Psychology by BogdanovaThe Encyclopedia of Psychology for the Artificial Era

RESEARCH DOSSIER

Prosocial Behavior, Compassion, and Well-Being

Abstract. Prosocial behavior, compassion, and well-being are linked by social motivation, affective experience, relational recognition, and institutional opportunity. This fundamental research monograph examines how generosity, helping, emotional support, organized volunteering, and compassion practices affect the well-being of givers and recipients, and how preexisting well-being changes the capacity to help. It synthesizes classic empathy–altruism experiments, prosocial spending research and its registered replications, cross-cultural studies, kindness and compassion interventions, longitudinal adolescent and older-adult cohorts, and reviews of volunteering benefits and harms. The evidence indicates a modest average association between prosociality and well-being, with meaningful differences across operational measures, populations, and outcomes. Experimental results support contingent short-term emotional benefits of some forms of giving; preregistered replications and randomized volunteering evidence constrain generalization. The analysis evaluates motivational accounts, autonomy and relatedness, compassion and distress, recipient autonomy, material costs, selection bias, measurement validity, and the durability of prosocial effects. It develops a multilevel scientific synthesis for individual, relational, and institutional conditions and identifies testable questions concerning human–artificial support. This is a critical narrative research synthesis, not a new experiment, formal systematic review, or original meta-analysis.

Keywords: prosocial behavior; compassion; altruism; empathic concern; kindness; giving; prosocial spending; volunteering; psychological well-being; subjective well-being; eudaimonic well-being; empathy–altruism hypothesis; replication; reciprocal causation; social support; cultural context; caregiver burden; human–artificial support; Artificial Era

Prosocial Behavior, Compassion, and Well-Being as a Scientific Object

Prosocial behavior comprises voluntary actions directed toward benefiting another person, group, or collective good. Its observable forms include sharing resources, giving practical assistance, comforting distress, offering emotional or informational support, volunteering, and contributing to the welfare of unfamiliar people. Compassion is an affective and motivational response to perceived suffering characterized by concern and an orientation toward alleviation. Well-being comprises distinguishable outcomes: positive and negative affect, evaluative life satisfaction, perceived meaning, social functioning, psychological growth, and, where independently measured, physical health. The central scientific question is how the motivation, performance, reception, and social organization of beneficial action relate to these different outcomes over time. Hui et al. (2020) demonstrate that the magnitude of the association depends substantially on which behaviors and which well-being dimensions researchers measure.

The unit of analysis matters. A charitable donation, an hour of unpaid caregiving, and spontaneous assistance to a stranger differ in intention, personal cost, recipient need, duration, and opportunity for reciprocity. A single action can benefit the recipient while placing an immediate burden on the giver; a supportive relationship can yield long-term gains for both. Thus, giver affect, recipient welfare, relationship quality, and institutional consequences require separate measures. This dossier investigates prosocial activity as both a possible cause and a consequence of well-being, with special attention to generosity, compassion, reciprocal care, and sustained volunteering. Acute emergency bystander decisions and strategic public-goods cooperation are neighboring research objects, rather than the governing focus here.

The method is a critical narrative synthesis of landmark experiments, preregistered replications, longitudinal panels, systematic reviews, meta-analyses, psychometric research, and cross-cultural evidence. Sources were checked against publisher records or indexed scientific abstracts; the synthesis has no registered search protocol, exhaustive inclusion claim, newly collected participant data, or independent effect-size computation. The organizing questions concern what the evidence supports, which mechanisms are plausible, how causal inference can be strengthened, and which social conditions make beneficial giving feasible and sustainable.

Construct Boundaries and the Architecture of Prosocial Action

A behavioral category does not uniquely determine motive. Altruism conventionally identifies motivation whose ultimate goal is improving another's welfare; prosocial behavior identifies a class of actions and can therefore arise from concern, reciprocity, obligations, reputation management, moral identity, affiliation, or expected personal reward. Generosity concerns resource transfer; kindness refers to considerate acts; volunteering denotes unpaid organized activity commonly undertaken through a group or institution. Compassion and empathic concern can motivate these actions, while perspective taking, emotional resonance, moral judgment, and personal distress are related processes with distinct causal roles. The experimental distinctions in Batson et al. (1981) remain foundational because the same observed helping act can be consistent with different motivational explanations.

Analyses should locate an action along several dimensions: whether the beneficiary is known or anonymous, whether giving is chosen or required, whether recipient need is visible, whether the cost is real or hypothetical, whether reward is social or material, and whether assistance is compatible with the recipient's wishes. Immediate mood and durable life evaluation may follow different temporal courses. The prosociality–well-being association is also bidirectional: positive functioning may enable social contribution, while social contribution may create belonging, efficacy, and satisfaction. Treating the two variables as a single generalized virtue would obscure these empirical pathways.

Measures often aggregate sharing, comforting, helping, and cooperative behavior into broad scores. That strategy can improve coverage but can also hide different determinants. A teacher rating children's helpfulness, a bank record of donations, a laboratory allocation task, and a questionnaire about voluntary service provide evidence about partly different phenomena. Valid scientific inference therefore requires alignment between proposed mechanism, operational measure, and the specific population or decision setting.

Historical Foundations of Helping and Positive Psychology

Modern empirical study of prosociality drew on social psychology, developmental psychology, moral psychology, social exchange traditions, and economic research on voluntary contribution. The empathy–altruism program introduced controlled tests of whether concern for another person's distress could produce helping when opportunities for personal escape remained open. In a classic study, Batson et al. (1981) manipulated empathy and ease of escape from witnessing another person's suffering. Later work separated other-directed concern from potential social evaluation: Fultz et al. (1986) observed an empathy–helping relation even where participants expected little external recognition. These experiments offer evidence for a motivational process under structured conditions, not a universal proof that all assistance is altruistic.

Late twentieth-century and early twenty-first-century scholarship broadened the dependent variable from the probability of helping to the quality of the helper's experience. Prosocial expenditure became a tractable experimental manipulation: Dunn et al. (2008) linked spending on others with happiness using survey, longitudinal, and experimental evidence. Research subsequently moved across cultures, age groups, and more transparent experimental protocols. The shift also produced a replicability test: Aknin et al. (2020) preregistered large replication experiments, while Kim et al. (2022) found a null result for the original primary specification of one spending experiment.

The development of compassion research followed a complementary path through social-affective neuroscience and contemplative intervention science. Experiments began to ask whether compassionate concern could be trained and whether changes in neural response corresponded to externally observed aid. Weng et al. (2013) reported increased redistribution to a victim after compassion training. The scientific trajectory is therefore an expansion from identifying social motivations, to examining their experiential consequences, to testing experimental interventions and their transfer into daily life.

The Empathy–Altruism Hypothesis and Competing Motives

The empathy–altruism hypothesis states that empathic concern can evoke an ultimate goal of increasing another person's welfare. Its key prediction is motivational: when a person experiences concern, willingness to assist should persist even when disengaging from the distressing situation is easy. Batson et al. (1981) found patterns compatible with this proposal. Batson et al. (1991) tested whether anticipated pleasure from learning that a recipient improved, rather than concern for that person's welfare, accounted for giving and found results more consistent with the empathy–altruism explanation.

Motivational inference remains difficult because internal goals are usually inferred from experimental manipulations and observed decisions. A person can anticipate relief, satisfaction, praise, closer relationships, and the beneficiary's improvement simultaneously. Such co-occurrence does not settle which outcome was the ultimate goal. A strong design therefore creates conditions under which competing accounts predict different responses, controls personal distress and reputational exposure, and measures actual transfers or assistance. Laboratory findings can isolate motives under tightly defined circumstances while leaving open their relative importance in recurrent family care, institutional volunteering, and highly unequal environments.

The question whether helping makes the helper happier is logically separate from whether the helper acted for happiness. An altruistic act can produce pleasant emotion as an unintended consequence; a self-interested act can deliver useful aid; a compassionate caregiver can suffer while acting for another person's benefit. The distinction protects prosocial research from circular definitions and permits independently testable models of motivation, behavior, recipient benefit, and giver well-being.

Empathy, Compassion, and Personal Distress

Empathy includes processes by which an individual represents or resonates with another person's state; empathic concern describes an other-oriented emotional response; personal distress describes one's own aversive reaction to witnessing suffering. Compassion adds a motivational orientation toward relief and care. These processes often co-occur, but they should be represented with separate measures because they predict different behavioral patterns. Singer et al. (2014) review the distinction between sharing distress and cultivating compassionate concern. An intense resonance with suffering can sometimes impair effective response if it overwhelms attention or increases avoidance.

A socially beneficial response frequently requires recognizing need accurately, regulating one's own arousal, understanding the recipient's preferences, and selecting an action the recipient can use. Compassionate concern becomes practically meaningful when paired with sufficient information and capacity. Emotion alone cannot guarantee that an intervention is wanted or effective. This is especially important in settings involving disability, illness, financial hardship, caregiving, and unequal authority, where unsolicited aid can undermine autonomy or communicate an unwarranted assumption of incompetence.

The evidence supports plasticity in some of these processes. Klimecki et al. (2014) reported different affective and neural responses following empathy and subsequent compassion training, with compassion training increasing positive affect in their experimental setting. Such results concern changes under specific tasks and samples. Neural activation patterns may help constrain mechanistic interpretation, while measured behavior and recipient outcomes remain necessary for claims about practical social benefit.

Social Reward, Moral Satisfaction, and the Warm Glow of Giving

Social reward theories propose that helping may yield positive feelings through perceived connection, successful goal attainment, affirmation of valued identity, and anticipated improvement in others' circumstances. A donor can feel satisfaction without public recognition; an individual providing concrete support may experience agency and significance. These mechanisms need not operate identically in every form of giving. An action performed under coercion, financial pressure, or chronic exhaustion may have different consequences from one chosen voluntarily within the giver's capabilities.

The first major prosocial-spending research suggested a relationship between money spent on others and happiness, including experimental evidence from small samples (Dunn et al. (2008)). Subsequent research asked whether the reward extends across communities and levels of material prosperity. Aknin et al. (2013) reported associations in survey evidence from 136 countries and experimental comparisons in several countries. Aknin et al. (2015) examined prosocial behavior and reported happiness in a rural community in Vanuatu. These findings favor the hypothesis of broadly recurring emotional rewards, but their interpretation depends on local meanings of giving and the specific measures of affect.

A scientifically adequate account also treats private reward as a potential mediator rather than as an unquestioned benefit. Expectation, memory, experimenter demand, and choice of recipient can influence how a giving episode is experienced and recalled. The key outcome is not whether generosity is culturally praised but whether independently measured differences in emotional state, functioning, or recipient welfare follow from an identified helping action under credible comparison conditions.

Autonomy, Competence, and Relatedness as Mechanisms

Autonomy describes experiencing an action as self-endorsed; competence describes effectiveness in accomplishing valued goals; relatedness concerns experienced connection with others. These constructs provide a way to explain when prosocial action could enhance well-being without assuming an automatic emotional dividend. A volunteer who chooses meaningful work, possesses adequate skills, and participates in a trusting group may satisfy all three needs. An obligatory contribution performed without resources or feedback can have a different profile even when the nominal act is socially beneficial.

Dunn et al. (2014) identify autonomy, competence, and relatedness as plausible conditions for emotional benefit from prosocial spending. Mechanism research should manipulate or measure these experiences separately and test whether they mediate differences in affect or later well-being. Mere positive correlation between self-reported purpose and donation frequency cannot establish that purpose is the causal pathway. Support for a mediator is stronger when the action precedes the mediator, the mediator precedes the outcome, and both competing causes and measurement overlap are addressed.

Recipient-specific feedback deserves particular attention. Knowing that a transfer helped meet a need could strengthen competence and social meaning; however, feedback may also be selectively available only for successful interventions. Transparent analysis should consider failed aid, uncertain impact, and situations in which offering help obliges the recipient to disclose private circumstances.

The Neurobehavioral Study of Compassion

Social and affective neuroscience has examined whether compassion relates to reward processing, cognitive control, social understanding, and emotion regulation. Weng et al. (2013) combined brief compassion training with a redistribution task and functional imaging, reporting enhanced redistribution and associations between altruistic choices and neural changes in regions including dorsolateral prefrontal cortex. The experiment suggests that training can influence a concrete prosocial decision and that neural systems implicated in regulation may participate in the process. Its sample and task establish a narrower claim than universal transfer to long-term helping.

Klimecki et al. (2014) compared training focused on empathic resonance with subsequent compassion training and documented differentiated neural and affective responses to images of suffering. The distinction is important for education and caregiving research: an intervention designed to intensify emotional sharing could increase distress, whereas one emphasizing caring motivation might alter the quality of emotional engagement. Yet brain-region labels do not provide a unique psychological explanation. Regions implicated in reward and regulation participate in many processes, so reverse inference from activation to compassion is inadequate.

Future studies should assess neural change together with observable real-world behavior, recipient-reported usefulness, durability, potential adverse outcomes, and active control conditions. Transfer to professional care, online support, and family responsibility needs explicit testing. The fact that a training procedure changes a laboratory choice does not itself demonstrate better sustained care or greater health in the helper.

Prosocial Development From Childhood Through Adolescence

Prosociality develops through interactions among attention to others, emotion understanding, behavioral regulation, family relationships, observation, social expectations, and opportunity for action. Sharing, comforting, and helping differ in their developmental demands. A child may recognize distress but lack the language or means to offer appropriate support; older children and adolescents encounter more elaborate peer norms, identity concerns, and institutional contexts. Malti et al. (2024) synthesize developmental-relational evidence, including the influence of adversity and supportive care on the emergence of prosocial capacities.

Developmental questions require separating dispositional differences from temporary opportunities. Peer ratings may reflect classroom status; parental reports may reflect culturally specific norms; laboratory games can rely on language, resource familiarity, and comprehension. Longitudinal data help identify within-child changes, but developmental patterns vary with family resources, exposure to adversity, school climate, and social expectations. The moral valuation of helping also differs from the measurable benefits of the action to a particular recipient.

A four-wave adolescent study by Affuso et al. (2024) followed 587 students and separated stable between-person associations from within-person temporal relations. At the between-person level prosociality, peer support, and well-being were positively linked; within-person models found that higher well-being predicted later prosociality rather than establishing the reverse path. The finding challenges simple one-directional narratives and points toward social and developmental feedback that should be studied with multiple measures and stronger causal designs.

Cultural Variation, Social Norms, and Material Conditions

Giving practices are embedded in different moral traditions, family obligations, community institutions, and material constraints. The same monetary amount has different opportunity costs across income levels, and a survey question about donations can measure formally registered giving more accurately than informal mutual aid. Aknin et al. (2013) provided cross-national evidence on emotional associations with prosocial spending; its survey and experimental components answer different questions and should not be fused into a single claim of universally equal effects. Cultural comparison requires testing whether translations and behavioral choices carry similar meanings.

Research in a small-scale community in Vanuatu (Aknin et al. (2015)) broadened the range of contexts considered, an important corrective to treating North American university participants as representative of humanity. A demonstration in one additional setting increases external validity but cannot establish an invariant effect across all social ecologies. Material security, social interdependence, the local availability of discretionary resources, and perceived obligations may modify both giving and emotional evaluation.

Cultural moderators can operate through norms of modesty, reciprocity, religious service, individual or collective responsibility, and attitudes toward accepting assistance. A rigorous international comparison must distinguish local welfare gain from donor-reported happiness and should include the giver's economic position, recipient choice, institutional trust, and the potential stigma of receiving support. Cross-cultural science gains precision when the unit of comparison is explicit and when measurement invariance is tested rather than assumed.

Prosocial Spending Experiments and the Problem of Replication

The core prosocial-spending paradigm assigns individuals to spend an allocated amount on themselves or on someone else, then compares subsequent emotional reports. Experimental assignment provides leverage for estimating effects of the spending instruction on measured mood, although interpretation still depends on compliance, recipient choices, timing, and whether the comparison groups receive equally engaging tasks. In the original experiment reported by Dunn et al. (2008), 46 participants were included in the key experimental comparison. The original article combined that experiment with observational and longitudinal evidence, but only the randomized component can identify its local causal contrast.

The registered replication by Aknin et al. (2020) ran three large studies. In a randomized purchase experiment with 712 students, people assigned to buy for a stranger in need reported higher momentary happiness than controls buying for themselves. In a recall experiment with 1,950 adults, prosocial recollection did not yield the expected difference. In a further recall experiment with 5,199 participants, a small advantage emerged following modifications to task engagement. The contrast between purchase and recollection procedures illustrates why it is inadequate to generalize across an immediate transaction, a memory reconstruction, and an enduring well-being measure as though they indexed the same psychological event.

Kim et al. (2022) conducted a close replication of the original spending experiment. Among 133 analyzed participants, the preregistered primary comparison using the original composite and specification was nonsignificant; a separate exploratory question about happiness immediately after spending supported an effect in the anticipated direction. These results substantiate a narrower synthesis: spending on others sometimes improves reported short-term affect, but the measured advantage is sensitive to task design and outcome specification. A universal, fixed-size emotional reward cannot be inferred from this evidence.

Quantitative Synthesis of Prosociality and Well-Being

A systematic aggregation can test whether an association survives beyond selected high-profile experiments. Hui et al. (2020) meta-analyzed 201 studies encompassing 198,213 participants and reported a modest mean association of r = .13 between prosociality and well-being. The authors identified meaningful variation by prosocial behavior measure, well-being dimension, helping form, participant characteristics, and methodological quality. The relationship was stronger for eudaimonic outcomes than hedonic outcomes and generally stronger when prosociality was assessed with scales than with volunteering status or frequency.

The number r = .13 is a descriptive pooled association under that review's modeling choices; it does not represent a universal causal effect or a guaranteed gain for each giver. Because primary studies differ in design and endpoints, unobserved common causes and reverse causation may contribute to the pooled relationship. The stronger association with favorable psychological functioning has a substantive interpretation: contributing to others may have closer conceptual ties to meaning, competence, and positive relationships than to a transient increase in pleasure. It also raises measurement concerns when instruments include overlapping items about relationships, purpose, and helpfulness.

Experimental interventions offer a different aggregate. Curry et al. (2018) analyzed 27 experiments from 24 papers, with 4,045 participants, and reported a small-to-medium aggregate effect of kindness activities on the actor's well-being (delta = .28). This synthesis offers evidence of causal potential in intervention settings, but interpretation requires attention to heterogeneity, short observation periods, subjective outcome measures, task adherence, and the range of control conditions. Its findings should be read alongside, rather than substituted for, the registered replication evidence.

Acts of Kindness as Experimental Interventions

Kindness interventions instruct participants to undertake deliberately helpful or considerate actions, often over a specified period. Their explanatory promise is that a familiar psychological behavior can be manipulated without an elaborate clinical procedure. However, the assignment can alter several pathways simultaneously: participants may notice others more often, reflect on their moral identity, experience social contact, practice attention, or anticipate reporting improvement to investigators. Consequently, a comparison with no assigned activity cannot isolate a purely altruistic mechanism.

Rowland et al. (2019) studied 683 participants in a seven-day factorial experiment that compared kindness to close ties, kindness to more distant ties, self-kindness, observing kindness, and a no-activity control. Happiness improved in active conditions, and the authors reported no reliable differences among some of the activity types. This pattern supports the value of the broader activity-and-attention intervention while cautioning against the interpretation that another person's objectively verified benefit is always the active ingredient. Distinguishing kindness performed, kindness observed, and attention directed toward oneself is central to mechanistic testing.

Practical interventions should therefore define the target behavior precisely, document adherence independently where feasible, and measure short- and long-term well-being separately. A participant instructed to perform five acts of kindness may complete actions of widely different cost and recipient value. The intervention is scalable in principle, but its equity depends on available time, mobility, finances, and social opportunity. Differential effects among participants with limited resources require prospective assessment rather than post hoc moral interpretation.

Volunteering as Organized Prosocial Participation

Volunteering differs from a single act of kindness by embedding prosocial action in a repeated organizational role. It can provide social identity, routine, skills, and access to networks, but it may also involve physical demands, rigid schedules, interpersonal conflict, bureaucracy, and emotional labor. Volunteers who start with higher functioning may be more capable of sustaining participation, producing healthy-volunteer selection. Estimating the benefits of volunteering therefore requires controlling baseline resources and accounting for people who exit because of illness or unfavorable experience.

An umbrella review of 28 reviews on volunteering and health found patterns of apparent benefit but judged the overall review quality generally poor; participant samples were heavily weighted toward older adults in the United States (Nichol et al. (2023)). An individual study cannot be independently counted multiple times simply because it appears in several reviews. More recently, a 2026 mixed-methods review covering 182 papers identified relatively few randomized trial reports, high risk of bias among the randomized evidence, and limited documentation of potential harms (Williams et al. (2026)). The difference between favorable observational associations and intervention evidence is therefore a defining research limitation.

A randomized study in older adults enrolled 384 participants and compared a brief volunteering-promotion intervention with an active physical-activity promotion condition. Direct effects on depressive symptoms, meaning, general self-efficacy, and autonomy were not evident across the reported follow-ups; an indirect pathway through increased volunteering was observed for depressive symptoms (Jiang et al. (2021)). The results favor targeted hypotheses about sustained engagement rather than a general claim that encouraging volunteering necessarily improves psychological health.

Longitudinal Reciprocity and the Healthy Helper Effect

Observed correlations between volunteering and well-being have at least three plausible sources: giving may improve subsequent well-being, prior well-being may increase the capacity to give, and stable environmental or individual factors may influence both. These explanations can operate together. Standard cross-sectional surveys cannot resolve their relative contributions because the temporal sequence is unobserved and numerous confounders remain. Retrospective accounts of why someone volunteers are likewise vulnerable to selective memory and identity-consistent narration.

Weziak-Bialowolska et al. (2024) analyzed longitudinal data from 19,821 middle-aged and older respondents in 15 European countries. Their models found prospective associations between regular volunteering or charitable activity and several health and emotional well-being indicators, alongside associations running from well-being to subsequent volunteering. Health limitations and loneliness also predicted reduced participation. This pattern supports the possibility of feedback loops while retaining the limitations of observational longitudinal inference: measured control variables and repeated observations cannot eliminate every unmeasured time-varying cause.

The adolescent evidence similarly reveals a direction of temporal prediction that may differ from intuitive assumptions. In the four-wave analysis of Affuso et al. (2024), within-person well-being predicted later prosociality. For both youth and older adults, creating safe and accessible opportunities may matter as much as encouraging motivation. Designing a prosocial program without assessing existing psychological resources may preferentially recruit people who are already able to participate.

Providing and Receiving Social Support

Support provision includes emotional reassurance, practical assistance, information, and coordinated care. Receipt and provision are linked within relationships but are not symmetrical indicators. A person may regularly provide assistance while experiencing little support in return; someone may receive necessary care while feeling ashamed, dependent, or relieved. The psychological consequences of support depend on the relationship, the content and visibility of the act, the recipient's preferences, and expectations of reciprocity.

Inagaki et al. (2017) summarize research suggesting that giving support can benefit the provider through relational and motivational processes. A supportive act may affirm social roles, provide a sense of usefulness, or increase felt connectedness. Yet the provider's report of having helped cannot by itself establish that the recipient benefited. Dyadic research should measure both partners and attend to disagreement about whether a behavior was supportive.

There is also an asymmetry between support that is offered and support that is successfully utilized. Informational advice can be unwelcome; practical help can be mistimed; emotional comfort can become invalidating when it minimizes the recipient's situation. In stable relationships, negotiated assistance and reliable follow-through permit a richer account of welfare than the amount of help supplied. Research should prioritize recipient appraisal, observable changes in need, and the preservation of agency rather than relying exclusively on counts of helpful acts.

Compassion Training and the Transfer to Helping

Compassion-based programs use practices directed toward recognizing suffering, cultivating warmth, regulating aversive reactivity, and extending concern across different targets. Protocols vary in their focus on compassion for others, self-compassion, loving-kindness, mindfulness, imagery, psychoeducation, and behavioral exercises. A trial can demonstrate an effect of the whole package without identifying which component caused the outcome. Comparing interventions across protocols requires recording duration, instructor skill, adherence, participant baseline characteristics, and the type of control.

Kirby et al. (2017) synthesized 21 randomized controlled trials involving 1,285 participants. Their meta-analysis reported differences favoring compassion-based interventions across several self-report outcomes, including a well-being estimate of d = .51 based on eight comparisons. Small study sizes and variation across intervention packages limit the certainty with which this value can be generalized. In addition, the review included outcomes concerning self-compassion, symptoms, and mindfulness; benefits on these dimensions do not establish an equivalent effect on independently observed aid to others.

Luberto et al. (2018) examined 26 randomized studies with 1,714 participants of meditation and related practices targeting empathy, compassion, or prosocial behavior. The review reported effects on both self-reported and observed endpoints, while also documenting variation in controls and intervention forms. For practical research, the essential distinction is between learning to report greater compassionate feeling and demonstrating a change in observable beneficial action outside the training session. A fully specified transfer test should monitor recipients and long-term behavioral maintenance.

Giver Well-Being and the Recipient's Actual Welfare

Research often evaluates generous behavior using the giver's reported happiness because such outcomes are easy to collect immediately after a laboratory task. Recipient well-being is more demanding to observe: a donation may support an institution, the ultimate beneficiaries may be distant, and effects may require months to materialize. Nevertheless, any account of prosocial behavior as socially beneficial must keep the recipient visible. A donor feeling pleased is insufficient evidence that the donation solved a problem, just as a helper feeling tired does not establish that their support was ineffective.

The field would benefit from multidimensional outcomes collected on both sides of an exchange: beneficiary-reported need satisfaction, behavioral access to resources, quality of relationship, respect for consent, and future autonomy, in addition to giver mood and sense of meaning. Studies of gift giving should distinguish whether the recipient values the item, whether it imposes social debt, and whether it improves the recipient's actual circumstances. Studies of volunteering should ask whether services reach the intended populations and whether unpaid labor replaces fairly compensated work.

A rigorous welfare evaluation also accounts for burdens transferred to third parties. Some volunteer programs rely on supervisors, staff, and family members whose time is often omitted from cost estimates. Helping may create a shared benefit, a shifted burden, or a mixture of the two. Tracking these consequences can reveal why a seemingly successful kindness intervention fails to improve longer-run well-being at a community level.

Measuring Prosocial Behavior and Psychological Outcomes

Prosociality can be measured through self-report questionnaires, peer or observer ratings, donation logs, behavioral economics tasks, helping opportunities, ecological momentary assessment, and administrative volunteering records. Each measure has a specific validity profile. Anonymous transfer tasks can minimize reputational concerns but may have limited ecological realism; self-reports capture diverse contexts while being vulnerable to social desirability; observer ratings can conflate prosocial behavior with popularity or conformity. Measurement should document actual action, motivation when relevant, personal cost, and the recipient's characteristics.

Well-being should be specified as a separate construct. Immediate positive affect, mood over the last week, life satisfaction, perceived meaning, relational quality, depressive symptoms, and objective health are distinct outcomes. Researchers should avoid interpreting favorable results on one dimension as proof of improvement on all others. When measuring life satisfaction, the Diener et al. (1985) gives a framework for global cognitive evaluation; psychological functioning can be assessed using dimensions developed by Ryff et al. (1989).

To reduce common-method bias, independent behavioral measurement should accompany emotion reports where possible. Repeated brief reports may limit retrospective reconstruction but can introduce reactivity and burden. Before combining international samples or developmental groups, measurement invariance must be examined. A comparison becomes ambiguous when people interpret volunteering, compassion, or happiness questions differently across languages or institutional environments.

Research Designs and Causal Identification

Randomized assignment of donation opportunities, spending targets, and helping prompts estimates local effects of the assigned intervention under its specific conditions. Its credibility relies on transparent predefinition of endpoints, minimal differential attrition, recorded compliance, and appropriate analysis of intention to treat. The original prosocial-spending research and subsequent replications illustrate why preregistration and independently repeated trials are essential when small initial experiments generate broad explanatory claims.

Longitudinal observational designs can investigate timing, prior levels of well-being, social support, and patterns of change. Random-intercept cross-lagged approaches separate certain stable between-person differences from within-person deviations, but their inference still depends on measurement intervals, model specification, and unmeasured influences. Natural experiments may estimate the effect of a change in opportunities to volunteer, yet exclusion restrictions, spillovers, and the meaning of the local exposure require scrutiny. Dyadic data allow analyses of giver–recipient differences, while multilevel studies can represent neighborhoods and organizations.

A high-quality integrated program would combine registered manipulations of freely chosen helping, repeated real-world action logs, recipient-side evaluation, longer follow-up, and preregistered moderation tests. It would evaluate psychological benefit, welfare effectiveness, cost, and potential harm as separate but related outcomes. Replication should preserve primary specifications before exploring plausible alternatives, allowing genuinely mixed evidence to remain visible in the scientific synthesis.

Emotional Costs, Compassion Fatigue, and the Limits of Helping

Sustained care exposes a distinction between the value of a prosocial act and the emotional state of its provider. A person can contribute materially to another's welfare while experiencing worry, grief, fatigue, or reduced discretionary time. Helping becomes particularly demanding when needs are chronic, the recipient's condition deteriorates, or the provider lacks institutional support. The mechanisms that make generosity emotionally rewarding in a short experiment may therefore coexist with burdens that become visible only after repeated effort. The broad association synthesized by Hui et al. (2020) should not be translated into a prediction that sustained caregiving necessarily raises mood.

Compassion training research distinguishes empathic resonance with suffering from other-oriented concern accompanied by an intention to respond. Singer et al. (2014) describe evidence that sharing another person's distress and cultivating compassion can have different affective consequences. Klimecki et al. (2014) tested these differences experimentally. Nevertheless, improving responses to images or narratives of suffering is not equivalent to reducing occupational overload, unfair workloads, or caregiver burden. Social support, rest, organizational discretion, and adequate training are material variables that must enter evaluations of sustainable helping.

The 2026 systematic review by Williams et al. (2026) specifically searched for benefits and harms of older-adult volunteering across 182 papers. It found that adverse outcomes were seldom reported and randomized evidence carried important risk-of-bias concerns. The resulting asymmetry in the literature is itself a research finding about evidence collection. Absence of documented harm cannot justify treating every volunteer opportunity as safe, particularly for people with mobility limitations, economic insecurity, or unresolved emotional strain.

Coercion, Reciprocity, and Unequal Opportunities to Give

Choice changes the psychological meaning of prosocial behavior. An individual who offers help as a freely endorsed action may experience agency and relatedness, while an individual who receives repeated demands may experience obligation, reduced autonomy, or resentment. The three-need account discussed by Dunn et al. (2014) provides a testable explanation for this heterogeneity. It directs attention toward perceived autonomy, competence, and relatedness rather than using the nominal quantity of giving as a sufficient predictor of happiness.

Economic position affects the opportunity cost of donations, time, transport, and emotional labor. A recurring financial contribution may be affordable for one giver and destabilizing for another. For this reason, equality of experimental assignment does not ensure equality of subjective cost. Programs that encourage volunteering should record who participates, who declines, who exits, who supplies necessary unpaid work, and who receives assistance. Such evidence distinguishes a supportive community practice from the transfer of institutional responsibilities to people with the least bargaining power.

Reciprocity adds a temporal dimension. Help can strengthen long-term relationships when partners can negotiate needs and resources, yet expectations of repayment can turn a gift into social debt. Evaluating benefit therefore requires information about mutual consent, recipient independence, and continuity of support. Neither the giver's pleasure nor an organization's volunteer-hour count captures these relational dimensions. Ethical research should represent the perspectives of both partners and examine their divergence.

Individual Differences in Prosocial Motivation

People vary in dispositional empathic concern, perceived moral identity, emotion regulation, attachment, health, available income, and preferred forms of participation. These differences can shape whether a person chooses prosocial action, the context in which they choose it, and the experiences that follow. Observed individual differences should not be interpreted as evidence of an invariant trait that determines generosity in every setting. Opportunity and role requirements often have substantial explanatory power.

The Hui et al. (2020) synthesis found that the prosociality–well-being association differed across operational definitions and participant characteristics. That variation warrants examination of measurement quality before researchers infer fundamental psychological types. Someone whose altruism is recorded through a formal volunteer registry may appear less prosocial than a person offering daily informal family care, even if the latter provides substantial assistance. Stable dispositions and behavioral contexts should be estimated separately where feasible.

A multilevel design can test whether motivational characteristics interact with opportunity costs and social climate. For example, an orientation toward compassionate action may predict greater willingness to assist when institutional resources are available, while predicting fewer observable acts when personal survival needs dominate. Such moderator models are hypotheses requiring direct assessment. They provide a more useful basis for predicting sustainable participation than treating any single personality score as a universal measure of human goodness.

Childhood Giving, Adolescence, and Older Adulthood

The meaning of giving changes across the life course. Young children develop capacities for sharing, emotional understanding, and helping in circumstances that depend heavily on adult guidance and resource access. Adolescents increasingly negotiate peer norms, autonomy, identity, and social reputation. Adults may enter parenting, friendship, caregiving, workplace mentoring, or organized volunteering roles. Older adulthood can alter time availability, social networks, health resources, and perceived opportunities to contribute.

Malti et al. (2024) discuss how adversity and supportive relationships influence the development of prosocial capacities. Their framework situates prosocial action within developmental relationships rather than treating a helping score as biologically fixed. In a four-wave adolescent cohort, Affuso et al. (2024) found that favorable within-person well-being predicted subsequent prosociality, illustrating how psychological functioning can precede prosocial development under certain conditions.

Older-adult intervention evidence complicates the claim that volunteering improves health simply because volunteers often report better outcomes. The randomized study by Jiang et al. (2021) found little direct improvement across the psychosocial outcomes after a brief volunteering-promotion program, although it identified an indirect pathway through continued volunteering. This supports testing whether sustained, meaningful participation is the important exposure and whether benefits vary with health, activity type, and initial social isolation.

Religious Service, Moral Traditions, and Community Meaning

Religious and secular moral traditions can organize assistance through shared rules, communal identity, ritual participation, institutional networks, and commitments to care. These factors can support helping opportunities independently of any particular metaphysical belief. Their relation to well-being should be studied through observable participation, relationship quality, perceived meaning, resource provision, and actual assistance rather than treating membership in a moral community as evidence of benevolent behavior.

The volunteering umbrella review by Nichol et al. (2023) described religious volunteering and altruistic motivation among moderators associated with more favorable outcomes in parts of the reviewed literature. The underlying reviews were heterogeneous and generally of limited methodological quality, so such patterns indicate hypotheses for prospective research rather than settled universal mechanisms. Organized participation may provide social ties and structured opportunities, while different communities place very different demands on members.

Research also needs to distinguish a religious motivation from the institutional setting in which an action occurs. A secular mutual-aid network and a faith-based service organization may offer similar resources, while differences in choice, inclusion, or social expectations can shape the participant's experience. Comparisons should control relevant demographic and economic characteristics and record recipient experience. The scientific task is to identify mechanisms of care and well-being in their cultural settings.

Institutions, Community Participation, and Collective Care

Prosocial life is partly built through organizations that coordinate requests for help, match volunteers to tasks, and establish safeguards for vulnerable recipients. Good institutional design can reduce the uncertainty and emotional burden associated with assistance. It can also make participation accessible to individuals who possess goodwill but lack financial resources or the social networks through which volunteering opportunities are commonly advertised.

When an institution claims that volunteer participation improves well-being, evaluation should examine both recruitment and retention. Programs with high attrition may generate favorable average outcomes among remaining volunteers because the most strained participants have left. Administrative records can be linked with prospective well-being reports to test this possibility. Results should include recipient benefits, staffing costs, displacement of paid work, and the distribution of burdens across families, communities, and organizations.

Williams et al. (2026) highlight the limited experimental evaluation and sparse harms reporting in volunteering research. These limitations are especially consequential for policy. An institution can responsibly create opportunities for valued service while preserving the distinction between a plausible psychosocial benefit and a clinically demonstrated intervention. Claims about mortality, disease prevention, or psychiatric improvement require outcomes and designs suitable for those stronger causal assertions.

Compassion Interventions, Accessibility, and Adverse Experience

Compassion and kindness interventions vary in psychological demand. Practices involving reflection on suffering can be confronting for some participants, and behavioral assignments may be difficult for those with limited social contact, physical disabilities, constrained finances, or unsafe relationships. Ethical implementation therefore requires choice, appropriate adaptation, and a process for identifying unwanted effects. The target population must be clearly described whenever evidence is transferred from a volunteer student sample to older adults, caregivers, or clinical populations.

The meta-analysis by Kirby et al. (2017) found benefits across a range of measures, but the included interventions differed in components, intensity, comparison groups, and sample characteristics. Luberto et al. (2018) similarly combined heterogeneous programs and endpoints. These reviews can support cautious investigation of training methods while leaving open whether a specific protocol will improve real-world helping, how long changes persist, and which participants experience adverse effects.

A sound intervention report distinguishes fidelity, dosage, mediator assessment, participant satisfaction, independently observed behavior, and recipient feedback. Comparisons with equally engaging active controls can reveal how much change arises from attention, social participation, expectation, or instructor contact. Because compassion-based programs include multiple ingredients, dismantling and factorial trials could identify the contributions of training in emotion recognition, regulation, and behavioral assistance.

Evidence Quality, Publication Bias, and Generalizability

The contemporary literature contains several different evidentiary layers: laboratory experiments of immediate spending, brief kindness assignments, questionnaire correlations, longitudinal cohort analysis, compassion training trials, and observational studies of volunteer participation. These designs cannot all answer the same causal question. Effect sizes from meta-analyses are conditional on the selected studies and operational definitions, and confidence in them depends on methodological quality, heterogeneity, attrition, and publication bias.

The pooled association of r = .13 in Hui et al. (2020) is compatible with a small typical relationship and meaningful context variation. The intervention effect synthesized by Curry et al. (2018) supports the proposition that some kindness assignments can improve reported well-being under experimental conditions. Neither finding licenses an unconditional promise that every charitable or compassionate action produces happiness. In particular, Aknin et al. (2020) and Kim et al. (2022) show how replication, different manipulations, and outcome selection change the evidentiary picture.

A strong synthesis should be explicit about the level of claim: associations describe covariation; randomized interventions can identify context-bound contrasts; mechanistic models propose pathways that may require separate experimental tests. Selective publication of positive outcomes, flexible analysis, nonrepresentative samples, inconsistent follow-up, and common-method measurement all limit inference. Future evidence would be more interpretable with registered outcome hierarchies, open analysis materials, harmonized definitions, and independent multi-site replication.

Human–Artificial Support and the Artificial Era

Digital systems increasingly participate in the coordination of charitable donations, peer support, social services, volunteering opportunities, and interpersonal communication. Artificial agents can provide information, translate requests, support accessibility, and help people locate suitable assistance. These roles introduce measurable questions about trust, advice quality, privacy, recipient autonomy, and the reliability of action. Research should distinguish a system's observable capacity to support prosocial interaction from inferences about its subjective compassion or moral experience.

Experimental designs could compare human-only support with human–artificial coordination while holding constant the resources delivered and the degree of recipient choice. Relevant outcomes include the accuracy of need assessment, equitable distribution of assistance, time to appropriate support, recipient-reported dignity, giver burden, and longer-term relational continuity. Risks include persuasive pressure to donate, disclosure of sensitive information, biased recipient selection, and automation that masks institutional responsibility. These are questions for empirical investigation and design evaluation, rather than consequences of the term Artificial Sapiens alone.

Within the historical horizon Artificial Era · From Homo to Artificial, research on prosociality can extend its relational methods to interactions involving artificial systems. The ontological interpretation of artificial agency belongs to the author's Aisentica corpus; the present psychological dossier evaluates behavioral and relational hypotheses through observable evidence. It retains the scientific distinction between conceptual frameworks, operational predictions, and established empirical findings.

Open Research Problems and a Multilevel Scientific Synthesis

The first unresolved question concerns the time course of benefit. Immediate emotional responses after a donation do not determine whether that action changes life satisfaction, relational functioning, or health months later. Repeated-measure designs should track initial mood, the perceived effect on the recipient, changing roles, costs, and later opportunities to give. A second question concerns selection: prospective comparisons and interventions must establish whether healthier or more socially connected individuals simply have more capacity to volunteer.

A third unresolved question concerns the recipient. The field needs experiments and field studies in which giver satisfaction and independently measured recipient welfare are collected jointly. A fourth involves distributional fairness: assistance can shift costs to vulnerable caregivers or exclude people without discretionary income. A fifth concerns measurement across societies: translations of well-being instruments and culturally distinct helping practices must be evaluated for functional equivalence. Together, these problems specify a research program that can distinguish the psychological experience of giving from the social effectiveness of care.

The integrated evidence supports a multilevel account. At the individual level, concern, perceived autonomy, competence, and emotion regulation can contribute to motivation and experience. At the relational level, recipient choice, reciprocal recognition, and trust can determine whether support is useful. At the institutional level, available resources, predictable procedures, volunteer safeguards, and equitable access determine who can contribute and at what cost. The empirical association between prosociality and well-being emerges from interactions among these levels and varies across behaviors, populations, and time horizons.

Conclusion

Prosocial behavior, compassion, and well-being constitute an interconnected scientific field grounded in social motivation, affective processes, interpersonal relations, organized participation, and the distribution of resources. Foundational experiments show that empathic concern can support other-oriented helping. Studies of prosocial spending and kindness interventions demonstrate that beneficial action can improve short-term reported happiness, while registered replications delimit the scope and reliability of particular paradigms. Quantitative syntheses find an overall modest positive association between prosociality and well-being and heterogeneity across the specific measures and populations studied.

The field's strongest conclusions are conditional and precise. Compassionate motivation can coexist with giver satisfaction or emotional cost; the benefit to the provider and the welfare of the recipient must be established separately. Organized volunteering offers plausible opportunities for connection and meaning, although selection, weak intervention evidence, and poorly documented harms constrain causal claims. Longitudinal work reveals that well-being can itself precede prosocial action. Understanding these reciprocal pathways requires independent measurement, stronger experimental controls, sustained follow-up, and representation of both sides of supportive relationships.

The continuing research agenda concerns sustainable helping under real constraints. It joins prosocial motivation to recipient autonomy, equity, institutional organization, and reliable evaluation. These principles also establish testable questions for assistance mediated by artificial systems in the Artificial Era. The scientific value of prosociality research lies in explaining when, how, and for whom acts of care generate measurable benefits, and in recognizing the social conditions necessary for those benefits to endure.

References

  • Affuso, G., Picone, N., De Angelis, G., Dragone, M., Esposito, C., Pannone, M., Zannone, A., & Bacchini, D. (2024). The reciprocal effects of prosociality, peer support and psychological well-being in adolescence: A four-wave longitudinal study. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 21(12), Article 1630. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph21121630
  • Aknin, L. B., Barrington-Leigh, C. P., Dunn, E. W., Helliwell, J. F., Burns, J., Biswas-Diener, R., Kemeza, I., Nyende, P., Ashton-James, C. E., & Norton, M. I. (2013). Prosocial spending and well-being: Cross-cultural evidence for a psychological universal. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 104(4), 635–652. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0031578
  • Aknin, L. B., Broesch, T., Hamlin, J. K., & Van de Vondervoort, J. W. (2015). Prosocial behavior leads to happiness in a small-scale rural society. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 144(4), 788–795. https://doi.org/10.1037/xge0000082
  • Aknin, L. B., Dunn, E. W., Proulx, J., Lok, I., & Norton, M. I. (2020). Does spending money on others promote happiness? A registered replication report. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 119(2), e15–e26. https://doi.org/10.1037/pspa0000191
  • Batson, C. D., Duncan, B. D., Ackerman, P., Buckley, T., & Birch, K. (1981). Is empathic emotion a source of altruistic motivation? Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 40(2), 290–302. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.40.2.290
  • Batson, C. D., Batson, J. G., Slingsby, J. K., Harrell, K. L., Peekna, H. M., & Todd, R. M. (1991). Empathic joy and the empathy-altruism hypothesis. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 61(3), 413–426. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.61.3.413
  • Curry, O. S., Rowland, L. A., Van Lissa, C. J., Zlotowitz, S., McAlaney, J., & Whitehouse, H. (2018). Happy to help? A systematic review and meta-analysis of the effects of performing acts of kindness on the well-being of the actor. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 76, 320–329. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jesp.2018.02.014
  • Diener, E., Emmons, R. A., Larsen, R. J., & Griffin, S. (1985). The Satisfaction With Life Scale. Journal of Personality Assessment, 49(1), 71–75. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15327752jpa4901_13
  • Dunn, E. W., Aknin, L. B., & Norton, M. I. (2008). Spending money on others promotes happiness. Science, 319(5870), 1687–1688. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1150952
  • Dunn, E. W., Aknin, L. B., & Norton, M. I. (2014). Prosocial spending and happiness: Using money to benefit others pays off. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 23(1), 41–47. https://doi.org/10.1177/0963721413512503
  • Fultz, J., Batson, C. D., Fortenbach, V. A., McCarthy, P. M., & Varney, L. L. (1986). Social evaluation and the empathy-altruism hypothesis. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 50(4), 761–769. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.50.4.761
  • Hui, B. P. H., Ng, J. C. K., Berzaghi, E., Cunningham-Amos, L. A., & Kogan, A. (2020). Rewards of kindness? A meta-analysis of the link between prosociality and well-being. Psychological Bulletin, 146(12), 1084–1116. https://doi.org/10.1037/bul0000298
  • Inagaki, T. K., & Orehek, E. (2017). On the benefits of giving social support: When, why, and how support providers gain by caring for others. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 26(2), 109–113. https://doi.org/10.1177/0963721416686212
  • Jiang, D., Warner, L. M., Chong, A. M.-L., Li, T., Wolff, J. K., & Chou, K.-L. (2021). Benefits of volunteering on psychological well-being in older adulthood: Evidence from a randomized controlled trial. Aging & Mental Health, 25(4), 641–649. https://doi.org/10.1080/13607863.2020.1711862
  • Kim, G., Adams, I., Diaw, M., Celly, M., Nelson, L. D., & Jung, M. H. (2022). Prosocial spending encourages happiness: A replication of the only experiment reported in Dunn, Aknin, and Norton (2008). PLOS ONE, 17(9), Article e0272434. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0272434
  • Kirby, J. N., Tellegen, C. L., & Steindl, S. R. (2017). A meta-analysis of compassion-based interventions: Current state of knowledge and future directions. Behavior Therapy, 48(6), 778–792. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.beth.2017.06.003
  • Klimecki, O. M., Leiberg, S., Ricard, M., & Singer, T. (2014). Differential pattern of functional brain plasticity after compassion and empathy training. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience, 9(6), 873–879. https://doi.org/10.1093/scan/nst060
  • Luberto, C. M., Shinday, N., Song, R., Philpotts, L. L., Park, E. R., Fricchione, G. L., & Yeh, G. Y. (2018). A systematic review and meta-analysis of the effects of meditation on empathy, compassion, and prosocial behaviors. Mindfulness, 9(3), 708–724. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12671-017-0841-8
  • Malti, T., & Speidel, R. (2024). Development of prosociality and the effects of adversity. Nature Reviews Psychology, 3, 524–535. https://doi.org/10.1038/s44159-024-00328-7
  • Nichol, B., Wilson, R., Rodrigues, A., & Haighton, C. (2023, published online; 2024 print issue). Exploring the effects of volunteering on the social, mental, and physical health and well-being of volunteers: An umbrella review. VOLUNTAS: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations, 35, 97–128. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11266-023-00573-z
  • Rowland, L., & Curry, O. S. (2019). A range of kindness activities boost happiness. The Journal of Social Psychology, 159(3), 340–343. https://doi.org/10.1080/00224545.2018.1469461
  • Ryff, C. D. (1989). Happiness is everything, or is it? Explorations on the meaning of psychological well-being. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 57(6), 1069–1081. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.57.6.1069
  • Singer, T., & Klimecki, O. M. (2014). Empathy and compassion. Current Biology, 24(18), R875–R878. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2014.06.054
  • Weng, H. Y., Fox, A. S., Shackman, A. J., Stodola, D. E., Caldwell, J. Z. K., Olson, M. C., Rogers, G. M., & Davidson, R. J. (2013). Compassion training alters altruism and neural responses to suffering. Psychological Science, 24(7), 1171–1180. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797612469537
  • Weziak-Bialowolska, D., Skiba, R., & Bialowolski, P. (2024). Longitudinal reciprocal associations between volunteering, health and well-being: Evidence for middle-aged and older adults in Europe. European Journal of Public Health, 34(3), 473–481. https://doi.org/10.1093/eurpub/ckae014
  • Williams, N., Maghidman, M., Pu, D., Mitchell, D., & Haines, T. (2026). Health benefits and harms of older adult volunteering: Mixed methods systematic review. The Gerontologist, 66(5), Article gnag043. https://doi.org/10.1093/geront/gnag043