RESEARCH DOSSIER
Narrative Transportation and Mediated Entertainment
Abstract. Narrative transportation is a state of attention, imagery, affective involvement, and simulated participation in a represented story world. This research monograph examines how narrative engagement develops, how it intersects with character identification and emotional responses, and under which conditions entertainment narratives alter beliefs, attitudes, intentions, and reported behavior. It reconstructs the field from seminal transportation experiments through narrative comprehension, entertainment-education theory, psychometric measurement, causal identification studies, and contemporary meta-analyses. Evidence from reading, film, health communication, advertising, and serialized streaming is evaluated with attention to causal inference, effect-size heterogeneity, construct overlap, self-selection, cultural transfer, and the distinction between immediate engagement and durable behavioral change. The synthesis distinguishes a demonstrated persuasive potential from claims of universal or automatic influence, and examines the opportunities and ethical responsibilities of artificial mediation in the Artificial Era. This work is a critical narrative review; it does not report new experiments or a formal systematic review or meta-analysis.
Keywords: narrative transportation; mediated entertainment; narrative engagement; character identification; narrative persuasion; mental simulation; mental imagery; entertainment-education; perceived realism; counterarguing; transportability; hedonic enjoyment; eudaimonic appreciation; storytelling; film psychology; streaming narratives; belief change; media psychology; Artificial Era
Narrative Transportation as a Psychological Research Object
Representation becomes psychologically consequential when a person follows a sequence of events as an unfolding world. Narrative transportation denotes a transient episode of concentrated attention to represented events, mental imagery or situation modeling, and affective involvement with the progress of a story. The central claim of Green & Brock (2000) is that this state can help explain why exposure to a narrative influences subsequent story-consistent beliefs and evaluations. A story may be fictional or factual, spoken or written, filmed or performed. What matters analytically is the coordination of events, agents, causal relations, and audience participation in reconstructing them. Transportation refers to a response of an audience member; narrative form names a property of a communicative artifact. Their difference is indispensable when interpreting experiments, because a vivid story does not necessarily transport every reader and two equally transporting stories may express opposing propositions.
The scope of mediated entertainment includes novels, television dramas, feature films, serialized streaming, and entertainment-education programs in which people encounter narratives through designed media. Its principal outcomes include attention, emotional experience, enjoyment, identification, interpretation of the represented world, and possible changes in attitudes or conduct. The research object is the process joining reception to these outcomes, rather than the proposition that entertainment always persuades. A reviewer must therefore distinguish the immediate phenomenology of immersion from content memory, from the endorsement of particular beliefs, and finally from enacted decisions. The same storyline can increase entertainment pleasure without changing the viewer's convictions; it can also convey ideas whose effects become visible only after later reflection Green et al. (2004) Appel & Richter (2007).
This monograph is a critical narrative synthesis of peer-reviewed foundational studies, controlled experiments, measurement research, research reviews, and recent investigations of long-form media. It considers primary designs and quantitative reviews separately and draws causal conclusions only where the underlying comparison permits them. Its central questions concern the determinants of transportation; the relation between transportation, identification, and narrative comprehension; the mechanisms of narrative persuasion; the reliability of measurement; and the conditions governing generalization across audiences, media, and time. The broader Media and Technology Psychology Science supplies the disciplinary context. More general persuasion processes, interactive game agency, and fully embodied virtual reality have separate research objects, although their findings may illuminate boundary conditions.
Historical Origins of Narrative Engagement Research
Contemporary transportation theory arose through the convergence of psychological studies of discourse comprehension, imaginative participation, and the effects of communication. The turning point was the program of Green & Brock (2000), which combined a psychological definition with scale development and studies of narrative-consistent judgment. The article reported four experiments with distinct tasks and samples, including a manipulation of processing instructions in the last study. Its importance was methodological as well as theoretical: the experience of entering a story became a measurable construct whose relation to persuasion could be compared experimentally. Earlier literary and cognitive discussions supplied conceptual resources, but the 2000 research program made the proposed mechanism available to quantitative investigation. The field subsequently expanded beyond print toward television, film, health messages, consumer narratives, and digital platforms.
The adjacent entertainment-education tradition asks how story-based programs communicate information and model responses to consequential social problems. Slater & Rouner (2002) interpreted narrative influence through message processing and elaboration, asking whether attention to a dramatic plot changes the kinds of resistance or counterargument that arise when a persuasive proposition is encountered. Green et al. (2004) broadened the account from persuasion to media pleasure, arguing that transportation can contribute to enjoyment through involvement and its consequences for the self and character relationships. Moyer-Gusé (2008) developed a theoretical account of entertainment persuasion with particular attention to resistance, identification, and parasocial processes. These works mark a research shift from a question about whether fictional content affects belief to an explanatory program investigating how distinct forms of engagement organize audiences' responses.
The field's conceptual history is also a history of correction. Cohen (2001) argued for distinguishing identification with a character from other audience responses; Busselle & Bilandzic (2008) framed narrative engagement in terms of mental models and differentiated fictionality from perceived external or internal realism; Busselle & Bilandzic (2009) operationalized several dimensions of engagement rather than treating immersion as one indistinguishable experience. Later quantitative reviews integrated these traditions: van Laer et al. (2014) analyzed antecedents and consequences, Braddock & Dillard (2016) distinguished beliefs, attitudes, intentions, and behavior, and Thomas & Grigsby (2024) systematically examined a marketing-centered body of 95 articles. The result is a theoretically plural field whose historical progress is best measured by sharper construct definitions and stronger empirical designs.
Narrative, Story World, and the Conditions of Representation
A narrative organizes agents, events, temporal relations, perspectives, and causal expectations into a communicable sequence. Its psychological force depends partly on how an audience constructs a situation model: readers or viewers track who acts, where events occur, which goals conflict, and how earlier events constrain later ones. The physical medium influences the cues available for this construction. A printed story requires more self-generated sensory imagery, while an audiovisual work supplies sight, sound, voice, and timing. Yet perceptual richness alone does not determine the depth of interpretation. The narrative audience must still infer intentions, update expectations, and assign significance to the portrayed events Busselle & Bilandzic (2008) Mar & Oatley (2008).
The realism of this constructed world has more than one meaning. Busselle & Bilandzic (2008) distinguishes the fact of fictionality from external realism, or correspondence to ordinary experience, and narrative realism, or coherence within the represented world. An openly fantastic narrative can be internally coherent and strongly engaging. A nominally realistic drama can undermine its own audience if a character behaves inconsistently without a plausible explanation. The model predicts that disturbances in world construction may interrupt engagement; these propositions require empirical examination for particular media and audiences. Whether a story carries the label fiction or fact is therefore analytically separate from whether its causal structure is intelligible, emotionally credible, and relevant to the recipient.
These distinctions clarify the scientific boundary between narrative transportation and technologies of spatial immersion. Film, literature, and streaming can foster a vivid feeling of presence through ordinary narrative processing; head-mounted immersive systems introduce sensorimotor contingencies and spatial embodiment that demand additional theories. Interactive games give participants choices that change simulated outcomes, making perceived agency and feedback major variables. The present dossier concentrates on receptive engagement with predominantly noninteractive narrative entertainment. References to interactive or synthetic storytelling are used to identify testable extensions of established mechanisms rather than to collapse technological presence, game flow, and narrative transportation into one construct Thomas & Grigsby (2024).
The Architecture of the Transportation Experience
Transportation has a cognitive dimension because a recipient allocates attention to narrative events, anticipates consequences, builds causal connections, and keeps represented information accessible. It has an affective dimension because the fates of agents produce concern, suspense, sympathy, fear, hope, or relief. It may also involve sensory imagery, although the kind and richness of imagery differ across print, speech, and audiovisual narratives. Green & Brock (2000) defined the phenomenon around these coordinated processes and showed its relevance to belief-consistent outcomes. Attentional concentration and emotional investment can reinforce one another: an unresolved conflict directs further observation, while a meaningful consequence gives the viewer a reason to continue following the conflict.
A transported viewer can remain aware of the mediation while experiencing the events as psychologically immediate. Engagement does not entail loss of reality testing, literal belief that characters exist, or a complete suspension of judgment. The phenomenology is episodic and graded: people sometimes move in and out of engagement as a dialogue becomes slow, an event seems implausible, or an external demand intervenes. Busselle & Bilandzic (2009) provides a measurement framework that includes narrative understanding, attentional focus, emotional engagement, and narrative presence. These dimensions may correlate strongly, but their distinction enables the examination of cases such as attentive comprehension without intense affect, and vivid emotion accompanied by poor understanding of a complicated plot.
An adequate process model must retain a temporal structure. Antecedents include narrative coherence, personal relevance, familiarity, prior beliefs, and situational distractions; transportation is the experienced state during reception; subsequent responses include memory, evaluation, enjoyment, and possible action. Conflating these stages makes it easy to mistake a high post-viewing transportation score for a proven cause of a later attitude. The synthesis of van Laer et al. (2014) demonstrates the breadth of candidate antecedents and consequences, while the review of Thomas & Grigsby (2024) reveals how often empirical work measures transportation without manipulating it. A plausible mechanistic diagram is a guide to experimentation; it becomes causal knowledge only when its links withstand designs capable of excluding alternatives.
Differentiating Transportation from Neighboring Constructs
Identification describes a viewer's or reader's temporary adoption of a character-centered perspective, including understanding or simulating that character's goals, interpretations, and emotions. Cohen (2001) set out the conceptual reasons for differentiating identification from liking, admiration, similarity, and a sense of social relationship with a character. A narrative can transport someone through suspense or uncertainty even when every protagonist is morally objectionable. Conversely, a viewer may identify with a recognizable figure but remain disengaged from the present episode's plot. Because identification targets a represented agent and transportation targets participation in the represented narrative world, the constructs must have distinct measures even when they co-occur.
Other neighboring constructs are narrative engagement, perceived realism, absorption, presence, enjoyment, and transportability. Engagement is sometimes used as an umbrella term and sometimes operationalized as a multidimensional response. Presence denotes an experiential feeling of being in a represented environment; the term has additional technical uses in virtual reality research. Enjoyment is an evaluation or affective consequence, and transportability is a relatively stable tendency to become transported across narratives rather than the state during a specific presentation. Bilandzic & Busselle (2008) investigated transportability in connection with genre-consistent attitudes, reporting that the relation between dispositional transportability and a particular narrative experience required more nuance than a simple linear effect.
A clear research design measures distinct constructs at their appropriate moments. It might assess transportability before assignment, narrative transportation after exposure, identification with named characters, realism judgments, and story-specific beliefs at multiple follow-up points. Even with such measurement separation, cross-sectional covariance cannot demonstrate that transportation produces identification or the reverse. de Graaf et al. (2012) advanced causal investigation by manipulating narrative perspective while measuring character identification and attitudes. Such designs reveal why construct definition matters: experimentally varying a feature that changes identification can support a more specific account than merely finding that viewers who report high transportation also report story-consistent opinions.
Mental Simulation, Situation Models, and Narrative Comprehension
The mental simulation account starts with a simple observation: people derive meaning from stories by modeling events that are absent from the immediate physical setting. They infer intentions, simulate consequences, and integrate scenes into a larger representation of persons and environments. Mar & Oatley (2008) proposed that fiction abstracts and compresses social information into intelligible simulations of interaction. Oatley (2016) further developed the view that reading fiction can recruit social inference and emotional involvement. These frameworks account for the plausibility of social learning through narratives, but a simulation metaphor does not by itself establish beneficial transfer. The psychological question is which representations are constructed, what is retained, and whether later social judgments change under independent assessment.
Situation-model construction has both local and global requirements. Local coherence enables a viewer to connect an utterance with the immediate event; global coherence enables the viewer to link motives and outcomes across scenes. A melodrama might repeatedly reinforce a character's commitments, whereas a mystery deliberately withholds crucial information while maintaining a coherent causal framework. Such variations can alter suspense without eliminating understanding. Busselle & Bilandzic (2008) suggests that violations of expected consistency may disrupt engagement because they conflict with the audience's emerging mental model. Empirical testing must distinguish genuine inconsistency from purposeful uncertainty, because a story can be intelligible precisely through its controlled gaps.
Simulated experience is also selective. Narratives spotlight particular people, challenges, and causal sequences while leaving much of the represented world implicit. That selectivity can heighten explanatory clarity and intensify emotional response, yet it can also encourage unwarranted generalization from an exceptional case. A single emotionally memorable patient in a health drama is not a statistical sample of patients. The route from simulation to judgment is therefore inseparable from the audience's background knowledge, the generalization invited by the content, and its relation to independent factual information. Dahlstrom (2014) treats the potential of storytelling in science communication together with the ethical implications of its persuasive structure.
Attention, Imagery, and the Allocation of Cognitive Resources
Transportation requires the coordination of attention with the temporal demands of a story. A person must follow a sequence closely enough to recognize why outcomes matter and to build expectations about what may occur. Selective attention can be interrupted by interface notifications, multitasking, poorly timed advertisements, or confusing editing, although the impact of each interruption depends on task demands and narrative design. The original transportation framework included attentional focus and imagery as components of absorption Green & Brock (2000). Later research distinguished these responses more explicitly and developed measurement procedures sensitive to narrative comprehension and emotional engagement Busselle & Bilandzic (2009).
Mental imagery is especially salient in prose narratives, where sensory properties must be supplied through imagination and prior experience. Audiovisual forms furnish perceptual detail, but still require audiences to infer unshown contexts, past events, and intentions. It would therefore be a mistake to identify narrative transportation solely with the vividness of pictures in the mind. A verbally mediated story can transport through conceptual, social, and emotional processes even when an individual reports modest visual imagery. Conversely, spectacular imagery can capture attention without producing coherent narrative understanding. The research program described by van Laer et al. (2014) treats imagery and transportation as related components whose effects need to be investigated through specific designs.
Cognitive effort poses a methodological problem. A person absorbed in a fictional world may elaborate the story's events actively while doing relatively little explicit counterarguing against a message embedded within the plot. The two observations can coexist because processing the represented situation and scrutinizing its implied claims are different tasks. Slater & Rouner (2002) proposed that narrative involvement reorganizes how persuasive content is encountered. Thomas & Grigsby (2024) reported that narrative persuasion research often treats transportation as a measured mediator, with experimental manipulation comparatively rare. Thus, claims that transportation necessarily reduces critical reasoning need precisely specified tasks: argument criticism, inconsistency detection, comprehension, and memory should be measured separately.
Character Identification, Perspective, and Experience-Taking
Characters provide social anchors around which audiences organize attention and feeling. Identification involves taking up a character's perspective and simulating events through that character's concerns. This operation may be supported by first-person narration, focalized camera work, access to a character's thoughts, or the gradual disclosure of motives. Conceptual analysis by Cohen (2001) separates identification from ordinary liking and parasocial relations. An audience member can disapprove of a fictional agent while nevertheless following that agent's perspective closely; this dissociation makes identification an empirical question rather than a synonym for approval.
Experimental work offers evidence that perspective matters. In two studies summarized by de Graaf et al. (2012), the researchers assigned participants to stories told from the viewpoints of characters with conflicting goals or opinions. Their first experiment included 120 participants and the second included 200. Perspective affected identification and story-consistent attitudes, with identification implicated statistically in the pathways. The manipulation strengthens the causal case for a role of perspective, although mediation estimates still depend on assumptions about the measurement and timing of the mediator. A complete account must consider whether perspective also changes available information, sympathy, or the credibility of a character's reasons.
Experience-taking concerns the imaginative adoption of a fictional character's identity-related perspective. Kaufman & Libby (2012) introduced the construct as an explanation for how stories can affect beliefs and behavior through temporary simulation of another person's life. It is related to identification but may have distinctive conditions, including when a reader learns an identity-relevant attribute of a protagonist. Research can examine these effects through changes in perceptions and actions after narrative exposure. Generalization requires attention to whose experiences are represented and whether the experimental manipulation changes both the reader's perspective and the information encountered. The strongest inference concerns the specific tested story, population, and outcome; claims about broad permanent changes in character or empathy require additional longitudinal evidence.
Emotion, Suspense, and the Evaluation of Entertainment
Emotion supplies motivational significance to a narrative sequence. Anticipated loss can hold attention; the resolution of conflict can generate relief; a reunion can produce tenderness; moral ambiguity can prompt reflection that persists after a viewing session. Transportation models assign emotion a constitutive role in the experience of narrative engagement Green & Brock (2000). But the intensity of an emotional response should not be assumed to indicate agreement with the represented viewpoint. A tragedy can be moving while remaining morally challenging, and a frightening documentary can be compelling without persuading its audience to adopt a specific causal explanation.
Entertainment evaluation operates along more than one dimension. Oliver & Raney (2011) developed a distinction between hedonic motivations, oriented toward pleasure, and eudaimonic motivations, oriented toward meaningfulness and reflection. Their four studies of scale development and preference patterns support treating these motives as distinguishable rather than placing every entertainment experience on a single pleasantness axis. Viewers may seek narratives that are sad, demanding, or morally unsettling because the experience helps them consider commitments, mortality, relationships, or identity. This broadens the potential outcomes of transportation: immediate enjoyment, emotional resonance, reflection, and value clarification may follow different pathways.
Emotion can simultaneously support memory and distort the weighting of represented information. A vivid scene has high subjective accessibility, but accessibility does not determine prevalence or factual reliability. Affective intensity may strengthen a character's personal significance while weakening the tendency to examine the representativeness of a single case. Researchers should therefore measure the content of emotion, its relation to protagonist goals, and the distinct outcomes of perceived significance and truth. Moyer-Gusé (2008) locates emotional and social engagement within theories of entertainment persuasion, while Dahlstrom (2014) makes clear that compelling science narratives need safeguards against exaggerated inference.
Models of Narrative Persuasion and Resistance
Classical persuasion research commonly examines arguments, credibility, prior attitudes, and the degree of deliberate elaboration. Narrative persuasion introduces an event-centered route: a recipient becomes engaged with a plot whose outcomes illustrate or imply propositions about the world. Slater & Rouner (2002) suggested that narrative absorption and character responses can modify the salience of counterarguing and topic involvement. Moyer-Gusé (2008) advanced a framework addressing the reduction of resistance in entertainment-education. These theoretical contributions describe mechanisms worth testing and help explain why a message embedded in a drama might be processed differently from a direct appeal with the same recommendation.
A plausible route begins when the plot makes the perspective of an agent intelligible and emotionally consequential. The viewer may rehearse the consequences of a decision, infer social norms from repeated scenes, and later retrieve a story-consistent example during judgment. Yet a narrative also competes with preexisting commitments, interpersonal knowledge, and competing exemplars. The same transportation state may facilitate the uptake of a beneficial health message, a biased stereotype, or a scientifically inaccurate claim. Narrative engagement is a mechanism of information reception and evaluation, not an ethical guarantee about the content it conveys Dahlstrom (2014) Mar & Oatley (2008).
An influential extended model is the transportation-imagery framework synthesized by van Laer et al. (2014). The authors integrated a heterogeneous literature on story properties, audience factors, and downstream consumer outcomes through quantitative meta-analysis. The model is useful as a map of candidate relationships; it should not be mistaken for one experimentally confirmed causal chain. The theoretical domain also incorporates the effects of prior knowledge, relevance, and perceived realism studied by Green (2004). Research now needs factorial designs that manipulate narrative structure, character perspective, and persuasive intent independently, use temporally separated measures, and assess whether resistance and transportation mediate outcomes under competing explanatory models.
The Transportation Scale and the Problem of Construct Validity
The foundational measurement program in Green & Brock (2000) operationalized transportation through self-reports of attention, emotional involvement, and imagery after reading narratives. A self-report score is evidence of the participant's reconstruction of the experience, subject to memory, vocabulary, and expectations about what a competent or involved reader should report. It is not a direct trace of an unobservable cognitive state. Nonetheless, a carefully specified scale makes relationships between engagement and outcomes testable, permits comparisons across experimental conditions, and provides a basis for examining reliability and discriminant validity. Investigators should report the items, response range, scoring procedure, treatment of missing responses, dimensional assumptions, and the linguistic validity of any translation.
Busselle & Bilandzic (2009) developed narrative engagement measurement around components including attentional focus, narrative understanding, emotional engagement, and narrative presence. The measure directs attention to episodes in which comprehension can be achieved without a vivid sense of entering the story or emotional attachment can develop despite some confusion. These distinctions become particularly important when comparing print reading with films, television, audiobooks, and streaming series. A medium may influence questionnaire responses because some items privilege visual imagery or a feeling of physical placement. Before comparing means across formats or cultures, researchers must test whether their indicators measure the same latent dimensions and whether item wording functions comparably.
Construct validity also requires examining boundaries with identification, perceived realism, empathy, absorption, narrative enjoyment, and transportability. When questionnaires ask several versions of the same experience, correlated scales can seem to confirm an elaborate mechanism while in fact reflecting shared language and response tendencies. A sound measurement study uses multiple types of evidence: factor structure, test-retest stability where appropriate, manipulations with theoretically expected effects, correlations with distinct constructs, and consequences measured using other methods. The broad review by Thomas & Grigsby (2024) is especially instructive because many articles describe transportation theoretically but omit a direct manipulation or measure of the construct. A citation to a model cannot replace a measurement strategy.
Experimental Manipulation, Randomization, and Causal Inference
A controlled narrative experiment can randomize participants to a narrative or comparison message, but such a design identifies the effect of the entire assigned message package. The narrative may differ from a factual control in length, emotional language, complexity, vividness, character detail, and the information supplied. If a narrative group changes more than a comparison group, transportation may be a candidate explanation, but the experimental effect cannot automatically be assigned to transportation itself. Green & Brock (2000) progressed beyond simple association by manipulating processing instructions in the fourth study, reporting that reduced transportation corresponded with less story-consistent belief and character evaluation. The causal claim is strongest for the instruction manipulation's effect; the precise mediation pathway still requires careful assessment.
Experiments that manipulate character perspective create complementary leverage. de Graaf et al. (2012) changed whose viewpoint structured a story and found differences in identification and associated attitudes, including statistical mediation. A researcher seeking to isolate perspective must ensure that competing versions preserve comparable information and narrative quality. A design that allows one version to conceal critical facts would change the audience's evidence at the same time as its standpoint. Factorial approaches could manipulate narrative viewpoint and implied moral recommendation separately, testing whether agreement follows identification with a character or the argument presented through that character.
Good designs begin with a causal diagram and preregistered comparisons. The investigators should specify whether transportation is a primary outcome, a hypothesized mediator, or an effect modifier. When a mediator is only measured after the same treatment that changes attitudes, causal mediation requires assumptions about unmeasured mediator-outcome confounding and the ordering of responses. Negative controls, alternative mediator measures, independent raters, and delayed behavioral outcomes can help evaluate rival pathways. Mixed effects models may be necessary when several stories and authors are sampled. Generalizing from one carefully chosen dramatic passage to all narratives amounts to stimulus-level extrapolation and requires replication across independently produced stories.
The Original Experiments and Their Evidentiary Reach
The classic Green & Brock (2000) article reports four experiments. Its first experiment, with 97 participants, associated greater transportation with stronger story-consistent beliefs and favorable evaluation of protagonists; the second, with 69 participants, examined detection of apparent false notes; the third and fourth, with 274 and 258 participants, extended the research on beliefs and character evaluations. In the fourth study, processing instructions manipulated transportation. These sample descriptions and principal findings come from the published article abstract, and should not be supplemented with invented manipulation details or unverified subgroup statistics. The empirical program established reproducible questions and initial effects across designs, while leaving open the magnitude and stability of effects in other contexts.
A distinct study by Green (2004) examined 152 undergraduate readers and found associations among relevant prior knowledge, transportation, perceived realism, and story-consistent beliefs. The evidence suggests that the capacity to connect a narrative with familiar social settings can facilitate engagement. However, preexisting knowledge and attitudes may influence both transportation and the subsequent evaluation of the story. That possibility matters because a viewer already sympathetic to a protagonist can find the world credible and report attitudes that were present beforehand. A study claiming persuasion must measure baseline beliefs or randomize content in ways that allow changes to be estimated.
The experimental evidence concerning character perspective offers specificity. de Graaf et al. (2012) reported two studies with samples of 120 and 200, testing characters with opposed goals or opinions. Its results support identification as one candidate mechanism of narrative persuasion and demonstrate that narrative format is not a unitary treatment. Kaufman & Libby (2012) investigated experience-taking and the possibility that temporarily assuming a character's perspective changes self-relevant beliefs and behavior. Together these programs show how narrative research can move from identifying correlations to isolating theoretically meaningful interventions. They also show why the endpoints need careful definition: agreeing with an experimental statement, expressing an intention, and performing an observable action are separate outcomes.
Meta-Analytic Evidence and Heterogeneity
Braddock & Dillard (2016) synthesized studies of narrative influence and reported positive average relationships for beliefs, attitudes, intentions, and behavior. Its abstract reported correlations of r = .17 for beliefs across 37 effects with 7,376 participants, r = .19 for attitudes across 40 effects with 7,132 participants, r = .17 for intentions across 28 effects with 5,211 participants, and r = .23 for behaviors across five effects with 978 participants. The smaller behavioral evidence base is an especially important limitation. The reported values are outcome-specific summary associations or effects as aggregated by that review and cannot be converted into a guarantee of behavioral change for every narrative, platform, or audience.
Shen et al. (2015) analyzed 25 health-communication studies including 9,330 participants, reporting an overall small narrative persuasion association, r = .063, with differences by format and message purpose. Its abstract indicated significant effects for audio and video narratives but not for print in that sample of included studies, and stronger evidence for detection or prevention than for cessation-related outcomes. Such moderation results are conditional on the scope and quality of the underlying corpus and do not imply that print storytelling is universally ineffective. Differences in manipulation, baseline preferences, population, and outcome operationalization can shift an aggregate estimate.
The transportation-imagery synthesis of van Laer et al. (2014) included 132 effect sizes from 76 published and unpublished articles. Its contribution is to map multiple antecedents and consequences across consumer, communication, and psychological domains; the meta-analysis does not mean that all antecedents were causally randomized. More recently, Thomas & Grigsby (2024) reviewed 95 peer-reviewed articles focused on transportation in persuasive marketing contexts. These reviews cover overlapping but differently selected literatures. Their sample counts are not independent numbers to be added together, and they should not be interpreted as measures of cumulative unique research without formal deduplication. A next-generation quantitative synthesis should map overlapping study populations and stimuli, harmonize constructs, assess publication bias, and distinguish between-subject from within-subject and observational estimates.
Delayed Outcomes, Replication, and Evidence Quality
Immediate post-exposure questionnaires may capture transient agreement, demand characteristics, or memory for the narrative's normative message. A test conducted days or weeks later addresses a different question: whether a representation has been incorporated into relatively durable knowledge, attitudes, or habits. Appel & Richter (2007) investigated the timing of persuasive effects of fictional narratives and provided a basis for considering delayed or increasing effects, rather than assuming immediate measurement is sufficient. Such outcomes may arise through later rehearsal or interaction with other experiences, but the processes must be measured directly. Longitudinal observation without randomized assignment is informative about trajectories while remaining vulnerable to exposure selection and confounding.
Independent replication should involve new investigators, materials, media, audiences, and outcome measures. Researchers can randomize several narrative stimuli within thematic categories and treat stimulus as a sampled factor instead of taking a single film excerpt as a universal model. Blinded coding, preregistered primary endpoints, checks for differential attrition, and transparent handling of missing data improve the reliability of inferences. Reporting standardized effects together with confidence intervals matters because the practical interpretation of a small mean effect depends on the consequence of the decision, audience size, and duration of exposure. The substantial heterogeneity represented in Braddock & Dillard (2016) and Shen et al. (2015) makes such specification especially important.
The evidence base supports a qualified but consequential synthesis. Narratives can affect story-consistent judgments under experimental conditions; identification and attention-related processes supply plausible mechanisms; and pooled analyses reveal average persuasive effects that are heterogeneous across tasks and endpoints. The strongest clinical or public-policy conclusion requires more than a changed attitude scale: it needs independent behavioral data, adverse-outcome monitoring where relevant, and adequate follow-up. A scientifically grounded account resists both the dismissal of narrative as merely decorative and the assumption that immersion produces a deterministic transfer of beliefs. The research program must explain when, for whom, through which features, and for how long any effect persists Green & Brock (2000) Braddock & Dillard (2016) Thomas & Grigsby (2024).
Media Enjoyment, Meaningfulness, and Emotional Aftereffects
Entertainment is selected and evaluated through motives that include pleasure, suspense, relaxation, curiosity, and the desire to confront meaningful questions. Transportation helps explain why the experience of watching or reading can be rewarding in itself, while the consequences of a story can create longer-lasting satisfaction or reflection. Green et al. (2004) proposed connections between narrative immersion, media enjoyment, relationships with characters, and changes in self-understanding. A compelling narrative can also provoke grief, disquiet, or ambivalence. These responses are intelligible as part of entertainment because audiences can value emotionally serious experiences even when their immediate feeling is unpleasant.
Oliver & Raney (2011) distinguished hedonic entertainment motivations from eudaimonic orientations to meaning and truth-seeking. Their evidence supports a model in which choices among light entertainment, emotionally intense drama, and reflective narratives express different audience goals. A study of transportation that samples only pleasant stories may therefore miss the very forms of engagement in which meaning and distress coexist. Researchers should independently assess enjoyment, appreciation, being moved, emotional valence, and the readiness to revisit the content. Their covariance can illuminate pathways, but one subjective rating should not stand in for the entire domain of entertainment experience.
A viewer may later discuss a moving story, rewatch a scene, seek information about its historical background, or question a prior judgment. Those actions are plausible downstream outcomes of reception but also reflect peer interaction, social norms, and additional information. To test durable consequences, studies should define an observable behavior and distinguish the effects of the original narrative from later conversations. The meaning of a story can also evolve as an audience reinterprets its characters. Entertainment reception is thus an unfolding relation between mediated representation and subsequent social life, not a one-time exchange whose consequences can be exhausted by a post-viewing satisfaction score Oliver & Raney (2011) Green et al. (2004).
Narrative Persuasion in Health and Public Communication
Health and public information campaigns commonly face the problem of making abstract risks or recommendations personally understandable. Stories can display the consequences of decisions through the experience of a character, potentially making medical or social information more memorable and relevant. Moyer-Gusé (2008) described entertainment-education as a particularly important context for understanding persuasion and resistance. Dahlstrom (2014) argued that narratives have legitimate potential in communicating science to nonexpert audiences, while emphasizing that their intrinsic persuasiveness carries ethical responsibilities. These analyses indicate why a narrative communication strategy should be evaluated both for psychological engagement and for factual accuracy.
The quantitative evidence requires restrained interpretation. Shen et al. (2015) reported a small pooled effect in 25 studies of health narrative persuasion, with variation across media and behavioral targets. The findings encourage intervention developers to test an audiovisual or written message against an explicitly defined comparator rather than infer its effectiveness from narrative form alone. A health story may improve perceived risk, memory, or intentions while failing to change health behavior; it may also amplify fear, reinforce misconceptions, or misrepresent the frequency of exceptional outcomes. Researchers should collect measures of both intended benefits and potentially harmful interpretations, especially when an entertainment narrative contains diagnostic or treatment information.
A practical evaluation of an entertainment-education intervention should begin with an accurate factual proposition, an audience assessment, and a model of how characters illustrate choices without substituting anecdotes for epidemiological evidence. A randomized design can compare a narrative version with an informational version matched for key facts, length, and presentation quality. It should test comprehension, correct recall, counterarguing, transport, identification, and delayed behavior. Ethical review is particularly important when vulnerable groups are depicted, identities are stigmatized, or the story implies clinical advice. These methodological requirements integrate narrative psychology with public communication while respecting the distinct research objects of clinical psychology and behavioral medicine Shen et al. (2015) Dahlstrom (2014).
Fiction, Social Cognition, and Perspective on Others
Fiction provides selective access to minds, motives, and situations that an audience could not otherwise directly encounter. Mar & Oatley (2008) proposed that stories function as compressed simulations of social interaction and can support the practice of perspective-taking. Oatley (2016) reviewed the potential connections between fictional engagement, social inference, empathy, and understanding other people. These proposals explain why psychology should investigate literature and dramatic entertainment as experiences with possible social-cognitive consequences. Yet the presence of social content is insufficient evidence that every exposure improves empathy. Characters may also reinforce hostility, justify prejudice, or encourage narrow interpretations of social groups.
Evidence concerning social cognition has to distinguish trait differences from induced change. People with greater interest in fiction may differ beforehand in empathy, education, social opportunity, and verbal ability. Correlations between lifetime reading and social cognition therefore need careful adjustment and cannot establish a training effect. Experiments should randomize exposure to relevant forms of fiction or comparison material, measure established social-inference skills, and include delayed assessments where feasible. The immediate adoption of a protagonist's perspective can be measured more directly through identification or experience-taking Cohen (2001) Kaufman & Libby (2012). Whether an episode produces enduring skill transfer is an additional claim that demands independent evidence.
Representational diversity is another important variable. If narratives depict only a narrow range of communities, the social simulations available to their audiences may be correspondingly restricted. The mechanism does not predict a universally positive effect: repeated exposure to stereotypes could make those stereotypes more accessible while exposure to complex counterexamples could challenge them. Research should examine narrative content, social distance, character complexity, and the audience's prior social knowledge. Green (2004) reported relationships between prior relevant experience and transportation, suggesting that existing familiarity shapes reception. Such work helps specify how narrative experiences interact with social cognition rather than assuming that fictional immersion changes everyone in the same way.
Marketing Narratives, Self-Relevance, and Ethical Persuasion
Commercial storytelling uses characters, journeys, and remembered episodes to attach significance to products or institutions. Escalas (2004) studied narrative processing in advertising and examined how consumers incorporate represented experiences into self-brand connections. The reported experimental findings support interest in the link between narrative interpretation and attitudes, but the outcome has to be distinguished from persuasion by factual evidence about product performance. A story may confer personal or moral meaning on a brand without informing the audience of the comparative quality of its goods. The psychological achievement of a memorable narrative is analytically separate from the truth of its commercial implication.
van Laer et al. (2014) proposed an extended transportation-imagery model integrating factors relevant to consumer response. The review Thomas & Grigsby (2024) systematically examined marketing-focused research and identified a wide variety of proposed antecedents, moderators, and effects. One implication is that the advertiser's intention to persuade and the consumer's experience of being transported may move in different directions. A clear manipulative-intent warning could change how audiences attend to a story; a familiar character could strengthen engagement without ensuring trust in a sponsoring organization. Research has to measure comprehension of sponsorship and perceived persuasive intent independently from narrative enjoyment.
The ethics of commercial narrative influence extend to disclosure, personal data, targeting, and the truthful representation of people. Persuasive communication can be legitimate while relying on emotional experience, but transparency becomes especially significant when storytelling is personalized using inferred psychological traits or when fictional testimonials are presented as historical facts. Scientific evaluation should examine actual consumer decisions, memory for disclosures, and misinference from cases selected for emotional power. The contribution of transportation research is to make the process of persuasion legible, enabling creators and audiences to distinguish the qualities of a story from the evidentiary standards for the claims associated with it Escalas (2004) Dahlstrom (2014).
Serialized Television and Streaming Narrative Worlds
Serialized entertainment extends narrative participation across episodes and seasons. Returning characters create opportunities for accumulating expectations, adjusting a mental model, and reinterpreting earlier scenes when new information becomes available. The state of transportation still unfolds during particular episodes, but familiarity with an established world can shape entry into that state. A single post-viewing measure may conflate the immediate episode's engagement with retrospective attachment to the entire series. Existing theories of transportation and perceived realism offer hypotheses for this extended setting; they do not supply an automatic longitudinal model of how repeated exposure changes values or everyday behavior Busselle & Bilandzic (2008) Bilandzic & Busselle (2008).
The 2026 investigation of streaming drama by Kim & Lim (2026) provides a contemporary example. It surveyed 300 adults in South Korea who had completed a particular Netflix series and analyzed self-reported transportation, identification, perceived verisimilitude, cultural familiarity, bittersweet emotion, relational moral beliefs, and behavioral intentions through structural equation modeling. Positive associations were consistent with both cognitive and emotional pathways. The authors explicitly characterized the study as cross-sectional evidence that cannot establish causal or temporal order. Its contribution is to expand observation into longer-format serialized viewing; its design cannot prove that the series changed a participant's moral beliefs rather than attracting viewers with prior compatible preferences.
Future longitudinal work could capture exposure episode by episode, sample transportation close to the actual viewing event, and record earlier beliefs before the first episode. A randomized encouragement design or assignment to carefully selected series may create stronger causal leverage, though compliance and self-selection remain concerns. Time-stamped diaries could clarify when plot-related reflections or social discussions take place. Platform-level viewing traces, collected with informed consent, could identify exposure duration without revealing the meaning audiences assign to particular scenes. The appropriate scientific task is to join behavioral measures with psychological interpretation while retaining the distinction between a person's engagement with a narrative world and the real-world commitments that person subsequently chooses Kim & Lim (2026) Thomas & Grigsby (2024).
Individual Differences and Narrative Selectivity
Audience engagement arises from the encounter between a particular story and the recipient's knowledge, concerns, dispositions, and circumstances. Readers differ in their tendency to become transported, their experience of the represented setting, and their prior evaluations of the issues portrayed. Green (2004) examined relevant prior knowledge and perceived realism, suggesting that familiar experiential cues can help readers construct a convincing story world. These variables complicate claims about change. People may select narratives precisely because their characters or worldview already resemble their own, so a correlation between immersion and agreement can reflect attitudes established before the encounter.
Dispositional transportability denotes the tendency to enter narrative worlds across experiences, rather than a person's involvement in a particular episode. Bilandzic & Busselle (2008) examined transportability in connection with genre-consistent attitudes and estimates, clarifying the need to distinguish predisposition from state. A defensible design measures prior interests before assigning stories and uses multiple stimuli instead of a single unusually effective passage. Repeated observations also enable analysis of whether an individual's reported engagement changes systematically with story characteristics rather than simply reproducing a general preference for dramatic media.
Age, language proficiency, literacy, cultural familiarity, and access needs may shape both narrative comprehension and responses to survey items. A story with unexplained historical references may be intelligible to a familiar audience and confusing to another. Consequently, comparisons across populations require samples appropriate to the target inference and tests of measurement invariance. The existence of variation does not establish a fixed direction for any demographic group. The instrument developed by Busselle & Bilandzic (2009) and the systematic review of Thomas & Grigsby (2024) provide starting points for asking which dimensions and outcome measures transfer to new audiences.
Medium, Distribution, and Platform Affordances
Printed stories, podcasts, feature films, television dramas, and streaming services differ in pacing, sensory information, interruption patterns, and opportunities for repetition. These affordances can influence attention, comprehension, and affect, but a comparison of a novel with its screen adaptation changes dialogue, acting, music, duration, and editing along with the medium. To claim an effect of medium, the researcher must isolate a property that can be experimentally or observationally distinguished from the content it carries. Busselle & Bilandzic (2008) provides a framework for narrative comprehension, while Shen et al. (2015) demonstrates the need to examine medium differences within specified communication contexts.
Recommendation systems, autoplay, social circulation, and content collections affect which narratives reach which audiences. These mechanisms chiefly influence selection and exposure, whereas transportation is the experienced response during reception. Viewing logs may establish that media was served or played; they cannot reveal comprehension, identification, or endorsement on their own. Researchers should combine privacy-preserving exposure measurement with assessments appropriately timed to the narrative episode. Without that distinction a system's success in presenting attractive content could be misrepresented as evidence that it caused a psychological change Thomas & Grigsby (2024).
Serialized media makes the time dimension especially important. Familiarity with recurring characters may facilitate reentry into a narrative world, yet previous attachment can also produce selective interpretations. Kim & Lim (2026) surveyed viewers who had completed a streaming series and reported associations among transportation, identification, verisimilitude, emotional responses, and moral beliefs. Because selection into viewing and completion preceded the survey, the design does not establish the direction of influence. Prospective diaries, baseline belief measures, and randomized exposure where feasible would provide stronger evidence about cumulative effects.
Persuasion, Framing, and Story-Based Evidence
A compelling narrative portrays agents who make choices and experience consequences. Such a sequence may communicate an implied claim about society or the efficacy of a decision. The represented case can clarify a possibility while offering little direct information about its statistical frequency. For this reason, the emotional vividness of a story must be distinguished from the evidentiary basis of its generalizations. Dahlstrom (2014) examines both the usefulness and responsibilities of narrative science communication. Researchers should separately assess correct recall, inference about prevalence, affective response, and whether recipients recognize the difference between illustration and evidence.
Gain-loss framing research poses another question: do audiences respond differently when comparable consequences are emphasized as benefits gained or harms avoided? Kim & Chen (2025) reviewed framing studies in narrative persuasion, indicating that framing can vary by outcome and research design. Narrative structure and framing should be manipulated independently where possible. A gain-framed personal testimony compared with a loss-framed factual article changes both presentation and proposition emphasis; such a contrast cannot identify a unique mechanism. Factorial studies can test whether transportation moderates the effect of framing, and whether identified effects survive measures of prior attitudes.
Claims about reduced counterarguing also need careful operationalization. A person deeply focused on fictional events may be actively reasoning about their causes while evaluating persuasive implications less explicitly. Slater & Rouner (2002) and Moyer-Gusé (2008) describe mechanisms linking narrative reception with resistance to messages, but the relevant responses must be measured rather than inferred from immersion alone. Separate measures of comprehension, claim verification, source trust, and delayed choice can distinguish persuasion arising from informative learning from persuasion arising chiefly through the accessibility of an emotionally memorable example.
Ethical Responsibilities and Audience Protection
Narrative influence can support learning and social understanding, while a selective account can also amplify misleading impressions. Representations have consequences when a memorable exceptional case is mistaken for a typical one or when fictional dialogue is treated as established scientific evidence. Braddock & Dillard (2016) supports the relevance of narrative persuasion across measured outcomes, without implying uniform effects for every story or person. Responsible publishing therefore attends to the factual basis of consequential claims, the social implications of representation, and the audience's capacity to recognize the communicative context.
Experimental studies that expose participants to intense emotion or assess sensitive reactions require appropriate informed consent, attention to foreseeable distress, and careful handling of personal information. When viewers' behavioral traces are connected with psychological measures, even a seemingly ordinary viewing record may disclose private preferences. Research data should be limited to what is necessary for the question, securely handled, and retained under clear governance. Disclosure of sponsorship or automated production may also be experimentally relevant because perceived authorship and intent can affect evaluation. The appropriate response is to make provenance legible and test what audiences understand about it.
The scientific ethics of storytelling also involves identifying unintended outcomes. A communication may increase engagement but weaken confidence calibration, exaggerate risk, or heighten reliance on a single example. Predefined adverse-inference measures, alternative factual explanations, and delayed comprehension tests can reveal such effects. Dahlstrom (2014) offers a framework for examining the tension between persuasive narrative appeal and the accuracy expected of public science communication. Creative narratives remain valuable cultural artifacts; claims promoted through them must be evaluated in the evidentiary contexts where they are presented.
Narrative Engagement and Synthetic Media in the Artificial Era
The Artificial Era expands storytelling through systems that generate written, spoken, and audiovisual narrative material. Artificially produced stories allow systematic variation of perspective, character continuity, stylistic coherence, and presentation, potentially creating new experimental designs. The existing psychological questions remain meaningful: whether an audience constructs a stable story world, identifies with represented agents, and transfers particular inferences beyond the encounter. Green & Brock (2000) and Busselle & Bilandzic (2009) supply human-audience constructs for these investigations. The existence of synthetic narrative production provides no independent evidence of an artificial system's subjective experience or psychological status.
Research should experimentally separate the form and provenance of a story. One study might compare fixed human-written and machine-generated narratives matched on length, readability, and perceived quality; another could manipulate the disclosure of authorship while holding text constant. Personalized stories require independent assessment of selection effects and privacy. If participants choose or receive content matched to prior preferences, higher measured transportation may result from compatibility rather than a distinctive property of artificial generation. Interactive stories introduce participant decisions and feedback, which invite additional analysis of agency outside this dossier's principal noninteractive boundary.
Open questions concern whether repeated exposure to adaptive characters changes recognition of persuasive intent, whether synthetic details produce unwarranted factual confidence, and whether narrative continuity affects delayed recall or interpretation. These hypotheses should be tested using preregistered comparisons, retained stimuli, user consent, and independent behavioral outcomes. Human–Artificial Relations and Artificial Cognition are relevant neighboring research programs; their concepts may guide testable models without substituting philosophical propositions for empirical evidence. The historical horizon From Homo to Artificial provides a context for studying changing practices of narrative production, distribution, and reception.
Integrating the Evidence Across Theories
The contemporary evidence supports a layered account of how people encounter mediated narratives. A narrative supplies temporally organized agents, events, and consequences; recipients construct a situation model, allocate attention, and respond emotionally; these processes may interact with character identification and produce subsequent evaluations. The foundational experiments of Green & Brock (2000) and the conceptualization of engagement by Busselle & Bilandzic (2008) Busselle & Bilandzic (2009) establish central questions about this organization. The process is not one homogeneous experience: cognitive comprehension, identification, emotional intensity, and reported presence can vary independently. A strong scientific model therefore specifies which component is affected, when it is measured, and how its contribution is distinguished from other responses.
The evidence for persuasive outcomes is most appropriately stated in terms of conditionally supported effects. Randomized narrative experiments show that exposure and presentation can alter story-consistent judgments in tested circumstances; de Graaf et al. (2012) provides more targeted evidence concerning manipulated character perspective; Kaufman & Libby (2012) investigates the particular effects of experience-taking. Quantitative synthesis by Braddock & Dillard (2016) identifies positive mean effects across several classes of outcome, while Shen et al. (2015) finds a smaller pooled association in a specifically health-oriented literature. Variation in message, comparator, audience, outcome, and timing is part of the explanation. It would be scientifically unsound to convert these findings into a universal prediction that an audience will believe a proposition simply because it finds a story compelling.
Theoretical accounts remain complementary at some levels and competing at others. The mental simulation view Mar & Oatley (2008) Oatley (2016) explains how represented social worlds can be modeled; transportation theory emphasizes attention, imagery, and emotional absorption; identification research focuses on the temporary perspective of a protagonist; entertainment-education models Slater & Rouner (2002) Moyer-Gusé (2008) examine persuasive processing and resistance. These frameworks can be integrated within a process design without presuming a single causal chain in every story. Their empirical relevance must be judged by whether they generate predictions that distinguish them under controlled conditions. A mechanism explanation should improve prediction beyond simply relabeling high engagement as transportation.
A Hierarchy of Inference for Narrative Effects
Scientific claims about mediated storytelling form a hierarchy. A description of audience experience establishes what participants report; a correlational study establishes patterns of covariation; randomized assignment to narratives identifies effects of the assigned content package; direct manipulation of theoretically relevant story features narrows the set of candidate causes. Mediation studies can test explanatory pathways, but they require assumptions that observational measurements of mediators rarely satisfy automatically. Delayed follow-up then asks whether the observed difference persists after the immediate viewing context, and objective behavior measures ask whether participants act rather than simply endorse a stated intention. Evidence from each level should be reported with a conclusion appropriate to that level.
The sources examined in this monograph exemplify different positions on that hierarchy. Green & Brock (2000) includes both associations and an experimental instruction manipulation; Green (2004) investigates prior knowledge and realism in an undergraduate sample; de Graaf et al. (2012) experimentally varies viewpoint; Kim & Lim (2026) models associations among self-reported states in an existing streaming audience. A causal statement about the last study would exceed the design; a blanket dismissal of its descriptive findings would also disregard what the survey can reveal about perceived engagement. The review literature van Laer et al. (2014) Thomas & Grigsby (2024) is valuable for mapping research fields but cannot erase the underlying variation in study designs.
Evidence appraisal should explicitly address selection of narratives, sampling of audiences, validity and invariance of scales, precision of estimates, selective reporting, attrition, and the difference between attitudes and behavior. Multi-story designs and preregistered analytic plans help protect against overgeneralization from a small set of unusually moving stimuli. Assessment of contradictory results is as necessary as reporting positive findings. The practical significance of an average effect depends on the potential benefits or harms of the content and its distribution; no abstract effect-size label can replace that contextual evaluation.
An Experimental Agenda for the Next Generation of Research
A useful experiment begins by specifying the hypothesized change in a particular audience outcome. Researchers might randomly assign participants to alternative versions of the same story in which viewpoint is altered but essential facts are conserved. They could assess prior beliefs, measure immediate engagement, and record story-specific understanding before collecting delayed attitudes and behavior. Independent outcome coding and exposure checks would help determine whether a change follows assigned narrative conditions rather than self-selection. Such designs improve upon a single post-exposure correlation between transportation and agreement de Graaf et al. (2012) Thomas & Grigsby (2024).
A larger cumulative program should sample independently authored stimuli spanning genres, emotional tones, cultural settings, and media. Hierarchical analysis can model both person and stimulus variability. Researchers should distinguish state transportation from transportability, establish reliability for new language versions, and test whether measurement items function similarly across prose, screen, and audio media. The process should include evaluations of identification, comprehension, emotional engagement, perceived realism, and perceived source credibility, chosen according to the proposed model. If a theoretical mechanism cannot be operationally differentiated from another, a claim that the mechanism has been established is premature Bilandzic & Busselle (2008) Busselle & Bilandzic (2009).
Research across long-form and adaptive media requires temporal precision. An experience-sampling protocol could record engagement immediately after an episode, then examine intervening social discussion, factual verification, memory rehearsal, and later action. Experiments could compare disclosure of synthetic production and different degrees of narrative personalization while recording which content each participant actually receives. Privacy protection is intrinsic to these designs because preferences inferred from narrative engagement can be personally consequential. The Artificial Era calls for methodological continuity with established psychology and appropriate innovation in how variable digital stimuli and distributed exposure are measured.
Scientific Boundaries and Connections to Adjacent Fields
Media and Technology Psychology is the principal disciplinary home of the present research object. Cognitive psychology supplies models of memory, attention, and narrative comprehension; social psychology contributes the study of perspective-taking, identification, attitudes, and persuasive interpretation; motivation and emotion research clarifies suspense, enjoyment, meaningfulness, and being moved. Psychology of Aesthetics and Creativity is relevant where narrative experience is valued as art or emotionally consequential expression. These relations establish scholarly pathways without merging the underlying objects into a single omnibus theory.
Related dossiers should have their own canonical identity. Persuasion and Attitude Change addresses persuasion across message types; Discourse and Narrative Comprehension concentrates on understanding linguistic and event structure; Parasocial Interaction and Mediated Social Presence investigates the viewer's enduring social relation to mediated figures; Mediated Emotion and Mood Regulation addresses mood management; Digital, Virtual, and Artificially Mediated Environments examines technological and environmental conditions. The present dossier asks specifically how an audience enters noninteractive narratives and how that engagement relates to entertainment and belief outcomes. Its experimental scope and its definitions preserve those boundaries.
Internal research links should be activated only after confirming that the corresponding neighboring works are publicly released and scientifically relevant. The primary Science route, /science/media-and-technology-psychology/, provides the appropriate eventual incoming connection. No subject-specific independent Publication was confirmed in the registry snapshot consulted for this manuscript, so a speculative Publications Index would create false precision. This research structure may be expanded after subsequent bibliographic and canonical verification. An unpublished reserved dossier address is a production identity, not evidence of public accessibility.
Unresolved Problems and Limits of Generalization
Several questions remain methodologically open. The causal ordering of transportation, identification, emotional response, and persuasion is frequently inferred from questionnaires administered at a single moment. Story effects may be driven by factual content, presentation length, narrator credibility, or audience selection as well as experiential immersion. In many studies, the measured outcome is an immediate belief or intention rather than a verified behavior months later. Braddock & Dillard (2016) reports a more limited pool of behavioral effects than attitudinal effects, and Thomas & Grigsby (2024) identifies heavy reliance on measured rather than manipulated transportation in a major marketing subset of the literature. Neither problem invalidates the positive results; both delimit their explanatory force.
Longitudinal adaptation, cultural translation, and algorithmic distribution present additional challenges. Repeated narrative exposure may change an audience's baseline expectations, while recommendation systems select those already receptive to a genre. A cross-sectional analysis of a streaming series Kim & Lim (2026) can identify plausible pathways but cannot estimate the effect of having watched the series without suitable comparison and baseline information. Generalizing across cultural environments requires careful translation, culturally diverse story samples, and attention to different interpretations of identification and realism. Research should report the range of populations and materials actually studied, not assume transfer across audiences as a matter of course.
Future work should give special consideration to counterevidence. A story may be remembered and liked without increasing persuasion, and transportation may amplify resistance when the audience evaluates a protagonist's worldview negatively. An experimental design should therefore preserve outcome distributions, report null results and confidence intervals, and examine whether the content itself is accurate. Only comparative designs can determine whether the benefits of narrative presentation exceed those of a well-constructed nonnarrative explanation. The public importance of mediated entertainment is a reason to strengthen these standards rather than to equate popularity with evidence.
Conclusion
Narrative transportation is a measurable form of situated engagement in which attention, simulated understanding, and affective response organize an audience's participation in a represented world. Its scientific importance lies in connecting the psychological experience of stories with questions about comprehension, enjoyment, identification, and subsequent evaluation. Decades of research have moved from initial transportation experiments to differentiated engagement scales, controlled perspective manipulations, studies of entertainment motives, and quantitative syntheses of persuasion. The resulting literature establishes narratives as consequential psychological environments whose effects depend on the organization of content, the dispositions of recipients, and the contexts in which encounters occur.
The strongest synthesis is conditional and specific. Engagement can contribute to story-consistent beliefs and attitudes, but measured transportation alone does not prove that immersion caused change, and a changed questionnaire response does not demonstrate durable action. Simulation, character identification, emotional involvement, critical reasoning, and later social discussion interact in ways that remain to be disentangled. A productive science of mediated entertainment combines accurate construct definitions, varied narrative stimuli, independent measures, time-sensitive designs, and ethical scrutiny of message accuracy. It recognizes meaningful and pleasurable narrative experiences as distinct outcomes with their own explanatory significance.
As storytelling enters increasingly adaptive and artificially generated environments, established psychological principles provide a research foundation for examining new media without confusing technological novelty with empirical proof. The horizon From Homo to Artificial frames an expansion of the environments in which narratives are authored, distributed, and encountered. Future research can test how synthetic character continuity, disclosure, personalization, and human–artificial interaction influence audience transportation and belief. The enduring task is to establish what the narrative does, how the recipient understands it, and which scientifically supported consequences follow beyond the story.
References
- Appel, M., & Richter, T. (2007). Persuasive effects of fictional narratives increase over time. Media Psychology, 10(1), 113–134. https://doi.org/10.1080/15213260701301194
- Bilandzic, H., & Busselle, R. W. (2008). Transportation and transportability in the cultivation of genre-consistent attitudes and estimates. Journal of Communication, 58(3), 508–529. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1460-2466.2008.00397.x
- Braddock, K., & Dillard, J. P. (2016). Meta-analytic evidence for the persuasive effect of narratives on beliefs, attitudes, intentions, and behaviors. Communication Monographs, 83(4), 446–467. https://doi.org/10.1080/03637751.2015.1128555
- Busselle, R., & Bilandzic, H. (2008). Fictionality and perceived realism in experiencing stories: A model of narrative comprehension and engagement. Communication Theory, 18(2), 255–280. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-2885.2008.00322.x
- Busselle, R., & Bilandzic, H. (2009). Measuring narrative engagement. Media Psychology, 12(4), 321–347. https://doi.org/10.1080/15213260903287259
- Cohen, J. (2001). Defining identification: A theoretical look at the identification of audiences with media characters. Mass Communication & Society, 4(3), 245–264. https://doi.org/10.1207/S15327825MCS0403_01
- Dahlstrom, M. F. (2014). Using narratives and storytelling to communicate science with nonexpert audiences. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 111(Suppl. 4), 13614–13620. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1320645111
- de Graaf, A., Hoeken, H., Sanders, J., & Beentjes, J. W. J. (2012). Identification as a mechanism of narrative persuasion. Communication Research, 39(6), 802–823. https://doi.org/10.1177/0093650211408594
- Escalas, J. E. (2004). Narrative processing: Building consumer connections to brands. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 14(1–2), 168–180. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15327663jcp1401&2_19
- Green, M. C. (2004). Transportation into narrative worlds: The role of prior knowledge and perceived realism. Discourse Processes, 38(2), 247–266. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15326950dp3802_5
- Green, M. C., & Brock, T. C. (2000). The role of transportation in the persuasiveness of public narratives. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 79(5), 701–721. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.79.5.701
- Green, M. C., Brock, T. C., & Kaufman, G. F. (2004). Understanding media enjoyment: The role of transportation into narrative worlds. Communication Theory, 14(4), 311–327. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-2885.2004.tb00317.x
- Kaufman, G. F., & Libby, L. K. (2012). Changing beliefs and behavior through experience-taking. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 103(1), 1–19. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0027525
- Kim, H. K., & Chen, M. (2025). A meta-analysis of gain–loss framing effects in narrative persuasion. Journal of Communication, 75(3), 220–230. https://doi.org/10.1093/joc/jqaf002
- Kim, H. S., & Lim, J. (2026). Bittersweet emotion and narrative transportation in streaming drama: Cognitive and emotional routes to persuasion. Frontiers in Psychology, 17, Article 1815433. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2026.1815433
- Mar, R. A., & Oatley, K. (2008). The function of fiction is the abstraction and simulation of social experience. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 3(3), 173–192. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-6924.2008.00073.x
- Moyer-Gusé, E. (2008). Toward a theory of entertainment persuasion: Explaining the persuasive effects of entertainment-education messages. Communication Theory, 18(3), 407–425. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-2885.2008.00328.x
- Oatley, K. (2016). Fiction: Simulation of social worlds. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 20(8), 618–628. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tics.2016.06.002
- Oliver, M. B., & Raney, A. A. (2011). Entertainment as pleasurable and meaningful: Identifying hedonic and eudaimonic motivations for entertainment consumption. Journal of Communication, 61(5), 984–1004. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1460-2466.2011.01585.x
- Shen, F., Sheer, V. C., & Li, R. (2015). Impact of narratives on persuasion in health communication: A meta-analysis. Journal of Advertising, 44(2), 105–113. https://doi.org/10.1080/00913367.2015.1018467
- Slater, M. D., & Rouner, D. (2002). Entertainment-education and elaboration likelihood: Understanding the processing of narrative persuasion. Communication Theory, 12(2), 173–191. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-2885.2002.tb00265.x
- Thomas, V. L., & Grigsby, J. L. (2024). Narrative transportation: A systematic literature review and future research agenda. Psychology & Marketing, 41(8), 1805–1819. https://doi.org/10.1002/mar.22011
- van Laer, T., de Ruyter, K., Visconti, L. M., & Wetzels, M. (2014). The extended transportation-imagery model: A meta-analysis of the antecedents and consequences of consumers’ narrative transportation. Journal of Consumer Research, 40(5), 797–817. https://doi.org/10.1086/673383