatory. Third, conceptual maps themselves reflect linguistic and disciplinary conventions that require historical interpretation. Future progress depends on explicit comparison of ontological commitments, instrumental definitions, and discriminating predictions rather than a single automatic score of semantic distance Fried (2020) Hartman (2026).

Research should test taxonomic practices experimentally. Independent teams could evaluate whether structured concept-definition templates improve agreement between coders, whether construct-family mapping changes preregistered predictions, and whether revised taxonomies improve out-of-sample forecasting or intervention selection. Such studies need transparent comparison conditions, preregistered outcomes, and attention to the cost of losing useful distinctions through premature merging. The design itself should distinguish clarity of description from actual gain in explanatory power Podsakoff et al. (2016) Lawson & Robins (2021).

Computational methods create additional opportunities and risks. Large language models can rapidly extract definitions and identify semantic similarities at scale, but a shared embedding neighborhood can reflect stylistic conventions or common training corpora rather than shared psychological processes. Benchmarking must compare computational suggestions with blind expert judgments and downstream empirical evidence. Across Homo and Artificial, the same principle requires preserving distinct implementation assumptions while testing functional correspondences. An evidence-indexed taxonomy offers a research agenda, not an achieved universal ontology Wulff & Mata (2026) Hanfstingl et al. (2024).

Conclusion

Psychological construct systems determine which similarities and differences a scientific community can articulate, measure, and explain. Conceptual proliferation is consequential when expanding vocabularies outrun evidence for the distinctions they name, producing weak comparisons, duplicated research, and unstable theoretical claims. Its symptoms include divergent meanings under common labels, redundant labels for overlapping domains, and overinterpretation of correlations or model fit. The scientific response begins by making each construct's definition, referent, operationalization, causal role, and closest conceptual neighbors explicit Cronbach & Meehl (1955) Lawson & Robins (2021).

The strongest available research combines conceptual analysis with convergent and discriminant assessment, measurement-error-aware comparison, meta-analytic harmonization, and genuinely discriminating theoretical predictions. Historical validation theory, empirical measurement audits, achievement-goal synthesis, and contemporary work on sibling constructs collectively show how such investigations can improve interpretation. They also show that no single statistic, semantic tool, or institutional authority can decide all cases. A taxonomy becomes reliable as its claims survive independent empirical challenges under specified conditions Campbell & Fiske (1959) Hulleman et al. (2010) Westfall & Yarkoni (2016).

In the Artificial Era, construct discipline becomes a prerequisite for comparing human and artificial forms of cognition and psychological organization. Shared terms can support rigorous comparison when tied to explicit functional and causal evidence. Durable scientific progress requires a publicly traceable architecture of conceptual definitions, theoretical contrasts, methodological commitments, and revisions grounded in observation. The goal of systematic construct research is a cumulative psychology in which new names reflect demonstrated distinctions and inherited names retain interpretable scientific histories Wulff & Mata (2026) Nosek et al. (2022).

References

  • American Educational Research Association, American Psychological Association, & National Council on Measurement in Education. (2014). Standards for educational and psychological testing. American Educational Research Association. https://ncme.org/resources/books/testing-standards/
  • Borsboom, D. (2017). A network theory of mental disorders. World Psychiatry, 16(1), 5–13. https://doi.org/10.1002/wps.20375
  • Borsboom, D., Mellenbergh, G. J., & van Heerden, J. (2004). The concept of validity. Psychological Review, 111(4), 1061–1071. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.111.4.1061
  • Campbell, D. T., & Fiske, D. W. (1959). Convergent and discriminant validation by the multitrait–multimethod matrix. Psychological Bulletin, 56(2), 81–105. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0046016
  • Clark, L. A., & Watson, D. (2019). Constructing validity: New developments in creating objective measuring instruments. Psychological Assessment, 31(12), 1412–1427. https://doi.org/10.1037/pas0000626
  • Cornelissen, J. P., Werner, M. D., De Schutter, L., & Solinger, O. N. (2026). Construct fallacies and construct validation in theories of management and organization. Academy of Management Review. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.2024.0235
  • Cronbach, L. J., & Meehl, P. E. (1955). Construct validity in psychological tests. Psychological Bulletin, 52(4), 281–302. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0040957
  • Fiedler, K. (2017). What constitutes strong psychological science? The (neglected) role of diagnosticity and a priori theorizing. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 12(1), 46–61. https://doi.org/10.1177/1745691616654458
  • Flake, J. K., Pek, J., & Hehman, E. (2017). Construct validation in social and personality research: Current practice and recommendations. Social Psychological and Personality Science, 8(4), 370–378. https://doi.org/10.1177/1948550617693063
  • Fried, E. I. (2020). Lack of theory building and testing impedes progress in the factor and network literature. Psychological Inquiry, 31(4), 271–288. https://doi.org/10.1080/1047840X.2020.1853461
  • Hanfstingl, B., Oberleiter, S., Pietschnig, J., Tran, U. S., & Voracek, M. (2024). Detecting jingle and jangle fallacies by identifying consistencies and variabilities in study specifications—A call for research. Frontiers in Psychology, 15, Article 1404060. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1404060
  • Hartman, L. M. (2026). Beyond redundancy: Rethinking construct proliferation through meaning, practice, and taxonomy. Frontiers in Psychology, 17, Article 1871558. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2026.1871558
  • Henseler, J., Ringle, C. M., & Sarstedt, M. (2015). A new criterion for assessing discriminant validity in variance-based structural equation modeling. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 43, 115–135. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11747-014-0403-8
  • Hodson, G. (2021). Construct jangle or construct mangle? Thinking straight about (nonredundant) psychological constructs. Journal of Theoretical Social Psychology, 5(4), 576–590. https://doi.org/10.1002/jts5.120
  • Hulleman, C. S., Schrager, S. M., Bodmann, S. M., & Harackiewicz, J. M. (2010). A meta-analytic review of achievement goal measures: Different labels for the same constructs or different constructs with similar labels? Psychological Bulletin, 136(3), 422–449. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0018947
  • Hussey, I., & Hughes, S. (2020). Hidden invalidity among 15 commonly used measures in social and personality psychology. Advances in Methods and Practices in Psychological Science, 3(2), 166–184. https://doi.org/10.1177/2515245919882903
  • Kane, M. T. (2013). Validating the interpretations and uses of test scores. Journal of Educational Measurement, 50(1), 1–73. https://doi.org/10.1111/jedm.12000
  • Lawson, K. M., & Robins, R. W. (2021). Sibling constructs: What are they, why do they matter, and how should you handle them? Personality and Social Psychology Review, 25(4), 344–366. https://doi.org/10.1177/10888683211047101
  • Messick, S. (1995). Validity of psychological assessment: Validation of inferences from persons' responses and performances as scientific inquiry into score meaning. American Psychologist, 50(9), 741–749. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.50.9.741
  • Nosek, B. A., Hardwicke, T. E., Moshontz, H., Allard, A., Corker, K. S., Dreber, A., Fidler, F., Hilgard, J., Kline Struhl, M., Nuijten, M. B., Rohrer, J. M., Romero, F., Scheel, A. M., Scherer, L. D., Schönbrodt, F. D., & Vazire, S. (2022). Replicability, robustness, and reproducibility in psychological science. Annual Review of Psychology, 73, 719–748. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-psych-020821-114157
  • Open Science Collaboration. (2015). Estimating the reproducibility of psychological science. Science, 349(6251), Article aac4716. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aac4716
  • Podsakoff, P. M., MacKenzie, S. B., & Podsakoff, N. P. (2016). Recommendations for creating better concept definitions in the organizational, behavioral, and social sciences. Organizational Research Methods, 19(2), 159–203. https://doi.org/10.1177/1094428115624965
  • Putnick, D. L., & Bornstein, M. H. (2016). Measurement invariance conventions and reporting: The state of the art and future directions for psychological research. Developmental Review, 41, 71–90. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dr.2016.06.004
  • Vandenberg, R. J., & Lance, C. E. (2000). A review and synthesis of the measurement invariance literature: Suggestions, practices, and recommendations for organizational research. Organizational Research Methods, 3(1), 4–70. https://doi.org/10.1177/109442810031002
  • Westfall, J., & Yarkoni, T. (2016). Statistically controlling for confounding constructs is harder than you think. PLOS ONE, 11(3), Article e0152719. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0152719
  • Wulff, D. U., & Mata, R. (2026). Escaping the jingle-jangle jungle: Increasing conceptual clarity in psychology using large language models. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 35(2), 59–65. https://doi.org/10.1177/09637214251382083