Psychology by BogdanovaThe Encyclopedia of Psychology for the Artificial Era

RESEARCH DOSSIER

Personality, Motivation, and Emotion in Creativity

Abstract. Creativity is the production of work judged both original and effective within a relevant domain. The personal foundations of creative performance encompass relatively enduring dispositions, motivational systems that organize effort and persistence, and affective states whose cognitive effects vary across time and tasks. This fundamental critical narrative research monograph reconstructs the development of personality, motivation, and emotion research in creativity; compares the componential, self-determination, dual-pathway, sociocultural, and dynamic accounts; analyzes classic experimental manipulations, trait and self-belief assessments, longitudinal and experience-sampling evidence, and meta-analytic findings; and evaluates causal identification, measurement quality, replication, domain specificity, and cultural generalizability. The strongest recurring associations concern openness to experience, intrinsic motivation, creative process engagement, and creative self-efficacy, but estimates are heterogeneous, outcomes are inconsistently defined, and observational associations do not establish deterministic causal pathways. Mood effects depend on activation, valence, regulation, comparison condition, and stage of creative work. Reward and evaluation can either constrain autonomy or provide useful feedback depending on their meaning and contingency. The synthesis defines a multilevel research agenda integrating persons, states, tasks, environments, and temporally extended creative achievement. It is a critical scientific synthesis of identified sources, not a preregistered systematic review, original experiment, or newly conducted meta-analysis.

Keywords: creativity; creative performance; personality; openness to experience; Big Five; intrinsic motivation; extrinsic motivation; self-determination theory; creative self-efficacy; affect; mood; emotion regulation; cognitive flexibility; cognitive persistence; creative identity; creative achievement; experience sampling; psychometrics

Introduction: The Research Object

Creative activity is simultaneously a personal, cognitive, motivational, affective, and social process. The same individual can display ingenuity in one situation and conventional performance in another; an unusually original idea may remain undeveloped, while a committed practitioner can refine initially ordinary material into a valuable product. The central research object of this dossier is therefore the interaction of personality characteristics, reasons for engaging in a task, and emotional states in the development and evaluation of creative work. It includes differences between people, fluctuations within people, the mechanisms connecting those levels, and the environments that shape their expression.

A useful starting definition treats creativity as the generation of products, responses, or solutions that are original and effective for an identifiable purpose, problem, or domain. Runco and Jaeger (2012) trace the standard two-criterion definition, while the broader interdisciplinary review of Hennessey and Amabile (2010) emphasizes that creative accomplishments depend on multiple interacting levels of explanation. Originality alone can include random or useless variation; usefulness or appropriateness alone can result from conventional expertise. An adequate outcome measure must address both dimensions and disclose the standards by which they are judged. Hennessey (2010) Runco (2012)

Personality refers here to relatively enduring distributions of characteristic ways of feeling, thinking, and acting. Motivation concerns the initiation, direction, quality, and maintenance of goal-directed engagement. Emotion and affect include momentary experiences, moods, arousal, and regulation processes that can change attention, strategy, effort, and evaluation. These constructs are connected but remain analytically separable: an open individual may lack time to explore; a motivated individual may be exhausted; a negative mood can prompt problem detection or impede sustained generative thought. Generalizing from any one dimension to a universal creative personality neglects these contingent interactions.

This study asks which traits repeatedly predict creative performance; when intrinsic and extrinsic incentives improve or disrupt it; how valence, activation, and mood regulation influence idea generation and evaluation; how individual differences interact with social conditions; and which research designs permit credible causal conclusions. Its evidence ranges from laboratory tasks to workplace ratings, longitudinal self-reports, historical achievement, and systematic syntheses. The result is a scientific map of an evolving research area, rather than a prescription for what a creative person must be.

Historical Formation of the Field

The modern empirical study of creativity gained institutional visibility when J. P. Guilford (1950) called attention to creativity as a problem for psychological science. Psychometric traditions subsequently investigated divergent production, originality, fluency, and other cognitive qualities, while personality research compared creative practitioners with less creative comparison groups. These paths advanced measurement but also generated a long-standing question: does a test of unusual ideas assess the same construct as sustained artistic, scientific, or practical accomplishment? Guilford (1950)

During the second half of the twentieth century, social and motivational explanations became increasingly prominent. Teresa Amabile's consensual assessment technique (1982) offered a domain-sensitive method of evaluating creative products through judgments by qualified assessors. Her componential conceptualization (1983) connected domain skills, creativity-relevant processes, and task motivation, placing interpersonal evaluation, work conditions, and the subjective meaning of incentives within the explanatory model. An influential experiment on creative writers subsequently manipulated motivational orientation rather than treating motivation as a fixed trait (Amabile, 1985). Amabile (1982) Amabile (1983) Amabile (1985)

A parallel tradition examined the creative lives of accomplished individuals in their institutional settings. Csikszentmihalyi (1996) studied the relations among practitioners, domains of knowledge, and fields of judgment, including the experiential organization of intensive creative work. The systems perspective helps clarify why a talented person's output may be accepted in one period, institution, or community and ignored in another. Creativity is partly an activity and partly a domain-specific judgment, requiring caution whenever social recognition is used as the criterion. Csikszentmihalyi (1996)

From the 1990s onward, accumulated trait research enabled Feist's (1998) meta-analytic comparison of scientists and artists with relevant groups. Later developments incorporated the Big Five, self-determination theory, self-efficacy, affective activation and regulatory focus, cognitive control, and repeated daily measurement. The field has consequently moved from searching for the singular creative personality toward testing relations among dispositional propensities, situated goals, emotional dynamics, and the stages of creative production (Hennessey & Amabile, 2010; Bledow et al., 2024). Bledow (2024) Feist (1998) Hennessey (2010)

Defining Creativity and Its Outcomes

Research conclusions depend on the exact outcome called creativity. Divergent-thinking tasks ask participants to generate multiple answers to an open problem; scoring can emphasize the number of responses, their semantic variety, or originality ratings. Consensually judged products, including poems, designs, and other artifacts, require informed assessors and a specified domain. Creative self-reports measure perceived behavior, while lifetime achievement inventories assess documented accomplishments across a much longer period. Workplace supervisors typically rate idea generation or implementation as an aspect of job performance. These criteria are related, yet each captures a different combination of opportunity, expertise, motivational investment, evaluative conventions, and measurement error.

Amabile's (1982) assessment approach addresses the difficulty of defining universally applicable creative features: judges with appropriate domain experience assess products according to their professional sense of creativity. Agreement among judges provides one form of reliability. Its advantages include ecological relevance and sensitivity to finished products; its limitations include shared conventions, differences in expertise, and potentially unequal recognition of unfamiliar styles. Scores depend on the product sample and the evaluative context. Amabile (1982)

Runco and Jaeger's (2012) standard definition makes the originality–effectiveness distinction explicit but leaves operational work to the researcher. An unusual answer may be highly original yet impractical. In scientific domains a theory may be judged by its explanatory value and predictive results; in artistic work originality and aesthetic reception can depend on historical and cultural contexts. A broad measure that conflates these criteria creates ambiguity about what any personality or mood effect predicts. Runco (2012)

Outcome selection also changes temporal scale. A five-minute fluency task samples transient cognitive performance; an employee creativity rating integrates social visibility; a lifetime award reflects long-term production and institutional selection. A careful study specifies which endpoint is primary, whether it measures ideas, completed products, or recognition, and whether judges know participants' identity or experimental condition. The same predictor may have different consequences for first-stage exploration, demanding revision, and eventual acceptance.

Conceptual Architecture: Traits, States, and Contexts

Three levels of explanation organize the findings. Between-person variation concerns stable average differences, including openness, creative self-concept, and dispositions toward goal pursuit. Within-person variation concerns changes in interest, effort, mood, arousal, and self-regulation during creative work. Context includes feedback, resources, task demands, time pressure, cultural norms, institutional opportunity, and criteria of evaluation. Scientific analysis must ask which level each measure actually captures.

A trait predicts a distribution of possibilities rather than fixing each event. Openness can increase attraction to novelty, but the effective translation of that attraction into a product requires sufficient task engagement and relevant skills. Conversely, a person with an ordinary openness score can produce creative work through domain mastery, persistence, collaborative feedback, or a compelling problem. A strong trait association is therefore a statement about sampled populations and operationalized outcomes, not a ceiling on individual creative capacity.

States can function as mechanisms, mediators, or moderators. Task interest may transmit part of an association between autonomy support and sustained exploration. Regulatory focus may alter how an emotionally activated participant allocates attention. Recent experience-sampling research by Bledow, Kühnel, and Kuhl (2024) demonstrates why it is valuable to examine sequences of mood, self-motivation, and daily idea production rather than interpret isolated mood measurements as universally causal. Bledow (2024)

The distinction between a between-person correlation and a within-person process is essential. People who report more positive affect on average might also have access to more supportive work environments, whereas a change in one individual's affect during a particular afternoon may have a different relation to originality. Cross-sectional associations cannot automatically explain day-level dynamics; within-person correlations alone do not establish the causal source of changes. The theoretical objective is to connect levels with research designs capable of separating them.

Personality: The Importance of Openness

Among the Big Five traits, openness to experience has the most consistent positive association with measures of creativity. It encompasses tendencies toward cognitive exploration, aesthetic sensitivity, imagination, intellectual curiosity, and engagement with novel experience. Feist's (1998) comparative meta-analysis found differences between creative groups and their counterparts on openness and related dimensions. A newer review by Cebrián and Ramos-Villagrasa (2026), focused specifically on workers' creative performance, reported an aggregate positive openness association of r = .46, with a 95% confidence interval of [.33, .59]. Its I² of 93.76% indicates extensive heterogeneity among the included estimates, sharply limiting any impression of a uniform universal effect. Cebrián (2026) Feist (1998)

Openness is theoretically relevant because generating uncommon ideas often requires admitting alternative representations, tolerating unfamiliar possibilities, and exploring associations beyond a task's first conventional solution. These behaviors are plausible mediators between a dispositional preference for novelty and successful idea generation. They remain hypotheses requiring process-specific evidence when the pathway itself has not been experimentally isolated.

Kaufman and colleagues (2016) provide an important refinement. Across four samples totaling 1,035 participants, they examined aspects of the broader Openness/Intellect domain and creative achievement in arts and sciences. Their work demonstrates that treating the entire domain as one undifferentiated predictor obscures differences between aesthetic-imaginative openness and engagement with abstract or semantic information. A predictor's apparent strength can vary depending on whether the criterion is artistic achievement, scientific achievement, or a laboratory ideation task. Kaufman (2016)

Openness also intersects with interest and identity. A person attracted to unfamiliar experiences may choose domains that provide more creative opportunities, invest in exploratory learning, and define creative activities as personally important. Such selection effects complicate causal interpretation: observed creative accomplishments may reflect both dispositional engagement and the opportunities encountered over time. Longitudinal designs, comparable domain exposure, and repeated creative products are needed to distinguish these pathways.

Other Big Five Traits and Personality Profiles

Extraversion, conscientiousness, agreeableness, and neuroticism have less uniform relationships with creativity than openness. Their theoretical significance depends on what creative work demands. Extraversion may help public presentation, collaborative exchange, and the social acquisition of resources, while solitude may support intensive individual exploration. Conscientiousness can assist revision and completion even when a highly rule-bound working style narrows the range of alternatives initially considered. Agreeableness can support cooperation and revision through feedback, while willingness to dissent may be necessary when challenging dominant assumptions. Negative emotionality may heighten threat sensitivity, but its relation to achievement also depends on coping, regulation, and the type of task.

Feist (1998) reported differentiating profiles across creative scientific and artistic samples, including lower conventionality and differences in self-confidence and affect-related traits. Those comparisons should be interpreted within their sampling eras and professional group definitions. Comparing established artists with nonartists combines effects of selection, long-term occupational experience, social recognition, and cohort characteristics. The reported group patterns are not evidence that hostility or impulsivity causes creativity. Feist (1998)

In a nationwide Polish sample of 2,674 people aged 15–59, Karwowski, Lebuda, Wiśniewska, and Gralewski (2013) examined how Big Five traits predicted creative self-efficacy and creative personal identity. Their structural-equation analysis attributed 23% of variation in creative self-efficacy and 21% in creative personal identity to the personality predictors. The findings concern self-beliefs, not a direct experimental effect of personality on independently judged creative products. Karwowski (2013)

Personality profiles offer an alternative to one-trait explanation. Two people with similar openness may differ in their capacity for sustained work, their reaction to evaluation, and their willingness to expose unfinished ideas. Yet profile research must demonstrate incremental prediction over its component traits, sufficient replication, and stable measurement before claiming a distinctive configuration. Descriptions of the 'creative temperament' have explanatory value only when translated into measurable variables and tested against ordinary combinations of known traits.

Creative Self-Efficacy and Personal Identity

Creative self-efficacy is an individual's belief that they can generate creative outcomes in a relevant activity. Creative personal identity is the degree to which creativity occupies an important place in that person's self-concept. Both constructs may influence choice of projects, resilience after setbacks, interpretation of feedback, and willingness to commit effort. Their relations to achievement are theoretically distinct from the Big Five: a person may be dispositionally open yet doubt their capacity within a particular field, or may identify as creative while lacking domain-specific preparation.

Tierney and Farmer (2002) developed research on creative self-efficacy using employees from two firms. Their study reported discriminant validity and showed that job conditions and self-beliefs helped predict creative performance beyond general job self-efficacy. The follow-up investigation by Tierney and Farmer (2004) examined 140 research-and-development employees and linked supervisory expectations, supportive behaviors, employees' own creative efficacy, and performance in a proposed Pygmalion process. These findings establish meaningful associations and modeled mediational relationships, but observational mediation alone cannot verify every causal arrow. Tierney (2002) Tierney (2004)

Karwowski and colleagues (2013) made the conceptual difference between creative efficacy and creative identity more explicit, while Tierney and Farmer (2011) examined changes in efficacy and creative performance over time. A longitudinal perspective matters because successful work can strengthen efficacy beliefs, which may then facilitate further engagement. The converse sequence is also plausible: low confidence after negative feedback can reduce future participation, even for a person with substantial skill. Karwowski (2013) Tierney (2011)

Research should therefore examine reciprocal feedback. Creative identity may support persistence while also creating pressure to defend a reputation. Efficacy can encourage difficult goals yet become miscalibrated if confidence is disconnected from performance feedback. Sound interventions would assess externally judged work alongside self-beliefs, explicitly testing whether increases in perceived creative ability translate into demonstrable improvements in originality and effectiveness.

Motivation and the Componential Tradition

Motivation organizes why people begin, continue, and evaluate creative activity. The componential tradition places task motivation alongside domain-relevant expertise and creativity-relevant thinking processes. In her foundational conceptualization, Amabile (1983) proposed that social context influences creativity partly through the motivational meaning attributed to the task. In the updated dynamic componential model, Amabile and Pratt (2016) incorporate progress, the meaning of work, and temporally changing psychological conditions within organizations. Amabile (1983) Amabile (2016)

Intrinsic motivation refers to engagement because the activity itself is interesting, satisfying, or absorbing. Extrinsic motivation refers to engagement governed by outcomes separable from the activity, including rewards, grades, deadlines, recognition, and sanctions. These are conceptual dimensions of regulation, not necessarily mutually exclusive classes of persons. A researcher may enjoy a problem and seek recognition; a musician may value artistic exploration and depend on payment; an employee may find meaningful autonomy within externally assigned objectives.

Cebrián and Ramos-Villagrasa (2026) reported an aggregate association between intrinsic motivation and employee creative performance of r = .39, 95% CI [.28, .50], with I² = 93.37%. The magnitude is noteworthy, while the heterogeneity shows that effect estimates vary markedly across settings and measurements. Their worker-centered review cannot by itself justify statements about children, professional artists, and all other domains. Furthermore, many component studies are observational, allowing reverse causation and common-method bias. Cebrián (2026)

A more complete motivational explanation distinguishes attraction to a problem, willingness to experiment, perseverance through uncertainty, investment in revision, and the decision to submit work for external judgment. Engagement can be intense at one stage and weak at another. Motivation is consequently best measured as a temporally distributed process rather than a single retrospective rating of enthusiasm.

Self-Determination: Autonomy, Competence, Relatedness

Self-determination theory provides a broader account of motivational quality. Deci and Ryan (2000) distinguish forms of behavioral regulation and argue that autonomy, competence, and relatedness are fundamental psychological needs influencing effective functioning and internalization. In creative work, autonomy can support ownership of problems and methods; competence can foster the confidence necessary to attempt difficult tasks; relatedness can enable trustworthy collaboration and constructive feedback. Each mechanism is situated within the larger theory and requires creativity-specific measurement to establish its actual contribution. Deci (2000)

Autonomy support differs from the absence of standards. Clear criteria, technical constraints, and informed criticism may help creative performance when participants retain meaningful choice about how to proceed. Competence support need not consist of indiscriminate praise; informative feedback can identify what is working and what requires revision. Relatedness can make experimentation socially safer while also exposing individuals to conformity pressures when group membership becomes the controlling concern.

The distinction between autonomous and controlled regulation helps explain why the same reward, deadline, or evaluation can have divergent effects. A commission freely accepted for a personally valued project may be integrated with an artist's existing goals, while intrusive monitoring of an otherwise engaging task may redirect attention toward compliance. The psychological meaning of the arrangement is more informative than the simple presence or absence of payment.

Self-determination theory also highlights how long-term creative participation develops. External expectations can become personally endorsed; instrumental skills can enable intrinsically rewarding exploration; creative practice may sustain both personal meaning and social contribution. A rigorous empirical test should manipulate autonomy-relevant features, measure perceived regulation, assess creative products independently, and separate immediate task performance from longer-term voluntary engagement.

Classic Experimental Evidence on Motives

Amabile's (1985) experiment on creative writers remains a landmark because it altered participants' motivational orientation before the production of new work. Seventy-two young adults who identified as engaged in creative writing produced poems under conditions that emphasized intrinsic reasons, extrinsic reasons, or neither emphasis. The study reported lower creativity in the poems written after the extrinsic-orientation manipulation compared with the other conditions. Its methodological strength lies in holding a task domain approximately constant while changing the frame through which participants approached it. Amabile (1985)

The result supports a situational influence of motivational orientation on judged output in the specific experimental setting. Generalizing it to all rewards, occupations, and creative products would exceed the design. An orientation questionnaire can change attention and self-interpretation without reproducing a workplace wage, a competitive award, or an educational feedback system. Judged poem creativity also differs from sustained professional achievement.

Amabile's (1982) consensual assessment methodology is especially relevant here: creativity ratings are outcomes produced by judges rather than mere participant claims of feeling imaginative. Whenever evaluators are used, research needs to report judge expertise, blinding, interrater agreement, product instructions, and possible order effects. A finding about motivation is only as interpretable as the creativity criterion used to obtain it. Amabile (1982)

Modern studies can improve on the paradigm by preregistering hypotheses, comparing alternative rewards and forms of evaluation, testing multiple creative stages, and including delayed voluntary engagement. The original experiments created a productive theory of contextual vulnerability and task interest; they did not establish that every external incentive necessarily suppresses creative capacity.

Rewards, Evaluation, and the Meaning of Feedback

The reward debate illustrates why motivational mechanisms cannot be reduced to simple slogans. Deci, Koestner, and Ryan's (1999) meta-analysis of 128 studies investigated how rewards affected intrinsic motivation. They reported reductions in free-choice intrinsic motivation for several reward contingencies and enhancements after positive verbal feedback. These outcomes measure intrinsic motivation; they are important to creativity but are not interchangeable with independently judged novelty and effectiveness. Deci (1999)

Eisenberger and Cameron (1996) challenged broad interpretations of reward-undermining research, and Eisenberger and Rhoades (2001) provided experiments in which rewards contingent on creativity could improve creative task performance. The latter work distinguishes reinforcement for creative outcomes from indiscriminate external control. The tension in this literature reflects differences in contingencies, instructions, outcome definitions, time horizons, and the social interpretation of rewards. Eisenberger (1996) Eisenberger (2001)

Evaluation can provide information that helps revision, communicate social expectations that narrow exploration, or alter attention from the emerging product to external judgment. Its consequences depend on whether evaluative criteria are intelligible, whether the recipient can act on them, and whether creative risk-taking is punished. A supportive reviewer may increase quality by showing how a proposal can become useful; an arbitrary evaluator may make conventionality the safest response.

An effective research design manipulates the informational versus controlling meaning of feedback while holding material resources and task conditions as constant as practical. It separately measures exploratory behavior, perceived autonomy, persistence, judged originality, and effective completion. The principal scientific conclusion is conditional: the consequences of incentives for creativity vary by the psychological processes that those incentives activate.

Goals, Persistence, and the Completion Problem

Creative work involves far more than generating alternatives. Development, selection, testing, error correction, and repeated revision often determine whether an initial idea becomes a coherent product. Motivation regulates these transitions through goal commitment, allocation of effort, response to setbacks, and the balance between exploration and exploitation. It can also influence whether an individual chooses a demanding creative problem in the first place.

Persistence is difficult to interpret without attending to task structure. Repeated effort can increase the quality of a complex design when progress depends on technical refinement. The same persistence can become counterproductive when an invalid assumption prevents a necessary conceptual shift. Consequently, a motivational account should measure the appropriateness of strategic changes, not merely the amount of time spent working.

The dynamic componential model (Amabile & Pratt, 2016) places progress and meaning within ongoing creative activity. Perceived progress can reinforce investment, while a stalled process may change the emotional meaning of the task. This approach allows for reciprocal relations among affect, efficacy, performance, and persistence; experienced progress both reflects and influences behavior. Amabile (2016)

The most informative observations therefore track multiple phases: identifying a problem, collecting relevant information, generating candidates, selecting promising alternatives, executing a solution, and seeking domain-specific evaluation. Experience sampling, digital work traces, and repeated product assessments can distinguish productive perseverance from rigid repetition. Stable motivation predicts sustained engagement only insofar as changing demands, strategy choices, and access to resources are considered.

Interest, Curiosity, and Flow

Interest is a motivational and affective process through which a person recognizes an activity or object as worth further attention. Silvia (2008) discusses interest as an emotion connected to appraisal, learning, and exploration. Creative processes often begin when a discrepancy, question, or promising possibility recruits attention. This may occur before any explicit reward is anticipated, making interest a plausible entry point into intrinsically motivated creative action. Silvia (2008)

Curiosity does not guarantee a creative product. Discovery of unusual materials or the accumulation of information must be organized into meaningful transformations, and creative evaluation can require disciplined rejection of appealing but ineffective alternatives. Interest may support the search for conceptual connections while expertise determines whether those connections can be developed responsibly.

Csikszentmihalyi's (1996) account of flow is relevant to periods of intense concentration and absorbed activity. Creative practitioners may report a deep engagement in which challenging demands are met with developed skills. But descriptions of flow must be distinguished from causal evidence that a particular subjective state produces originality. Flow can accompany effective skilled performance in both creative and routine tasks, and retrospective accounts of exceptional people are susceptible to selection and narrative reconstruction. Csikszentmihalyi (1996)

Research can connect interest and flow to creativity by separately observing momentary engagement, challenge–skill balance, attentional switching, and independently evaluated products. The timing of measurement matters: absorption during execution might assist refinement, while exploratory breaks may be critical for reframing a problem. Interest and flow are therefore informative dimensions of creative experience rather than universal markers of a successful idea.

Emotion: Valence, Activation, and Function

The emotional dimension of creativity includes hedonic valence, physiological or subjective activation, regulation, and the cognitive meaning attributed to a state. Positive versus negative mood is only one distinction. Excited interest and relaxed contentment differ in activation; alert anxiety and low-energy sadness also differ. Treating all positive states as equivalent and all negative states as equivalent obscures the mechanisms through which emotion may alter attention and persistence.

Baas, De Dreu, and Nijstad (2008) synthesized 102 effect sizes and reported that positive moods produced more creativity than mood-neutral controls, with an overall correlation-scale effect of approximately r = .15. They did not observe a significant overall difference between negative and neutral moods. Their analysis identified the importance of activating positive states associated with approach motivation. Davis (2009) independently synthesized 62 experiments and 10 nonexperimental studies, finding that the mood effect varied by comparison condition and task and was consistent with a contextual interpretation. Baas (2008) Davis (2009) De Dreu (2008)

The difference between a general average and a conditional mechanism matters. A modest pooled effect should not be transformed into the claim that happiness reliably causes creativity in each person. Conversely, an overall nonsignificant negative-mood comparison does not establish that activated negative emotion can never support a particular stage of creative work. Both generalizations confuse heterogeneous observations with universal laws.

Affect may function as a cue about progress, a driver of cognitive activity, a source of evaluative sensitivity, or a correlate of other processes. Research must specify whether the tested outcome is initial ideation, originality of accepted responses, quality of revision, or sustained achievement, because the same mood may have different roles at different stages.

The Dual-Pathway Model: Flexibility and Persistence

De Dreu, Baas, and Nijstad (2008) developed a dual-pathway model in which creativity can emerge through cognitive flexibility, sustained cognitive persistence, or combinations of the two. The framework connects mood activation and valence to distinct routes toward idea fluency and originality. In four studies with different tasks and mood manipulations, activating states supported creative performance, while the proposed mechanism differed according to affective tone. Baas (2008) De Dreu (2008)

The flexibility pathway emphasizes shifts between conceptual categories, broader associative exploration, and the generation of alternatives. Activated positive affect can support approach-oriented flexibility when task demands allow broad exploration. The persistence pathway emphasizes continued effort, systematic analysis, and extended search within a problem space. Activated negative states can under some conditions support narrower, effortful engagement rather than expansive association.

These are explanatory hypotheses supported by a particular experimental program, not independently observed universal neural mechanisms. The relationship between activation, attentional scope, and strategy is influenced by task content, participants' cognitive skills, and motivational meaning. One task may reward semantic switching, another may require patient constraint satisfaction, and a third may involve alternating between exploration and verification.

The dual-pathway model implies an important research design principle: include measures of both the creative product and the process believed to generate it. If a manipulation increases originality while leaving cognitive flexibility unchanged, the claimed mediation needs further testing. Because creativity may be achieved by several strategies, theory should accommodate multiple sufficient routes and identify their boundaries rather than seek a single privileged emotional condition.

Negative Mood, Problem Detection, and Regulatory Context

Negative mood can change how unresolved problems are noticed and interpreted. George and Zhou (2002) investigated conditions under which negative mood related positively to employee creativity, emphasizing perceived recognition for creative work and clarity of feelings. Their workplace findings illustrate a mood-as-input account: emotional states may indicate whether a situation requires additional effort or adjustment, but the interpretation depends on contextual expectations. George (2002)

A subsequent organizational study by George and Zhou (2007) examined positive mood, negative mood, and supervisory support. The findings supported a context-sensitive dual-tuning interpretation in which combinations of affective states could accompany elevated creative performance when the environment supported experimentation. These observational results are informative about possible workplace dynamics, while their design leaves scope for reciprocal effects and shared-context confounding. George (2007)

Negative emotions also impose cognitive costs. Anxiety can occupy working-memory resources, promote vigilance toward possible errors, and reduce willingness to expose unconventional ideas to evaluation. Byron and Khazanchi's (2011) meta-analysis of 59 independent samples found an overall negative association between anxiety and performance on creative tasks, with moderation by task and anxiety characteristics. A narrow conclusion that distress is a creative necessity would therefore conflict with the broader empirical pattern. Byron (2011)

The strongest interpretation is functional and time-sensitive. Dissatisfaction can help identify a problem; sustained rumination may obstruct productive modification; relief after progress can support subsequent exploration. A researcher must distinguish negative mood at the onset of a task from its persistence, change, and regulation during creative work. Clinical distress should never be romanticized as a condition of artistic or scientific value.

Emotional Dynamics in Everyday Creative Work

Daily-life methods investigate processes hidden by one-session experiments. Bledow, Kühnel, and Kuhl (2024) collected repeated mood reports from 210 participants three times daily across five workdays. Their analysis related action–state orientation, self-motivation, changes in mood, and evening reports of novel and useful ideas. Higher creativity was reported when negative mood declined and self-motivation was high, and the within-person relationships varied by action–state orientation. This evidence links emotional recovery and self-regulation rather than treating initial negative mood alone as the active ingredient. Bledow (2024)

Conner, DeYoung, and Silvia (2018) examined associations between everyday creative activity, affect, and flourishing. The research helps shift attention from a simple mood-to-creativity model toward reciprocal and lagged relations: creative engagement may itself shape subsequent positive emotion and well-being. The possibility of reverse direction is central. A creative day can feel rewarding, and an enjoyable day can encourage creative pursuits; distinguishing the sequence requires adequate temporal resolution and appropriate statistical controls. Conner (2018)

Ivcevic, Lin, Liu, and Brackett (2024) examined affect and creativity with a person-centered approach, identifying combinations of positive and negative activated affect and the relevance of contextual factors. Such work challenges one-dimensional emotional categories by asking how mixed affective profiles correspond to creative behavior. Ivcevic (2024)

Experience-sampling evidence is constrained by how creativity is reported. Participants may remember salient ideas differently depending on mood, and a short evening rating cannot automatically substitute for independent appraisal of completed work. Still, repeated measures improve the ability to distinguish stable differences from temporal fluctuations and can guide stronger experiments testing whether deliberate regulation changes performance.

Stress, Evaluation, and Threat

Stressors influence creativity through several channels: perceived controllability, evaluative intensity, resource depletion, physiological arousal, and expectations about consequences of failure. Byron, Khazanchi, and Nazarian (2010) synthesized 76 experimental studies involving 82 independent samples and found that relationships depended on the type and strength of stressors. Low evaluative stress could improve creative performance relative to controls, whereas highly evaluative conditions tended to impede it. Greater uncontrollability showed a negative linear relation to creative performance. Byron (2010)

The findings make two methodological points. First, stress is not a unitary experimental variable; its operational definition should distinguish evaluation, time constraints, uncontrollability, and threat. Second, evaluation can change effort and the willingness to generate risky alternatives in opposite directions. Moderate challenge may mobilize attention when it is interpreted as manageable; severe threat can narrow exploration and interfere with executive control.

The evidence should not be simplified into a general inverted-U law that predicts an identical optimum in every task. The form of the dose–response relationship depends on which stressor is administered, how creativity is scored, and which participants are studied. A stress manipulation also may change motivation, affect, and task engagement simultaneously; mediation claims require separate measurement of these processes.

Research and practice should distinguish stimulating standards from coercive pressure. Creative work benefits from clear expectations and resources in some settings, but conditions that make experimentation psychologically costly can suppress the visibility of novel proposals. Robust conclusions require manipulation checks, comparison groups, independent judging, and attention to delayed effects on voluntary participation.

Cognitive Mechanisms Linking Person and Performance

Personality and motivation cannot yield creative work without cognitive operations. Creative problem solving often requires accessing relevant knowledge, inhibiting dominant but unsuitable responses, exploring remote alternatives, representing constraints, monitoring progress, and selecting workable combinations. These operations are sometimes labeled divergent and convergent thinking, but successful performance typically requires their coordination rather than an absolute separation.

Nusbaum and Silvia (2011) examined divergent-thinking performance in relation to fluid intelligence, executive switching, and strategy use. Their two studies suggested that category switching and the ability to implement a useful strategy contribute to apparently divergent output. This research challenges an overly romantic account of creativity as unconstrained spontaneous association. Cognitive control may enable the deliberate avoidance of common responses and maintenance of productive search strategies. Nusbaum (2011)

Interest can encourage broader exploration, while self-efficacy may increase willingness to attempt difficult representations. Emotional activation may modify the relative appeal of flexibility and persistence. These hypotheses are plausible only when the corresponding process is measured. A positive relation between a trait and an output score, by itself, does not demonstrate which executive operation mediates that association.

A comprehensive experiment might measure task-level creativity, category switching, working-memory demands, time allocation, and self-reported regulation while manipulating incentives or affect. Such designs can test whether motivation changes creative output by altering exploration, persistence, or product evaluation. Neural measurements can complement behavioral work, but neural activation is not equivalent to demonstrated originality or to a specific psychological cause.

Experimental Research Designs and Causal Inference

The field combines laboratory experiments, cross-sectional personality studies, longitudinal studies, field observations, and meta-analyses. Each design answers a different question. Randomized induction of mood or motivational framing can support a causal conclusion about that particular manipulation under controlled conditions. Trait associations predict differences without establishing that the trait itself can be experimentally changed or that the relationship is unconfounded.

Laboratory creativity studies require a manipulation that meaningfully changes the intended construct, a valid outcome criterion, and appropriate comparison conditions. Mood induction may change arousal and motivation as well as valence. Rewards can carry both informational and controlling meaning. Instructions to be creative can alter effort and strategy independent of personality. Ideally, research includes manipulation checks, preregistered primary outcomes, blinded evaluators, and adequate statistical power.

Longitudinal studies improve understanding of developmental ordering but remain vulnerable to time-varying confounding. Experience sampling captures microtemporal fluctuations but may create measurement reactivity and substantial missingness. Studies of occupational achievement capture ecological relevance while combining ability, opportunities, institutional selection, and socioeconomic resources.

Causal claims should distinguish randomized treatment effects, predictive longitudinal relationships, statistical mediation, and theoretical mechanism. A mediation coefficient in an observational design describes covariance that is compatible with multiple causal structures. Stronger triangulation uses distinct measures, interventions, and temporal arrangements that test the same explanation from different directions. The central scientific task is to match the inferential strength of a claim to the research design that supports it.

Measurement, Reliability, and Construct Validity

Measurement is a major source of inconsistency in creativity research. Divergent-thinking fluency is sensitive to task duration and verbal speed; originality ratings can correlate with the number of generated ideas; self-report measures can incorporate social desirability and self-concept; supervisor ratings can reflect visibility and relationships; counts of patents or publications depend on institutional opportunity and disciplinary conventions. None is a complete measure of creative potential or accomplishment in every setting.

Personality instruments similarly vary in facet coverage. An openness scale emphasizing aesthetic imagination may behave differently from one emphasizing intellectual curiosity. Motivation measures may focus on enjoyment, autonomous regulation, persistence, or expected reward. Affect measures differ by intensity, valence, activation, sampling window, and whether the question concerns an immediate feeling or typical mood. Researchers should report their exact scales and provide evidence of reliability and validity for the population examined.

The results of Cebrián and Ramos-Villagrasa (2026) are a useful warning against treating pooled correlations as transportable constants. The review identified 79 personal factors across 82 workplace studies, with very high heterogeneity for several central associations. The creative process engagement estimate was r = .52 with I² = 97.39%, while the positive affect estimate was r = .31 with I² = 81.53%. Such dispersion requires moderators, sensitivity analyses, and scrutiny of overlapping constructs and common-method reporting. Cebrián (2026)

Improved assessment uses multiple tasks, independent product judges, longitudinal behavioral indicators, and explicit domain criteria. When feasible, researchers should publish scoring procedures, reliability estimates, measurement invariance tests, data-processing decisions, and code. A theoretically attractive relationship becomes scientifically useful when its underlying constructs are measured consistently enough to survive changes in instruments, contexts, and research teams.

Effect Sizes, Meta-Analysis, and Heterogeneity

Meta-analyses are central evidence sources but do not eliminate differences among original studies. Feist (1998) compared creative and comparison groups using personality measures; Baas and colleagues (2008) synthesized mood manipulations and associations; Davis (2009) examined mood studies across experimental and observational designs; Byron and colleagues (2010) examined stressor manipulations; and Cebrián and Ramos-Villagrasa (2026) reviewed individual characteristics of creative job performance. These projects answer partially overlapping questions with different inclusion criteria and outcome definitions. Baas (2008) Byron (2010) Cebrián (2026) Davis (2009) Feist (1998)

A correlation of r = .46 should not be compared mechanically with an experimental standardized mean difference or interpreted as the amount by which creativity increases when an individual changes a trait. A pooled estimate can be sensitive to sample selection, publication bias, multiplicity of outcomes, and whether effect sizes have been adjusted or transformed. Confidence intervals quantify one form of sampling uncertainty, while I² describes observed between-study heterogeneity relative to total variability under specific statistical assumptions.

The 2026 workplace review reports large heterogeneity for openness, intrinsic motivation, creative efficacy, and process engagement. This implies that the pooled values are useful summaries of available research, but prediction in a new domain requires evidence about populations, tasks, and scoring practices. Very heterogeneous findings invite moderator analysis rather than simplistic ranking of all personality and motivational predictors.

For this dossier, published meta-analytic estimates are quoted as results of their authors' analyses, not recalculated from primary data. No new database search protocol or independent pooled effect has been executed here. The scientific synthesis uses the original review questions and eligibility restrictions to specify where broad conclusions are supported and where the evidence remains conditional.

Development, Culture, and Access to Creative Opportunity

Creative practices emerge over developmental trajectories. Childhood exploration, educational feedback, access to materials, and opportunities for practice influence both skills and motivation. In adulthood, occupational constraints, time availability, and social commitments influence whether ideas become projects. An individual's observed creativity therefore reflects accumulated opportunities alongside dispositional preferences. Directly comparing people without accounting for their environments can misattribute structural differences to personality.

Affect and motivation may also differ across developmental contexts. He (2023) investigated creativity motivation in Hong Kong secondary-school students and undergraduates, including a mood study and an experimental emotion-induction study. Both positive and negative affect were related to creativity motivation in the reported analyses, with stronger effects for positive affect. The study assesses motivation to be creative, which must be distinguished from independently validated creative output; its cultural and educational settings also constrain generalization. He (2023)

Cross-cultural generalization requires meaningful equivalence of constructs, translated instruments, and the social criteria used to judge novelty and usefulness. A behavior considered unconventional in one setting may be evaluated differently in another. Institutional support, language, power relations, and access to expert evaluation further influence who is recognized as creative.

Research should therefore consider socioeconomic opportunity, educational domain, language, age, and cultural conventions as substantive variables rather than statistical inconveniences. A globally relevant psychology of creativity requires samples beyond the conventional university and workplace populations and should test whether its measures retain comparable meaning across communities. The absence of evidence in a population is a knowledge gap, not a demonstration of the absence of creativity.

Differences Across Artistic, Scientific, and Workplace Domains

Creative accomplishment depends on the knowledge systems and evaluation rules of the domain. Artistic production may require perceptual sensitivity, aesthetic risk, sustained revision, and audience reception. Scientific creativity may depend on conceptual expertise, empirical constraint, methodological rigor, and the ability to identify testable questions. Workplace innovation often requires organizational sponsorship, coordination, and implementation after idea generation. A common psychological predictor may influence these endpoints differently.

Kaufman and colleagues (2016) found differentiated associations of openness and intellect-related dispositions with creative achievement in artistic and scientific areas. Feist's (1998) older meta-analysis likewise compared scientists, artists, and relevant noncreative groups. These sources support domain-sensitive analysis instead of treating 'creative achievement' as a unitary outcome. They do not imply that traits predetermine field selection or that particular occupational groups possess a fixed personality essence. Feist (1998) Kaufman (2016)

Social recognition introduces a second distinction: a strong idea can fail to receive attention for institutional reasons, and an accepted product can receive recognition unrelated to its intrinsic novelty. Professional gatekeeping, network access, and material support shape the observed distribution of achievement. A useful model should therefore separate production from selection, dissemination, and evaluation.

For research synthesis, the domain should be treated as a moderator, accompanied by explicit task descriptions and independent outcome criteria. Where a research program compares multiple domains, it should test measurement comparability before drawing conclusions about the relative creative potential of participants. The psychological mechanisms of exploratory attention and sustained motivation may recur across fields, while their manifestation is mediated by domain-specific skills and standards.

Social Conditions, Supervision, and Collaborative Work

The environments in which people create influence their motivation and emotional regulation. Supervisory expectations, feedback quality, time allocation, social safety, access to tools, and the reception of unusual proposals can support or obstruct expression of an individual's capacities. In the componential tradition, these conditions shape task motivation and the available resources for creative production (Amabile & Pratt, 2016). Amabile (2016)

Tierney and Farmer (2004) studied supervisory expectations and creative self-efficacy among research-and-development workers; George and Zhou (2007) investigated how supportive supervision conditioned the relation between mood and creativity. These studies show why explanations limited to stable traits omit theoretically relevant situational information. Yet field observations also involve reverse causation: supervisors may provide more support to workers they already perceive as capable, and high-quality work may create positive emotional experiences. George (2007) Tierney (2004)

Collaboration adds interpersonal coordination and conflict-management demands. Extraversion and agreeableness may matter for sharing ideas, whereas dissent can protect a team from premature consensus. A group can generate many proposals and still struggle to select effective ones. Measurement should distinguish individual contributions, team-level outcomes, and external judgments of the completed product.

The appropriate analysis is multilevel and temporally informed. People select environments, environments respond to people, and creative successes or failures can reshape both future opportunity and self-belief. Research that isolates a single predictor while ignoring this reciprocal organization will often produce effects that are fragile outside the original setting.

Creativity, Psychological Health, and Well-Being

The relation between creativity and psychological health has attracted public attention, particularly through narratives connecting artistry, suffering, and exceptional achievement. Scientific inference requires more precise distinctions among ordinary affect, trait negative emotionality, clinical symptoms, impairment, and well-being. A transient negative mood is not equivalent to a psychiatric diagnosis, and exceptional achievement does not establish the necessity or benefit of distress.

The available mood meta-analyses show context-dependent effects on creative tasks, while the anxiety meta-analysis by Byron and Khazanchi (2011) points to cognitive costs across studied samples. Conner, DeYoung, and Silvia (2018) examined daily creative behavior in relation to affect and flourishing, supporting the possibility that engagement itself contributes to psychological well-being. These findings concern psychological processes and associations rather than clinical treatment efficacy. Byron (2011) Conner (2018)

Creativity can create meaning, connection, and absorption, but also expose individuals to evaluation, uncertainty, workload, and rejection. Professional support and conditions of reasonable autonomy may matter for sustaining creative practice. The assumption that severe distress is a prerequisite for original thought has no warrant from findings that certain negative moods occasionally accompany problem detection or cognitive persistence.

Clinical and health-related claims require diagnosis-specific evidence and qualified review. This monograph does not supply medical treatment recommendations. Its contribution is to specify psychological mechanisms relevant to creative activity while keeping distinct the evidence on mood, the experience of creative engagement, and the scientific assessment of mental disorders.

An Integrated Temporal Account of Creative Action

A coherent synthesis treats creative work as an evolving sequence of encounters among dispositional tendencies, task-specific goals, affective regulation, skills, opportunities, and external evaluation. At the initial selection stage, openness, interest, identity, and access to novel problems can affect engagement. During exploration, cognitive flexibility, working memory, task enjoyment, and psychological safety can influence the diversity of candidates. During development and revision, persistence, expertise, usable feedback, and tolerance of uncertainty become increasingly relevant. Finally, the institutional and interpersonal environment affects visibility and recognition.

The interaction can be represented conceptually as creative outcome at time t being a function of the individual's prior skills and trait dispositions, current goals and affective state, available task resources, strategies deployed, feedback history, and domain standards. This is an organizing synthesis, not a fitted causal equation. Its scientific value lies in generating separable tests, including whether motivational effects change across stages and whether affect regulation mediates the conversion of novelty into successful completion.

Recent research helps make the temporal view empirically tractable. Bledow and colleagues (2024) demonstrate within-person affective sequences; Amabile and Pratt (2016) emphasize progress and meaning; Tierney and Farmer (2011) examine the development of creative self-efficacy; and Conner and colleagues (2018) raise the issue of daily reciprocal effects. Together they suggest that psychological organization is dynamic even when dispositional measures show continuity. Amabile (2016) Bledow (2024) Conner (2018) Tierney (2011)

The model also explains why simple optimization claims are inadequate. Raising momentary positive affect may improve one kind of ideation without improving execution; incentives may strengthen effort while shifting attention away from exploratory goals; a confident identity may encourage risk-taking while making critical feedback threatening. Empirical progress depends on identifying stage-specific mechanisms and observing their consequences across different outcomes.

Artificial Era: Human–Artificial Creative Work

The Artificial Era introduces new research settings in which human creative activity is mediated by artificial systems capable of generating suggestions, images, text, code, or alternative problem representations. For this dossier, the scientific focus remains the human psychological variables of personality, motivation, and emotion. The relevant new questions concern how these variables change when an artificial system becomes part of the working environment, rather than assuming any particular psychological property of the artificial system.

Artificially generated alternatives may lower the cost of exploration and thereby increase engagement, yet they may also induce reliance, reduce feelings of authorship, or shift evaluation standards. A highly open individual might use such systems to test more divergent possibilities; a person with high creative self-efficacy might treat machine output as material for revision. These are testable propositions, not established universal effects. The significance of interface design, attribution, intellectual ownership, and task expertise requires direct empirical work.

Research designs can compare solo creation with human–artificial collaboration using identical tasks, randomized tool access, blind assessment of products, and repeated measures of motivation, ownership, affect, and subsequent independent performance. Detailed trace data can distinguish original human contributions, adopted suggestions, selection decisions, and the final artifact. Where cognitive offloading is studied, delayed independent tasks can test whether immediate performance benefits translate into durable skill.

The larger philosophical horizon From Homo to Artificial motivates the investigation of new configurations of creative work. Scientific evaluation must preserve operational specificity: a system's generative behavior, a human user's emotional relation to that behavior, and the perceived creativity of an output are different research objects. This distinction keeps the present monograph anchored to measurable human creative psychology while identifying legitimate interdisciplinary questions.

Critical Scientific Discussion and Competing Accounts

The strongest results in this literature concern associations rather than complete explanations. Openness repeatedly predicts creative outcomes, but some designs use self-reported creativity, some compare selected occupations, and others measure brief ideation. Intrinsic motivation correlates with creative performance, yet the strength and even direction of situational incentive effects depend on contingency, perceived autonomy, domain, and the stage of work. Positive activated affect can facilitate certain tasks, while negative affect can contribute under specific regulatory conditions and anxiety often imposes costs.

Several theoretical accounts remain simultaneously useful. Componential theory emphasizes task motivation and domain expertise; self-determination theory explains the quality of regulation; the dual-pathway model distinguishes flexibility and persistence; trait models describe systematic between-person differences; and systems approaches emphasize the institutional construction of recognition. A scientifically productive integration specifies where these accounts make nonredundant predictions rather than treating conceptual compatibility as proof of a unified mechanism.

Important threats to cumulative knowledge include ambiguous outcome constructs, common-method measurement, restricted occupational samples, selective reporting, insufficient attention to publication bias, cross-sectional mediation interpreted causally, and inadequate differentiation between between-person and within-person effects. High heterogeneity in recent meta-analytic estimates is evidence that moderators matter. It is a reason to formulate narrower, better-tested predictions.

The evidence also leaves fundamental causal questions unresolved. Can stable creative performance change through sustained increases in autonomous motivation? Does training emotional regulation improve the originality and utility of independently judged products? Does a particular profile of dispositions predict success beyond expertise and opportunity? What are the delayed effects of creative support tools on intrinsic engagement and independent skill? These questions demand coordinated experimental, longitudinal, and multilevel research with transparent protocols and comparable outcome measures.

Priorities for Future Research

Future work should establish common definitions for the stage of creativity measured and report originality and effectiveness separately wherever possible. Studies should provide full task descriptions and independent rater agreement. Better construct separation is needed for openness, general intellectual ability, creative self-efficacy, identity, task interest, and creative engagement, which are often assessed with partially overlapping self-report content.

A second priority is temporal causal identification. Experience sampling can locate sequences in which mood, effort, and creative output change together; randomized micro-interventions can test whether those state changes drive subsequent performance. Longer follow-up periods can determine whether beneficial effects persist after initial novelty, and intensive repeated product assessment can connect momentary cognition to meaningful accomplishment.

A third priority is generalizability. Cross-cultural, multilingual, developmental, and occupational sampling should be accompanied by measurement-invariance analysis and explicit description of access to creative resources. Comparisons of artistic, scientific, and applied domains must preserve domain-relevant criteria while investigating whether mechanisms recur across contexts.

Finally, research should integrate external incentives and human–artificial tools into psychologically precise designs. The key outcomes should include not only immediate idea counts but product quality, sustained voluntary engagement, independent later performance, experienced autonomy, and distribution of credit. Findings should be replicated across independent laboratories and settings, with null effects and contradictory results treated as informative evidence about theoretical boundaries.

Conclusion

Personality, motivation, and emotion contribute to creativity through distinguishable and interacting pathways. Stable traits, especially openness to experience, help explain differences in attraction to novelty and creative engagement. Creative self-efficacy and personal identity influence willingness to attempt and sustain demanding projects. Autonomous motivation and interest can support exploratory work, while rewards and evaluation influence creativity according to their meaning, contingencies, and the conditions in which they are delivered. Emotional activation and regulation affect cognitive flexibility, persistence, and the interpretation of progress, with outcomes dependent on task demands and timing.

The strongest research synthesis rejects deterministic portraits of the 'creative type.' Meta-analytic estimates are informative but heterogeneous; short experimental tasks and long-term achievement measure different outcomes; observational mediation does not prove causal mechanisms; and culture, expertise, and opportunity shape both production and recognition. The major advance of the field is the possibility of moving from generalized correlations to temporally specified, empirically testable mechanisms.

The resulting scientific position is that creative accomplishment emerges from organized interactions among personal dispositions, motivational commitments, emotional processes, cognitive strategies, domain expertise, and social evaluation. A complete explanation requires methods capable of following these interactions across tasks, environments, and time. This conclusion supplies a durable foundation for subsequent independent research on creativity measurement, educational intervention, creative practice, collaboration, and human–artificial production.

References

  • Amabile, T. M. (1982). Social psychology of creativity: A consensual assessment technique. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 43(5), 997–1013. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.43.5.997
  • Amabile, T. M. (1983). The social psychology of creativity: A componential conceptualization. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 45(2), 357–376. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.45.2.357
  • Amabile, T. M. (1985). Motivation and creativity: Effects of motivational orientation on creative writers. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 48(2), 393–399. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.48.2.393
  • Amabile, T. M., & Pratt, M. G. (2016). The dynamic componential model of creativity and innovation in organizations: Making progress, making meaning. Research in Organizational Behavior, 36, 157–183. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.riob.2016.10.001
  • Baas, M., De Dreu, C. K. W., & Nijstad, B. A. (2008). A meta-analysis of 25 years of mood-creativity research: Hedonic tone, activation, or regulatory focus? Psychological Bulletin, 134(6), 779–806. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0012815
  • Bledow, R., Kühnel, J., & Kuhl, J. (2024). Personality dynamics turn positive and negative mood into creativity. Journal of Personality, 92(6), 1587–1601. https://doi.org/10.1111/jopy.12913
  • Byron, K., & Khazanchi, S. (2011). A meta-analytic investigation of the relationship of state and trait anxiety to performance on figural and verbal creative tasks. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 37(2), 269–283. https://doi.org/10.1177/0146167210392788
  • Byron, K., Khazanchi, S., & Nazarian, D. (2010). The relationship between stressors and creativity: A meta-analysis examining competing theoretical models. Journal of Applied Psychology, 95(1), 201–212. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0017868
  • Cebrián, J., & Ramos-Villagrasa, P. J. (2026). Personal correlates of creative performance: A systematic review. Frontiers in Psychology, 16, Article 1727094. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2025.1727094
  • Conner, T. S., DeYoung, C. G., & Silvia, P. J. (2018). Everyday creative activity as a path to flourishing. The Journal of Positive Psychology, 13(2), 181–189. https://doi.org/10.1080/17439760.2016.1257049
  • Csikszentmihalyi, M. (1996). Creativity: Flow and the psychology of discovery and invention. HarperCollins. https://search.worldcat.org/title/34078996
  • Davis, M. A. (2009). Understanding the relationship between mood and creativity: A meta-analysis. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 108(1), 25–38. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.obhdp.2008.04.001
  • De Dreu, C. K. W., Baas, M., & Nijstad, B. A. (2008). Hedonic tone and activation level in the mood-creativity link: Toward a dual pathway to creativity model. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 94(5), 739–756. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.94.5.739
  • Deci, E. L., Koestner, R., & Ryan, R. M. (1999). A meta-analytic review of experiments examining the effects of extrinsic rewards on intrinsic motivation. Psychological Bulletin, 125(6), 627–668. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.125.6.627
  • Deci, E. L., & Ryan, R. M. (2000). The “what” and “why” of goal pursuits: Human needs and the self-determination of behavior. Psychological Inquiry, 11(4), 227–268. https://doi.org/10.1207/S15327965PLI1104_01
  • Eisenberger, R., & Cameron, J. (1996). Detrimental effects of reward: Reality or myth? American Psychologist, 51(11), 1153–1166. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.51.11.1153
  • Eisenberger, R., & Rhoades, L. (2001). Incremental effects of reward on creativity. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 81(4), 728–741. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.81.4.728
  • Feist, G. J. (1998). A meta-analysis of personality in scientific and artistic creativity. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 2(4), 290–309. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15327957pspr0204_5
  • George, J. M., & Zhou, J. (2002). Understanding when bad moods foster creativity and good ones don't: The role of context and clarity of feelings. Journal of Applied Psychology, 87(4), 687–697. https://doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.87.4.687
  • George, J. M., & Zhou, J. (2007). Dual tuning in a supportive context: Joint contributions of positive mood, negative mood, and supervisory behaviors to employee creativity. Academy of Management Journal, 50(3), 605–622. https://doi.org/10.5465/AMJ.2007.25525934
  • Guilford, J. P. (1950). Creativity. American Psychologist, 5(9), 444–454. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0063487
  • He, W.-J. (2023). Positive and negative affect facilitate creativity motivation: Findings on the effects of habitual mood and experimentally induced emotion. Frontiers in Psychology, 14, Article 1014612. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1014612
  • Hennessey, B. A., & Amabile, T. M. (2010). Creativity. Annual Review of Psychology, 61, 569–598. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.psych.093008.100416
  • Ivcevic, Z., Lin, S., Liu, X., & Brackett, M. (2024). Creativity and affect: A person-centered analysis. Learning and Individual Differences, 113, Article 102481. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.lindif.2024.102481
  • Karwowski, M., Lebuda, I., Wiśniewska, E., & Gralewski, J. (2013). Big Five personality traits as the predictors of creative self-efficacy and creative personal identity: Does gender matter? The Journal of Creative Behavior, 47(3), 215–232. https://doi.org/10.1002/jocb.32
  • Kaufman, S. B., Quilty, L. C., Grazioplene, R. G., Hirsh, J. B., Gray, J. R., Peterson, J. B., & DeYoung, C. G. (2016). Openness to experience and intellect differentially predict creative achievement in the arts and sciences. Journal of Personality, 84(2), 248–258. https://doi.org/10.1111/jopy.12156
  • Nusbaum, E. C., & Silvia, P. J. (2011). Are intelligence and creativity really so different? Fluid intelligence, executive processes, and strategy use in divergent thinking. Intelligence, 39(1), 36–45. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.intell.2010.11.002
  • Runco, M. A., & Jaeger, G. J. (2012). The standard definition of creativity. Creativity Research Journal, 24(1), 92–96. https://doi.org/10.1080/10400419.2012.650092
  • Silvia, P. J. (2008). Interest—The curious emotion. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 17(1), 57–60. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8721.2008.00548.x
  • Tierney, P., & Farmer, S. M. (2002). Creative self-efficacy: Its potential antecedents and relationship to creative performance. Academy of Management Journal, 45(6), 1137–1148. https://doi.org/10.2307/3069429
  • Tierney, P., & Farmer, S. M. (2004). The Pygmalion process and employee creativity. Journal of Management, 30(3), 413–432. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jm.2002.12.001
  • Tierney, P., & Farmer, S. M. (2011). Creative self-efficacy development and creative performance over time. Journal of Applied Psychology, 96(2), 277–293. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0020952