RESEARCH DOSSIER
Prayer, Contemplative Communication, and Psychological Regulation
Abstract. Prayer encompasses intentional forms of sacred address, contemplation, petition, thanksgiving, confession, receptive attention, and interpersonal communication. This fundamental research monograph examines how prayer is represented and enacted psychologically, reconstructing historical and contemporary typologies, the empirical study of attentional and emotional regulation, imagined dialogue, social cognition, religious coping, neuroimaging, sensory interpretation, stress, and clinical outcomes. The method is a critical narrative synthesis of original experiments, psychometric studies, cross-cultural observational research, clinical trials, and published systematic reviews; no new experiment, registered systematic review, or quantitative meta-analysis was conducted. Evidence supports differentiated associations and task-specific changes in anger, social-cognitive recruitment, felt security, pain appraisal, and aspects of psychological well-being. Observational findings do not establish causality, in-person prayer interventions combine multiple active components, and randomized distant intercession has not demonstrated clinical benefit. Particular attention is given to spiritual struggles, intrusive-thought neutralization, consent, confounding, causal comparators, replication, and transportability. A coherent future research agenda requires episode-level measurement, culturally valid operationalization, longitudinal observation, and independently replicated active-comparator experiments.
Keywords: prayer; contemplative communication; psychological regulation; psychology of religion; religious cognition; emotion regulation; attention; imagined dialogue; sacred attachment; religious coping; religious and spiritual struggles; thanksgiving prayer; petitionary prayer; intercessory prayer; social cognition; psychological well-being; psychophysiology; prayer neuroscience; clinical research; research methods; Artificial Era
Scientific Overview: Prayer as an Object of Psychological Research
Prayer is a family of culturally organized activities in which a person addresses, attends to, or maintains a relationship with a sacred or transcendent referent. It can be spoken or silent, scripted or improvised, solitary or shared. The psychological object is the enacted practice: its attention, language, imagery, affect, expectations, relational meanings, and consequences for action. The reported reality of the addressee belongs to participants' lived experience and explanatory frameworks. Scientific analysis examines observable processes and reported outcomes while accurately representing the religious interpretation given by practitioners. A prayer frequency item alone cannot specify which of these processes occurred. Ladd & Spilka (2002) Laird et al. (2004)
This monograph asks how different prayers organize cognition and emotion, what people understand themselves to be doing when they pray, which psychological and neural processes have been measured, and what follows from controlled studies and longitudinal or cross-sectional evidence. It includes petition, adoration, confession, thanksgiving, reception, contemplative attention, and interpersonal prayer. It examines individual outcomes and the interactional meaning of prayer offered in another person's presence. Collective ritual and general meditation are related research domains examined here only where they illuminate prayer-specific mechanisms. Poloma & Pendleton (1989) Schjoedt et al. (2009)
The method is a structured critical narrative synthesis of identified original experimental, psychometric, qualitative, cross-cultural, clinical, and neuroscience studies, supplemented by published reviews. Studies are compared by their operational definitions and causal leverage. Source identification was conducted through scientific databases and journal records, and numerical claims are used only where visible in identifiable original abstracts or accessible articles. The review has no registered protocol, comprehensive search audit, risk-of-bias coding by independent reviewers, or pooled effect estimate; it is therefore a monograph rather than a formal systematic review or meta-analysis. Masters & Spielmans (2007) Brandão (2025)
Conceptual Boundaries: Prayer, Contemplation, Meditation, and Worship
The term contemplative communication identifies prayer episodes with sustained attention toward an experienced sacred addressee, including listening, imagining responses, or interpreting felt guidance. It is an analytic description of a practice rather than a validated diagnostic scale. In some traditions, contemplation seeks receptive stillness and minimal verbal activity; in others, it includes repeated words, scriptural reflection, devotional visualization, or direct conversational address. Shared attentional features do not establish functional equivalence. A study of a breathing exercise, for example, should not be represented as direct evidence about petitionary prayer. Ladd & Spilka (2006) Crosswell et al. (2024)
Religious worship may contain prayer, music, synchronous movement, prescribed responses, and identity-affirming social participation. Their joint effects require designs that isolate the specific practice being investigated. Similarly, an encounter with a chaplain or prayer practitioner adds interpersonal contact, expectancy, touch, encouragement, and community recognition to the verbal prayer itself. Inferences about the efficacy of words directed to a sacred agent require different comparisons from inferences about the value of receiving caring human attention. These distinctions are especially consequential in clinical studies and experiments on intercession. Schjoedt et al. (2011) Jacobson et al. (2026)
The scope of psychological regulation includes shifting attention, reappraising stressors, expressing emotion, seeking reassurance, reorganizing goals, tolerating uncertainty, and mobilizing help-seeking behavior. Regulation may produce momentary comfort, persistent adaptation, avoidance, or heightened distress depending on content and context. A decrease in arousal following prayer is one outcome among several, not a general definition of effective regulation. Prayer may make loss more tolerable while preserving grief, increase moral accountability while temporarily increasing guilt, or support decisive action without removing uncertainty. Gross (1998) Pargament et al. (2000)
Historical Foundations of the Psychological Study of Prayer
Early psychological writing on religious experience made inner testimony, intentionality, conversion, and prayer legitimate objects for description. William James's The Varieties of Religious Experience, published in 1902, treated religious feeling and its consequences as phenomena open to psychological inquiry while acknowledging differences among traditions and individual histories. The enduring methodological question is how to relate first-person reports to outward conduct without equating an interpreter's judgment of spiritual truth with a psychological observation. Later empirical research translated these broad concerns into observable variables and questionnaires. James (1902)
During the late twentieth century, survey and factor-analytic work displaced the assumption that prayer was a single homogeneous behavior. Poloma and Pendleton's 1989 analysis distinguished colloquial, petitionary, ritual, and meditative forms using survey items and associated these forms differently with quality-of-life measures. This was an important measurement advance because multiple practices could generate divergent correlations even within the same population. The typology arose from a specific American survey setting, and category meanings require translation and validation before application to other religious and secular contexts. Poloma & Pendleton (1989)
Research subsequently connected prayer to cognitive activity, relational representation, coping with crises, physiological states, and experimental emotion regulation. Ladd and Spilka examined inward, outward, and upward cognitive foci, whereas the RCOPE work by Pargament and colleagues embedded religious responses within multidimensional stress and meaning processes. In the twenty-first century, functional imaging and cross-cultural fieldwork made it possible to examine social cognition and sensory interpretation during specific prayer practices. These programs are complementary because they measure different levels of organization, from narratives and thoughts to hemodynamic correlates. Ladd & Spilka (2002) Pargament et al. (2000) Schjoedt et al. (2009)
Taxonomies of Prayer and Their Explanatory Limits
The distinction between types of prayer has theoretical significance because form influences the opportunities for regulation. Supplication seeks assistance with a concrete concern; thanksgiving foregrounds benefits and benefactors; confession makes perceived wrongdoing available for reflection; adoration allocates attention to valued qualities of the sacred; reception involves listening or waiting; and petition for others may shift an individual's focus toward another person's needs. Laird and colleagues developed a multidimensional private-prayer inventory including these five broad types and reported initial evidence of factor discrimination and clinical relevance in arthritis. Their categories are operational proposals rather than exhaustive universals. Laird et al. (2004)
Ladd and Spilka's 2002 factor-analytic work separated inward, outward, and upward connections through the thoughts respondents associated with prayer. Their subsequent scale-validation study supported a hierarchical interpretation with a general prayer dimension, three subfactors, and eight specific scales. The difference between the two reports demonstrates why theory, instrument, and analytical sample matter: the apparent existence of a general factor can change when item wording, sample composition, and modeling choices change. A spiritual practice is multidimensional even when statistical summaries can represent it through broader factors. Ladd & Spilka (2002) Ladd & Spilka (2006)
Prayer classifications should not be treated as interchangeable outcome mechanisms. Two respondents may both report a daily petition while differing in perceived divine responsiveness, certainty, emotional tone, and whether the request is accompanied by practical action. An ostensibly grateful prayer might express genuine appreciation or be used as a compulsory response to guilt. A meditative prayer may sustain openness in one setting and elicit intrusive worries in another. Research therefore needs repeated episode-level assessment of intention, content, context, appraisal, and immediate psychological response, rather than relying exclusively on how often someone reports praying. Pérez et al. (2011) Exline et al. (2014)
Theoretical Models: Meaning, Social Cognition, and Regulatory Process
A cognitive model treats prayer as an organized sequence of perception, attention, retrieval, imagination, self-monitoring, and interpretation. A relational model treats the sacred addressee as a psychologically represented interlocutor whose expected benevolence, availability, authority, or distance can influence felt security and appraisal. A coping model examines the practice as a response to demands experienced as threatening or exceeding current resources. These explanations can coexist within a particular prayer episode and need not imply the same outcome for every practitioner. Each mechanism requires its own observable indicators and appropriate counterfactual comparison. Schjoedt et al. (2009) Pargament et al. (2000)
An emotion-regulation framework locates possible effects at successive points in the emotional process: choosing or modifying situations, directing attention, interpreting events, and changing expressive or bodily responses. Prayer can alter a person's description of a crisis before its meaning stabilizes, provide words for a difficult emotion, or guide choices after the emotional response occurs. The process model developed by Gross gives a useful comparison framework, although its validation does not itself prove that prayer produces any particular physiological effect. Prayer-specific experiments are needed to adjudicate the proposed links. Gross (1998) Bremner et al. (2011)
The explanatory challenge is to separate the general benefits of structured attention, repeated language, expressive disclosure, supportive imagery, and expectancy from the additional significance of addressing a perceived sacred other. Studies that compare prayer with silent rest alone confound many ingredients. Stronger tests compare credible, meaning-matched prayer, self-talk, secular reflection, interpersonal support, and routine activity, while measuring whether the participants identify the tasks as psychologically equivalent. This requirement follows from competing mechanisms and from newer prayer-versus-self-talk experiments, whose 2026 results are currently available as a preprint rather than a peer-reviewed publication. Cherniak et al. (2026, preprint) Masters & Spielmans (2007)
Petition, Agency, and the Appraisal of Controllability
Petitionary prayer presents a problem, request, or hope to a sacred addressee. Its psychological consequences depend on what agency is assigned to the person and to the addressee. A request can coexist with planning, treatment adherence, and interpersonal action; it can also become associated with passivity or persistent efforts to resolve uncertainty through repetition. The mere presence of petition is consequently a poor predictor of adaptation. RCOPE's differentiated coping categories offer a more informative description by asking whether people seek collaborative action, relinquish feared control, reinterpret stress, or experience conflict with the sacred. Pargament et al. (2000)
The timing of petitions matters. An urgent prayer during exposure to threat may redirect attention and provide an immediately available response, even where practical options are constrained. A later prayer may help organize a course of action or reinforce expectations about future events. These mechanisms can be tested by recording stress appraisal before and after a defined prayer task and comparing outcomes with equally credible problem-solving or supportive reflection. Observational associations between high petitionary frequency and distress can also reflect reverse causation: people facing more problems may pray more, and the petitions themselves may be indicators of adversity. Masters & Spielmans (2007) Froese et al. (2024)
Psychological control should be measured at several levels. Perceived personal efficacy, acceptance of uncertainty, perceived external assistance, behavioral persistence, and objective task performance are separable outcomes. A person may relinquish the demand to control a medical outcome yet become more willing to attend appointments; another may experience petition as evidence that human action is futile. Studies that treat these experiences as one 'external locus of control' conceal the distinction between relinquished certainty and relinquished responsibility. A valid account compares concrete subsequent behavior with prior expectations, not only post-prayer reassurance. Pérez et al. (2011) Brandão (2025)
Thanksgiving, Adoration, and Positive Emotional Orientation
Thanksgiving prayer focuses awareness on perceived gifts, assistance, relationships, or fortunate circumstances. Its possible mechanisms include positive-memory retrieval, selective attention to support, gratitude-related appraisal, and a shift from immediate threat toward meaningful continuity. The relevant dependent variables may be positive affect, interpersonal appreciation, relief from rumination, or sustained prosocial action. Each represents a different hypothesis. Prayer that names a specific relationship has a different cognitive content from a generic gratitude inventory, although both can orient attention toward a valued benefit. Laird et al. (2004) Pérez et al. (2011)
In a cross-sectional study of 179 adult cancer outpatients, Pérez and colleagues found that thanksgiving prayer was associated with fewer depressive symptoms and that statistical mediation involving rumination was consistent with a possible regulatory pathway. The reported indirect effect was an estimate within an observational path model. It cannot establish that gratitude prayer reduced rumination and thereby caused lower depression. Cancer burden, disposition to gratitude, family support, and selection into specific prayer modes may influence both reported practice and mental health. The sample's predominantly White, female, Christian composition also constrains generalization. Pérez et al. (2011)
Adoration can direct attention toward admired qualities or a larger value system, giving a practitioner a reference for self-evaluation and action. It may facilitate awe, reverence, comfort, or motivation, but its effects depend on how the revered figure and relationship are represented. A benevolent image can encourage acceptance; an image dominated by rejection or punishment can have different emotional consequences. Because devotional terms are embedded in cultural meanings, researchers should include qualitative interpretation of participants' own descriptions when constructing adoration tasks and interpreting scales. Poloma & Pendleton (1989) Exline et al. (2014)
Confession, Guilt, Moral Repair, and Reconciliation
Confessional prayer makes a perceived mistake, violation, or failure explicit within a morally significant relationship. Its psychological functions can include acknowledging responsibility, organizing emotional disclosure, negotiating forgiveness, and committing to repair. A confession may produce distress while it makes wrongdoing salient and later support constructive behavior. An immediate reduction in anxiety is therefore an incomplete index of its value. The appropriate outcomes depend on the circumstance: reduced destructive shame, increased accountability, willingness to apologize, accurate self-appraisal, or restoration of social trust. Laird et al. (2004) Gross (1998)
The emotional distinction between guilt tied to a specific action and global negative self-evaluation is important for research design. Confessional language that invites correction may differ from language of permanent condemnation; the same conventional prayer can be interpreted differently across people and communities. Measures should record what was believed to have happened, how blame was assigned, what response was expected, and whether the individual subsequently engaged in restitution. A generalized confession scale can miss these temporal and relational features. Religious and Spiritual Struggles Scale research offers related measures of moral and divine struggle, although its purpose is broader than classifying prayer itself. Exline et al. (2014)
Clinical contexts introduce a particularly consequential complication. Some people experiencing obsessional intrusive thoughts use repetitive compensatory prayer to neutralize feared moral danger. An experimental study of 85 Christian-identifying students linked such responding with moral thought–action fusion and short-term anxiety reduction after prayer. The observation shows why immediate relief can reinforce a maladaptive cycle of intrusive thought and neutralization; it does not make ordinary confession or religious prayer pathological. Clinical assessment requires the person's degree of choice, distress, functional impairment, repetition, and relationship to feared consequences. Berman et al. (2014)
Receptive Prayer, Listening, and Imagined Dialogue
Receptive prayer emphasizes waiting, attending, and becoming available to perceived guidance. In traditions of conversational prayer, participants may direct questions to God and report impressions, memories, ideas, or inner words as responses. These experiences involve attention to internally generated material and learned rules for interpreting its source and meaning. The relevant cognitive phenomenon is source attribution under a particular social and religious model. The research question concerns how instructions, practice history, expectancy, individual imagery capacity, and community feedback shape such interpretations. Schille-Hudson et al. (2024) Luhrmann et al. (2021)
Interview-based work makes clear that prayer can be organized as an imagined conversation carrying the emotional functions of social interaction. Sharp's qualitative analysis of intimate partner violence survivors described prayer as providing an imagined other for emotional disclosure, affirmative appraisal, cognitive reinterpretation, attentional redirection, and modeling emotional responses. These mechanisms are grounded in participants' accounts and an interpretive theoretical framework, not in a randomized demonstration that the imagined interaction caused recovery. Treating participants' own religious language accurately is essential to understanding how the practice functions for them. Sharp (2010)
A 2024 study by Schille-Hudson, Weisman, and Luhrmann found, across three studies and five cultures, that time spent in prayer correlated with several forms of reported spiritual perception, especially ordinary dreams, emotions, or thoughts interpreted as originating outside the self. Associations were also reported for voices or sensed presence, but not for some more dramatic experiences such as possession or sleep paralysis. These differentiated results challenge any model in which more prayer uniformly heightens all unusual experiences. They also leave causal direction and the influence of self-selection open. Schille-Hudson et al. (2024)
Attachment Representations and Perceived Sacred Support
Relational models investigate how a person represents the sacred addressee as present, caring, responsive, demanding, distant, or rejecting. Such representations may resemble familiar processes of social expectation and support seeking without requiring researchers to equate a spiritual relationship with an ordinary interpersonal relationship. Prayer can activate internalized responses to abandonment, protection, or evaluation and can influence whether a stressor is appraised as shared or faced alone. The model generates testable predictions about attachment measures, momentary felt security, and the perceived availability of support across different prayer tasks. Schjoedt et al. (2009) Sharp (2010)
The 2026 preregistered preprint by Cherniak, Granqvist, and Mikulincer describes three experiments comparing prayer reflection with self-talk and routine-activity conditions in Jewish participants. Across the reported studies, prayer increased felt security and empathic concern relative to both controls; positive affect increased similarly with prayer and self-talk relative to routine activity. Effects on negative affect and transcendence were more differentiated, and attachment avoidance toward God moderated certain responses. These results are promising direct tests of relational specificity; their current preprint status and use of brief reflection primes limit conclusions about regular prayer practice. Cherniak et al. (2026, preprint)
Perceived divine support can also interact with human support. A person who experiences prayer as reassurance may become more willing to contact family, professional helpers, or community members. In other circumstances, fear of disapproval or an expectation of punishment may intensify isolation. A rigorous study must therefore collect data on social-network access, religious setting, prior attachment experiences, the immediate content of prayer, and subsequent help seeking. Analyses restricted to a global prayer-frequency score cannot identify these mediating processes or establish that sacred attachment is protective across all forms of distress. Pérez et al. (2011) Exline et al. (2014)
Attention, Absorption, and the Regulation of Mental Salience
Prayer makes some thoughts and images more prominent while reducing the availability of competing stimuli. Repetition of a familiar phrase may stabilize attentional selection, whereas improvised personal prayer may recruit autobiographical memory, internal speech, interpersonal simulation, and prospective thought. Contemplation can sustain attention to sensations, symbols, or the perceived presence of a sacred interlocutor. These tasks differ in working-memory demand and the scope of spontaneous thought. Claims about a unitary prayer-induced attentional state therefore require experimental specification of task instructions, stimulus content, duration, prior experience, and the comparison condition. Schjoedt et al. (2009) Ladd & Spilka (2002)
Absorption describes a tendency to become immersed in imagery or experience. In four cross-cultural studies involving more than two thousand participants, Luhrmann and colleagues connected immersive orientation and culturally shaped views of the mind–world boundary with reports of spiritual presence. The work supports a model in which attention and interpretation operate together, because a vivid inner event becomes religiously meaningful through learned assumptions about possible sources. It does not establish that prayer practice by itself creates new sensory capacities. Experimental training with preregistered perceptual measures is needed to separate training, self-selection, and changes in reporting criteria. Luhrmann et al. (2021)
Attentional regulation may be adaptive when it allows a practitioner to reengage with a difficult task after a period of calm. It may become constricting when sustained inward monitoring increases vigilance for unwanted mental events, invites compulsive reassurance, or displaces necessary decision making. Accordingly, a valid study should assess what the person attends to after prayer as well as during it. Repeated ecological assessment can record whether attention later broadens toward social engagement, practical problem solving, and flexible action, or returns compulsively to the same feared outcome. Berman et al. (2014) Masters & Spielmans (2007)
Prayer, Emotional Expression, and Cognitive Reappraisal
Prayer provides an organized setting for labeling emotion. A person may express anger, sorrow, fear, gratitude, or hope in language addressed to a personally meaningful listener. The imagined or believed relationship shapes how that expression is interpreted: it may authorize lament, contain an otherwise socially difficult disclosure, or prompt self-censorship where disapproval is expected. This means that prayer-based emotional expression cannot be identified solely through words such as 'comfort' or 'stress relief.' The speech act, perceived audience, and felt permission to express a particular emotion are distinct research variables. Sharp (2010) Laird et al. (2004)
Reappraisal occurs when an event is represented under a different meaning. In prayer, this can involve interpreting adversity within a moral story, considering the perspective of another person, remembering prior support, or changing an estimate of what matters most. The capacity for reframing is a familiar emotion-regulation mechanism; its existence does not establish that all reframing is accurate or ethically desirable. Some interpretations diminish threat while others intensify perceived guilt or imply that suffering reflects punishment. Research must consider both immediate distress and downstream behavior before characterizing a reappraisal as beneficial. Gross (1998) Exline et al. (2014)
Sharp's interviews with survivors of intimate partner violence illustrate the interpretive complexity of emotionally meaningful prayer. The identified strategies included venting anger and obtaining positive reflected appraisals, but the practical meaning of these strategies depends on safety, power, available assistance, and consequences for decisions about relationships. A person can report emotional relief without a corresponding improvement in external circumstances. Research should therefore examine coping and agency together, especially where harmful relationships or structural vulnerability form part of the stressor. Qualitative mechanisms deserve subsequent testing without prematurely assigning them a universal causal direction. Sharp (2010) Pargament et al. (2000)
Anger, Aggression, Forgiveness, and Prosocial Orientation
Prayer for another person can redirect attention from personal grievance toward the other's needs, vulnerability, or shared moral status. Bremner, Koole, and Bushman tested this idea in three experiments in which provoked participants prayed for another person or completed comparison reflection tasks. They reported lower anger, aggressive responses, or angry appraisal patterns in the prayer conditions according to the specific experiment. These findings provide experimental evidence for short-term regulation under structured laboratory circumstances, with outcomes tied to particular social prompts rather than to every form of prayer. Bremner et al. (2011)
The experimental contrast is important. Asking a participant to pray for the offender can induce perspective taking and prosocial attention at the same time as it activates a religious meaning system. The available results support the effectiveness of the assigned task relative to the study's controls, while a unique sacred-specific mechanism requires credible comparison tasks matched for benevolent wishes, perceived obligation, concentration, and interpersonal perspective. Differences in religious motivation and comfort with prayer may also modify compliance and the meaning of the manipulation. Future work could preregister mediators and measure behavioral choices after the provocation rather than relying only on ratings. Bremner et al. (2011) Cherniak et al. (2026, preprint)
Forgiveness should be distinguished from reconciliation, withdrawal of accountability, and tolerance of abuse. A prayer that reduces destructive anger need not entail restoring a relationship, declining protection, or denying wrongdoing. Positive prosocial regulation can support boundaries and protective decisions. Conversely, a socially pressured prayer may conceal anger while increasing self-reproach. Research focused on interpersonal harm should monitor behavioral consequences, asymmetries of power, perceived coercion, and longer-term changes in safety. The normative expectation that a prayerful person should be forgiving cannot substitute for empirical analysis of what people actually experience and do. Sharp (2010) Gross (1998)
Religious Coping: Resources, Conflict, and Stress Response
Religious coping is a broader construct than prayer, encompassing beliefs, community practices, interpretations of adversity, rituals, and relationships. Prayer can be one component. Pargament, Koenig, and Perez developed the RCOPE to measure multiple coping patterns, including expressions associated with perceived divine support and forms of conflict or abandonment. This work made it possible to distinguish strategies that may carry different implications even when they occur in the same religious population. Studies of prayer must measure coping functions directly when seeking to explain adaptation rather than treating all religious involvement as functionally identical. Pargament et al. (2000)
Ano and Vasconcelles's 2005 meta-analysis synthesized 49 studies and 105 effect sizes on religious coping and psychological adjustment. The overall pattern linked positive and negative forms of religious coping with correspondingly different adjustment profiles. Because religious coping extends far beyond prayer and the underlying designs varied, the findings support a differentiated research program rather than a numerical estimate of the therapeutic effect of praying. In particular, an association between constructive coping and well-being cannot exclude the possibility that people with more resources use different coping strategies from those experiencing intense distress. Ano & Vasconcelles (2005)
A systematic review of quantitative studies published in 2025 likewise identified religion and spirituality as relevant to emotion regulation but found conceptual and methodological heterogeneity across measures and populations. This literature supports testing precise pathways linking practice to emotion rather than inferring a uniform protective effect from religious identification. Better longitudinal work would establish which coping response precedes which psychological change, whether reciprocal feedback operates, and how contextual threats alter the meaning of prayer. The key unit of explanation is the situated coping episode nested within a person's life and cultural relations. Brandão (2025) Masters & Spielmans (2007)
Spiritual Struggles, Intrusive Thoughts, and Regulatory Costs
Prayer can occur in the setting of conflict with one's beliefs, moral ideals, or sacred relationship. Such conflict may include feeling abandoned, fearing punishment, doubting the legitimacy of religious expectations, or experiencing interpersonal exclusion. Exline and colleagues developed a 26-item Religious and Spiritual Struggles Scale addressing divine, demonic, interpersonal, moral, doubt-related, and ultimate-meaning dimensions. The instrument concerns struggle rather than prayer frequency, but it offers a way to study why superficially similar prayer behaviors correspond to relief for one person and distress for another. Exline et al. (2014)
Compensatory or neutralizing prayer deserves special care. In the 2014 experimental study of Christian-identified undergraduates, participants responded to induced intrusive thoughts and researchers examined how thought–action fusion and religious motivation related to compensatory prayer. The observed short-term reduction in anxiety for maladaptive prayer illustrates a learning mechanism: immediate relief can strengthen repetitive neutralization even where long-term anxiety remains. This is one experimental context, not a prevalence estimate or a diagnostic rule for religious practice generally. Clinical interpretation requires evidence of impairment, rigidity, distress, and loss of behavioral choice. Berman et al. (2014)
Religious practices also interact with shame, stigma, and cultural expectations. A prayer presented by family or institution as compulsory may carry very different psychological implications from a freely chosen exercise. In research, sampling from congregations alone can underrepresent people who have ceased attendance after spiritual struggles or who avoid discussing unwelcome experiences. Appropriate measures should include perceived choice, safety, community response, and the possibility that silence reflects conflict rather than well-being. Ethical interpretation requires attention to the person and setting instead of assigning positive or negative value to the practice in isolation. Exline et al. (2014) Froese et al. (2024)
Expectations, Perceived Authority, and Prayer Received from Others
A person receiving prayer experiences interpersonal behavior as well as religious communication. The perceived status of the prayer giver, expectation of benefit, social desirability, and the recipient's opportunity to express concerns can affect experience. Schjoedt and colleagues' 2011 experiment investigated how participants' judgments of a speaker's charismatic authority shaped neural responses to intercessory prayer. Their findings are informative about expectancy and social influence, although they do not isolate any objective healing effect and should not be generalized to all religious communities. Schjoedt et al. (2011)
Expectancy is not a nuisance variable that can simply be subtracted from meaningful prayer experiences. It is part of the lived encounter and may shape attention, safety signaling, and perceived relief. For causal attribution, however, investigators must distinguish what was caused by the whole interpersonal procedure from what would remain under a comparison equally matched for human contact, time, touch, interpersonal warmth, and credibility. Otherwise, a comparison of prayer with an emotionally neutral recording reveals the effects of an intervention package rather than a uniquely prayer-specific causal pathway. Jacobson et al. (2026) Crosswell et al. (2024)
Ethical consent is central to studies of received prayer. Individuals may welcome prayer, regard it as intrusive, experience it as social pressure, or interpret it as an implication that medical treatment is inadequate. Researchers should assess whether prayer was requested, whether declining was possible without penalty, what language and bodily contact occurred, and whether the practitioner was a person of perceived authority. Participant consent to an experiment and participant endorsement of its religious meaning are separate matters. These considerations shape interpretation and are research variables in their own right. Schjoedt et al. (2011) Jacobson et al. (2026)
Spiritual Perception, Absorption, and Interpretive Learning
Some practitioners report impressions of an unseen presence, unexpected inner words, vivid images, or bodily feelings during prayer. A scientific study can investigate when these experiences arise, how they are described, and how communities teach people to recognize and evaluate them. The 2021 multinational work by Luhrmann and colleagues found that absorption and cultural models of the boundary between mind and world helped account for reports of sensed spiritual presence. The pattern supports interaction between psychological predisposition and cultural learning rather than a universal sensory signature of prayer. Luhrmann et al. (2021)
In 2024, Schille-Hudson and colleagues examined prayer and perceptual experiences across cultural settings. They found associations between prayer duration and interpretations of everyday mental events as spiritual, with variations among experiences. This differentiation is essential: dreams, intuitions, emotions, sensed presence, and auditory experiences differ phenomenologically and may require distinct measures. If all are collapsed into an 'extraordinary experience' outcome, it becomes difficult to test whether a practice changes sensory vividness, beliefs about origin, narrative recall, or willingness to report an experience. Schille-Hudson et al. (2024)
Longitudinal and experimental training designs are needed to establish causal learning. One design could compare a prayer practice focused on attentive listening with meaning-matched reflective journaling while recording prior absorption, religious participation, and expected experiences. Experience-sampling methods could capture whether changes precede self-report shifts, and interviews could reveal altered categories of interpretation. Ethical protocols should avoid incentivizing misleading reports of unusual perceptions or pathologizing culturally ordinary spiritual accounts. Clinical significance is determined by impairment, distress, contextual interpretation, and broader functioning, not by spiritual attribution alone. Schille-Hudson et al. (2024) Exline et al. (2014)
Cultural Traditions, Linguistic Forms, and Comparative Validity
The term prayer covers distinct practices across religious histories. Some traditions emphasize a responsive personal divinity; others include chant, invocation, inward devotion, contemplation without an anthropomorphic interlocutor, or prescribed communal recitation. Researchers should therefore describe the practice using the participants' own terms and specify linguistic form, intention, social setting, and relevant teachings. An item such as 'How often do you talk to God?' may be meaningful within a theistic population but cannot index all prayer-centered practices across world traditions. Poloma & Pendleton (1989) Ladd & Spilka (2002)
Cross-cultural comparisons require more than translating questionnaire words. A construct may be experienced differently when sacred presence is understood as interpersonal, impersonal, ancestral, or embedded in ritual obligations. Multi-group measurement invariance, differential item functioning, and cognitive interviewing are necessary to determine whether scores from separate communities measure similar attributes. Otherwise, apparent group differences in contemplative engagement may reflect different interpretations of questions, familiarity with private prayer, or expectations about disclosure. The cultural variation documented in perception-related work underscores why a universal score should be demonstrated rather than assumed. Luhrmann et al. (2021) Schille-Hudson et al. (2024)
Sampling methods also influence conclusions. Student samples recruited from religious colleges, congregants who regularly attend services, and population-based panels represent different distributions of belief, experience, and social support. A community with strong prayer norms may produce socially desirable reporting, while a minority group may guard intimate practices from external researchers. Mixed methods can reveal whether a translated category has equivalent meaning, but cultural interpretation should not be used as a reason to abandon falsifiable analysis. The strongest comparative studies combine emic description with carefully calibrated common measures and transparent sampling frames. Laird et al. (2004) Froese et al. (2024)
Pain, Embodied Expectancy, and Physiological Regulation
Pain is an informative test case because self-reported intensity, unpleasantness, expectancy, sensory processing, and autonomic state can be measured separately. Elmholdt and colleagues' 2017 experiment enrolled 28 highly religious Protestants and compared religious with secular prayer during experimentally delivered electrical pain. Religious prayer was associated with reduced ratings of intensity and unpleasantness and reduced activity in parietofrontal networks. The authors found that expectancy accounted for much of the observed pain modulation, illustrating the interaction between meaning, expectation, and sensory appraisal. Elmholdt et al. (2017)
An experimental difference in pain ratings does not establish that prayer replaces analgesic treatment or produces the same effects in chronic illness. The laboratory model used short-duration stimuli with a selected religious sample, and subjective pain reports may reflect both sensory and affective components. Studies should report baseline symptoms, treatment, blinding conditions where feasible, pain catastrophizing, expectancy, follow-up, and adverse outcomes. The clinically meaningful question is how a voluntary practice interacts with appropriate care, not whether a brief laboratory task can stand in for complex clinical treatment. Elmholdt et al. (2017) Jacobson et al. (2026)
Crosswell and colleagues proposed a 2024 integrative 'deep rest' model of contemplative practice that connects safety signaling, stress physiology, and restorative resource allocation. It offers hypotheses applicable to prayer but is not direct experimental proof that prayer causes the proposed cellular changes. Studies of heart-rate variability, respiration, cortisol, immune function, and sleep must distinguish anticipatory shifts, contemporaneous responses, and sustained adaptation. Biological outcomes require adequate controls and multiple measurements, and a theoretical pathway does not become established merely because some contemplative practices correlate with better self-reported health. Crosswell et al. (2024)
Prayer and Mental Well-Being in Population Research
Large surveys provide a wider population frame than specialized religious recruitment, but their cross-sectional designs constrain causal inference. Froese, Bonhag, Uecker, Andersson, and Upenieks analyzed 2021 Baylor Religion Survey data reported in 2024. They examined prayer forms and emotions in relation to happiness, anxiety, depression, perceived control, dignity, and mattering. Praying with others and reporting positive emotions during prayer correlated with more favorable well-being indicators, whereas petition topics and negative emotional experiences coincided with less favorable indicators. This differentiated pattern shows the value of measuring prayer's meaning and immediate affective character. Froese et al. (2024)
These associations are compatible with several pathways. Positive prayer experiences could support later well-being; well-being could affect how prayer is experienced; and social support, previous adversity, or personality could influence both. Statistical adjustment for demographic characteristics and service attendance reduces some measured confounding without resolving temporal ordering or unmeasured differences. Petitionary prayer may become common during periods of acute distress, which can produce a negative association even if the practice helps individuals cope with hardship. An accurate empirical conclusion reports the association and the remaining causal uncertainty together. Froese et al. (2024) Masters & Spielmans (2007)
A population-level study should distinguish the extensive margin of whether someone prays from the intensive margin of how, when, and why they pray. Public, communal, scripted, and private practices may involve different networks of relationships and disclosure. People who report no prayer may have rich nonreligious coping repertoires, while individuals who pray daily may differ in emotional content. Longitudinal surveys and within-person observations could evaluate whether increases in distress precede petition and whether changes in prayer content predict later adjustment after accounting for stable personal characteristics. Froese et al. (2024) Ladd & Spilka (2002)
Prayer in Serious Illness: Coping, Selection, and Social Support
Illness frequently makes uncertainty, dependency, bodily vulnerability, and concern for loved ones salient. Prayer may provide a language for expressing fear and hope, organize practical support, and sustain an identity amid treatment. These meanings are psychological outcomes even when the medical condition does not change. Research on cancer outpatients found different associations across types of prayer: in a cross-sectional study of 179 adults, thanksgiving and prayer for others were associated with fewer depressive symptoms, with statistical mediation through rumination and social support respectively. The mediation design was correlational, so these patterns require longitudinal or experimental replication. Pérez et al. (2011)
The major confounding problem is indication: a worsening illness can cause both greater prayer and greater distress, making simple associations difficult to interpret. Severity, prognosis, access to care, religious community support, financial strain, and previous psychiatric symptoms can affect use and outcomes of prayer. An apparent protective association among individuals who remain engaged in support networks may also reflect selective participation. Prospective studies should report diagnosis, treatment, clinical stage, baseline symptoms, attrition, and the exact mode of prayer rather than treating prayer frequency as an independent exposure. Pérez et al. (2011) Froese et al. (2024)
Clinical support can respect a patient's religious coping without presenting prayer as treatment for the underlying illness. A patient may prefer silent private prayer, conversation with a chaplain, joint prayer with family, secular emotional support, or no prayer. The psychological aim is voluntary meaning-making and support in the individual's context, alongside appropriate evidence-based medical care. Clinicians and researchers should monitor when religious guilt, interpersonal pressure, or unrealistic claims intensify distress. Outcome measures should include both the patient's subjective benefit and the safety and continuity of professional care. Brandão (2025) Exline et al. (2014)
In-Person Intercessory Prayer: Experimental Evidence and Active Ingredients
Prayer delivered face to face combines spoken address with a recognizable social encounter. Boelens, Reeves, Replogle, and Koenig reported a 2009 randomized crossover study of direct person-to-person prayer for depression and anxiety. Participants assigned to six weekly one-hour prayer sessions showed improved symptom ratings relative to those receiving no prayer sessions, whereas salivary cortisol did not differ significantly. Because the intervention entailed repeated supportive interpersonal contact and the control condition lacked comparable sessions, these results do not isolate the effects of a sacred verbal act from therapist-like attention, expectancy, and relationship formation. Boelens et al. (2009)
A more recent 2026 primary care randomized trial by Jacobson and colleagues assigned 180 patients, 90 per group, to five minutes of in-person Christian prayer involving trained volunteers or five minutes of soft music. Participants assigned to prayer reported larger reductions in some pain and anxiety measures immediately and during follow-up. This supports a comparative effect of the tested intervention package in the studied population, and does not determine whether spoken prayer, touch, supportive presence, expectancy, or their combination produced the differences. The authors' financial and organizational interests also warrant transparent attention when interpreting clinical implications. Jacobson et al. (2026)
Design and measurement determine what can be concluded. In-person prayer trials need credible controls matching duration, touch permission, provider attention, emotional warmth, and expectation of relief. They should preregister primary endpoints and clinically meaningful differences, document attrition and treatment exposure, track existing care, and monitor unwanted experiences. Replication in independently recruited religious and nonreligious populations would test transportability. Small positive trials and favorable immediate symptom reports can motivate such investigations without establishing a universal therapeutic recommendation or a substitute for treatment with an established evidence base. Jacobson et al. (2026) Boelens et al. (2009)
Distant Intercessory Prayer and the Limits of Outcome Trials
Distant intercessory prayer is a distinct experimental claim: someone prays for patients without necessarily meeting them, and investigators test whether assignment to prayer changes measured clinical outcomes. It should be separated from the psychological effects of an individual's own prayer or receiving another person's visible emotional support. A distant-prayer recipient who is unaware of assignment may lack the attentional, meaning-making, and interpersonal pathways examined in much prayer psychology. Studies of this design thus test a different proposition from whether prayer helps a believer manage fear, anger, or uncertainty. Benson et al. (2006) Masters & Spielmans (2007)
The multicenter STEP trial reported by Benson and colleagues in 2006 randomized 1,802 cardiac bypass patients to three groups that varied in intercessory prayer and knowledge of its provision. Among those uncertain whether they received prayer, complication rates were 52% in the prayer group and 51% without prayer; the relative risk was 1.02 with a 95% confidence interval of 0.92–1.15. Among patients certain they would receive prayer, complications were recorded more often than among uncertain recipients who received prayer. The trial found no improvement in complication-free recovery attributable to distant prayer. Benson et al. (2006)
Masters and Spielmans's 2007 review and meta-analysis of prayer and health concluded that distant intercessory prayer studies provided no discernible overall effect. Such findings neither measure the existential meaning of devotion nor supply a general verdict on a participant's religious commitments. The inferential lesson is precise: controlled assignment to distant prayer has not established a reproducible benefit for the clinical outcomes studied. Psychological mechanisms remain appropriate subjects for separately designed experiments, with patient autonomy and care decisions governed by clinical standards. Masters & Spielmans (2007) Benson et al. (2006)
Clinical Boundaries, Safety, and Spiritually Responsive Practice
Prayer may be experienced as supportive, burdensome, compulsory, or frightening. Clinical judgment must address the content and consequences of the practice, particularly when a person attributes symptoms to punishment, repeatedly neutralizes intrusive thoughts, or is pressured to abandon medical treatment. A 2014 experimental study of prayer following intrusive thoughts illustrates that relief can reinforce repetitive neutralization in vulnerable circumstances. It supports assessment of rigidity, avoidance, impairment, and distress, rather than an assumption that prayer frequency alone indicates either health or disorder. Berman et al. (2014)
Consent and cultural humility matter equally. A patient should be able to request religious support and to decline it. Health professionals can ask what a practice means to the patient, whether it has been helpful or distressing, and whether it conflicts with care or personal safety. Such questions are also important when religious identity and family or institutional expectations diverge. In-person prayer trials should report who offered prayer, whether touch occurred, and how refusal or withdrawal was handled. Scientific evaluation is more reliable when participants' agency is protected and outcomes include adverse as well as beneficial experiences. Jacobson et al. (2026) Exline et al. (2014)
Clinical claims require independent replications, population-specific effect estimates, and evidence of benefits beyond credible active comparators. Studies of prayer may have value for understanding patient coping and preferences even when evidence for treating a disorder remains limited. For research participants with significant anxiety, depression, obsessive-compulsive symptoms, or pain, prayer may form part of their personal life while validated assessment, professional treatment, and medical follow-up remain essential. Claims about direct medical efficacy must reflect trial design and current evidence, with appropriate clinical review before any strong practice recommendations are published. Boelens et al. (2009) Masters & Spielmans (2007)
Operational Definitions, Constructs, and Measurement Validity
The first methodological obligation is to state which aspect of prayer is being studied. Frequency is a behavioral summary; meaning and intention are interpretive properties; expectation of response is a belief; felt support is an appraisal; and physiological arousal is a measured state. None automatically substitutes for the others. Prayer research often connects scores on broad religiosity scales with outcomes that plausibly depend on more proximal experiences. Valid explanation requires matching each theoretical construct with measures and observed events that can distinguish it from alternative explanations. Ladd & Spilka (2006) Laird et al. (2004)
Measurement validity can be assessed by comparing factor structures, temporal stability, reports from interviews, within-person covariation, and predictive behavior. The Multidimensional Prayer Inventory, inward–outward–upward scales, and religious coping instruments answer related but distinguishable questions. An instrument intended for religious coping does not validate a distinct prayer practice by itself, and neither can establish that a particular prayer caused subsequent emotional changes. Transparent item wording and cultural response processes are crucial where private practices and distinctive forms of sacred address are involved. Laird et al. (2004) Pargament et al. (2000)
An improved measurement battery would record what a person did during a specified episode, whom or what the prayer addressed, the experience of the addressee, perceived choice, dominant emotions before and after prayer, expectations, social setting, and resulting action. The battery should be piloted through cognitive interviews across traditions and tested for responsiveness without collapsing different experiences into a single 'positive prayer' index. Repeated assessments can then distinguish stable tendencies from the dynamics of particular stress episodes. Such work supplies a path from broad correlational evidence toward defensible process models. Ladd & Spilka (2002) Froese et al. (2024)
Experimental Comparators, Causal Identification, and Blinding
A randomized experiment estimates the causal effect of its assigned condition relative to a specified comparator. If participants are assigned to pray for a distressed person rather than think about that person, the estimated contrast includes the differences in language, religious meaning, intention, and social imagination induced by the instructions. It does not automatically identify which ingredient carried the effect. Stronger trials factorially manipulate the intended components where ethically feasible and document differences in expectation, task credibility, practice familiarity, and emotional content. Bremner et al. (2011) Cherniak et al. (2026, preprint)
Blinding creates particular difficulties. Participants generally know whether they are praying, and providers cannot usually be blinded to whether they offer prayer. Objective outcomes and assessment by blinded evaluators can reduce some bias, while active controls can attenuate expectancy and attention differences. Statistical models should specify primary endpoints, handling of missing follow-up data, multiplicity adjustments, and whether analyses follow intention-to-treat assignment. Trial registration and accessible protocols help distinguish planned outcomes from exploratory findings. The design of in-person prayer experiments makes these precautions especially important. Jacobson et al. (2026) Boelens et al. (2009)
Experimental results should be evaluated against plausible causal competitors rather than against a generic null alone. An effect of personal prayer relative to quiet rest may be due to inner speech or autobiographical attention; a benefit of group prayer may be due to human interaction; an effect of personally meaningful prayer on pain may involve expectancy. By matching the plausible active ingredients, researchers can test the added value of specific forms of sacred address and identify where participant interpretation moderates outcomes. Null findings under such controls are informative about the boundaries of a proposed mechanism. Elmholdt et al. (2017) Schjoedt et al. (2009)
Longitudinal Diaries, Experience Sampling, and Contextual Research
Daily diary studies can examine whether prayer follows a rise in stress, predicts a shift in emotional appraisal, or both. They can identify variation within the same person rather than assuming that individuals who pray more are otherwise comparable to those who pray less. For each episode, researchers could record type of practice, duration, what prompted it, how the sacred relationship was represented, immediate affect, and later social or practical action. Multilevel models can estimate between-person differences and within-person deviations separately, with lag structures chosen to match the hypothesized psychological timescale. Froese et al. (2024) Pérez et al. (2011)
Experience sampling also has interpretive challenges. Prompting individuals repeatedly about prayer may alter the behavior being measured, and some traditions consider intimate prayer unsuitable for immediate self-report. Missingness may rise during grief, acute illness, worship, or extreme distress, precisely the episodes most relevant to the theory. Researchers should document prompt compliance, offer culturally appropriate recording choices, test sensitivity to missing-not-at-random patterns, and protect participants' private spiritual disclosures. Qualitative follow-up can explain patterns that otherwise appear as statistical anomalies. Sharp (2010) Luhrmann et al. (2021)
Multiwave designs should model reciprocal relationships among symptoms, life events, prayer modes, religious conflict, and supportive networks. Stable trait or community differences may account for much of a cross-sectional association; time-varying confounders can still complicate within-person estimates. When appropriate, interrupted time-series or randomized encouragement designs may add causal leverage, but their assumptions should be stated explicitly. Longitudinal measurement invariance must also be considered, because what an individual understands by prayer can change as experience, religious identification, and life circumstances change. Ladd & Spilka (2006) Brandão (2025)
Critical Synthesis: What the Evidence Establishes and What Remains Open
The strongest prayer-specific experimental evidence concerns bounded psychological responses: changes in anger under provocation, felt security after prayer reflection, social-cognitive recruitment during improvised prayer, and pain-related appraisal under selected laboratory conditions. These studies support the scientific proposition that prayer can organize attention, social representation, appraisal, and emotion in measurable ways. Their results differ by task, participant population, comparison, and outcome. They do not establish a uniform biological mechanism or universally beneficial effect of praying. Bremner et al. (2011) Cherniak et al. (2026, preprint) Schjoedt et al. (2009) Elmholdt et al. (2017)
Observational studies describe associations between forms of prayer and well-being, often with meaningful contrasts between gratitude, shared practice, petition, and negative religious experience. Their greatest contribution is differentiation of the phenomenon rather than causal proof. Clinical trials of prayer delivered in person test packages combining social contact and religious activity; evidence for independent therapeutic effectiveness is currently limited by comparator quality and population-specific design. Controlled distant intercessory trials have not shown a clear clinical benefit. A consistent synthesis must preserve these distinct evidentiary levels rather than compress them into a single verdict about prayer and health. Pérez et al. (2011) Froese et al. (2024) Jacobson et al. (2026) Benson et al. (2006)
Open questions include the specific contribution of perceived sacred address beyond structurally similar self-talk; whether attention training changes reported spiritual perception or only its interpretation; how different prayer modes interact with attachment, shame, social exclusion, and coercion; and whether within-person improvements lead to durable behavioral adaptation. A coordinated research program would combine culturally grounded qualitative work, validated episode-level scales, preregistered active-comparator experiments, longitudinal cohorts, and independent replications. The empirical goal is a set of precise, falsifiable explanations for particular outcomes in identifiable circumstances. Schille-Hudson et al. (2024) Exline et al. (2014) Crosswell et al. (2024)
Conclusion
Prayer is a psychologically organized practice of sacred address, attention, contemplation, expression, and meaning. Its many forms recruit processes studied in cognitive psychology, affective science, social cognition, and coping research. The central scientific result of this monograph is that these processes become intelligible when each prayer episode is described in terms of its intention, content, perceived interlocutor, cultural setting, and observed consequences. Historical classifications, factor-analytic instruments, interview studies, experiments, neuroscience, and contemporary survey research converge on the importance of differentiating prayer modes rather than treating frequency as an adequate scientific definition. Poloma & Pendleton (1989) Laird et al. (2004) Schjoedt et al. (2009)
The evidence supports context-dependent effects on particular psychological outcomes, including attentive focus, emotion interpretation, felt security, anger management, and the experience of support. It also documents conflict, rumination, intrusive-thought neutralization, and adverse meanings in some circumstances. Positive clinical claims require the standards of causal identification, replication, and safety used for other interventions. The contrast between personal prayer, received in-person prayer, and distant intercession is especially important, because each tests a different causal pathway and measures different outcomes. Bremner et al. (2011) Berman et al. (2014) Jacobson et al. (2026) Benson et al. (2006)
An adequate future science of prayer will connect the lived significance of sacred communication with independent evidence about psychological function. It will ask how culturally learned representations influence the orientation of attention, how relational expectations alter affect, how emotional change shapes behavior, and which pathways support agency and health under specific conditions. In the Artificial Era, comparable research on technologically mediated prayer prompts or human–artificial dialogue would additionally require clearly operationalized human expectations and observed effects, without assuming equivalence between artificial communication and human devotional relations. The enduring research object is the situated organization of psychological life through prayer and its measurable consequences. Cherniak et al. (2026, preprint) Brandão (2025)
References
- Ano, G. G., & Vasconcelles, E. B. (2005). Religious coping and psychological adjustment to stress: A meta-analysis. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 61(4), 461–480. https://doi.org/10.1002/jclp.20049
- Benson, H., Dusek, J. A., Sherwood, J. B., Lam, P., Bethea, C. F., Carpenter, W., Levitsky, S., Hill, P. C., Clem, D. W., Jr., Jain, M. K., Drumel, D., Kopecky, S. L., Mueller, P. S., Marek, D., Rollins, S., & Hibberd, P. L. (2006). Study of the Therapeutic Effects of Intercessory Prayer (STEP) in cardiac bypass patients: A multicenter randomized trial of uncertainty and certainty of receiving intercessory prayer. American Heart Journal, 151(4), 934–942. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ahj.2005.05.028
- Berman, N. C., Stark, A., Ramsey, K., Cooperman, A., & Abramowitz, J. S. (2014). Prayer in response to negative intrusive thoughts: Closer examination of a religious neutralizing strategy. Journal of Cognitive Psychotherapy, 28(2), 87–100. https://doi.org/10.1891/0889-8391.28.2.87
- Boelens, P. A., Reeves, R. R., Replogle, W. H., & Koenig, H. G. (2009). A randomized trial of the effect of prayer on depression and anxiety. International Journal of Psychiatry in Medicine, 39(4), 377–392. https://doi.org/10.2190/PM.39.4.c
- Brandão, T. (2025). Religion and emotion regulation: A systematic review of quantitative studies. Journal of Religion and Health, 64(3), 2083–2100. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10943-024-02216-z
- Bremner, R. H., Koole, S. L., & Bushman, B. J. (2011). “Pray for those who mistreat you”: Effects of prayer on anger and aggression. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 37(6), 830–837. https://doi.org/10.1177/0146167211402215
- Cherniak, A. D., Granqvist, P., & Mikulincer, M. (2026, September 21). Psychological functions of prayer: Findings from a series of experiments comparing prayer to self-talk [Preprint]. OSF Preprints. https://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/e67h8
- Crosswell, A. D., Mayer, S. E., Whitehurst, L. N., Picard, M., Zebarjadian, S., & Epel, E. S. (2024). Deep rest: An integrative model of how contemplative practices combat stress and enhance the body’s restorative capacity. Psychological Review, 131(1), 247–270. https://doi.org/10.1037/rev0000453
- Elmholdt, E.-M., Skewes, J., Dietz, M., Møller, A., Jensen, M. S., Roepstorff, A., Wiech, K., & Jensen, T. S. (2017). Reduced pain sensation and reduced BOLD signal in parietofrontal networks during religious prayer. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 11, Article 337. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnhum.2017.00337
- Exline, J. J., Pargament, K. I., Grubbs, J. B., & Yali, A. M. (2014). The Religious and Spiritual Struggles Scale: Development and initial validation. Psychology of Religion and Spirituality, 6(3), 208–222. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0036465
- Froese, P., Bonhag, R., Uecker, J., Andersson, M., & Upenieks, L. (2024). Prayer and mental well-being in the United States: An overview of original and comprehensive prayer data. Journal of Religion and Health, 63(6), 4745–4772. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10943-024-02121-5
- Gross, J. J. (1998). The emerging field of emotion regulation: An integrative review. Review of General Psychology, 2(3), 271–299. https://doi.org/10.1037/1089-2680.2.3.271
- Jacobson, K., Zipp, J., Jones, B., Case-Cook, B., Schrieber, M., Brown, C. G., & Brown, J. W. (2026). Prayer for pain and anxiety in a primary care setting: A randomized controlled trial. Annals of Family Medicine, 24(3), 192–197. https://doi.org/10.1370/afm.250302
- James, W. (1902). The varieties of religious experience: A study in human nature. Longmans, Green, and Co. https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/621
- Ladd, K. L., & Spilka, B. (2002). Inward, outward, and upward: Cognitive aspects of prayer. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 41(3), 475–484. https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-5906.00131
- Ladd, K. L., & Spilka, B. (2006). Inward, outward, upward prayer: Scale reliability and validation. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 45(2), 233–251. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-5906.2006.00303.x
- Laird, S. P., Snyder, C. R., Rapoff, M. A., & Green, S. (2004). Measuring private prayer: Development, validation, and clinical application of the Multidimensional Prayer Inventory. The International Journal for the Psychology of Religion, 14(4), 251–272. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15327582ijpr1404_2
- Luhrmann, T. M., Weisman, K., Aulino, F., Brahinsky, J. D., Dulin, J. C., Dzokoto, V. A., Legare, C. H., Lifshitz, M., Ng, E., Ross-Zehnder, N., & Smith, R. E. (2021). Sensing the presence of gods and spirits across cultures and faiths. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 118(5), Article e2016649118. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2016649118
- Masters, K. S., & Spielmans, G. I. (2007). Prayer and health: Review, meta-analysis, and research agenda. Journal of Behavioral Medicine, 30(4), 329–338. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10865-007-9106-7
- Pargament, K. I., Koenig, H. G., & Perez, L. M. (2000). The many methods of religious coping: Development and initial validation of the RCOPE. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 56(4), 519–543. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10775045/
- Pérez, J. E., Smith, A. R., Norris, R. L., Canenguez, K. M., Tracey, E. F., & DeCristofaro, S. B. (2011). Types of prayer and depressive symptoms among cancer patients: The mediating role of rumination and social support. Journal of Behavioral Medicine, 34(6), 519–530. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10865-011-9333-9
- Poloma, M. M., & Pendleton, B. F. (1989). Exploring types of prayer and quality of life: A research note. Review of Religious Research, 31(1), 46–53. https://doi.org/10.2307/3511023
- Schille-Hudson, E., Weisman, K., & Luhrmann, T. M. (2024). Prayer and perceptual (and other) experiences. Cognitive Science, 48(12), Article e70029. https://doi.org/10.1111/cogs.70029
- Schjoedt, U., Stødkilde-Jørgensen, H., Geertz, A. W., & Roepstorff, A. (2009). Highly religious participants recruit areas of social cognition in personal prayer. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience, 4(2), 199–207. https://doi.org/10.1093/scan/nsn050
- Schjoedt, U., Stødkilde-Jørgensen, H., Geertz, A. W., Lund, T. E., & Roepstorff, A. (2011). The power of charisma—perceived charisma inhibits the frontal executive network of believers in intercessory prayer. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience, 6(1), 119–127. https://doi.org/10.1093/scan/nsq023
- Sharp, S. (2010). How does prayer help manage emotions? Social Psychology Quarterly, 73(4), 417–437. https://doi.org/10.1177/0190272510389129
Social-Cognitive Neuroscience of Personal Prayer
Neuroimaging studies distinguish the tasks participants actually perform. In the 2009 experiment by Schjoedt, Stødkilde-Jørgensen, Geertz, and Roepstorff, Danish Christians engaged in improvised personal prayer, recited a familiar prayer, and performed secular comparison tasks during functional magnetic resonance imaging. Personal prayer recruited medial prefrontal, temporoparietal, temporopolar, and precuneus regions implicated in thinking about social agents. Familiar formulaic prayer showed a different pattern more consistent with practiced verbal retrieval. This is evidence of task-dependent social-cognitive recruitment in a specific religious sample. Schjoedt et al. (2009)
The presence of activity in a social cognition network does not prove that an external addressee responded, nor does it imply the imagined addressee is psychologically unreal. It establishes that participants' manner of addressing and representing God engages processes also implicated in interpersonal understanding. Reverse inference is a major risk: because many cognitive tasks recruit overlapping regions, an activation pattern cannot uniquely diagnose spiritual connection, empathy, or belief. Within-person contrasts between improvised and scripted prayer are more informative about differences in task organization than comparisons between isolated activations and an unmeasured religious concept. Schjoedt et al. (2009)
Neural findings should be interpreted as one level in a multilevel explanation. Prayer content, felt agency, prior practice, and social assumptions must be measured alongside imaging for a functional mechanism to be credible. Comparisons should use equivalently familiar religious and secular utterances, narrative dialogue, and personally important nonreligious relationships. Analyses should preregister regions or whole-brain correction, document motion and task compliance, and consider that prayer performed in a scanner differs from prayer in a private room or group setting. Schjoedt et al. (2009) Crosswell et al. (2024)